Saturday, February 29, 2020

MEA on Joint Declaration b/w Afghan and US Govts; signing of US-Taliban pact in Doha


 India's Ambassador to Qatar P Kumaran represented the country at the signing of the landmark peace deal between the US and the Afghan Taliban in Doha on Feb 29, 2020. 



India's decision marks a major shift in the policy. India was invited for the signing-in ceremony by the Qatar government. It is for the first time New Delhi sent an official representative to an event involving the Taliban.

In November 2018, however, India had sent two former diplomats in "non-official" capacity to a conference on Afghan peace process in Moscow. 

Diplomats from a number of countries including Pakistan, Turkey and Indonesia were present during signing of the deal which marks end of the United States' war in Afghanistan since 2001.

Friday, February 28, 2020

Hands of Time Machine have taken a full circle --- Focus on 'Mayhem of 2002 and Riots 2020'?


(I had landed in Ahmedabad by an early morning Indian Airlines flight on Feb 28, 2002 - a day after Godhra railway station inferno....covered 2002 riots in Gujarat extensively for Press Trust of India)


Snap of Sept 13, 2013: When BJP declare Modi as PM Candidate


(have two books on the subject --- Godhra - A Journey To Mayhem and 'Godhra - Journey of a Prime Minister')


People in general seemed to have developed a complaint against his regime for farmers’ distress, joblessness and economic policies – a combine of GST and demonetisation - that has actually led to choking of cash flow. People's expectations were too high from Narendra Modi and his promises were higher !

The more things change, the more they remain the same! 

On February 27, 2002, eighteen years back, the Godhra railway station mayhem took place killing 59 Hindus returning from Ayodhya. This set Gujarat ablaze in a frenzy of violent Hindu-Muslim conflict killing an estimated 2000 people, and mostly Muslims.


The Hindutva-infected Gujarat, Narendra Modi-led administration and mayhem -- had become an unholy trinity. Mr Modi was denied US Visa in 2005. 


There was assumption and allegation as well that the violence that rocked Gujarat --- something for which he ought to bore personal responsibility.


The hands of time machine seemed to have full circle. Feb 27 and circa 2020 --- riots is again the global headline and Narendra Modi is now the elected Prime Minister of India.

There is a big commonality or difference yet again as now in carca 2020 as against the 2005 Visa row.

This time around, President Donald Trump has his own reasons and aptitude to reflect faith in Modi's words of assurances on "religious freedom".

Trump said: “I will say the Prime Minister (Modi) was incredible on what he said (about religious freedom)... He wants people to have religious freedom very strongly.” 
The US President did not want to embarrass his host-in-chief  Narendra Modi.

Notably, Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders has flayed Donald Trump and tweeted:
"Over 200 million Muslims call India home. Widespread anti-Muslim mob violence has killed at least 27 and injured many more. Trump responds by saying, "That's up to India." This is a failure of leadership on human rights."

Revisiting the past is not without pitfalls. To talk of 2002 mayhem, are we glorifying a wrong?

"....the ethnic violence in Delhi has drawn comparisons with two of India's worst sectarian riots in living memory.
Nearly 3,000 people were killed in anti-Sikh riots in the capital in 1984 after the then prime minister Indira Gandhi was assassinated by her Sikh bodyguards. And in 2002, more than 1,000 people, mostly Muslims, died after a train fire killed 60 Hindu pilgrims in Gujarat - Mr Modi was then the chief minister of the state," says a BBC report.

On Wednesday, the Delhi High Court hearing petitions about the latest violence in the capital has said it cannot let "another 1984" happen on its "watch".
But politics and time moves on. BJP and Narendra Modi supporters have always maintained that they stood by the
wishes of the majority.
Of course these have helped the BJP to win elections and also expand the party base across India.

Moreover, it is not without good reason that a section of Modi-detractors of 2002 seemed to have reconciled and thus Ram Vilas Paswan - who had quit the Vajpayee government - is today Prime Minister Modi's co-partner in the development yatra as his ministerial colleague.

In fact, in relation to 2002 riots and subsequent politics at the national level, a Germany-based Indian scholar
Subrata K Mitra of Heidelberg University says: “The impressive victory of the BJP under Narendra Modi raises a fundamental question about governance, leadership and the imperative of development and the making of popular will”.


Mitra further points out -“The more the ‘secularists’ of India and their foreign backers hit out at Modi as a tainted leader, the more Modi fell back on his identification with the people of Gujarat and his showcasing of Gujarat’s development as the raison d’e^tre of his leadership”.


It is said Prime Minister excels in gauging public mood very well. And as they say, - a leader is after all a creation of his own people.

Come back to Delhi violence of 2020, it is true the BJP had largely banked on a polarising campaign to win just concluded Delhi polls.

Some of their leaders including Union MoS Finance Anurag Thakur and a sitting Delhi lawmaker Parvesh Verma have been pulled up by the Election Commission, but there were no FIRs from police.
Apparently, the top leadership allowed the hate speech politics. Another leader Kapil Mishra tried to attack Shaheen Bagh protest calling it work of traitors.

"BJP leader Kapil Mishra had openly given a call for forcibly removing the protesters from various sites. Detailed reports and video images are available of the highly provocative and communal slogans given by groups of men armed with lathis and bricks in the areas surrounding the protest sites. A journalist’s account is graphic evidence of the communal nature of the mobilization by groups to disrupt and attack the protest sites," CPI-M leader Brinda Karat said in her letter to Home Minister Amit Shah.

Such allegations were widely reported in 2002 also. Congress leader Digvijaya Singh also says
there is a similarity between 2002 Gujarat mayhem and the fresh violence in Delhi.
The death toll has risen to 34 already and two of the deceased are a police man Ratan Lall and an Intelligence Bureau staffer Ankit Sharma, but it is presumed most casualty include Muslims only.

The Congress party has decided to step up campaign for ouster of Amit Shah as the Home Minister for his "inability" to deal with the violence.

In a memorandum to President Ram Nath Kovind, the Congress party has said both the centre and the newly elected AAP regime have remained "silent spectators" as Delhi streets were on fire.

"Rashtrapati ji you are given the highest possible responsibility under the Constitution of India: to act as the conscience
keeper of this Government and to remind it of its Constitutional duty and the pillars of Raj Dharma,
by which any just government must abide," the Congress said in its memorandum.

In 2002 yet again, the then Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee had asked the then Gujarat Chief Minister Modi to uphold Raj Dharma -- the ethics of governance.

In the words of constitutional expert Subhash Kashyap, Modi does not have 'excuse' for failure.
Expectations were high in 2014 and also in 2019. The mandate of 2014 had less to do with the Hindutva agenda, but returning to power in 2019 - the Modi regime has abrogated the special status of Jammu and Kashmir, the only Muslim majority state.

His government seems to be more than keen for building of a Ram temple at Ayodhya - of course armed with a favourable mandate from the Supreme Court.

Under PM Modi, people of India have experienced unfulfilled electoral promises about job creation.

A hardcore populist, but his administration has  provided over a steep economic downturn.

According to a large number of BJP supporters in West Bengal -- where the saffron party is emerging as a strong force - the major apprehension is PM Modi should not turn out to be like 'Chief Minister Jyoti Basu' --- whose initial years have seen atime of great expectations; but the end marred by disillusionment with Marxism and a stint (after him under Buddhadeb Bhattacharya) scandalously belied. 

