Thursday, November 24, 2022

Gujarat: Signboard parties may not give run for money to big players


Ahmedabad

Gujarat generally has been dominated by bipolar politics between the BJP and the Congress.

Even after 2002 anti-Muslim mayhem, the Third Front parties such as the NCP, Samajwadi Party and JD(U) could not make much impact. Moreover, in several seats the NCP harmed the interest of Congress by splitting the anti-BJP votes. 



Namo and Vanjara : Yesteryears 









In the run up to the fast approaching assembly elections - Dec 1 and Dec 5 - we have the AAP of Arvind Kejriwal trying to play a significant role and all eyes are on whether it will harm Congress prospects.

But in addition to AAP, there are a few parties. In psephology terms -- one can say signboard parties.

Most often these signboard parties make hell of a difference in the ultimate analysis in many states but in Gujarat they could hardly make much impact.


Much controversial cop D J Vanzara, a former "encounter specialist", has floated the Praja Vijay Party (PVP) and says his new outfit is wedded to Hindutva ideology but would be fighting the BJP.


Vanzara was acquitted in the alleged fake encounter case of Sohrabuddin Shaikh and Tulsiram Prajapati and also has been discharged in the infamous Ishrat Jahan alleged fake encounter case.

\



He was acquitted in 2017 in the fake encounter cases of Sohrabuddin Sheikh and Tulsi Prajapati (2005) 

after spending nearly eight years behind bars. 


"People of Gujarat do not easily accept a non-Hindutva party. Only a Hindutva party can provide an effective

alternative to the BJP," he says. 


Apart from Vanzara's party, PVP and three better known parties the BJP, Congress and the AAP;

other parties are in the 2022 fray are Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), Communist Party of India (CPI), 

Bharatiya Tribal Party (BTP), All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) and 

All India Trinamool Congress (AITC).


Now it remains to be seen how much or how significant roles these parties will play in terms

of garnering support for themselves or spoiling games for others from much more credible parties

in the state.

For 89 seats that go to polls in the first phase on Dec 1, both the BJP and the Congress have fielded

candidates in all 89 seats. AAP has named nominees for 88 seats, BSP of Mayawati in 57 and AIMIM -

six.

 

From 2012 and 2017 records here are the statistics on how these smaller parties perform in Gujarat.


Notwithstanding much hype, in 2012, even former BJP stalwart Keshubhai Patel-led Gujarat Parivartan Party (GPP)

could poll only 3.63 percent votes and could win only two seats The NCP vote share was 0.67 per cent and surprisingly,

it also won two seats. The Janata Dal (United) also could manage to win only one seat and 0.45 percent of votes.

The Independents had a share of 5.83 per cent of votes and only one of them could make it.


The Congress could win 61 seats and the vote share stood at 38.93 percent. 

The BJP could win 115 seats and its vote share was 48.85 percent.


In 2017, Independents managed 4.3 percent of votes and picked up 3 seats.

The Bharatiya Tribal Party (BTP), won 2 seats with a modest 0.7 vote share. 

Bahujan Samaj Party 0.7 percent  and no seat, NCP - 0.6 percent and one seat while

the little known All India Hindustan Congress Party managed 0.3 percent of votes while

Rashtriya Samajwadi Party (Secular) only 0.2 percent and Aam Aadmi Party only 0.1 percent of votes.


In Odisha there is a joke. Most new and large cars are seen in front of Congress Bhavan and ironically

many of those cars belong to Congress people who contested and lost elections and even lost deposits.


One may face defeat in polls, but one could grow rich. It's time to figure out what works.


ends 


Nagaland preparing for 'Na janey ho' moment

'Delay magic' to work again in Peace talks 

New Delhi 

The rendezvous with destiny matters a lot. 

For 25 years and counting the Naga peace parleys are on. For two decades and a half, Nagaland story has been more than its mere history and geography. 







For the last 22 years or so, the Nagaland state polity has also been the story of
Neiphiu Rio, who quit Congress and embraced regional politics -- tailored
himself to suit BJP's oneupmanship at times and built up his career.

Even the likes of S C Jamir have been politically outsmarted and electorally humbled in a by-election. The Government of India - irrespective of party affiliations - has been a player all these years. 


The Manmohan Singh government could have done more but despite limitations
Oscar Fernandes tried his best.


The Vajpayee government between 1998 and 2004 trusted the 'anti-Congress' spirit and encouraged regional party - that is the NPF. Despite victory of seven seats in 2003, the BJP did not bother much to expand base or convince Naga voters about the virtues of its definition of nationalism. 


Nagaland Page link


Likes of M Venkaiah Naidu and Nitin Gadkari as BJP presidents were so engrossed with personal ambitions and 'reviving' BJP in cow belt that Nagaland hardly mattered. But the saffron kept flying due to tireless works of some committed leaders -- M Chuba Ao, James Vizo and Late Visasolie Lhoungu and so on.
The Modi government gave a mega push. But things have been hijacked since October 2019. 

The result oriented Governor R N Ravi also shifted base.

