Thursday, December 8, 2022

Gujarat swears by Hindutva, Focus shifts to Christian states in NE :::::: BJP beats Congress best of 149 in 1985

Nonetheless, even after the loss of Himachal Pradesh and a recent defeat in local elections in Delhi, Verma said that nationally the BJP remained in a “formidable position”.

Even if at state level the BJP faces some issues going forward, when Modi is on the ticket, given his level of popularity, he pulls the BJP up nationally. - The Guardian   


Gujarat swears by Hindutva, Focus shifts to Christian states in NE


Many Nagas or even Meghalaya leaders prefer BJP hoping to accelerate development


New Delhi 







Unprecedented success for the BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Hindutva laboratory, Gujarat, is bound to have its mega impact in national politics.


The 'Moditva phenomenon' was at its best in the just concluded polls in Gujarat. Congress did well to wrest power again in Himachal Pradesh. But with a wafer-thin majority Congress will face trouble ensuring stability.


Focus will gradually shift to northeastern states where elections are due in two Christian-dominated states of Meghalaya and Nagaland and also in another BJP-ruled Tripura -- which also accounts for a substantial number of tribal and Christian voters.


The just concluded polls and next year's elections in three northeastern states and also Mizoram and three agrarian states of Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan and also in Karnataka will set the ball rolling for 2024 general elections,


Jubilant BJP leaders should send a bouquet to Arvind Kejriwal for contesting and campaigning hard in Gujarat. They will also thank Rahul Gandhi for staying away from Gujarat.

These might be a combo -- a delicious recipe for the voters to embrace the Moditva much more enthusiastically preparing ground for 2024 polls when Hindu voter's folk hero Namo will try for a hat-trick at the national level.


In Nagaland, doubts persist whether polls will be held on time or it would be the default pension for some players in the corridors of power at Kohima.


But ensuing polls are more than serious in Meghalaya. In Tripura, which was once a communist forte,

the saffron party will hope for an easier contest with rivals Congress and CPI-M marginalised.

A new tribal-based party may make a difference, but it cannot win more than 20 seats.


In Meghalaya, defection games will start soon in a big way. Three MLAs who resigned could rush to

Delhi anytime later this week to embrace BJP.


The BJP’s mega promise is to provide a corruption-free government focused on people’s socio economic development. 


The hilly state of nearly 3 million people has 75 percent Christian population and yet the BJP has plans 

to garner votes. BJP's national vice president and in-charge Meghalaya is a Naga veteran M Chuba Ao. 

He is confident of a much better show this time as compared to two-seats win in 2018.


Nalin Kohli then BJP in-charge of Meghalaya is now in-charge of Nagaland and he has famously inked

the 20:40 formula pact probably with much enthusiasm. He was pleasing his bosses and helping a new found

friend in the hills of Northern Angami.

But in Northern Angami II, BJP mandal workers pledge to sweat it out.


The NPP of Conrad Sangma in Meghalaya is faced with an anti incumbency and a series of corruption 

allegations. Money flows during election time in Meghalaya, 'some people say' as goes the cliche about

Fox News channel.


The Congress was in power for 15 years till it was ousted in 2018; but the grand old party has lost veterans

such as Mukul Sangma to Trinamool and the party base has crumbled too.


In Baptist-majority Nagaland, the BJP shares power in a coalition led by NDPP and does not even

mind playing second fiddle. 


Christians, who make up 90 percent of Nagaland’s 1.95 million people, may want to give a pleasant surprise to

the BJP. The Central Nagaland and especially Mokokchung district is witnessing a pro-saffron wave despite

lackluster performance by state unit president Temjen Ima Along.


Nagas are at crossroads, look toward a Solution for peace and extortion-free life. Many Nagas see merits in

the pro-Hindutva BJP presuming this will accelerate their development. 

Congress is nowhere in the battle scene and the NPF is also a victim of its own power-politics shenanigans. 


In states where non-Hindus are politically decisive, the BJP always smartly employed a singular political strategy of 

aligning with regional parties. Things are changing a bit in Meghalaya. But in Mizoram, the saffron party

does not mind as long as the Zoramthanga-led MNF continues in office.


In Meghalaya, the BJP is reportedly also working to attract “non-Christian local tribal groups” who continue 

to practice age-old aboriginal customs and socio-religious practices.


ends 








 Congress tally drops from 77 to 17, AAP - only 5 






(Three decades of power in Gujarat, it was still a litmus test for the BJP. A lethal combination of Modi Magic and a simpleton CM Bhupendra Patel -- calling himself Common Man - has done all the difference. BJP wins record best. In Himachal Pradesh, with a wafer-thin majority Congress will face trouble ensuring stability.) 