May b it can b called ...#Congressmukt LUNCH : Amit Shah, Mamata hav lunch at Odisha CM's residence, Nitish also joins !


In a tweet, Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik said, “Such a pleasure having the company of Union Home Minister @Amit Shah ji, my colleague CMs, @MamataOfficial, @NitishKumar ji & Union Minister @dpradhanbjp ji at Naveen Niwas. Had a wonderfully interactive time over some home cooked #Odia delicacies.”


Amit Shah and Mamata Banerjee --- meeting for the first time since September 2019 meetig in Delhi and first time since CAA row - sat facing each other across the table.
All the key leaders were in Bhubaneswar for the Eastern Zonal Council meeting.

As expected, there was no official word on what was talked about during the meal !!

Does the snap of Amit Shah and Mamata sharing a lunch indicate about a possible scale down in their attacks on each other?

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Doval takes charge of Delhi law and order !!

India slams USCIRF comments on Delhi violence


In response to a media query regarding comments made on recent incidents of violence in Delhi, MEA spokesperson Raveesh Kumar said:

"We have seen comments made by USCIRF, sections of the media and a few individuals regarding recent incidents of violence in Delhi. These are factually inaccurate and misleading, and appear to be aimed at politicising the issue. Our law enforcement agencies are working on the ground to prevent violence and ensure restoration of confidence and normalcy. Senior representatives of the Government have been involved in that process. Prime Minister has publicly appealed for peace and brotherhood. We would urge that irresponsible comments are not made at this sensitive time. "


In what is seen as a clear indication that the role of Delhi police in controlling violence was found 'wanting', Prime Minister's Office on Wednesday took charge of affairs and National Security Advisor Ajit Doval was directed to take control of the situation.

Sources said Doval, a former IB chief, was mandated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah after Mr Modi held a detailed review of the situation. The Cabinet Committee on Security was also briefed in details during the day as the violence that was triggered coinciding with President Donald Trump's visit has claimed at least 20 lives.


While two of them include an Intelligence Bureau driver Ankit Sharma and a Delhi police head constable Rattan Lal, the rest are civilians.
Doval on Wednesday evening went around violence-hit Jafrabad area in north east Delhi and interacted with locals - mostly Muslims - trying to instill confidence.

"We are all with you....," said one Muslim youth as Doval tried to give patient hearing to him and others. Several locals in the area said Doval's visit has given them confidence.



Some of the lanes and bylanes he went around witnessed sporadic incidents of violence and stone pelting.

“Situation is totally under control. People are satisfied," NSA Ajit Doval says after visiting Delhi’s Jafrabad


"My message on this occasion is whoever loves his or country, will love his or her neighbour".

Some shopkeepers and women came out and tried to repose confidence in NSA.

Interacting with media persons and flanked by local citizenry, several of them Muslims, Doval said: "What has happened should be seen as a matter of past and peace will prevail. Everyone is doing their job to ensure peace".

Narendra Modi appeals for peace in Delhi


"Peace and harmony are central to our ethos. I appeal to my sisters and brothers of Delhi to maintain peace and brotherhood at all times. It is important that there is calm and normalcy is restored at the earliest."

"Had an extensive review on the situation prevailing in various parts of Delhi. Police and other agencies are working on the ground to ensure peace and normalcy." ---- PM Modi

US statement on UN Sanctions on ISIS-West Africa and ISIS-Greater Sahara


US statement on
United Nations 1267 Sanctions Committee Designation of ISIS-West Africa and ISIS-Greater Sahara


The United States welcomes the action taken by the United Nations Security Council’s 1267 al-Qa’ida and ISIL (Da’esh) Sanctions Committee on February 23 to add ISIS-West Africa (ISIS-WA) and ISIS-Greater Sahara (ISIS-GS) to its designations list.  The United States designated ISIS-WA and ISIS-GS as Foreign Terrorist Organizations under Section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act and Specially Designated Global Terrorists under Executive Order 13224 on May 23, 2018 and February 28, 2018, respectively.  ISIS-GS and ISIS-WA are the second and third ISIS affiliate designated by the UN.  ISIS-Khorasan was the first listed at the UN in May 2019.

ISIS-WA is responsible for killing hundreds of innocent civilians in dozens of attacks since its inception in 2015.  ISIS-GS has also carried out numerous attacks since its formation in 2015, including the October 2017 attack that killed four U.S. soldiers in Niger.  This UN designation obligates all member states to implement an arms embargo, a global travel ban, and asset freeze on ISIS-WA and ISIS-GS, actions that will cut the groups off from the resources they need to continue their terrorist activities.

This designation is a necessary step in the global fight to defeat ISIS.  Despite the complete liberation of ISIS-held territory in Iraq and Syria, ISIS affiliates around the world remain a significant terrorist threat, including in Africa, and the international community must work together to deny them the resources they seek.  The United States remains fully engaged with our African partners to address security challenges and to advance peace and security on the continent.

Tuesday, February 25, 2020

Joint Statement: Vision and Principles for India-U.S. Comprehensive Global Strategic Partnership

Issued at the end of two-day visit of Donald Trump
Add caption



The President of the United States of America, the Honorable Donald J. Trump, paid a State Visit to India on 24-25 February 2020, at the invitation of Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi.


Comprehensive Global Strategic Partnership


As the leaders of sovereign and vibrant democracies recognizing the importance of freedom, equal treatment of all citizens, human rights and a commitment to the rule of law, Prime Minister Modi and President Trump vowed to strengthen a India-U.S. Comprehensive Global Strategic Partnership, anchored in mutual trust, shared interests, goodwill and robust engagement of their citizens.


Prime Minister Modi and President Trump pledged to deepen defence and security cooperation, especially through greater maritime and space domain awareness and information sharing; joint cooperation; exchange of military liaison personnel; advanced training and expanded exercises between all services and special forces; closer collaboration on co-development and co-production of advanced defence components, equipment and platforms; and partnership between their defence industries.


Noting that a strong and capable Indian military supports peace, stability, and a rules-based order in the Indo-Pacific, and reaffirming his pledge to support the transfer to India of advanced U.S. military technology, President Trump welcomed India’s recent decision to procure MH-60R naval and AH-64E Apache helicopters. These capabilities will advance shared security interests, job growth and industrial cooperation between both countries. As India works to acquire new defence capabilities, President Trump reaffirmed India’s status as a Major Defense Partner affording it the highest consideration for procurement and technology transfer purposes. The leaders looked forward to early conclusion of defence cooperation enabling agreements including Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement.


Prime Minister Modi and President Trump resolved to enhance security of their homelands through cooperation and to jointly fight international crimes like human trafficking, terrorism and violent extremism, drug-trafficking and crimes in cyberspace. They welcomed the decision by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and India’s Ministry of Home Affairs to reinvigorate the Homeland Security Dialogue. As a demonstration of their shared commitment to combatting the threat that illicit drugs pose to their citizens, they announced their intent to establish a new Counter-Narcotics Working Group between their respective law enforcement agencies.