 
In the 2018 polls, notwithstanding the not so confident approach, the BJP produced 'best striking rate' in Nagaland -- surpassing both NPF and Neiphiu Rio-led NDPP. It won 12 seats out of mere 20 it was given in the deal by Ram Madhav-friendly NDPP. 


Had there been no interference from Kohima's power lobby -- Atouizu and Pughoboto seats could have come as well. In Phek district, Chizami almost reposed faith in the 'pro-Hindu' BJP and thus the margin of loss for BJP's Kevechutso Doulo was quite narrow - only 403 seats.

 
Now all eyes are on New Delhi. 

A microscopic minority among stakeholders could be optimistic of a solution to the talks before Christmas or before assembly polls. The 'delay magic' is at work ! And who would say 'double standards' propelled by money power will not succeed yet again?


Of course much hope is still reposed on a man called, Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi from certain quarters like a section of civil societies who have lately yet again penned a letter pressing for urgency. 







“By any standard, be it physical developments or be it the well being of the citizens, Nagaland has retrogressed by decades under the weight of elongated negotiations," said the statement. Strong words indeed!


There is a virtual catch-22 situation and elections are at doorsteps yet again.
But can the rendezvous with destiny be postponed indefinitely?


The NDPP-BJP poll alliance lacks political conviction and even fails logic to a large extent.


The general refrain being an ambitious party like the BJP has surprisingly decided to play second fiddle to a regional partner which does not have much in its credit in terms of administration or working towards an early Solution to the pending Naga issue.  


However, if it is a self-goal, why should it be not corrected at all ?

B L Santhosh and J P Nadda may be finding themselves with tied hands in 

a tough situation.


Several NDPP legislators and leaders on the other hand are still running around Delhi hoping miracles may 

happen and the BJP will review the status of 20-40. 


There is speculation that another regional player, NPF, is trying to play its own games and notwithstanding 

Shurhozelie's radical-regionalism -- it has offered the saffron a much better deal -- 40 for the BJP and 20 for itself.


A marginalised and fund-staved NPF would love such an arrangement. But this is easier said than

done and could be even called 'day-dreams'.


The BJP is still giving mixed signals. While it has geared up full steam in Meghalaya and Tripura for polls,

in Nagaland there is a peculiar inertia.


The state unit president was expected to be replaced and despite repeated assurances by a few 'men of honour'

in BJP headquarters nothing like that happened. 


"Why should we....," goes a rumour mongering line when the party knows the ultimate results -- 2-3 seats at the

mercy of NDPP !    


In the ultimate; NDPP and its chief minister Rio are forces to reckon with. Rio's detractors have to wait for a few

more new twists in the entire plot and miracles to surprise and oust him.


A few leaders are still working. Money always counts a lot in Nagaland elections. Perhaps no other factor

matters so much.


But in politics -- the most powerful sentiment often is emotion. Are Nagaland voters emotionally with the NDPP

in a real sense?


If Solution is dear to their hearts and only such a stage can end extortion menace; will they still think money is

important and status quo should prevail ?


The civil society's statement may be just another piece of paper for Delhi. Himanta Biswa Sarma may be more

influential in Nagaland politics than any previous Assam Chief Minister. 


But how will Nagaland voters work out their strategies? Corruption - it is argued - came to Nagaland because

India imposed it; and policy makers in Delhi encouraged it.


For a change, good political logic at the level of common people and some amount of honesty need to unite at 

this juncture. Or else, last two decades of 'ceasefire terror' and economic hardships will become the order

of the day. 


Next time if someone asks -- how did all the mess happen; elders cannot give the characteristic Nagamese response - 'Na janey ho'.

 

ends 

 

Wednesday, November 23, 2022

Do not trust your girl friend, politics and Football world cup encounters : Anything can happen ! Germany and Argentina humbled

Desert drama called Battle of Boots has just unfolded !!


Asano, one of Japanese coach Moriyasu’s five replacements at half time, took down a floating ball expertly along the right, outmuscled Nico Schlotterbeck and, after racing in on Manuel Neuer’s goal, rifled in.... (The Guardian) 



and that made history!!

Do not trust your girl friend, politics and Football world cup encounters. Anything can happen !!


I am a fan of #German soccer !! really admire their skills...but today Japan is great ....the Asian Pride 



Football has a funny way of bringing up narratives, and two Japan players - who play their club football in Germany - on Thursday, Nov 23, conspired to score the goals that defeated the former world champions at the World Cup in Qatar. 







Germany fans were vastly outnumbered and deafeningly outsung, their only real cheer coming when Ilkay Gundogan scored from the penalty spot for a 1-0 half-time lead.


Japan failed to have a shot on target in the opening period, but scored with two of their three efforts in the second period to complete a superb turnaround, says BBC.






"Japan's fans are truly the best. 
They beat Germany in a famous win, but before celebrating stuck around at the Khalifa International Stadium to help clean up.👏" -- tweeted Ben Jacobs 

wonderful gestures. truly a great country and their great culture !! 