 

New Delhi/Ahmedabad

 







In 2002, Narendra Modi was impossible to ignore. In 2022 -- twenty years after - he is still impossible to ignore and in the Indian sub continent's politics for the next few years, Modi will never be out of the news. And that too as a catalyst of development and a strong proponent of Hindutva-brand of nationalistic politics. A jubilant Gujarat Chief Minister Bhupendra Patel should send a bouquet to Arvind Kejriwal for contesting and campaigning hard in Gujarat; he must also thank Rahul Gandhi for staying away from Gujarat.

 

These might have made a combo -- a delicious recipe for the Gujarat voters to embrace the Moditva much more enthusiastically preparing ground for 2024 parliamentary polls when their favourite folk hero Namo will try for a hat-trick at the national level. 

While analysts and ivory tower TV experts focused on Patidar voters and other intellectual analyses like giving hyped importance to the AAP factor, the ruling BJP focused on women empowerment and this section either Patidars or non-Patidars changed the entire game. 

A crucial message from the 2022 mandate both in Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh also suggests that 'Revdi' -- freebies culture --- succeeds in Delhi or Punjab but it cannot do so in Gujarat or in the rest of India. Therefore the rhetoric assertion is - Modi's Gujarat and the 'new India' also means giving importance to talent, skills and labour. Everyone may not agree but this new growing phenomenon has slowly started to discard the politics of dynastic rights and preferences, say BJP booth workers. The BJP is certainly more than delighted and this will give them a major advantage for 2024 polls in terms of Modi's magical vote gathering power.

The just concluded polls and next year's elections in three north eastern states Nagaland, Meghalaya, Tripura and also Mizoram and three agrarian states of Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan and also in Karnataka will set the ball rolling for 2024 general elections that will decide the fate of nationalists, BJP.
It will also decide the outcome of the politics of the likes of Chandrababu Naidu, K Chandrashekhar Rao, Mamata Banerjee, Arvind Kejriwal and even Rahul Gandhi. 

Many BJP workers said one simple message from Gujarat in 2022 perhaps is that the governance should be people-centric. It is also important to develop a culture of hard work and help vulnerable sections like women. Days of free lunch for some and government Babus, their wives, children, dogs and cronies are over. If at all, there are some, these too would fade away soon.

Two decades back, In 2002, 'India Today' wrote --- "Narendra Damodardas Modi shocks India. And how. Look at him, look at him up close. For so long, he was just another politician. Then one day, he was just another Chief Minister. Today, he is just Modi. What's in a surname?" Some people could still write these lines; and wonder in awe on the magic of Moditva.

 

  

AAP myth explodes:

 

The polls in Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh were major setback for AAP which could  win only six seats in Gujarat after the hoopla. It also scored a big zero in Himachal Pradesh.

No sooner the results came in, social media postings went viral. Some sounded caustic but realistic -- Freebies - the 'revdi' culture could work in Delhi and Punjab; but it does not work elsewhere. Thus, the big - but over ambitious' dream of Kejriwal and his colleague Manish Sisodia to emerge as major opposition leaders at the national level for 2024 battle has come a cropper. The Aam Aadmi Party, which was basking with the MCD win, has been once again told by the faceless Indian electorate that it was still a Delhi-based party. And Punjab story could be seen as a mix of an accidental win and an outcome of a catastrophic way of handling things by the Congress.

 

Percentage wise break up of results both in Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh is also crucial. The BJP vote share was a record 53.03 -- a significant jump from 49.05% in 2017 in Gujarat. For Congress, it was a nosedive fall from 41.44% five years back to 27.04 percent. AAP gained 12.80 percent and hence the analysts have been proved right that Kejriwal's party has damaged the grand old party the most. The Congress drop in number of seats was stupendous and worst in its record for Gujarat -- 77 to a humble 19. But it was still too early to say that Gujarat polity has opened a door for a third front.

 

Never in the past too, any third front could emerge as a viable force in Gujarat.

Shankersinh Vaghela launched Rashtriya Janata Party (RJP) and Keshubhai Patel floated Gujarat Parivartan Party (GPP). In 1998, RPP had won only four seats. The GPP fought the 2012 polls and won only two seats. The AAP’s tally is slightly better at 6. In 2017, assembly election, the AAP contested 29 seats and could manage only 0.10 per cent of the vote share.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Stability and Defection:

 

How things pan out in Himachal Pradesh vis-a-vis formation of the new government will be interesting to see. The Congress has emerged as the single largest party and has crossed the majority mark by winning 39 seats. But it is too close to the magic figure of 35. The BJP has won 26 and if three others support it; the tally will be 29 -- and this also is too close to the 34-35 mark.

 

In terms of vote shares, notwithstanding the hype created by Left liberal English media and the fact that Himachal is next door neighbour of Punjab, the AAP could bag only 1.08 percent of votes. For Congress the vote share in 2022 was 43.6 and that is slightly more than 41.7 of 2017. The BJP came much closer to the saffron party winning 43.3 percent but that was a drop of about 4.5 per cent -- from 48.8% of 2017. This made all the difference in the number of seats.