Prime Minister Modi and President Trump recognized the increasing importance of the trade and investment dimension of the India-United States relationship, and the need for long-term trade stability that will benefit both the American and Indian economies. They agreed to promptly conclude the ongoing negotiations, which they hope can become phase one of a comprehensive bilateral trade agreement that reflects the true ambition and full potential of the bilateral commercial relations, advancing prosperity, investment, and job creation in both countries.


Prime Minister Modi and President Trump welcomed growing links between India and the United States in trade and investment in hydrocarbons. Through their Strategic Energy Partnership, India and the United States are seeking to enhance energy security, expand energy and innovation linkages across respective energy sectors, bolster strategic alignment, and facilitate increased engagement between industry and other stakeholders. 

Prime Minister Modi and President Trump noted the potential for the U.S. to meet India’s goal to diversify its import base for coking/metallurgical coal and natural gas, welcoming recent commercial arrangements intended to accelerate access to LNG in the Indian market. 


Prime Minister Modi and President Trump encouraged the Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited and Westinghouse Electric Company to finalize the techno-commercial offer for the construction of six nuclear reactors in India at the earliest date.
Prime Minister Modi and President Trump expressed satisfaction with their longstanding and practical collaboration in science, technology and innovation. 

They welcomed an endeavour by Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) and National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) for development and launch in 2022 of a joint mission with the world’s first dual-frequency Synthetic Aperture Radar satellite, and applauded discussions that advance cooperation in Earth observation, Mars and planetary exploration, heliophysics, human spaceflight, and commercial space cooperation.

Monday, February 24, 2020

CAA did not come up: "On religious freedom....there was appreciation on both sides that pluralism and diversity are the common binding factor"


Seven people die in Delhi arson, Trump-Modi avoid CAA reference

New Delhi,  At least seven people including a police personnel died in fresh incidents of stone-pelting and arson in the national capital even as the turmoil and chaos coincided with the visit of US President Donald Trump.
However, according to Foreign Secretary Harsh Vardhan Shringla, thecontroversial CAA row did not figure at the bilateral talks between Trump and his Indianhost Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Talking to reporters, he said the CAA issue "did not come up" at the talks but added: "...with regard the term religious freedom.....here I think there was appreciation on both sides that pluralism and diversity are the common binding factor of both countries".



On Monday, sporadic incidents of violence claimed several lives and
left over 100 injured in several parts of Northeast Delhi. Clashes had
erupted in Maujpur, Chandbagh, Khureji Khas and Bhajanpura areas of
Northeast Delhi on Sunday and it spilled over to Monday as well.

On Tuesday, Union Home Minister Amit Shah held a meeting with Delhi Lt
Governor Anil Baijal and Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal among others.
On Monday night after his return from Ahmedabad - where he was for
'Namaste Trump' event, Shah was briefed by
Union Home Secretary Ajay Bhalla and Intelligence Bureau (IB) chief
Arvind Kumar.

Shah also met Delhi Police Commissioner Amulya Patnaik and reviewed
the law and order situation.

Chief Minister Kejriwal said he is "very worried" about the prevailing
situation in certain parts of Delhi. In a tweet, the chief minister
also urged everyone to shun violence.

On Monday, MoS Home G Kishan Reddy said there was 'conspiracy' behind
triggering the violence coinciding with Trump's visit.

Answering questions at the media briefing, Foreign Secretary Shringla
said --- on Kashmir:
"We (both sides) did share the fact that there has been a great deal
of positive developments in the state. Recently we had two groups of
envoys visiting Jammu and Kashmir including ambassador Ken Juster of
the United States. The sense is that focus is now on development, how
to attract tourism to J&K and that things are moving in the right
direction".

On Trade talks between PM Modi and the visiting President, Shringla:
".....bring that (talks) to closure...So we are talking about it as
soon as possible, providing a legal basis to the sticks and concluding
this round of negotiations. Following which, the intention of the two
leaders is to facilitate the commencement of the negotiations for a
larger inverted commas 'Big Deal'.

With regard Pakistan, Shringla said: "....There was clearly a sensethat the issues cross border terrorism, the issues of ensuringaccountability (with regard financial support to terror bodies)...theissue of narcotics, ....issues that concern India were certainlyraised and discussed. And I think, in this context, clearly - concernswere put out on the table .....but you will appreciate that thesediscussions did take place in a restricted format and so I cannot saybeyond these".


Meanwhile, a senior police official Satish Golcha said: "We will be
detaining the miscreants and taking legal action against them. People
should cooperate with us to maintain peace. We are here till the
situation normalises".

Police said person who opened fire on Monday has been identified as Shahrukh.

The CPI-M in a letter to Home Minister Shah said there could presence
of 'criminal elements' in the violence in Delhi.



CAA issue "did not come up" at talks between PM Narendra Modi and President Donald Trump, says Foreign Secretary Harsh Vardhan Shringla at a special briefing here !!

"But with regard the term religious freedom.....here I think there was appreciation on both sides that pluralism and diversity are the common binding factor of both countries...."

On Kashmir:

"We (both sides) did share the fact that there has been a great deal of positive developments in the state. Recently we had two groups of envoys visiting Jammu and Kashmir including ambassador Ken Juster of the United States. The sense is that focus is now on development, how to attract tourism to J&K and that things are moving in the right direction".


On Trade talks between PM Narendra Modi and President Donald Trump:

Foreign Secretary Harsh Vardhan Shringla: ".....bring that (talks) to closure...So we are talking about it as soon as possible, providing a legal basis to the sticks and concluding this round of negotiations. Following which, the intention of the two leaders is to facilitate the commencement of the negotiations for a larger inverted commas 'Big Deal'".

"...If you ask me the difference between the first and the second -- the package and the Big Deal is that whatever we do under MFN but the Big Deal will be based on Bilateral agreements between two countries.
In other words, if we look at mutual tariff concessions then it will be extended to each countries and not for other trading partners. That is the unique aspect".

Violence in Delhi::: Trump Visit Timing raises questions

New Delhi:


On a day, India threw up a grand welcome to the visiting US President Donald Trump at Ahmedabad and Agra, there were violence and arson over the highly controversial Citizenship Amendment law. 


“We are in support of the CAA. If they want to protest, they should go somewhere else,” one pro-CAA protester said. 

Hundreds of people supporting the new law clashed with those opposing it. There was stone pelting from both sides. At times there were even chanting of 'Jai Shri Ram'slogans.



Lt Governor Anil Baijal said on Twitter, "Instructed @DelhiPolice and @CPDelhi to ensure that law and order is maintained in North East Delhi. The situation is being closely monitored". 

He urged everyone to exercise restraint for maintenance of peace and harmony.




President Trump was in Ahmedabad and Agra on the first day of his visit and would be in Delhi or the vital diplomatic engagements on Tuesday, Feb 25.
But some parts of Delhi have witnessed violence and arson. Importantly, the national capital is also dotted with several half-finished construction projects stalled due to multiple reasons including disappearing funding, as they put it.



Delhi minister and Babarpur MLA Gopal Rai also urged the people in the area to maintain peace.

Clashes broke out on Sunday evening, Feb 23, between pro and anti-CAA groups near Jaffrabad over blocking of the road.


BJP leader Kapil Mishra demanded that police remove the anti-CAA protestors within three days.