Japan boss Hajime Moriyasu, who gave an animated post-match team talk with his players in a huddle on the pitch, also hailed the battling abilities of his players.

"We are reaching the global standard," he said. "We are showing our capability from Asian football. They have a wonderful goalkeeper however, our players were very intelligent.






"When we conceded a goal, we continued. You have to be persistent, then you can go. Our team fought really hard. We need to be tough until the very last minute and then we can grab this moment.

"Maybe we could show that Japanese players have been building up to their true abilities."

Former England striker Chris Sutton said on BBC Radio 5 Live: "What a strange World Cup. What a strange game.


"Japan weren't in it in the first half - Germany were controlling it. Then all of a sudden Japan show they can play. Then Asano with a brilliant finish, he lifts the ball into the roof of the net past Manuel Neuer.
- BBC  



Japan’s first victory over Germany sent a seismic jolt through the World Cup and was reward for the courage shown by Hajime Moriyasu. The coach wrested this Group E opener his side’s way with a series of second-half substitutions that transformed the contest and consigned Germany to defeat in their opening World Cup match for a second consecutive tournament.


Four years ago in Russia a Hirving Lozano strike gave Mexico a famous win over the four-times champions. On Wednesday it was Takuma Asano of the Bundesliga’s Bochum who sent the vocal Japanese fans at Khalifa International Stadium into ecstasy along with his teammates and the rest of the squad who flooded on to the pitch to celebrate his 83rd-minute winner. 

- The Guardian !!

Meanwhile, 

Spain humbled Costa Rica 7-0. It's their biggest ever World Cup win, surpassing the 6-1 victory over Bulgaria in 1998.  

In 2010 when Spain won the World Cup they only scored 8 goals in total!










Can Small spell 'big' ? : Signboard parties of Nagaland

New Delhi/Dimapur


“First method of estimating the intelligence of a ruler is to look at the men he has 
around him.”
— Niccolo Machiavelli

The Congress party is perhaps no longer the same political outfit that took Nagaland by storm for decades. 

Of course it is the party that gave stalwarts Hokishe Sema, S C Jamir and even party hoppers J B Jasokie, K L Chishi, Chingwang Konyak, T A Ngullie and so on !

Stalwart Hokishe Sema with Rajiv Gandhi 



But in the ensuing assembly polls, the scene refuses to be the same. Today, Congress is almost regarded a signboard party. "We do not have enough funds....even high command does not have," lamented a key Congress leader.


Nagaland Page - Link


In 2023 polls thus the focus is on old war-horse K L Chishi, who is set to contest probably one of the last electoral battles of his chequered career from Atouizu. "You are right it was Atouizu which made me what I am today...," comes a cryptic  remark from the former Chief Minister.


In 2018, he had lost from Atouizu -- owing to multiple factors inspired from Kohima -- but on the BJP ticket. In 2019, a fighter that he is, he returned to Congress fold and contested Lok Sabha polls. 


Now in the run up to the 2023 polls, the Congress party does not know whether it will field five candidates or 15 or even 60.







There are of course signboard parties around. Before we go into those -- it may be worth discussing briefly that some parties such as AAP (man of the match in Punjab) and Trinamool Congress (cash-rich corruption-hit outfit in West Bengal) could come at the last moment.


K L Chishi with blogger 



"Some old war horses but mostly disgruntled ones are hopping between Shillong, Kolkata and Delhi....If they promise to change the fate of Nagas, they must be depending a lot on fate and money," said a BJP leader.


How 'fate' changes? Once, the BJP was an easy pushover. Today it has 12 MLAs. But thanks to their friends in Kohima's corridors of power -- the saffron party is reconciling almost to reduce its strength to less than four!


Chingwang Konyak will be smiling somewhere in Mon district and if confronted by any BJP tycoon, he could easily

say - "There is nothing in my hands, there is nothing in underdeveloped Mon. Everything happens accord to wishes

from Kohima".


The satire may not be over. If 'fate' bans Chinese guns and Indian currencies - the 'Kohima players' will be 

reduced to single digit as well. Politics is always full of miracles. Chingwang can smile again and say - "I mean, I told

you all these".

Nevertheless, the polity is generally dependent on good old saying - nothing is permanent except change.


Veteran Shurhozelie is also an experienced regionalist. Whether he is ready to allow NPF to turn into a signboard party too in 2023? He is also a victim of 'neo-loyalists' --- and the crying gang of G-21 is again reportedly protesting in their new home.


A few regionalist colleagues visible in the scene are presumably too weak, lacking the fighting instinct and also too close to 'Kohima's corridors of power'. We have two names from Phek district as of now who could try to play havoc in regional politics. But the so-called 'balance of power' is obviously not in their hands.


Shurhozelie, T A Ngullie, Vamuzo : From Right to Left 




Will NPF go the Congress way? Because here too the theme song is 'who will provide us funds' ! The money from Bara Bosti does not travel outside. 


There are other genuinely signboard parties - the Janata Dal (U) and RPP. The latter still has a leader - son of a former Congressman and a press release activist. For JD-U the shocker was G Kaito's defection four-five years back. Nitish Kumar visited the state recently but his dreams are about 2014.