 

Five years back, BJP had won 44 and the Congress had managed to win only 21.

 

 

## Inset:

 

$$ BJP humbled AAP’s so called chief ministerial face Isudan Gadhvi rather convincingly. Ayar Mulubhai Hardasbhai Bera polled 61,781 percent of votes while Isudan Gadhvi of AAP finished second with 44, 589 votes and Vikrambhai Arjanbhai Maadam of Congress finished third with 36,345 votes.
 
 
$$  For BJP, 155 haul is a record. Madhavsinh Solanki had managed to win 149 in the 182-member assembly in 1985 when politics was hugely dominated by the Congress. The BJP's best performance so far was in 2002 when it won 127 and that had elevated Narendra Modi as a formidable player in state and national politics.

 

 

 

Ends  

 

Wednesday, December 7, 2022

BJP set to win 156 in 182-member Gujarat assembly::: Congress tally drops from 77 to 7:::: AAP - only 5

Two decades back, In 2002..... 'India Today' wrote --- 

"Narendra Damodardas Modi shock India. And how. Look at him, look at him up close. For so long, he was just another politician. Then one day, he was just another Chief Minister. Today, he is just Modi. What's in a surname? 


Modi Magic gives BJP historic 156 haul in Gujarat

(Three decades of power in Gujarat, it was still a litmus test for the BJP. A lethal combination of Modi Magic and a simpleton CM Bhupendra Patel -- calling himself Common Man - has done all the difference. In Himachal Pradesh, with a wafer-thin majority Congress will face trouble ensuring stability.) 



2022 polls: Now, BJP 155...Congress 19 and sickularism's new baby AAP - only 6  


BJP to cross 150 mark in 182-member assembly. Trends suggest BJP is far ahead of 2002 tally of 127 in Gujarat and Congress's all time best of 149 in 1985. 






The Moditva phenomenon is at its best in the just concluded polls in Gujarat and
Himachal Pradesh.





Breaking the trends, BJP may retain power in Himachal Pradesh as the saffron party was leading in 39 seats as against 27 by Congress.


In Gujarat, the BJP set to cross its best 127 mark of 2002 as the party took early leads in 135 seats in the 182-member assembly. 






The so-called secular forces -- also called Sickularism - were set for a big setback as the new 'saviour' 

AAP of Arvind Kejriwal was leading only in 5 seats and Congress was also in for a shocker with leads just in 40 seats.


A lot of hype was generated around the AAP factor in Gujarat. But the first few rounds of counting shows the Delhi-based

party is yet to make a mark in terms of occupying the opposition space at the national level. 


According to initial rounds of counting, the Aam Aadmi Party’s (AAP) efforts to emerge as the third front in a state that has traditionally witnessed bipolar contests between the BJP and the Congress has come a cropper.

If the trends come true, the BJP will be more than delighted and this will give them a major advantage for

2024 polls in terms of Modi's magical vote gathering power.


Many BJP workers said one simple message from Gujarat in 2022 perhaps is that the governance 

should be people-centric. It is also important to develop a culture of hard work and help vulnerable

sections like women.


Days of free lunch for some and government Babus, their wives, children, dogs and cronies

are over. If at all, there are some, these too would fade away soon.


Everyone may not agree but this new growing phenomenon has slowly started to discard the politics of

dynastic rights and preferences, say BJP booth workers.


Therefore the rhetoric assertion is - Modi's Gujarat and the 'new India'

also means giving importance to talent, skills and labour.



Population figures disputed by ENPO and Nagaland 'state cabinet'

Statehood was 'red flagged', but cabinet favoured autonomy



New Delhi 


One can always put a paper boat in water, but it is also true 'water' will soon get into that boat. 




The problem with administration and governance with the Tuensang-Mon region, now a hub of as many as six districts, is more than just human error.

Circumstances and historical legacy - like water boat and water - also played a part. The institutions of governance were never quite built up and the focus remained elsewhere, many say.


'Nagaland Page' Link


Corruption and greed and non-performance of Neta-Babu combine could not be underestimated. 


In hindsight, the fact that the Nagaland cabinet had red flagged statehood for the ENPO region and rather favoured autonomous Council is no rocket science or state secret.


But according to sources in Delhi, the ENPO anguish is essentially due to the manner statecraft was mishandled at various levels vis-a-vis Eastern Nagaland since statehood was earned for Nagaland in 1963.


Interestingly the state cabinet used the years old issue of 'Naga unification' of all contiguous areas in strengthening one of their arguments.


In a few confidential reports submitted to the Union Home Ministry, the state government had said - "the cabinet strongly reiterated its position by the four resolutions already passed by the state assembly on various occasions, demanding integration of all contiguous Naga inhabited areas under one administrative umbrella".