In the violence on Monday, a Delhi Police head constable was killed and a deputy commissioner of police injured as clashes over the amended citizenship law broke out again in northeast Delhi's Jaffrabad and Maujpur. Violence between groups supporting and opposing the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA) was also reported in the Chandbagh and Bhajanpura areas as well.


The deceased cop is Ratan Lal, a head constable attached to the office of the ACP Gokalpuri.

There was heavy stone pelting in Maujpur. Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal urged the Centre to restore law and order in the national capital.

"Very distressing news regarding disturbance of peace and harmony in parts of Delhi coming in. I sincerely urge Hon'ble LG n Hon'ble Union Home Minister to restore law and order n ensure that peace and harmony is maintained. Nobody should be allowed to orchestrate flagrations (sic)," Kejriwal tweeted.


Taj Mahal Inspires awe --- Trump at Agra



Henry Kissinger once quipped that "it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal." That may be how Modi detractors would like to caution the country!!


"Your magnificent country.....we will always remember your hospitality" - Trump at Ahmedabad


"The Taj Mahal inspires awe, a timeless testament to the rich and diverse beauty of Indian culture! Thank you, India" -- Trump 
       (heartfelt note in the visitor's book at the Taj Mahal)




"Trump basked in the raucous reception that has eluded him on many foreign trips, some of which have featured massive protests and icy handshakes from world leaders. In India, he instead received a warm embrace — literally — from the ideologically aligned and hug-loving Prime Minister Narendra Modi." --- report in Pakistani paper website -- 'Dawn'

Namoste Trump: US Prez speech - a setback to SICKULARISTS, MODI-BASHERS

Trump speech - a setback to SICKULARISTS, MODI-BASHERS



Congress leader Manish Tewari flayed US President Donald Trump for not mentioning Mahatma Gandhi in the visitor book of Sabarmati Ashram and instead praising Modi and called him “great friend” (PM Modi) and called his tour a “wonderful visit”
“This is a snapshot of the note that someone sent. It ostensibly is @realDonaldTrumps note at Sabarmati. No mention of the Great Mahatma. Does he even know who Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi was?” Manish Tewari wrote while tweeting the pictures of the visitor book.


tRUMP'S address had no mention of the protests that had hit India over the new Citizenship Amendment Act, which provides a fast track to naturalisation for migrants - including Hindus, Christians and Buddhists who entered India while fleeing religious persecution !!


But the law -- excludes Muslims. The new law has raised fears that the world's largest democracy is moving toward a religious citizenship test !! 

In Ahmedabad,


Trump opened his speech by declaring that he traveled 8,000 miles to deliver the message that “America loves India, America respects India and America will always be faithful and loyal friends to the Indian people”.

He said PM Narendra Modi is a “tremendously successful leader” who has transformed India !!

(After the Nameste Trump programme, President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump left for Agra to enjoy the tourist attraction and one of the seven wonders - the majestic Taj Mahal.)

The US President heaped praises on PM Narendra Modi calling him an "exceptional leader" who works day and night !! 

Narendra Modi hailed President Trump's leadership in fighting the menace of global terrorism.
Trump says all Indians --Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Jews, rich and poor -- must take pride in glories of past and bright future



Modi is a "living proof" of what an Indian can achieve with hard work: Donald Trump 

Placards, banners and billboards with slogans hailing Indo-US relations and having pictures of Trump and Modi walking together, shaking hands, and waving at the crowd during the 'Howdy Modi' in Houston dotted across Ahmedabad, Prime Minister Modi's original political laboratory of a right synthesis between as a crusader of Hindutva polity and a catalyst of development and change !!



Prime Minister WELCOMED visiting guests at the airport. 

In Ahmedabad, Trump visited Mahatma Gandhi's Sabarmati Ashram and took part in a roadshow with Modi and jointly addressed over one lakh people at the newly constructed spacious cricket stadium.

Trump is accompanied by daughter Ivanka, son-in-law Jared Kushner and several top guns in his administration.


Dance groups and singers from different parts of the country performed on stages that are dotting the 22- km route of the 'India roadshow'. 


In his speech, Modi said: "The name of this program - Namaste -- it has a very deep meaning... It is one of the oldest languages in the world, a Sanskrit word. Its sense is that not only the person, but also the divinity within him".


Modi had good words for the work First Lady Melania Trump also and said -- "First Lady Melania Trump, it is an honour to have you here. What you have done for a healthy and happy America is getting good results. What you are doing for the children in the society is admirable". 


Modi said, "You say: Be Best! You must have felt that the same sentiment of people is being expressed in today''s reception."

In his address, Trump praised Modi's leadership and said both India and the US shared much !!

"There is so much that we share: Values and ideals, spirit of enterprise and innovation, opportunities and challenges, hopes and aspirations," Modi said.
Connecting the United States and India through two statues -- the Statues of Liberty and the Statue of Unity, PM Modi smartly positioned India as a nation that has much in common with the United States.


"US and India are committed to stopping terrorists and fight their ideology. For this reason, since taking office, my administration is working in a very positive way with Pakistan to crack down on terrorist organisations and militants which operate on the Pakistani border," said Trump.


Sunday, February 23, 2020

Well, the politician who had called Trump an 'insurgent' was -- India-born Aruna Miller, then a US Democrat delegate



"India looks forward to welcoming @POTUS @realDonaldTrump. It is an honour that he will be with us tomorrow, starting with the historic programme in Ahmedabad," Modi wrote on Twitter.


PM responded to a tweet from Gujarat Chief Minister Vijay Rupani that "entire Gujarat speaks in one voice- #NamasteTrump".




Do you know the India-born US politician who called Trump - an insurgent ?

(As the stage is set for US President Donald Trump's visit to India and that also coinciding with his electioneering season, let us take a closer look at circa 2016 when two other American politicians had visited India -- that also months ahead of US presidential polls and recalls one Democrat leader calling Trump an 'insurgent' !)


Well, the politician who had called Trump an 'insurgent' was -- India-born Aruna Miller, then a US Democrat delegate (equivalent to India’s legislator – member of a state legislative assembly) from
Maryland.

"In our party (Democrats), the super delegate system allows screening of candidates for the US presidential polls. I wish Republican also had similar system. Our Democratic Party has a system of super delegates. Republicans do not have this. If they had Super delegate mechanism, I don't think their candidate would have been an insurgent like Donald Trump," Hyderabad-born Aruna Miller had said in an interaction at the American Center Library, New Delhi.

Sept 22, 2019, Houston 

In American politics, 'Super delegate' is considered 'unpledged
delegate' to the Democratic National Convention who are free to
support any candidate for the presidential nomination. This mechanism
is, however, not practiced in the Republican Party to which Trump
belongs.

Interestingly, even as lot of hype is created about Indian-Americans
role vis-a-vis 2020 presidential polls, in 2016 too a lot of
importance was given to this bloc of citizenry in the US.


"You guys (Indians as individuals) are greatly involved in the world
affairs. It is a good sign. It is a sign of mature citizenry of the
world's largest democracy," Republican senator Wayne Harper had
remarked at the same venue - of course in the presence of Miller.


It will be interesting to note that in 2016 - in the run up to the
polls pitted against Hillary Clinton - Trump, the maverick Republican
candidate, used to make headlines generally for wrong reasons.