NPP is also a political force but Tura hills and idyllic Shillong have made life tougher for Meghalaya Chief

Minister. His party was humbled in Manipur and so Conrad Sangma's theme song could be 'around' the Indian money -- with or without

snap of Hindu Goddess Laxmi.


In 2018 assembly polls in Nagaland, the smaller and not so small parties vote share was thus: --

- NPP - 6.9 percent and could win 2 seats, JD(U)) - 4.5 percent - one seat, Independents - 4.3 percent and one seat, 

Congress - 2.1  out of 18 seats it contested and scored zero. In the process it lost 8 MLAs it had won in 

2013 and NCP vote share was 1.1 and it too failed to open an account. 


The Aam Aadmi Party and Lok Janshakti Party also contested in 2018 but the vote share was less than one percent. 


But the importance does not lie in winning many seats. All those smaller parties simply had to

plunge into the realistic politics of 'Kohima power politics' and could easily become ministers and so on.


In Odisha there is a joke. Most new and large cars are seen in front of Congress Bhavan and ironically

many of those cars belong to Congress people who contested and lost elections and even lost deposits.


Why then should there be any widespread feeling of gloom in Nagaland ?    


One may face defeat in polls, but one could grow rich. It's time to figure out what works.


ends 




Why Modi thinks beyond Gujarat polls, routine administration ?


(The centre has got busy with Budget 2023-24 - that will be the last full-fledged Budget before 2024 polls. Startup India and Stand Up India have boosted entrepreneurship. The Modi Govt is eyeing abundant job creation at the grassroots level)


New Delhi 

Politicians in democracy often break hearts. But common people most often tend to draw hopes from political masters. Amid challenges and as food inflation and agonies would often refuse to be tamed, there are some in the Neta class who will continue to create excitement. 






They will help you build monuments of pride and national honour.

Narendra Modi is one such star on the horizon. He is also a protagonist who often refuses to play by any known rules yet there is a discipline in what he does to defeat chaos and confusion.


Right now political focus in government apparatus is the elections in Gujarat. But maybe the Prime Minister of India - also a Gujarati politician - is working on something else.


He spent busy schedules in Bali in Indonesia interacting and shaking hands with global leaders, sharing

mutual concerns about climate change and Russia-Ukraine conflict. In governance sense in the corridors

of power in Delhi, he has other issues to attend to.


The ensuing Winter session of Parliament and of course much importantly the Budget 2023-24. This will be the last Budget which will have a few welfare schemes and also a possible one or two reforms tinkering to augment funds and foreign investment. The bugle for 2024 general elections will be blown by next six months

and Modi and his party will also have to bother about elections in central India -- the 'country's heart' Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh and also Rajasthan in the west in 2023 itself.


The global situations offer more than the customary challenges. There are multiple crises before the United Kingdom.

Things are not good either for the US, China and Europe. The impact left by Russian defence policies and war on the oil front is global.


Both the Prime Minister and his Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman have their jobs cut out.


Their biggest challenge, according to industry experts, is to identify and minimise non-priority spending to meet 

the 2022-23 (FY23) fiscal deficit target of 6.4 per cent of gross domestic product.


"We have not strayed away from the fiscal glide path. We remain committed to the fiscal glide path given in the Budget," FM Ms Sitharaman said in October in Washington, DC. Around October 10th her ministry had started the normal pre-Budget consultations.

The Budget 2023-24 will be the last full steam Budget for Modi 2.0 and hence the Prime Minister has rightly placed his focus areas as well.


There are some figures in the media and other fora about 'surge' in the unemployment rates.

FM counters this and says, "Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) enrolments have doubled in the last quarter, indicating that employment has doubled".


Of course there is a lot of reshaping and recasting happening in the Indian economy. Sitharaman says even the nature of employment is being speedily ramped up.


The Narendra Modi-led government has emphasised the formalisation of jobs. The EPFO data is cited to show an increase in formal jobs.

Objective analysis suggests things are 'improving' in terms of domestic investments as well and Indian corporate players who coughed up a considerable amount in the UK would now look towards India again.

Vedantas and Mittals are getting active in India and so do other players including in the Pharma sector and of course automobile front too.

The auto market is expected to experience elevated demand for commercial vehicles from the flourishing logistics and the passenger transport sector. Government initiatives and policies are prominent factors influencing market growth and are expected to upkeep the growth over the coming years, says a Grand View Research report.



According to the European Automobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA), India is ranked fourth in the top 10  global car-producing countries. 

It is argued that India's automotive sector is powered by the rising population, increasing disposable income, and ease of availability of credit and financing. 

The Indian pharma industry is expected to grow to $130 billion by 2030 and become the leading provider of medicines. It is also stated that behind India's pharma success story is the world class manufacturing excellence, robust 
infrastructure, cost-competitiveness and trained human capital. 





Another highlight is India the largest provider of generic drugs globally. The pharmaceutical-sector industry 

supplies over 50 per cent of global demand for various vaccines, 40 percent of generic demand in the US 

and 25 percent of all medicine in the UK. 