This has been for long part of peace parleys but the concept had its own issues. During Sept 12, 2022 meeting with Nagaland CM Neiphiu Rio and state ministers and legislators, Home Minister Amit Shah had quizzed what about the Nagas of Myanmar. 

On this a feeble response from a senior politician was, "Sir, it is out of box".


This issue also threatened to alter the boundaries of three other states Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur and Assam and which had been opposed vehemently in all three states. In fact, in Manipur even Naga legislators and towering personalities such as Rishang Keishing were part of those who adopted unanimous resolutions that no compromise on Manipur's integrity would be entertained.


Rising above party affiliation, Congress chief minister Okram Ibobi Singh had opposed visit of Thuingeleng Muivah to his native village in Manipur in 2010 -- a request the then Union Home Minister P Chidambaram had agreed to.


The Nagaland cabinet in their report had also made it clear that while formation of an autonomous council could be

taken up; "the cabinet was of the firm view that the Govt of India is expected to know what would be the best

way of resolving the issue at hand (ENPO demand for a separate state)".


It is worth mentioning here that according to clause 10 (b) of the 16 Point (or Statehood) Agreement, there was a provision for setting up of a Regional Council with elected representatives from all the tribes (from the region) 

and the Governor may nominate representatives to the Regional Council. 


It was also stated that the "Regional Council will elect members of the Naga Legislative Assembly".


In their charter of demands in the context of grievances, the ENPO leaders had submitted before the centre that

the dissolution of the Regional Council in the 1970s has affected the representation of the Eastern Nagaland in the political

set up.

The Nagaland cabinet had countered this argument maintaining that "initially the area sent six MLAs to an 

assembly of 46 which works out to 13 percent only. This was raised to 12 in an assembly of 52 in 1968 which

again works up to 23 per cent." The state government in its report also said -- "However, upon discontinuation

of the Regional Council in 1974, Mon and Tuensang districts were given 20 MLAs to be directly elected along with the

rest of the state. This works out to 33 per cent".


Importantly, there remains a sharp difference between the versions of ENPO and the state cabinet in the context of

population share.

The state government officially says population of the ENPO region has remained 28.8 percent of the entire

state of Nagaland; but the ENPO claim has been that almost 50 percent of the state's population resides in these

districts.


The 2011 Census figures indicate that the population of these districts (then only four) was 5,72,098 only and 

that worked out as 28.8 percent of the state's population was 19,78,502.


Notably, yet again, while the ENSF had complained that no one from the region was made President of the

influential Naga Students Federation, it is well known that no leader from the region could become Chief Minister.


Chongshen Chang from Tuensang district had become deputy Chief Minister in 1990 under the United Front ministry headed 

by K L Chishi in 1990.

The ministry, however, lasted only for a month and Chishi was toppled when two rivals of the time S C Jamir and Late

Vamuzo had joined hands. 

 Incidentally, incumbent CM Rio was Chishi's Power Minister; but he was also a disqualified member and so was

even Chongshen Chang.


As pradesh Congress chief Chingwang Konyak missed chief ministership in 1993 when he lost assembly polls from 

Wakching and later he was not given ticket for Tehok assembly seat. Chingwang resigned as pradesh chief and also

subsequently quit Congress. 


ends 


Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Frontier Nagaland ---- ENPO: Matured master stroke; Shah to visit Eastern Nagaland for 2 days in January 2023



A Spl panel in December, 'Eastern Nagaland' grievance to be addressed by March 2023 








 


New Delhi

 

It was a game-changer event. It was clear the Home Ministry was well prepared and had a blueprint ready. 


Elections in Nagaland by February-March 2023 now seem unlikely and the issues related to the demand for a separate state for Eastern Nagaland may be addressed by the centre by March end. 


He may be known for a Machiavellian style of politics. But on the politico-administrative front, Home Minister Amit Shah on Tuesday played a mature and a virtual master stroke.


Those with a basket full of grievances vis-a-vis Eastern Nagaland were perhaps more than
satisfied at the end of the day and the Team ENPO issued a statement on Tuesday evening
saying their meeting was "very successful".
"Hon’ble Union Home Minister highlighted a clear Road-map for amicable, legislative and sustainable solution for Eastern Nagaland. Which will include consultation with the people of Eastern Nagaland and Nagaland State government. Hon’ble Union Home Minister has also assured to visit Eastern Nagaland personally by January 2023; for which, the ENPO eagerly awaits his visit," the statement said.

Sources said the meeting was also attended by BJP MP (Rajya Sabha) Phangnon Konyak, also a native of Mon district and hailing from Konyak tribe who are also among the chief protagonists demanding a separate statehood.


Among others Home Secretary, Director Intelligence Bureau, Addl. Secretary Home (NE) and A K Mishra, peace emissary in Naga talks also attended.


