A declassified CIA research paper titled “India and the Sikh Challenge” has dealt with critical questions 'confronting' American policymakers from time to time:
--- How serious was the Sikh militancy/insurgency?
--- Was Pakistan actively supporting Sikh extremists?
Could India defeat the Khalistani movement? And what consequences would prolonged instability have for South Asia?
The most overlooked contribution of the CIA finding remains -- in its analysis of what it called the “Sikh International Network.”
Long before global terrorism financing became a dominant security concern, the CIA devoted an entire section to the overseas ecosystem sustaining the Punjab insurgency.
The Sikh organisations in Britain, Canada and the United States had developed extensive fundraising and propaganda networks that alsp generated financial support for extremist groups operating in Punjab.
Curiously, the paper validates Indian allegation and also paint a 'nuanced picture' that differs from both official Indian narratives and Pakistani denials.
The Khalistan movement is a 'Sikh separatist campaign' that sought to establish an independent sovereign state called Khalistan in the Punjab region of the Indian subcontinent.
The movement remains a prominent political and diplomatic issue, particularly among the Sikh diaspora in Canada, the UK, and Australia.
It remains largely curbed or suppressed in India.
The CIA had warned (in late 1980s) that unless the Govt of India addressed both the security and political dimensions of the crisis, Punjab could face a prolonged period of instability.
It also concluded that India had succeeded in slowing the growth of the insurgency.
Despite several successful security operations, Sikh extremists retained the ability to sustain violence through targeted assassinations, bombings and intimidation, it said.
Notably, under the leadership of religious figure Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, the movement escalated into an armed insurgency.
The period in 1980s and 1990s saw severe unrest and violence was met with decisive military action by the Indira Gandhi government, primarily the 1984 Operation Blue Star.
Militants were eliminated and flushed out of the Golden Temple in Amritsar, and there was also subsequent anti-Sikh riots following the assassination of Indira Gandhi on Oct 31, 1964.
The conflict and subsequent police crackdowns in the late 1980s and early 1990s largely eradicated the violent militancy in India.
The early 1990s were the deadliest phase of the conflict.
Between 1990 and 1991, around 6,000 people were killed in the region, including nearly 1,000 police officers and paramilitary personnel.
While earlier efforts predominantly targeted Hindus, by 1990, militants were increasingly killing proportionately more Sikhs who opposed their ideology.
Militant organizations such as Babbar Khalsa issued mandatory edicts across Punjab. They enforced strict religious and social codes, such as mandating religious uniforms in schools, banning alcohol and cigarettes, and dictating media representation.
The movement experienced significant internal factionalism and criminalization.
Under the guise of the separatist struggle, criminal gangs and armed groups began coercing businessmen and landowners for protection money to fund weapons and equipment.
The government had launched aggressive counter-militancy and policing operations, dispatching heavy army and paramilitary convoys into the state.
The CIA paper in the meantime did not portray Pakistan as directing every aspect of the insurgency. Instead, it described what amounted to calibrated support, sufficient to keep the movement alive without inviting unacceptable international costs.
The CIA report’s assessment of Pakistan was revealing.
By 1987, American intelligence believed Pakistan was “most likely training small numbers of Sikh extremists” and permitting them to use Pakistani territory as a sanctuary.
The CIA assessed that Islamabad was unlikely to dramatically expand its support because President General Zia-ul-Haq remained conscious that overt involvement could damage Pakistan’s improving relationship with Washington during the Soviet-Afghan war.
In other words, the CBI believed Pakistan sought to exert pressure on India while carefully avoiding actions that could trigger a larger confrontation or jeopardise Islamabad's strategic value to Washington.
The CIA also examined the organisations operating inside Punjab.
It identified the All India Sikh Students Federation and the Damdami Taksal as the principal extremist groups.
The organisations had become better armed.
The CIA report stated that these organisations probably received some assistance from Pakistan and that members were believed to have travelled across the border for training.
It also referred to diplomatic and intelligence reporting suggesting that elements of Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence were involved in facilitating support for Sikh extremists.
 |
| KPS Gill : Man who did 'miracles' and courted controversies |
ends
No comments:
Post a Comment