On Nov 17, Finance Minister Ms Sitharaman asked the National Investment and Infrastructure Fund Limited 

(NIIFL) to continuously engage investors.


Opportunities ought to be explored under the National Infrastructure Pipeline, PM GatiShakti and the 

National Infrastructure Corridor, which will also include a big pool of investible greenfield and brownfield 

projects.


The NIIF is now an internationally credible and commercially viable investment platform.


The NIIF’s first bilateral fund – an “India Japan Fund” with a contribution from the Government of India 

has been proposed with cooperation from the Japan Bank for International Development (JBIC).


Capital Gains


The central government has already received suggestions and proposals from the industry to simplify the capital gains tax structure to be carried out in the Budget for 2023/24.

Now, look on the other side, housing sales touched all-time lows in China. 
At least 70 percent of China's GDP relies on the real estate sector and when developers lost the ability to give home buyers their properties, it led to buyers losing confidence.


China's real estate has come down crashing.

Now, Beijing has announced a 16-page playbook to finance the ailing sector.
Robust Tech-Govt cooperation: Prime Minister Modi and his government has rightly laid emphasis on technology.


The government has termed the current decade (2020s) as the “techade” -- a decade of technology. 


Thus, Accessible India Campaign and Mobile App, BHIM (Bharat Interface For Money), Agrimarket App, and DigiLocker under the Digital India mission are showing
results.


This has enabled people to maximize their access to emerging digital tools and technologies in the country.

Most global companies have also expanded their business to India to leverage the country’s soaring tech talent.

Global investment is being targeted for transforming India into a global manufacturing hub.


Startup India and Stand Up India have boosted entrepreneurship. These demonstrate how the government is 

striving to create a tech-driven economy. There is little realisation that results are already visible.

We have abundant job creation at the grassroots level, including financial assistance and technical training.


ends  


Tuesday, November 22, 2022

What ails Congress in Gujarat, but why Rahul stayed away from campaign?


Ahmedabad/Rajkot 


Gujarat elections are often reflections of socio-political churning. The Patidar agitation should be seen from that prism.

Prior to that the state saw so-called 'Hindu unity' and polarisation politics. In the past -- the eighties was a decade of caste mobilisation.

But it is also a given fact that though labeled as 'Hindutva laboratory', the Congress party has always enjoyed a considerable support base. 






Even during the peak of 2002 riots and Hindu polarisation, the Congress
vote share was not negligible. 

Narendra Modi and his 'Moditva' phenomenon though hyped faced a lot of hardships. The same challenge was seen in 2007 also. 


BJP's vocal Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma from Assam recently visited the western state for campaigning and was surprised to note that in the Kutch region, local BJP workers and leaders told him, "Sir, do not highlight the AAP factor here. Our main rival in the Kutch is the Congress".


The BJP poll strategists have since tried to rework the equations.   


Himanta told this journalist, "It is important to note that the Congress remains a major force despite

the Modi factor in Gujarat elections. But we have the big trump card and which makes all the difference that

is Moditva phenomenon". At the same breadth he says, "The social media and other players have only hyped

AAP factor. They will not make much of a difference other than a few typical Patidar pockets".


These sum up paradoxical factors of Gujarat elections and socio-political permutation and combination.


In Ahmedabad, an educationist Mrinmoy Ghosh says, "In Gujarat a new set of ideas come into play from

time to time. This is not understood from outside and many may not feel that even staying for two-three months

in Ahmedabad. The transformation starts from rural pockets. The old status quo comes under challenge

by new assertive forces".


Others tend to agree. The Patidar agitation of 2015 was one such phenomenon. And prior to that there was

Hindu polarisation. "If there is a quality of unsettledness of Gujarat politics, it is due to frequent agitational

habit of mobilisation".


Businessman Basant Ray says, "You will not agree to me but Gujarat is actually a very strong pocket for Congress

traditionally. Former CM and a RSS man Shankersinh Vaghela understood that and he himself joined

Congress. But the only difference is the powerful Narendra Modi image. He has come in the way for Congress

revival".


These would lead us to question the reason why Congress leaders and especially Rahul Gandhi stayed away from

Gujarat campaign this year.


A Muslim leader in Gujarat Congress told this journalist, "This is our tragedy sir...High Command did not understand

the importance of Gujarat. Some of us wrote to Digvijaya Singh and Rahul Gandhi himself and told him the Bharat

Jodo Yatra should have started from Gujarat".


Closer scrutiny suggests perhaps Rahul Gandhi has committed a series of mistakes on Gujarat strategy.


First, unlike 2017, he stayed away from the campaign. Secondly, some controversial remarks were made

on Savarkar and thirdly, he allowed being photographed with Medha Patkar.


Let us look at these step by step. The remarks on Savarkar were not called for because this only brings

back Hindutva politics in the debate. This is BJP's strength and the Congress weakness especially

in the context of Gujarat.


