Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Should the Naga talks be allowed to go the Free Trade Agreement way ? ::::: Nagas may be floating between different streams - a good Govt job or a lucrative business

I attended a seminar on 'Management Rules and Failures' sometime back. Among many interesting anecdotes and 'lessons'; the gathering was told that --


Rewarding a non-performer—whether through bonuses, light workloads, or lenient treatment— actually destroys team morale and pushes high performers toward burnout or resignation.


They were also told that many companies across the globe including in developed countries fail to differentiate payouts or rely on equal or effort-based rewards rather than clear output metrics. 


Studies show nearly 25 to 30 percent of managers in Canada and the US award financial bonuses to their lowest performers. On way back, when I posed a question -- to my subconscious mind --


"Why Rewarding Non-Performers Happens" !! -- I remembered several Naga leaders - a few friends and a large army of my 'critics'. 


The fact is even with Naga talks; the 'stakeholders who matter more often dodge difficult conversations, preferring to appease underperformers".  


No more guessing - the prize goes to the Bolero scheme champion. 


However, mine is never a chilling mystery, 'no secrets buried deep' and not a case of a truth waiting to be uncovered. Most of it is well exposed by default and otherwise. 





2023 appeal for Solution - Remains unheard 




The 'mood' in general in Delhi is to ink a peace agreement and herald a new era of peace and tranquility. The BJP leaders remember the --  'Election for Solution' slogan during the 2018 state elections.

We would be soon soon in 2027 and by March 2028, two tenures of BJP-Regional party Govts will be over.


The biggest achievement so far has been 'no performance'. In the entire two developments came up - the creation of FNTA for 'eastern Nagaland' and the split in the NSCN-IM and formation of the Eastern Flank. 


The prizes can be shared between Kohima and Hebron. New Delhi can take credit for FNTA of course. 


Thus, the Ministry of Home affairs now expected to work for a conclusion to the Naga issue ahead of the 2028 polls. Well, by now a kid a born in 1997 - when talks started - is "enough adult" and can easily sing the song - the Solution should be "honourable, acceptable and inclusive".


The Naga peace talks had begun during the stint of I K Gujral as Prime Minister in 1997. All issues have been "discussed and finalised" since 2019 or so and now only a final solution pact is awaited. 


So what's the big deal ?  


With regard to the Trade Agreement with the US, the Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal said -- 

“As soon as the US is able to give us the preferential rate in comparison to our competition, we will finalise the Trade Agreement and announce the final details".  


I have marked the phrase 'preferential rate' in blue and will leave it at that.  


Should the Naga talks be allowed to go the Free Trade Agreement way ? I do not have the answer. 




Reward and Non-Performance 



I switch on to something else - 


"New ideas, new thinking and a new outlook into the future led to radical changes in the socio-political and socio-economic frontiers and the new awakening in the Nagas by turn of the first decade of the new millennium and array of developments led to the birth of the Nagaland Tribes Council - NTC in 2013". 

(Status Paper inked between New Delhi and NNPGs) 



But something else is on play in real sense.  A strong impression has gone that the Rio Govt is not doing enough to convince the NSCN-IM leadership to agree for a Solution pact. But on the other hand, the Eastern Flank has been criticising the NSCN-IM (Hebron camp).  



In a communique in August, the Eastern Flank alleged that the Government of India had served a three-month ultimatum from August to October 2019, stating there would be no further talks on a separate Naga flag and constitution. 


Despite this, it alleged, the Hebron leadership continued with "meaningless and endless talks" based on compromised "Competencies" within the Indian Constitution.


It further cited the Framework Agreement signed on August 3, 2015, between the Centre and NSCN-IM, alleging that after New Delhi  betrayed the agreement.


The EF also said Muivah had on November 7, 2024, declared that the NSCN-IM would resume violent 'armed resistance' if its political initiative was rejected, but Hebron failed to act on that declaration.






R-Day parade in Delhi : India is emerging power 




The taste of a cake is in its eating.  The Nagas are still awaiting a final Solution and Peace Agreement to end the Naga political problem. 

But 'business' is a different terminology altogether. 

Can Gautam Adani solve all problems ? People and precisely, the Nagas of Nagaland - will have to answer the question. 

The formation of Naga Youth Movement is one way to answer. But there are miles to go. 




In Bengali culture -- 'byabsa (business)' is still a bad connotation and a groom may not get bride of his choice with such credentials. In Uttarakhand, being a Fauzi is the most-preferred profession. 