Mishra's presence also makes it amply clear that the MHA and Home Minister Shah himself understand very well the intricacies of the ongoing peace parleys with the NNPG and the NSCN-IM and how all these are inter-linked.


A delegation of NNPG led by N Kitovi Zhimomi is also expected for crucial rounds of discussions with Mishra

later this week. Mishra reportedly has lately adopted 'more crystal clear' stance vis-a-vis his interaction with

the stakeholders. 


The absence of any state government representative on Dec 6 (Tuesday's) meeting despite the hoopla created by 

a section of NDPP and ministers when a delegation including Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio had air-dashed to Delhi 

on Dec 3 show a different story. Things are now open for interpretation.


One key ENPO source on December 2 itself steadfastly opposed the presence of any minister or Chief Minister Rio (for Dec 3 meeting) saying no third party presence was required unless 'they do not want to sabotage' things.


Sources say it was indicated that at today's meeting that by December 15, 2022, the Home Ministry will set up a special committee. It will be assigned to visit Eastern Nagaland for on the spot review of the demand and grievances probably in the presence of Nagaland state government representatives.  


The panel will visit the region and submit a detailed report to Shah, who is then likely to visit Eastern Nagaland region by the second week of January 2023.

 

Shah may make a two-day halt in the region and verify things at his personal level.


"The issues related to the grievances of the people of the Tuensang-Mon region will be possibly addressed by 75-80 days once Home Minister Shah makes his visit to Eastern Nagaland," a source told 'Nagaland Page' on the condition of anonymity.


The ENPO statement issued from Delhi said the organisation is grateful to Hon’ble Union Home Minister for his concern and granting ample time to the ENPO team.


"It is to be stated that the Hon’ble Union Home Minister had appreciated the Eastern people for being a part of the nation building thus far, which, Hon’ble Prime Minister Shri. Narendra Modiji is also aware, he stated. Hon’ble Union Home Minister stated that the grievances and request for separate entity is understood," the statement said.  


The seven tribes from the region - Konyaks, Sangtams, Changs, Phoms, Khiamniungans, Yimchungrus and Tikhirs have stayed away from this year's annual tourism extravaganza of Hornbill Festival being hosted in the state capital.


Some community leaders say the gesture could be interpreted as Eastern Nagaland's lack of trust in the Rio government in which paradoxically BJP and regionalist NPF are still the key constituents.


Surveys in the 1990s had revealed that along the entire eastern belt of Nagaland (encompassing the six districts),  runs a rich vein of coal, limestone, nickel, marble and cobalt. 


But most of these have remained untapped due to a plethora of reasons.


ends 




ENPO leaders laud Amit Shah's proactive steps on demand for 'Frontier Nagaland'


Sources said the Home Minister is likely to visit Eastern Nagaland for a two night halt in January, 2023.
A special panel will also be set up to study the people's grievances in detail.


New Delhi

The apex Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO), which held a crucial
meeting with Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Tuesday, expressed satisfaction at the
manner the centre has handled their demand for carving out a separate state out of the
16th state of Indian Union.

"Hon’ble Union Home Minister highlighted a clear Road-map for amicable, legislative and sustainable solution for Eastern Nagaland. Which will include consultation with the people of Eastern Nagaland and Nagaland State government. Hon’ble Union Home Minister has also assured to visit Eastern Nagaland personally by January 2023; for which, the ENPO eagerly awaits his visit," the ENPO statement said.

It was given out as a landmark meeting which was later hailed by Eastern Nagaland-based body as "a very successful" one.


Mr Shah assured the delegation that time-bound steps will be taken to address the grievances of the far-flung region.


"It is to be stated that the Hon’ble Union Home Minister had appreciated the Eastern Nagaland people for being a part of the nation building thus far, which, Hon’ble Prime Minister Shri. Narendra Modiji is also aware, he stated. Hon’ble Union Home Minister stated that the grievances and request for separate entity is understood," the statement from the Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO) said.

The seven tribes from the region - Konyaks, Sangtams, Changs, Phoms, Khiamniungans, Yimchungrus
and Tikhirs have stayed away from this year's annual tourism extravaganza of Hornbill Festival being hosted in
the state capital.

Eastern Nagaland comprises six districts - Tuensang, Mon, Shamatore, Longleng, Noklak and Kiphire.

Shah held the much awaited crucial meeting with ENPO leaders in presence of sitting BJP MP (Rajya Sabha),
S Phangnon Konyak and two former MPs Asungba Sangtam and Wangyuh Konyak.
  
Among others Home Secretary, Director Intelligence Bureau, Addl. Secretary Home (NE) and A K Mishra, peace emissary
in Naga talks also attended.

Mishra's presence also makes it amply clear that Home Minister Shah understands very well
the intricacies of the ongoing peace parleys with the NNPG and the NSCN-IM and how all these are inter-linked.