Sociologists say every decade in Gujarat has seen prolonged agitation and each liberating new forces

and tapping dormant sentiments. The water movement related to Narmada and Sardar Sarovar project was

one such stir. In this, they say, Medha Patkar is seen as a blatant 'anti-Gujarat'.


The explanation is -- who needs a 'friend' when Modi has Rahul Gandhi and his misguided team in the

Congress.


The socio-political changes on ground compel political leaders and parties to "devise" processes and fashion

multi-pronged institutions to harness 'new vibrancy'. For BJP, both Late Keshubhai Patel and Narendra Modi

had played those 'agents' of social change.

Keshubhai used to tell Dalits - "If you are Dalit, I am also Dalit. If I am Patel you are also Patel...Because

we both are Hindus". This was in the 1990s and slowly such approaches broke the caste games in Gujarat

and Hindutva slowly emerged.

Modi played Hindutva and punctuated it with development. He also played Gujarati asmita -- a key factor in Gujarat

politics for the last 10-15 years. He dubbed Congress - ironically a party of Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Patel - as anti-Gujarati.


 This worked so well that today - Sardar Patel is seemingly a pro-BJP Hindutva icon. Modi's powerful phrases 'Mia Musharraf'

and 'Sonia ben' made a huge impact and Congress had no clue to counter these.


Of course by 2014-15, the Congress was back in the game with Patidar politics. Fortunately Dalits were also

wooed and also Thakors. But there was no consistency and once Ahmed Patel expired, the Congress lost even

a figment of imagination to try new experiments.


"The worst of all in our list of mistakes is 2022 indifferent shown by the Congress high command. It was a case

of criminal negligence," says the Muslim Congress leader. 


Minute analyses of socio-political battles in Gujarat could lead to diagnosis of some of the malady.


Old timers in Ahmedabad say Navnirman Movement was another major factor in Gujarat politics. 


It had played havoc with the party system. People like Keshubhai Patel and Narendra Modi understood

these better. Both had played individual-centric politics keeping the broad Hindutva base alongside.


This had in the past also led to a new characteristic of Gujarat politics. Madhavsinh Solanki successfully played KHAM 

(Kshatriya, Harjan, Adivasi and Muslim) card but it was all his show. At later stages, Congress lost ground

because Congress high command did not allow a major face to emerge.


Sonia Gandhi experimented with Veghela - but he was a RSS man at the end of the day.


Organisational loyalty especially in the Congress camp, obedience and discipline took a beating. At local

level MLAs and other leaders could change positions and pretensions overnight and they did not invite any

electoral punishment - provided they went with the right leaders. Unfortunately for Congress, they did not

have a popular face locally. Amarsinh Chaudhary was a tribal but a meek leader who was 'imposed'

from Delhi during the Rajiv Gandhi-Arun Nehru era. He thought blind sycophancy was his best quality.


Thus, obviously Modi and Keshubhai Patel attracted leaders and followers like any fairy tale.


But Solanki's over dependence on the KHAM fetched initial dividends. This also gradually alienated upper castes

and Brahmins, Patels and Banias from Congress. 


At the national level came Mandal politics. In Gujarat, Solanki had won 149 seats in the 1985 polls.


"Gujarat politics was again headed for a transition....The anti-reservation sentiment was pushed by RSS,

alienated Patels and also the Gujarati press...Slowly it turned communal also as BJP launched Rath

Yatra and in the national politics Ayodhya Movement made waves. Things simply changed," says analyst

Basant Ray.


However, he hastened to add in all these that Congress was still a powerful political force. Therefore the so-called

Third Front party of Janata Politics never survived for long.


But in the 2022 polls, the Congress went away from the scene and now it remains to be seen whether AAP is a factor. The Patidars would have a large say in the game of the AAP; and hence the BJP did play its card when Bhupendra Patel was made the Chief Minister.


ends 






Rahul woos voters in 'BJP's weak spot' Saurashtra and Surat region 



Rajkot/Surat


Better late than never!  The Congress is finally in its combative mood -- so essential to weaken 'Modi Magic' in the Prime Minister's native state of Gujarat.

Electioneering has picked up in Gujarat even as hardly a week is left for campaigning for the first phase of polls on December 1.


Congress 'star campaigner' and Bharat Jodo protagonist Rahu Gandhi
addressed two public rallies on Monday (Nov 21) as part of the party's campaign and ridiculed what  he said the BJP follows a "corruption, nepotism and commission model".


Sensing the general mood he spoke on the Morbi Bridge collapse tragedy and said no action has been taken 
against the "real culprits" while the helpless security guard has been put behind bars.
He alleged that the BJP follows a "corruption and commission model".
He also dwelt on issues related to farmers' loans, tribal welfare and unemployment.
In Rajkot, the Saurashtra heartland, Gandhi said while watchmen who were posted at the site of the 
accident were arrested and jailed, no action was taken against the real culprits. 
He suggested probably nothing would happen to the real culprits of the tragedy as they have 
a "good relationship with BJP".

The Morbi bridge collapse certainly would haunt BJP and its hyped Good Governance model.