“I think this will be the last election (2016 polls) that the Republicans have a chance of winning because you’re going to have people flowing across the border, you’re going to have illegal
immigrants coming in and they’re going to be legalized,” Trump had said.

“....Already the path is much more difficult for the Republicans. You just have to look at the maps," the illustrious Trump had said.


Aruna Miller had never approved of Trump's style of mannerism and anti-migrants comments and had emphasized that a leader contesting the prized post of US President’s office should conduct himself  “responsibly”.

To a question from this writer, Ms Miller had remarked: "Donald Trump is a polarizing individual. The statements he has been making (in run up to 2016 polls) have only damaged America".

Ms Miller had strongly defended Democrat's decision to field Hillary Clinton in 2016 and had said:“The selection of Hillary Clinton as the presidential candidate is reflective of the our Democratic party's policy and the overall commitment of the United States. We always wanted an inclusive society. But for Trump, I must say, if you are contesting for such a high post, you must show responsibility. You cannot keep making such sweeping statements".


Aruna Miller ran for Congress in 2018 to represent Maryland's 6th congressional district.
In April 2018, Miller won a straw poll of Democratic activists in Western Maryland.

Trump-Modi similarities

Well, as much as they change as much they remain constant. Trump is certainly amid headlines this time round too and is more often accused of being a polarising figure.


In fact, both Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi share some similarities. Trump has a strong anti-migrant image and seen as a pro-industrialist and as someone who has taken a strong stand against Islamic radicalism.

These elements are true of Modi too. Thus, the two global leaders, who have almost the same vices and virtues, would be sharing stage on Monday at Ahmedabad -- months after their historic first at Houston in September 2019.


"Look so forward to being with my great friends in India, " President Trump tweeted on Saturday, just on the eve of his visit.

In Ahmedabad, PM Modi's original 'political laboratory'; Trump will address the “Namaste Trump” event jointly with Modi at the newly built Motera Cricket Stadium that has a capacity siting of 1.2 lakh people.

There is a serious political component certainly. The size of the Indian diaspora in the US is estimated at around four million and Trump will be eyeing Indian votes.
More than 10,000 police personnel have been deployed as part of  massive security arrangement for Trump's mega road-show.

A similar roadshow was organised in Ahmedabad with much pomp and gaiety for Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on September 14, 2017.


In July 2019, Modi hosted his Israeli counterpart and another right wing leader Benjamin Netanyahu in Ahmedabad and both the leaders had embarked on a eight-km long roadshow from the airport to Sabarmati Ashram dedicated to the peace apostle Mahatma Gandhi.






"While US Embassy had no objection to the presence of CM and Deputy CM, we appreciate their recognition that this isn't a political event and that it's best to ensure focus is on education, school, and students," a spokesperson in the US embassy said following a media query on the issue.


"Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and I would have loved to personally receive the First Lady in the Delhi Govt school and brief her about the concept of Happiness Classes and the positive impact that it has had on students, during her visit to the classrooms," he said in an official statement.



Home Minister Amit Shah arrived in Ahmedabad on Sunday ahead of US President Donald Trump's visit to the city. 
Shah is also the president of Gujarat Cricket Association (GCA) that owns the newly-built cricket stadium at Motera, where Trump and Prime Minister Narendra Modi would address over one lakh people in the 'Namaste Trump' programme.

Both Trump and Modi would first take part in a 22-km long roadshow on Monday.

They are also scheduled to visit the Sabarmati Ashram.


Motera stadium is the world's largest cricket stadium with a capacity to accommodate 1.10 lakh spectators.


Saturday, February 22, 2020

Trump skips Golf, tweets about his enthusiasm on India visit



"Look so forward to being with my great friends in India " - Donald Trump tweeted. 


On his return to the White House after four days of hectic political campaigning in the western parts of the country, the US President did not go for a round of golf, which is normally done during a bright sunny weekend day in Washington !!

President Trump will pay a state visit to India on February 24 and 25 at the invitation of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Now, a few salient features !!

- Kimberly Guilfoyle, who is presently the National Chair of the Trump Victory Finance Committee, was the key architect for the success of the "Howdy, Modi!" event in September 2019 at Houston.

It is said - with her dynamism and sincerity Guilfoyle has taken the Trump campaign to a higher level, reaching out to all minority communities in the US including Indian-Americans.


Trump's high-level delegation to India would include First Lady Melania Trump, the President's daughter Ivanka Trump, son-in-law Jared Kushner and a galaxy of top American officials.

According to one of his associates, Al Mason, advisor to Global Real Estate Investments, Education Institutions, President Trump loves Indians and Indian-Americans and in return for their part, the . Indian Americans nationwide also like him as much.


"Why else would 1,20,000 Indians sign up to attend Trump's rally in the world largest cricket stadium in Ahmedabad"... he said. An estimated 5 million Indians would be greeting President Trump from the Airport to the cricket stadium on Monday, Feb 24, 2020.

Trump's visit comes months ahead of crucial Presidential elections in the US wherein Trump would be seeking re-election.

(In the meantime in the US, Trump's campaign just reportedly paid millions to buy out the ad space on YouTube's homepage ahead of the election, ensuring it will reach viewers at a crucial time, reports Business Insider)

Friday, February 21, 2020

'Namaste Trump': Take away: Trump is out to "erase" Obama legacy, for Modi, target is Nehru

President Trump expected to talk about shared tradition of democracy and religious freedom both in his public remarks and in private. He will raise ...particularly the religious freedom issue, which is extremely important...": US official in Washington


The visiting American delegation to accompany President Donald Trump during India visit will include Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, Energy Secretary Dan Brouillette, Acting Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney and National Security Advisor Robert O' Brien.


Trump's daughter Ivanka, and son-in-law Jared Kushner, who serve as Assistant to the President and Senior Advisor to the President respectively, will also be visiting India.

Ambassador Ken Juster will be also travelling with the visiting delegation, reports from Washington said.

Senior advisors to the President Stephen Miller, Dan Scavino,  Assistant to the President and Special Representative for International Telecommunication Policy and Senior Advisor to the Chief of Staff Robert Blair, and White House Press Secretary Stephanie Grisham are the other members of the delegation.




A senior US official has said that Trump's upcoming visit to India demonstrates the strong and enduring ties between the two largest democracies.

"These are ties based on shared democratic traditions, common strategic interests, and enduring bonds between our people. And, in part, this has been exemplified by the very close relationship between the President and Prime Minister Narendra Modi," said the official.

Chief of Staff to the First Lady Lindsay Reynolds is also part of the delegation.

Participants in additional bilateral meetings would include Chief Executive Officer of US International Development Finance Corporation Adam Boehler, Chairman of the FCC Ajit Pai, Deputy Assistant to the President for South and Central Asian Affairs Lisa Curtis, Special Assistant to President and Senior Director for Counterterrorism Kash Patel and Director for India, National Security Council, Mike Passey.

The visit will focus on several key areas. "First, we will focus on building our economic and energy ties," the US official said.

Even as a trade deal may not materialise, it has to be noted that the two-way trade in goods and services exceeded USD 142 billion in 2018.

India is the fifth-largest economy in the world with massive energy needs. Lately, the energy exports from the US to India grew by 500 per cent to nearly USD 7 billion.