A delegation of NNPG led by N Kitovi Zhimomi is also expected for crucial rounds of discussions with Mishra
on December 8. 

Mishra reportedly has lately adopted a 'more crystal clear' stance vis-a-vis his interaction with
the stakeholders. The Centre has categorically rejected the demands for a separate Naga flag and Constitution 
as articulated by the NSCN-IM.

One key ENPO source on December 2 itself steadfastly opposed the presence of any minister or Chief
Minister Rio (for Dec 3 meeting) saying no third party presence was required unless "they do not want to sabotage things".

Rio's cabinet has ministers from Eastern Nagaland. Now pressure will mount 
on 20 elected legislators from the region to quit the NDPP-BJP-NPF ministry.

Surveys in the 1990s had revealed that along the entire eastern belt of Nagaland (encompassing the six districts), runs a rich vein of coal, limestone, nickel, marble, cobalt and magnite.

But most of these have remained untapped due to a plethora of reasons.

The people from the region have grievances of being not treated properly by the mainstream Nagaland.

The charge is, however, denied by the mainstream politicians.

The Tuensang-Mon region had joined Nagaland state since the 1960s when the 16 Point Agreement was inked between Naga public leaders under the banner of Naga People's Convention (NPC) and the Government of India.


No leader from the region could become Chief Minister while Chongshen Chang (from Tuensang district) had become deputy Chief Minister in 1990 under the ministry headed by K L Chishi.


Sources said it was indicated at Tuesday's (Dec 6) meeting that by December 15, 2022, the Home Ministry will set up a special committee. It will be assigned to visit Eastern Nagaland for on the spot review of the demand and grievances
probably in the presence of Nagaland state government representatives.  

The general feeling in Eastern Nagaland is that this region has been failed by main-stream Nagaland.
 
This view is of course countered by mainstream Naga politicians. One viewpoint is a number of MPs from various 
parties actually hailed from this region.

The list includes sitting Rajya Sabha MP, S. Phangnon Konyak of BJP. She is also the first woman Rajya Sabha from Nagaland.

Others were former MPs Chingwang Konyak, Asungba Sangtam, Wangyuh Konyak and Late CM Chang.

The Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO) has been stewarding a demand for Frontier Nagaland
for the last decade or so.

The influential Eastern Nagaland Students Federation (ENSF) had also quit the apex Naga Students Federation
(NSF) a few years back.

ends 






#'Frontier Nagaland' #ENPO demand for a new state carving out of Nagaland .... Amit Shah likely to visit Tuensang-Mon region in January


#FrontierNagaland #ENPO demand for a new state carving out of #Nagaland .... A spl panel to be set up by Centre for on spot studies; @AmitShah @HMOIndia likely to visit #Tuensang-Mon region by first week of January, 2023 





(If BJP Nagaland does not act, NPF chief Shurhozelie must)


It was a game-changer event. It was clear the Home Ministry was well prepared and had a blueprint ready. 


"Hon’ble Union Home Minister highlighted a clear Road-map for amicable, legislative and sustainable solution for Eastern Nagaland. Which will include consultation with the people of Eastern Nagaland and Nagaland State Government. Hon’ble Union Home Minister has also assured to visit Eastern Nagaland personally by January 2023; for which, the ENPO eagerly awaits his visit." 

- Team ENPO   









A crucial meeting between ENPO delegation and Home Minister Amit Shah was held in Delhi on Tuesday, Dec 6 evening.


The meeting scheduled earlier on December 3 was deferred as Union Home Minister Amit Shah was in Gujarat in view of elections in the western state.



Seven Naga Tribes reside in six administrative districts Tuensang, Mon, Shamatore, Kiphire, Longleng and Noklak bordering Myanmar. 



These tribes are Konyaks, Sangtams, Changs, Phoms, Khiamniungans, Yimchungrus and Tikhirs. Earlier the region had only two districts Tuensang and Mon.



An 11-member delegation of ENPO leaders accompanied two former MPs Asungba Sangtam and Wangyuh Konyak are in the capital.

Some of the ENPO leaders are critical of the Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio and his NDPP-BJP-NPF dispensation in Kohima.









These seven tribes have stayed away from this year's annual tourism extravaganza of Hornbill Festival being hosted in the state capital Kohima. 



Some community leaders say the gesture could be interpreted as Eastern Nagaland's lack of trust in the Rio government.



On December 3, a few ENPO leaders did not appear much enthusiastic about the state government delegation led by Chief Minister Rio to attend the meeting with Home Minister Shah. 



"Are they also coming? But why?," remarked the source on the condition of anonymity.



Another ENPO leader said as far as the people of the Mon-Tuensang region are concerned; only those who back "Our demand for Statehood" should logically attend the meeting.