The former Congress president also said that farmers have told him that their loans of Rs 50,000 to Rs 1 lakh 
are not waived off by the state government but the loans amounting to crores of the "three to four richest figures in 
India" are waived off.

"If the farmers don’t return the loans, they are called defaulters, but if the crorepatis do the same, it’s called 
non-performing assets and no action is taken against them," said Rahul Gandhi.

In 2017 assembly polls, the agrarian Saurashtra region had played havoc for the BJP and forced it's strength to
go below 100 -- that is 99. In 201, the BJP had won as many as 115 seats.

In 2017, riding on the support of the Patidar movement and also encashing the distress of groundnut and cotton growers, the Congress could add seats around Amreli and also Somnath, Talala, and Kodinar to its kitty.


Four key seats of Dhari, Lathi, Savarkundla and Rajula seats in Amreli district also went to Congress.






Importantly, the BJP's defeat came five years back in the prestigious Somnath seat wherein Jasha Barad, the sitting BJP MLA and a minister, was humbled by Congress nominee Vimal Chudasama. 



The Congress successfully dislodged the BJP from Amreli district - winning all five seats. The BJP nominees were humbled in three seats in neighbouring Gir Somnath district.


Thus, observers say though belated Rahul Gandhi's visit and campaign trail to Rajkot on Monday, Nov 21
was crucial.

"Even in 2022, we will do well in the Saurashtra region," says a Congress leader, Bobbhai Parmar in Rajkot.

He adds, "Saurashtra region will yet again pose a herculean task for the BJP as the saffron party faces 
infighting, ineffective political management and of course overall misgovernance". 

Though putting up a brave face, BJP poll strategists at the local level in places like Amreli say
the Saurashtra region "encompassing 11 districts made all the difference in 2017 elections as out of the 16 seats 
loss for the BJP from the 2012 tally of 115, as many as 13 of them came from the Saurashtra region.

Congress workers in the Lathi area say the Patidar parents are in dilemma. They want children to become doctors
and engineers. But all seats are reserved for others. The crop insurance also failed to address farmers' problems.

Moreover, in Amreli district, with about 45-50 per cent of the population being Patidars and about 8-10 per cent Muslims, the 
Congress knows there are "inherent advantages". 
 
Speaking in Surat, Rahul Gandhi focused on tribals and said the BJP wants to marginalise them by calling 
them "forest-dwellers" but the Congress party wants to give all the rights to the tribals as they are 
the "owners of the country". 
He also compared the work of the two parties on NREGA and said the Congress government brought the scheme 
for tribals and gave employment to all but the "BJP came and took away the land of tribals and scammed NREGA".

Five years back in 2017, the BJP faced tough questions and hence stiff electoral competition in South Gujarat and
Surat region. Though in the ultimate, the BJP did well in Surat city and won all 12 seats, the 'latent anguish'
against joblessness and GST prevails.
The issue was hotly debated and Rahul Gandhi had even dubbed the GST as the 'Gabbar Singh Tax'. 
 
Gujarat’s richest city Surat's textile and diamond traders shut down markets protesting the imposition of the
new tax norms. But when the results came in of the 16 seats in Surat district, the Congress could win just one.
Things were for delight of poll strategists and systematic campaigners like the then Finance Minister
Arun Jaitley, now deceased.

The Congress feels there were local booth management problems.

But in 2022 polls, the AAP is likely to be a major factor in Surat and other seats in South Gujarat.

Thus, closer scrutiny of voters' mood in the region suggest
seats like Varachha, Surat West and Katargam would be important in this year's polls.

In Katargam, the Patidars and OBC voters are key players and so the BJP is cautious and has hence fielded 
its sitting MLA and minister of state Vinu Moradia. He will be pitted against AAP's state president Gopal Italia among others. 

In Varachha, the BJP has decided to renominate Kumar Kanani (sitting MLA) in this
Patidar-dominated seat. 

"Some calculations are necessary, and all issues have been handled well by the BJP," says a local trader.

Of course, this region is most likely set to see a three-way tussle as the newcomer AAP had won all the 
municipal corporation ward seats in Varachha. Moreover, AAP's candidate will be PAAS Convener Alpesh Kathiria.
The PAAS had led the Patidar reservation stir in 2015.

Similarly, the BJP has repeated MLA Purnesh Modi in Surat West.

But in another Patidar stronghold Kamrej, the BJP has replaced V D Zalawadia
and instead shown confidence in Praful Panseria. Among other seats in South Gujarat, BJP is yet again fielding
minister of state for home Harsh Sanghavi from Majura. The party had won the seat in 2017 by a big margin.

In Limbayat, also part of Surat, Sangeeta Patil will be BJP candidate. She had won the seat in 2017 and also
in 2012.

In Surat East, while the AIMIM has fielded a candidate, the Congress too will be banking on
minority voters. Here too, the BJP's nominee is Arvind Shantilal Rana, a sitting member.

In 2017, Rana had trounced Congress leader Nitin Bharucha by a margin of 13,347 votes.