In Gujarat and with Marwaris in Rajasthan -- it is business again. Common Nagas may be floating between three streams - a good Govt job, business and 'politico-business'. Recently, a Bengali college pass-out from Dimapur called me seeking my help. 


I thought he was -- looking for some advise or reference for media works. He surprised me and wanted to know what he should do to launch a startup business project. 


My quickest response was --  "Go to Northern Angami hills".  Are you all surprised at my suggestion? 


He had a bigger surprise -- the young man said - "Correct sir, my uncle also suggested me the same". 




When will an 'effective' Double Engine come to Nagaland ?


 



ends 

"No single charge of corruption has been levelled against any participant in Govt or against any minister" -- Defence Minister Rajnath Singh in Tokyo

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh said in Tokyo:


"Despite running the government continuously for twelve and a half years, no one—not just in India, but anywhere in the world—can point a finger and claim that a single charge of corruption has been levelled against any participant in the government, any minister, or the government as a whole. 



No one can say that...I can state with confidence that no one can cast a doubt on the integrity of this government...".  









Rajnath Singh also said:


"No one can deny the fact that India has emerged as one of the fastest-growing economies in the world. There is a crisis unfolding in West Asia, and you can see various other crises within the international community...


"Despite this, our growth rate remains around 7.8%. This is no small feat. You are aware of how difficult and risky it is for oil tankers to pass through the Strait of Hormuz; consequently, India is unable to source the full volume of oil it requires through that route. 


"All of this is well known. Yet, our government has ensured that the momentum of the economy—the pace at which it moves—has not slowed down...".   


Rajnath Singh also said:


"You will be pleased to know that today, India is exporting weapons and various other defense items worth Rs 40,000 crore. 


".... defense production has now grown to over 1,80,000 crore. As for our nation’s armed forces—the Army, the Navy, and the Air Force—you may have witnessed the remarkable feats they have achieved, such as in 'Operation Sindoor'...". 

Shiv Sena tears pages from Sonia Gandhi's book over remarks on Savarkar, demands ban ::::: "Sonia Gandhi has hatred towards the country and Hindus"

Shiv Sena protested Sonia Gandhi's memoir, accusing it of insulting Veer Savarkar and Marathi pride, tearing pages and demanding the publisher withdraw the book until corrections are made.   


"While Congress freedom fighters were enduring assaults and imprisonment at the hands of the British rulers, senior ideologues of the RSS like Vinayak Damodar Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to their colonial masters and their members were colluding with the British authorities as informers," the passage in Sonia's book reads.









Shiv Sena leaders outlined three demands -- 

First, HarperCollins should withdraw the book and remove all pages containing what the party considers derogatory remarks about Savarkar. 

Second, circulation of the book in Maharashtra should be banned. 


Third, the party would take its protest to various online platforms.


The Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena on Wednesday launched a protest against Sonia Gandhi's memoir, tearing pages from the book over remarks on Hindutva ideologue V D Savarkar and demanding its withdrawal from circulation in Maharashtra. 


Accusing the Congress leader of insulting Savarkar and undermining Marathi pride, the party sought the removal of two contentious passages from the memoir. 


The party also demanded that circulation of the book be stopped in Maharashtra until the publisher makes the necessary corrections. Shiv Sena leaders Sanjay Nirupam, Shaina NC, Anand Dubey and others participated in the protest.


The controversy centres on remarks about Savarkar, who was from Maharashtra and the RSS in two passages cited by the protesters, appearing on pages 201 and 443 of the book.


On page 201, while mentioning Indira Gandhi's antipathy to the politics of the RSS, Sonia Gandhi wrote that while Congress freedom fighters were facing assaults and imprisonment under British rule, senior RSS ideologues such as Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to the colonial authorities.  


On page 443, Sonia describes Savarkar as the founder of the ideology of Hindutva and says his vision viewed India primarily as a nation where Hindus were supreme. It further links this outlook to the RSS, the BJP and their affiliates, collectively referred to as the Sangh Parivar.


"That ideology dismisses the delineation of the country and the rights of its citizens set down in the Constitution as ideas opposed to the ethos of Hindu civilisation, ideas they dismiss as being derived from Western countries with fundamentally alien values," the book said.


Reacting to the passages, Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Nirupam launched a sharp attack on Sonia Gandhi, describing the book as "Belonging: A Journey of Hate" rather than Belonging: A Journey of Love.