Monday, December 5, 2022

ENPO meeting with Shah for 'separate state' slated Tuesday evening


New Delhi 


Amid fast progress in peace talks to resolve the decades-old Naga insurgency, all eyes are on the centre's stance on the demand for a separate state 'Frontier Nagaland' carving out of eastern part of the state. 

The meeting between Home Minister Amit Shah and Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO) is likely to be held on Tuesday, Dec 6th, evening. 
Eastern Nagaland region - native home of seven tribes- was included as part of Nagaland state by way of the 16 Point Agreement inked in 1960.





"Ball in the centre's court," says the Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO), the apex organisation stewarding the demand for separate statehood. 


The meeting scheduled earlier on December 3 was deferred as Union Home Minister Amit Shah was in Gujarat in view of elections in the western state.


Seven Naga Tribes reside in six administrative districts Tuensang, Mon, Shamatore, Kiphire, Longleng and Noklak bordering Myanmar. 


These tribes are Konyaks, Sangtams, Changs, Phoms, Khiamniungans, Yimchungrus and Tikhirs. Earlier the region had only two districts Tuensang and Mon.


An 11-member delegation of ENPO leaders accompanied two former MPs Asungba Sangtam and Wangyuh Konyak are in the capital.

Some of the ENPO leaders are critical of the Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio and his NDPP-BJP-NPF dispensation in Kohima.


These seven tribes have stayed away from this year's annual tourism extravaganza of Hornbill Festival being hosted in the state capital Kohima. 


Some community leaders say the gesture could be interpreted as Eastern Nagaland's lack of trust in the Rio government.


On December 3, a few ENPO leaders did not appear much enthusiastic about the state government delegation led by Chief Minister Rio to attend the meeting with Home Minister Shah. 


"Are they also coming? But why?," remarked the source on the condition of anonymity.


Another ENPO leader said as far as the people of the Mon-Tuensang region are concerned; only those who back "Our demand for Statehood" should logically attend the meeting.


Answering questions, the source went on to state, "Unless they are coming to sabotage our demand and a very specific demand of a new state, why will they feel comfortable in the room?"


Tsapikiu Sangtam, president ENPO, Chingmak Chang, president ENSF, Y Konyak, ENWO representative and Lemba Chang member ENPO are also part of the delegation.


When Tuensang and Mon districts were included in the 1960s to be 'parts of the 16th state of Indian union', that is the present day state of Nagaland, there were a lot of hopes and aspirations for seven tribes from this region.


But the general feeling now is that this region has been failed by main-stream Nagaland. 

This view is of course countered by mainstream Naga politicians. One viewpoint is a number of MPs from various parties actually hailed from this region.


The list includes sitting Rajya Sabha MP, S. Phangnon Konyak of BJP. She is also the first woman Rajya Sabha from Nagaland.


Others were former MPs Chingwang Konyak, Asungba Sangtam, Wangyuh Konyak and Late CM Chang.


The Eastern Nagaland People's Organisation (ENPO) has been stewarding a demand for Frontier Nagaland

for the last decade or so.


Surveys in the 1990s had revealed that along the entire eastern belt of Nagaland (encompassing the six districts), runs a rich vein of coal, limestone, nickel, marble, cobalt and magnite. But most of these have remained untapped due to a plethora of reasons.


A retired IAS officer in the state told IANS: "Blessed with the temperate climate, Nagaland on the whole has remained one of the few green spots, rich in sub tropical diversity and mineral wealth. Yet it has retained the sub-Himalayan climatic characteristics".


Some years back, the students from Eastern Nagaland took the tough plunge and the Eastern Nagaland Students' Federation (ENSF) dissociated themselves from the apex and much influential Naga Students' Federation (NSF).


The grievance was never in its history a Naga from Tuensang-Mon region was allowed to become

President of NSF.


The government of India has on the other hand made significant progress in peace talks with NNPG, an umbrella organisation

of Naga underground outfits. The NSCN-IM demand for a separate Flag and Constitution have been

rejected by the centre.


According to clause 10 (b) of the 16 Point (or Statehood) Agreement, there was a provision for setting up of a  Regional Council with elected representatives from all the tribes and the Governor may nominate representatives to the Regional Council. It was also stated that the "Regional Council will elect members of the Naga Legislative Assembly". 


The demand for a separate state comprising Eastern Nagaland had gained momentum at a time when the NSCN-IM was negotiating with the Government of India for 'unification of all Naga contiguous areas'.  Nagas reside in parts of Myanmar and also in states such as Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh. The centre has earlier ruled out possibilities of redrawing the boundaries of these three northeastern states.  

The Nagas of Assam and Arunachal Pradesh have lately supported the initiatives of umbrella organisation NNPG to resolve the Naga issue with the government of India through dialogues and discussions.