Wrap up:

Gujarat elections are often reflections of socio-political churning. The Patidar agitation should be
seen from that prism.

Prior to that the state saw so-called 'Hindu unity' and polarisation politics. In the past -- the eighties
was a decade of caste mobilisation.
But it is also a given fact that though labeled as 'Hindutva laboratory', the Congress party has always enjoyed
a considerable support base. Even during the peak of 2002 riots and Hindu polarisation, the Congress
vote share was not negligible.
Narendra Modi and his 'Moditva' phenomenon though hyped faced a lot of hardships. The same challenge
was seen in 2007 also.

Monday, November 21, 2022

Civil Societies churning identify 'faultlines' in Naga peace talks

"Let us make no mistake" - say some 

New Delhi



What has really 'delayed' the Naga peace process especially at the most decisive and the last phase ?

Does Status Quo suit some stakeholders and even a section of Babudom in Delhi? 

What should be 'ideally' the roles of an elected state government and state legislators in the entire bargain? 

Some of these questions figured prominently at a meeting of NGOs and civil societies in Dimapur on Friday, Nov 18.








The general refrain is in a situation such as these in Nagaland, the democratic and civil voice is of "paramount importance" at both the stages -- pre-Solution and even post-solution scenario.

  
Next few questions could be: What is the timing for playing 'facilitators'? Does any resignation by an MLA count after everything is worked out between the Centre and underground militants?


So far there is no written statement yet from the participants. The joke is 'Himanta inspired Lahe Lahe kaam choli asey'.

Bravo NDPP's love and dependence on Himanta ?


In 1998-99 when the Vajpayee government was in power, senior officials used to often say one big demerit of the 1997 Naga ceasefire was that it "lacked clear definition". 


"There were no written terms and conditions and it was merely based on an understanding....But 

worse before announcing the ceasefire as PM I K Gujral never even meet NSCN-IM leaders," the official

had said.


According to reports the Naga People's Action Committee (NPAC) is back in action but at quite a snail

and cautious pace. "Let us not make any mistake...," a key NPAC leader had told this writer in October.


Some civil society leaders are keen to impress upon Prime Minister Narendra Modi once again that 'delay'

on the Naga peace solution is no longer a sign of 'patience'.  


Perhaps -- its weakness; and it could be still revolving around 'cowardice, greed and indecisiveness'.


Of course leaders of Nagaland Tribes Council (NTC), Central Nagaland Tribes Council (CNTC),

Nagaland Gaon Burrah Federation, Ex Parliamentarians forum and ACUT examined things

in details.


Apparently, the churning during the debate could identify a few faultlines. One observation

was that while the Naga movement has been a people's movement, it should not be

allowed to be hijacked by a few individuals and some group(s). If someone is taking

the people of Nagaland for a ride -- by throwing up lofty goals and quotable quotes -

It may now be time to say -- pack off. 


Insiders suggest the roles of Centre and also the state government headed by Neiphiu Rio

should be 'revisited' in the context of Naga peace talks. 


The general diagnosis so far is -- the Govt of India is not showing the much required political will.

PM Narendra Modi is known for his decisiveness and risk-taking approaches but is he being too

cautious on Nagaland?


This 'political will' is not merely casting of votes and counting them.


The Prime Minister now needs to handle things at his level and if some off the record briefing goes on

in Kohima -- things should be taken with a pinch of salt. In other words, 'Kohima players'

should not give the impression that great and serious parleys are on between the centre and a

Kohima-friendly outfit -- when probably nothing much is happening.


The truth of the matter is things are stalled as no Indian PM and the central government can

allow a separate Naga Constitution and Flag. Moreover, any 'tweaking' would violate basic

structure of the Indian Constitution and could be immediately called illegal !


So, we also get a glimpse of what kind of role a section of political leaders in the state are really planning. 

 

The Vajpayee government at the behest of overseas-travel loving interlocutor Padmanabhaiya 

had indulged in a flip-flop in 2001 when ceasefire was extended to all Naga inhabited areas.


Manipuris/Meiteis protested and 18 people were killed forcing the NDA government to withdraw

the new clauses.


That was a misadventure and a loss of face too for NDA-1. Prime Minister Narendra Modi knows 

these finer aspects and so hardly any elbow room to commit mistakes. 


Hence all precautions and go-slow theory even by India's most decisive and a 'gutsy' Prime Minister.


The reports that the ‘Federal Hoho’ as a concept finding enhanced acceptability in 2022 are encouraging for 

Nagas because it essentially enhances the possibility of an early solution.


The civil society should keep persisting pressures. 'March on' must now become a political mission

for NTC, NPAC and friends,

 

They will certainly have a more crucial role once Solution comes.


ends 


Indian Politics, Freedom struggle and History :::: Need Revisit :::: Even Quit India Movement 'resolution' by Congress sought to make .... "its fullest contribution towards realisation of human freedom in the world, which is in danger of being crushed"

Indian history has many features, many layered anecdotes where politics, trade, warfare, and culture intersect.  Long-distance ties shaped I...