"Sonia Gandhi harbours deep hatred towards the freedom fighters and revolutionaries of this country. She also has hatred towards the country and its Hindus," Nirupam said.


He accused the Congress leader of insulting Savarkar through her remarks and said the party had gathered to protest against the alleged disrespect.


"As a mark of protest, we tore out the page of the book that contains the insulting remarks about Savarkar," he said. "The Shiv Sena in Maharashtra will not tolerate any insult to Savarkar".  






On plea seeking removal of videos of Italian leader questioning Indian elections at Bharat Summit, Advocate Syed Rizwan Ahmed says, 


"Our petitioner is represented by Advocate Zahid Ali from Delhi. We argued that during a program organised in Telangana by the Government of Telangana and the Samudra Bharat Foundation, under the banner of the 'Global Progressive Alliance', certain terminology was used by foreign nationals that directly challenges our democratic process. 


They employed highly offensive and abusive language... A foreign national, while on Indian soil, is claiming that he will 'save' India's democracy. 


"We have sought two forms of relief. First, we have requested an interim order to have all this material, which is currently circulating online, taken down. Second, we have demanded an unconditional apology from both the Government of Telangana and the Samudra Bharat Foundation. 


"Additionally, we have sought an undertaking that any future programs they may organise must not challenge India's democracy or its institutions...".


ends 


Putin says - Europe was in a “humiliating decline” and anti-Russian sanctions backfired" :::::::: “We should eliminate trade and investment barriers... and also promote balanced development,” says Chinese President :::::

US President Trump Lands in Shenzhen Ahead of Key Talks With Chinese and Russian Leaders


Trump's stated goal for the first-ever summit between the nations' three leaders is to start a discussion on nuclear disarmament. 

But the fear is that he could go off script and take positions on Ukraine or Taiwan that undermine their interests or appear to side with their chief adversaries, according to several European officials and Western diplomats.


"We know that every time President Trump talks to or sees Putin, it translates into bad news for Ukraine and for Europe. We brace for anything," a European diplomat said. 



Chinese president Xi Jinping opened the Apec CEO summit on Wednesday with a speech calling for freer trade and greater cooperation around AI. 


“We should not only eliminate trade and investment barriers... but also promote inclusive and balanced development,” he said. 


“We should actively build partnerships for scientific and technological innovation, deepen cooperation in the digital economy and artificial intelligence and promote a green and low-carbon transition.”


Russian president Vladimir Putin also addressed the summit, speaking after Ukraine destroyed the vital Kerch road bridge linking occupied Crimea to Russia in a major blow to his four-year-old war.









 Putin followed Xi on stage with a speech that described Western powers as “former hegemons”. 


He said Europe was in a “humiliating decline” and that anti-Russian sanctions imposed ⁠after his invasion of Ukraine had backfired, instead making his country stronger. Xi and Putin headed into a meeting after their opening addresses, according to Chinese and Russian state media.  







The much-anticipated trilateral meeting between US president Donald Trump, Xi and Putin will take place on Thursday. The three men are due to meet on the sidelines and potentially discuss Russia’s war with Ukraine and the US war in Iran, as well as other flashpoints such as trade, ⁠AI and nuclear weapons.


The meeting has drawn comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference between the US, Britain and the Soviet Union that formalised spheres of influence, set the stage for world order after the second world war and became shorthand for great power deals imposed on smaller countries.


It is unclear whether North Korean leader Kim Jong-un will attend the talks, but Trump has floated the possibility. On Wednesday US secretary of state Marco Rubio said the US president was willing to engage, but he did not confirm whether a meeting had been set in Shenzhen.


Trump said on Wednesday that the US has just ⁠concluded a “very big ⁠trade ​deal” with the Philippines, but he did not provide any details, and Manila ⁠did not announce any agreement. 


“We’ve just consummated a very big trade deal, the ⁠biggest trade deal we’ve ever made so far, and it ​is a fair ‌deal for both countries,” ‌Trump said during a state luncheon at the Philippine ‌presidential palace.  



Neither China nor Russia was enthusiastic about discussing denuclearization. But China agreed after Russian lobbying. And Putin saw the summit as a chance to lobby Trump on Ukraine.


Behind the scenes: The Trump-Xi-Putin summit was a topic of closed-door talks among European leaders at a meeting in Dublin last week, according to a European diplomat.


Some of them raised concerns about what Trump might say about the war in Ukraine, the diplomat said.  German Chancellor Friedrich Merz was among the more vocal during the private session. He then went out and spoke about it publicly.