During the trip, the two countries will focus on defense and security cooperation to fight terrorism and promote a free and open Indo-Pacific.


Trump is making a 36-hour visit on Feb. 24-25 to Ahmedabad, Agra and New Delhi, and importantly the visit comes ahead of the US presidential elections in November.

A serious component of Trump’s visit will be Ahmedabad, the business capital of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's home state of Gujarat, which witnessed rampant anti-Muslim violence in 2002. Modi was the chief minister of the state at the time.

The administration is busy building walls on sides of roads to hide the slums from  Trump when his car passes through the city. After all, the "Gujarat Model" was the development model Modi used for his political campaigns. 


In Ahmedabad, Trump will address the “Namaste Trump” event jointly with Modi at the newly built Motera Cricket Stadium, the world’s largest cricket stadium.


Trump's visit has a serious political component. The size of the Indian diaspora in the US is estimated at around four million. Faced with a severe electoral battle, Trump will be eyeing Indian votes. 

Now comes the vital part. Trump has a strong anti-migrant image, nationally and internationally. He is also seen as a pro-industrialist or corporate honcho and taken a strong stand against Islamic radicalism when it suited his political goals.


Notably, all these three statements are true of Modi too. The two global leaders, who have almost the same vices and virtues, can expect to boost their sagging political popularity by sharing a stage in Ahmedabad on Feb. 24.


blogger 


Both Trump and Modi also play to the hilt the politics of nationalism. Modi government's campaign and welfare measures are more than often named trying to espouse a hardline patriotic tone and tenor and that also inclined towards a Hindu India. One such initiative has been ‘Ek Bharat Shreshtha Bharat’  (meaning One India, Great India) launched in 2015 and is said to be the brainchild of the
Prime Minister. 'Shreshta Bharat' phrase is actually linked to the glorious past of medieval period when oriental civilisation values and Buddhist teachings made ways in various parts of the world.

Buddhism was cultivated and grown in India and Nepal and later spread to China, Korean Peninsula and Japan as well.

There are lot many such programmes of the Modi government which are quite similar to Trump's hyped "Make America great again" campaign line.

Both the leaders are also known for strong views on Muslims. In fact, in September 2019 at the Howdy Modi event at Houston in presence of Modi, Trump had a few pleasing words for ears of Indian Prime Minister. 

Trump had said that the United States is committed to protecting innocent Indian-Americans from the "threat of radical Islamic terrorism" and it is not without good reason that Modi had given him a standing ovation and clapped.

There are, in fact, similarities in their respective individual personalities as well.
Like Trump, Modi has often displayed liking for 'gut instincts'. In 2016 November, he announced ban on high value currency notes against the
"counseling" of the then Reserve Bank of India Governor.
US watchers know it pretty well that "Trump evidently trusts his gut instincts more than the advice of the US foreign policy and security establishment, and
those instincts have drawn him towards autocrats and away from traditional democratic allies" (says 'The Guardian'')


There is also a ''constant" in the Trump's world view and policies that is to "erase" the legacy of Barack Obama and his other predecessors.
"Almost everything Obama was for, Trump has been overwhelmingly against.....," says 'The Guardian''.


In the case of Modi, there have been often blasphemous and personal attack on the legacy of Pt Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first Prime Minister and an educated liberal and a great champion of parliamentary democracy.

Obama's parting shot: 2015


In his address at a Delhi function on Jan 27, 2015, Obama had said: “India will succeed so long as it is not splintered along the lines of religious faith, as long as it is not splintered along any lines, and it is unified as one nation".

Obama's remarks came on the backdrop that Hindu vigilante groups were opposing Christians and Muslims in more ways than one - including on religious conversion and food habits.

Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Amit Shah, Nadda to review party's defeat in Delhi polls


BJP top leaders including Home Minister Amit Shah and party chief J P Nadda to review party's defeat in Delhi polls on Wednesday,  Feb 12, meeting.

JP Nadda said -  "accepting this mandate, BJP will play the role of constructive opposition".

Party leaders are already listing out several factors for the humiliting defeat despite aggressive campaigning.

Focus shift to Bihar - Polls likely in October-November, 2020

Prashant Kishor may emerge a key player in Bihar. Bihar state leaders of AAP has said that the state would be the next destination of the party and Nitish Kumar-led JD(U)-BJP-LJP alliance will get a good fight.

In 2015, BJP contesting alone had lost miserably and JD(U)-RJD-Congress had won the elections !!


The partys state unit has said it would contest a large number of seats in the assembly elections later this year and seek to "defeat polarization by focusing on issues like health and education".



Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar on Tuesday side-stepped queries on the outcome of assembly polls in Delhi, where the coalition comprising his JD(U),BJP and LJP has been drubbed by the incumbent Aam Aadmi Party, with the terse observation the will of the people is supreme.

"Janata maalik hai", uttered Kumar with hands folded above his head and the ghost of a smile playing on his lips as he sauntered past a posse of journalists tossing queries on the sidelines of a function where he unveiled a statue of Sangh ideologue Deen Dayal Upadhyay.

The JD(U), of which Kumar is the national president, had contested two assembly segments in Delhi Burari and Sangam VIhar and lost both to AAP by staggering margins.

Although the JD(U) has never been a major player in the national capital, the current elections were significant because it was the first time that the BJP a formidable force in the city chose to take its smaller allies in Bihar along to take on the huge challenge posed by Arvind Kejriwals party, which is less than a decade old.

The tie-up in Delhi had been frowned upon by JD(U) national general secretary Pavan Varma a socialite based in the national capital, who aired his differences in the open and faced the axe.

Similar was the fate of Prashant Kishor whom the Chief Minister had made his partys national vice-president and whose position in the JD(U) had become increasingly untenable on account of his collaboration with Kejriwal in capacity of an election strategist.

An indignant Kishor has threatened to visit Patna after the dust settles on Delhi and unveil his future strategy besides "exposing" Kumar.

Kishor rendered his service to Kejriwal's party in drawing strategy for the Delhi election.

Bihar unit of AAP has indicated that the state would be the next destination of the party.

The partys state unit has said it would contest a large number of seats in the assembly elections later this year and seek to "defeat polarization by focusing on issues like health and education".

The torpid opposition in Bihar, led by Lalu Prasads RJD with the Congress as a major ally, after its dismal performance in Lok Sabha polls is hoping for a burst of vigour

among supporters on account of the results in Delhi, which came barely a couple of months after the BJPs ouster in the adjoining Jharkhand.

Tejashwi Yadav, the RJDs Chief Ministerial candidate hailed Kejriwal for defeating NDAs "hate campaign" and took a swipe at Kumar, saying "yes, Janata is maalik. But he will have to face the maalik here when the assembly polls are held".

Yadavs exultation over the "one-sided" poll result, though, was ironic as the massive AAP wave smashed the NDA, besides pulverizing the Congress-RJD combine, which sank without a trace.

However, interestingly, the development is likely to be received with a sense of relief by the JD(U) as well since the party will now be even more hopeful that Nitish Kumars detractors in the BJP will be kept on a tight leash.

After the Lok Sabha polls last year when the BJP returned to power with a brute majority, several BJP leaders in the state had begun to make statements that the time had come for the saffron party to stake claim for the Chief Ministers post,thereby threatening to upend the alliance with the JD(U).

