Thursday, November 19, 2026

"Status of circulated competency papers, proposed Pan Naga Hoho, representation, permanent residency ... all must be explained without ambiguity" - say Naga citizens

Diseases are the same everywhere, diagnosis are not 


The Naga underground leaders and the Govt of India emissaries may be negotiating on behalf of the Naga people and others, but the consequences of the final settlement will be carried by the common people both in Nagaland state and beyond and also the country by and large. 



That is why the public must not remain silent or uninformed. 


"The Government of India and the Naga negotiating groups must place clear information before the people. The status of the circulated competency papers, the proposed Pan Naga Hoho, the question of representation, permanent residency, recruitment, land and the future of the present State must be explained without ambiguity," says Atoke B. Aye in his article to a local newspaper.  









There are merits in Mr Atoke's argument.  He raises a few fundamental issues. 

The spirit of 'Naga unity' and a broad larger family is not rejected by him.


"I am not suggesting that Nagas from other areas should be denied opportunities. But our own youth should not be placed at a disadvantage in their own State. 


Before accepting any common service arrangement, the recruitment rules, eligibility conditions, reservation and promotion policies must be made clear to the public. Otherwise, a proposal that appears beneficial on paper could create uncertainty for the very people whose future it is supposed to protect.  



Permanent residency: Who will qualify and what rights will it bring?," he says.  



The Naga talks must be 'seen' with a closer lens from some of these perspectives.  









The writer further states:


"For the people of Nagaland, land is not merely property. It is connected to our villages, clans, customary practices, identity and inheritance. Article 371A provides important constitutional protection concerning religious and social practices of the Nagas, Naga customary law and procedure, administration of civil and criminal justice involving customary law, and ownership and transfer of land and its resources. 


Any proposed political or administrative arrangement must therefore explain clearly how these protections will continue to operate.


The 2017 Status Paper contains proposals concerning the constitutional and administrative arrangements for Nagaland, including the proposed Tatar Hoho and changes relating to Article 371A. 

These are proposals in the Status Paper, not provisions of the short signed Agreed Position itself. 


"The 2020 competency paper also proposes new governing and council structures with separate powers and responsibilities. The public must know exactly how such arrangements would relate to the existing State Government, village councils, tribal institutions and the protections already enjoyed by the people."


Atoke raises a few questions : Who will have the final authority over land and natural resources? 


Will decisions concerning our land remain with the people and institutions whose customary rights are protected? 


Now comes a few more critical areas of a larger debate. 


Should no less than the Govt of India also forget .. how the talks process progressed "especially during the stint of R N Ravi" as the interlocutor ? 


The need for an inclusive approach and to pave way for the future of the coming generations was a thought process that the Naga Tribes Council (NTC) had mooted. This brought all like minded "minds" to form a common platform. In subsequent developments came in the Agreed Position. This document had a simple language but clearer mandate. 




The paper inked on Nov 17, 2017 stated: ".... the two entities (GoI and NNPGs) have agreed to work out the details of a relationship that is honourable, enduring and an inclusive peace co-existence with due regard to contemporary realities". 



This was to keep the document as practical and also as candid as possible. It was also underlined that New Delhi had "invited" NNPGs to have a holistic approach. 


But whether new troubles and a new set set of complications are now being added. 


 









Are stakeholders 'forcefully or deliberately' diluting their political stance and bringing in elements - who are better known as business operators and 'a lesser' player in social activism. What is the design ? 



Perhaps it is not properly understood. The creation of FNTA is a proof that governance and developmental activities did not show expected results even between 2018 and 2026. That's a pretty long period for a Double Engine Sarkar. The BJP may ignore this. But the RSS should not. 


The Sanghparivar fountainhead Mohan Bhagwat is in Manipur. Should he drop in to nearby Nagaland too ? On Sept 10, veteran S C Jamir did one of the durable steps of his career - when he met Mr Bhagwat. 


The loss of any community actually means reinforcing 'tendencies' towards factionalism. This is accompanied by complete collapse of collective responsibility. This phrase 'collective responsibility' by itself. More the modern day's development and socio-political games; each man or woman becomes an island of their own self-creation. Some days may slip into history almost unnoticed. But their significance will be revealed only with the passage of time. 


A few days in the calendar - mid-November - might have been such a period. Those who did the damage may escape scrutiny. But the future is often a stage for the ghost of the past.







Chanakya - Should never be underestimated 





ends 


No comments:

Post a Comment

How someone 'accused' and once arrested by NIA attend a meet organised by Ministry of External Affairs ??? ::: "National security and accountability matter"

"Reports that C A Rauf, former Popular Front of India ( PFI) state secretary arrested by the NIA and booked under UAPA in 2022, attende...