The Modi government stance and decision on Ladakh region vis-a-vis Jammu and Kashmir in 2019 has fueled speculation in some quarters on whether a similar roadmap may be adopted even with regard to the eastern part of Nagaland state. 



Ends



Had Naga issue was resolved; probably 'ENPO frustration' would not have been so stark as it is today

The BJP in Nagaland must also own up its share of utter failure.  


In remembering Oting, we must lay emphasis on Solution 

Unfortunately that is yet to be the public pledge




New Delhi 


It is the solemn duty of every Naga and every Nagaland watcher to recall the Otingmassacre with anguish and pain.
The Nagas were waiting for a Christmas gift and peace and solution to the decade old insurgency issue.

But what came about was a great tragedy.


'Nagaland Page' Link



Things have come a full circle yet again. But what has changed in the last 12 months?
Politicians battling it out with no holds barred has been a hallmark of statehood history. In 2022, there is an added flavour and twist as the demand for carving out of Frontier Nagaland has reached its crescendo.





A section of pseudo intellectuals and urban Naxals may try to drag helpless Nitin Gadkari in the row from the old files; but the fault line was elsewhere. In fact, more than a fault line it had cropped up as a statecraft.

The good old Divide and Rule ! 

In terms of what happened in Oting, this journalist has stated earlier that perhaps nothing has changedmuch between 1995 and 2021 or even in 2022. One needs to talk about restoring the confidence of the people in the government apparatus vis-a-vis

development and also on the use of forces in relation to the Disturbed Area Act. This is true for Nagasin the ENPO region and also in mainstream Nagaland.The anti incumbency mood is gradually turning into a hidden volcano. Visit the Whatsapp university for atrailer. The Naga peace talks is at an advance stage. But games are still on to further delay the process that beganin 1997.

The ENPO politics from Delhi's Babudom in effect had started around 2010-11 after the mandarins realisedthat nothing much was moving on peace parleys as the status quo suited some stakeholders andalso players in the corridors of power in Kohima. The accidental Prime Minister Manmohan Singh was in office.

The regionalist doyen Shurhozelie may in 2022 realise some of the follies of his politics; but his party and the leadership did not do much to resolve the problem over the years.

They got an opportunity and a long stint in office as Nagaland voters were already disenchanted with the Congress party.

But the golden opportunity was wasted. 

The NPF giants were sitting happy to have continued in power. The legacy was systematically passed ontothe 2018 created and Ram Madhav-blessed NDPP. Other BJP stalwarts Prime Minister Narendra Modi andHome Minister Amit Shah did not interfere much into Nagaland matters. At best things used to reach NSAAjit Doval and that had given former Governor R N Ravi, a friend of Doval from Kerala cadre days,an edge to handle things.

Had the vexed Naga issue was resolved a decade back; probably the ENPO frustration would not have been so starkas it is today.

Shurhozelie and his friend-turned-rival Neiphiu Rio never seemed to appreciate one fact that Solution not onlymeant end of extortion agony, it also would have ensured enhanced development package for the six districtsof the ENPO region.

More importantly, the Disturbed Area Act and The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 could have beenhandled differently.

Hence the CNTC appeal in December 2021 -- 'AFSPA is a killer and Political Solution is a Healer' was the mostrelevant thing to have happened. But that somehow did not become a general state-wide pledge.

Shenanigans of Power Politics continued. A sitting Chief Minister of Assam, Himanta Biswa Sarma was almosthanded over a blank cheque provided it was known who will reap the harvest.

Shurhozelie and Rio would have done well to take note that the euphoria that was followed across Indiain the wake of Modi's spectacular win in 2014 and prior to that the real fruits of Liberalisation of the economyhad always eluded Nagaland.

Let's leave advanced states such as Gujarat or Karnataka, even hilly states such as Sikkim and ArunachalPradesh have benefited.

After the recent CSR Conclave as I interacted with officials and corporate captains in Delhi on their return, some of them pointed out what Nagaland lacks by way of infras and even law and order is made up by the immense mineralwealth and tourism and horticulture potentials.

But the movers and shakers had other plans. Unfortunately, some of them have not changed their mindset.

In August 2022 while interacting with NPF chief Shurhozelie, I got a sense that he realises some of the lapses of yesteryear. He used a powerful phrase -- "We will wake up on time".


A new dawn begins every day, we wake up. It is a natural phenomenon.
But with regard statecraft; -- it will be the biggest lie to claim that well, give us the moon and we can replace the old chaos upside down. 
The BJP in Nagaland must also own up its share of utter failure.  


ends  



Indian Politics, Freedom struggle and History :::: Need Revisit :::: Even Quit India Movement 'resolution' by Congress sought to make .... "its fullest contribution towards realisation of human freedom in the world, which is in danger of being crushed"

Indian history has many features, many layered anecdotes where politics, trade, warfare, and culture intersect.  Long-distance ties shaped I...