A lid was, however, put on the controversy with repeated assertions by Amit Shah, then the BJP chief and still the de facto party strategist, that Kumar will lead the NDA charge in the assembly polls.

Nonetheless, JD(U) sources say, a better than expected show in Delhi could have emboldened Nitish-baiters in the BJP and not augured well for the ties between the two parties re- stitched with tenuous threads in the wake of recent acrimony that lasted for a four-year period during which Kumar remained outside the NDA and vowed to make a Sangh-Mukt Bharat.

The carefully worded statement issued by the BJPs Bihar unit spokesman Nikhil Anand, who offered his take the Delhi polls outcome, was a straw in the wind.

"The election result of Delhi has reflected the local sentiment of the voters and it has nothing to do with Bihar politics.


"BJP as well as our NDA allies, JDU and LJP are busy strengthening the organisational structure at the root level in Bihar. NDA will sweep the 2020 assembly election in Bihar under the leadership of CM Nitish Kumar", he said.


ZZZZZZZZZZZZ
The BJP was trounced in the Delhi assembly polls against the expectations of its top leaders, as the saffron party trailed far behind the AAP that returned to power with 62 seats in the 70-member legislature.

Although the BJP managed to improve its vote share to over 39 percent as compared to 32.19 percent in the 2015 elections, the increase did not materialise in sufficient number of seats to bring the party back to power after a gap of over two decades.

The party managed to win 8 seats, registering a slight increase from the three it had bagged in 2015.

Some BJP leaders believe the defeat was mainly contributed by the "hyper-nationalist pitch" of the poll campaign that focused on the anti-CAA protests at Shaheen Bagh and also lack of any answer to Kejriwal government's freebies including power and water supply and free rides to women in public transport buses.

"The party had planned to promise a bouquet of free services to people including water and power as well as benefit of the Ayushman Bharat health scheme, but the idea was shelved and it could not become a part of the election manifesto," said a senior Delhi BJP leader.

In the over three-week long high voltage campaign for the polls, the BJP leadership including Union Home Minister Amit Shah and party chief JP Nadda as well as Prime Minister Narendra Modi assailed AAP and chief minister Arvind Kejriwal over a host of issues including the Shaheen Bagh protest against the amended citizenship law and their alleged failure to come up with schools, hospitals and other facilities promised by them.

Shah would end his election speeches by appealing to people to press the electronic voting machine (EVM) buttons with such anger that its "current" was felt at Shaheen Bagh.

Objectionable statements also came from BJP leaders like MP Parvesh Verma and Union minister Anurag Thakur resulting in the Election Commission imposing temporary bans on campaigning by them.

The opposition AAP and Congress accused the BJP of running a campaign of "division and hatred" in the elections.

A section of Delhi BJP leaders held that the party went "overboard" while focusing on its agenda of "Hindutva and nationalism" in the campaign.

"With party leaders seen prompting slogans like 'shoot the traitor' and giving speeches and terming a chief minister as terrorist in election campaign, you cannot expect to have a positive response from the masses," said a top BJP leader.

Some BJP leaders also cited lack of a chief ministerial face, organisational shortcomings, failure to reach out to voters in unauthorised colonies and JJ clusters, and differences of leaders in Delhi party unit as possible reasons for the party's "humiliating" defeat.

However, Delhi BJP chief Manoj Tiwari rejected the charge of opposition parties that his party fought the polls on a "divisive" agenda.

"We do not practice politics of hatred, our principle is 'sabka saath sabka vikas'. In elections much is talked about as per emerging developments. But, we would never want that some people block a road for protest and cause problems to others. We opposed it (Shaheen Bagh road block) in the past and still do," Tiwari said.

Tiwari, however, said the causes of BJP's debacle will be "reviewed" on the party forum.

He also rejected the claim that AAP's freebies like power and water supply were not countered well by the BJP in its campaign.

"We do what we promise. We could not have possibly promised something that we had to do by cutting corners," he stated.

BJP national spokesperson Shahnawaz Hussain alleged that the party's poor show was due to Congress "shifting" its votes to the AAP in the elections.

"BJP is the only party which has gained and our seat tally increased while even the number of AAP seats has gone down. Congress shifted its vote to the AAP yet we gave a good fight," Hussain told reporters at the Delhi BJP office.

The results have come as a rude shock to the BJP that had fought the Delhi polls under the leadership of Prime Minister Modi.

Shah, who had spearheaded the party's poll campaign, had predicted that BJP would win more than 45 seats. Tiwari had tweeted that BJP will form the government in Delhi by winning 48 seats and had even dared people to save his tweet.


The BJP has been out of power in Delhi for over two decades.

QQQQQQQQ

NCP chief Sharad Pawar on Tuesday attributed the Aam Aadmi Party's stellar performance in the Delhi assembly elections to the common people rejecting the BJP's "communal polarisation" agenda which he said marked the "mood of change" in the country.

Pawar also underlined the need for regional parties to come together to keep the BJP out of power.

As per the latest update, the Arvind Kejriwal-led AAP has won 46 of the total 70 assembly seats and leading on 16 as per the latest results and trends. The BJP has won five seats and is leading on three others, while the Congress stares at a blank.

Pawar said the BJP committed "blunders" during the campaigning for the Delhi polls like "inciting religious sentiments to divide people along communal lines", but failed.

Without naming Union minister Anurag Thakur, the NCP chief said some people in the government made statements such as 'goli maro', which were indicative of the BJP "crossing the limits, but people of Delhi rejected them".

Talking to reporters here, Pawar said the results of the Delhi elections indicated that "winds of change" were blowing in the country. "The series of BJP's defeat in elections will not stop now," he added.

"The BJP, as usual, played the communal card to polarise votes, but failed. The Delhi Assembly poll contest was only between the Aam Aadmi Party and BJP, hence one might claim the saffron party's vote share is soaring," Pawar said.

He said the Delhi poll results indicated that the "winds of change" are blowing in the country. "The results are not surprising to me," he said.

Today's result is not limited to Delhi alone as people from various states live in the national capital. There is an environment of change in their own states which they expressed while voting in Delhi, the former Union minister said.

"There is an area called Karol Bagh in Delhi, where many Marathi-speaking people live. I had once gone there for a function. I had asked people about the poll trend and they had said only Kejriwal (will win)," he said.

"People had said that the the Kejriwal government tried to solve basic issues such as electricity and water bills, healthcare, education in Delhi," he said.

Referring to the BJP's defeat in the assembly polls held in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh during 2018-19, Pawar said, "I don't think this series of BJP's defeat will stop now".

"There is some kind of disappointment among the people which was reflected in the outcome of Delhi polls," he said.

Underlining the need for regional parties to come together to keep the BJP out of power, Pawar cited the example of Maharashtra, where the Shiv Sena, NCP and Congress formed an alliance to come to power.

"Regional parties need to come together under a 'common minimum programme' and provide a stable government to keep the BJP out of power.

"In Kerala, there is Communist party...in Maharashtra, we did some experiment. It means going forward, there is a need to come together on the basic common minimum programme, and I am sure people will support it," the veteran politician said.

Pawar said there is a feeling among Opposition parties that the BJP is like a "calamity" for the country, and there was a need to stand united.

"Last time we had come together in Kolkata and put forth our stand. Today, people have expectations from us and there is a need to go with a common minimum programme," he said.

Pawar also congratulated Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on victory in the polls.

Without taking names, Pawar said some "egotistic people are in power at the Centre".

"What I hear about (Prime Minister Narendra) Modi and (Union Home Minister Amit) Shah from MPs suggest that there is a great anxiety among people in the government," he said.

Pawar said BJP MPs look "scared" these days.

"They ensure that they do not get heard when they talk about their party. A BJP MP first looks to his right, then to his left, and after ensuring that nobody listening, he reveals the truth," Pawar said.

Referring to the vitriolic poll campaign, Pawar said, "The BJP committed some blunders in the Delhi elections by trying to incite religious sentiments of people and create a chasm between communities".

"The way they treated people from minority communities and ensured to create a rift on the lines of religion..but the people of Delhi did not accept it and rejected them," he added.




zzzz

 It will still take time for AAP national convenor Arvind Kejriwal to emerge as a "national leader" despite his party coming to power in Delhi for the third consecutive term, experts opined on Tuesday.



The experts said Kejriwal would need to have a pan-India base to establish himself as a national leader.

The AAP is at present recognised by the Election Commission as a state party. It emerged as the principal opposition in Punjab in 2017. However, its national ambitions suffered a setback when its campaigns in Goa and in the last two Lok Sabha elections were unsuccessful. It won four Lok Sabha seats in Punjab in 2014 and just one in 2019, while Delhi voters rejected it both times.

Kejriwal also burnt his fingers in 2014 when he contested against Narendra Modi, who was the BJP's prime ministerial candidate, in the Varanasi Lok Sabha seat, losing by over three lakh votes.

Many saw a shift in the AAP's strategy after the party's drubbing in the 2017 civic polls in Delhi at the hands of the BJP, as it again focussed on its development pitch in the national capital.

"It is still early to say that because it was a local election and of course, there is a positive platform on which he contested but whether he can replicate it at an all-India level is difficult to say. His party doesn't have any substantial base or party infrastructure. It is premature," said Sanjay Pandey, a political analyst and JNU professor.

The AAP is headed for a landslide victory on Tuesday in the high-stakes Delhi Assembly polls, leaving main rival BJP way behind and decimating the Congress in a bitterly-fought contest.

Kamal Chenoy, JNU professor, said the Indian polity is "very complex" where people have different ideas.

"For Arvind to be an all-India leader would take time. But what he has done has shown that there is some different kind of argument by using whatever the people need and giving them empowerment so that is important. He will grow but becoming national is going to take time," he said.

Chenoy said these elections gave the AAP a kind of empowerment which will help it get support of other opposition parties that have been trying to put up a united front against the BJP.

"The BJP is upset because now Arvind has got his foot in the door and the AAP is going to move on from here," he added.

Jagdeep Chhokar, one of the founding members of the Association for Democratic Reforms, said the AAP has to do a lot more before they go national.

"Going national is a very different level of activity. Last time, in national elections they contested around 400 seats, they had no clue who they had nominated as their candidates," Chhokar said.


What is common between Tilak Nagar, Janakpuri, Madipur, Rajouri Garden, Hari Nagar, Vikaspuri, Uttam Nagar, Dwarka, Matiala and Najafgarh -

all fall under West Delhi and here BJP scored a zero, but why and how ???


you name it, all have been taken control by AAP candidates with decisive margin. His protege Tajinder Bagga who was fighting from Hari Nagar and Verma made numerous rounds to bolster his campaign also lost from the seat. So much so, Verma unveiled a constituency specific manifesto for Bagga. Nothing seems to have cut the ice.

Same goes with Rajiv Babbar, who fought from Tilak Nagar, a constituency Bagga hoped he would get a ticket from. Babbar is not a newbie. In run of to 2019 general election, the BJP had appointed Rajiv Babbar, as in-charge of East Delhi parliamentary constituency. Babbar held "training" for BJP workers back then but in 2020, failed to perform himself.

Ashish Sood from Janakpuri is another old horse. AAP's Rajesh Rishi outperformed BJP's Ashish Sood by a magnificent margin that went above 50,000 votes.

The spectacular debacle is surprising given BJP's main electoral agenda till they raised 'Shaheen bagh' -- regularisation of unauthorised colonies find resonance in this Lok Sabha constituency. A large chunk of those 1,700 unauthorised colonies fall under Verma's area. Yet, this debacle raises question on his ability as well as his aggressive campaign pitch probably backfiring.

Verma, an otherwise non controversial MP and son of BJP's former Delhi Chief Minister Sahib Singh Verma came to the limelight when he attacked the blockade at Shaheen Bagh and even suggesting that the protesters are "rapists and murderers". Even on the day of election, half way through, he tweeted a provocative video that started with Shaheen Bagh bashing and ended with "Jai Shri Ram", a religious chant, intended to polarise the voting.

But February 11 proved, people from his own constituency didn't buy his argument, leave aside people of Delhi listening to him. At least two Delhi BJP leaders told IANS on condition of anonymity that "few of our leaders went a bit too far on Shaheen Bagh", without naming Verma.

ZZZ



The BJP failed to make much impact in constituencies where its leaders made controversial remarks while targeting their opponents during campaigning for the Delhi assembly polls.



Only three seats, which were among 12 constituencies where Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath addressed rallies, were bagged by the BJP. The party won 8 seats as against 62 by the AAP.

During his hectic campaign schedule which stretched over four days, he addressed rallies for BJP candidates in Patparganj, Kirari, Mehrauli, Uttam Nagar, Dwarka, Tughlakabad, Vikaspuri, Rohini, Karawal Nagar, Jahangirpuri and Badarpur.

The firebrand BJP leader kept the protesters at Shaheen Bagh in crosshair at each rally and alleged that the AAP government had been supplying them "biryani", for which the Election Commission issued him a notice.

Barring Badarpur, Karawal Nagar and Rohini, where BJP's Ramvir Singh Bidhuri, Mohan Singh Bisht and Vijender Gupta emerged victorious, the party candidates were humbled by opponents from the AAP.

In Janakpuri, where BJP MP from West Delhi Parvesh Verma made a controversial remark during a rally, the BJP candidate, Ashish Sood, lost to AAP's Rajesh Rishi by 14,917 votes.

"What happened in Kashmir with Kashmiri Pandits could happen in Delhi also. Lakhs of people gather at Shaheen Bagh, they could enter houses rape and kill your sisters and daughters. The people need to decide now," Verma had said.

The Election Commission had barred Verma from campaigning for four days over the remarks.

Shaheen Bagh, a key anti-CAA protest site in south Delhi, had taken a centre stage in the BJP's poll campaign.

Verma's uncle and the party's candidate from Mundka, Azad Singh, lost to AAP's Dharampal Lakra by 19,158 votes.

In Rithala, where Union minister Anurag Thakur made the infamous "desh ke gaddaron ko" remark, AAP's Mohinder Goyal trounced BJP's Manish Chaudhary by 13,817 votes.

The BJP candidate from Model Town, Kapil Mishra, who was barred from campaigning for 48 hours for his controversial tweet likening the elections to an "India versus Pakistan match", lost to AAP's Akhilesh Pati Tripathi.