"Our message to the U.S. before Trump meets Putin is: No surprises, please," Merz said.  


Japanese officials also privately relayed concerns to U.S. counterparts about the message the summit might project about Washington's stance on Taiwan or Asia more broadly.


A potential public meeting between Trump and Kim Jong Un would be even more concerning for Japan.









ends 

"No other political party can build temples in Mathura and Kashi", says BJP leader and UP Minister Siddharthnath Singh

Uttar Pradesh BJP leader Siddharthnath Singh says, "Mathura-Kashi-Ayodhya is a cultural issue for the BJP, and it always will be. 


"The Ram temple has been built in Ayodhya. The people of the country and all the followers of Sanatan Dharma are confident that no other political party can build (temples) in Mathura and Kashi. It will only be built by the Bharatiya Janata Party under the leadership of Modi ji and in Uttar Pradesh under the leadership of Yogi ji. So it's natural, and we have always said, 'Radhe Radhe, Kamal Khila De'"









"Akhilesh ji is now using the word 'Rath', which is a bit surprising to me. May he take Lord Ram's blessings in Ayodhya. One thing is certain, Akhilesh ji: your party, the Samajwadi Party, will be finished in 2027 this time around."

From the past :::: Relevant and Hot topic ::: "Like the proverbial Phoenix, Sonia Gandhi's foreign origin will keep cropping up again and again"


"I am not presumptuous enough to think that Mrs Sonia Gandhi decided to renounce her claim to the office of prime minister as a result of my article. But, I do feel that her decision shows she has the right instinct and has a tremendous capacity for lucid thinking," wrote former Additional Secretary B Raman.

He was in the Cabinet Secretariat heading the counter-terrorism division of R&AW. 


His article created political ripples in 1999 and later in 2004 when Sonia Gandhi actually did not take oath as the Prime Minister and instead gave the coveted post to Dr Manmohan Singh. 


"Whatever the critics of those who had raised this issue might say, it was an important issue which had to be debated in a balanced manner in the intellectual and Constitutional plane on the basis of facts and figures. Unfortunately, during the recent election, it was raised by her opponents in an extremely offensive and indecorous manner, befitting more Hyde Park orators than responsible political leaders of a complex country like India," Raman wrote in an article for Rediff.com in 2004.



Sonia Gandhi and P V Narasimha Rao 




The fact that her critics were defeated in the election does not mean that this issue is dead forever. 


Like the proverbial Phoenix, it will keep cropping up again and again, poisoning the political atmosphere and debate and creating one more cause of polarisation in an already much polarised society.


"In many democracies, there is a simple mechanism in the form of a referendum to deal with issues like this. Whereas the results of the recent elections could be interpreted in conflicting ways on the question of the right of a citizen of foreign origin to aspire to high office, there could be only one interpretation to the results of a referendum. Either accepted or rejected," said Raman.


He also wrote:


"Mrs Sonia Gandhi should persuade the Congress (I) to take the initiative for amending the Constitution with the support of all the parties in order to provide for a referendum. 


Thereafter, the Congress (I) government should hold a referendum on the single question: 'Should a person of foreign origin be entitled to hold office as the President, the Vice-President or the Prime Minister?'


If the majority votes yes, that would be the end of the controversy once and for all and the Congress (I) would re-emerge in the next election, whenever held, as the party with an absolute majority, totally marginalising all her opponents and confining them to political vanavas for many years."









Raman wrote:


"In April 1999, I wrote an article on the inadvisability of Mrs Sonia Gandhi aspiring to the office of prime minister and had sent copies of it to The Statesman of New Delhi and Business Line of Chennai. It was not carried by either of them for nearly five weeks. I presumed they must have trashed it and forgot about it.


On the morning of May 16, 1999, I received a phone call from Mike Woolridge of the BBC for an off-the-record interview on my article on Sonia Gandhi, which had appeared in the Statesman of that morning. "When were you the intelligence chief of India?" he asked me. I replied I was never the chief of any intelligence agency and asked him why he posed that question.


He replied that the Statesman had carried my article as a second lead story on the front page under the heading 'Sonia, a security threat, says ex-intelligence chief' and asked me whether I wrote the article. I replied that I did write an article on Sonia Gandhi and sent it to the Statesman and Business Line, but thought they had both rejected it. I added that in my article I had drawn attention to some national security related problems that could arise if she became the prime minister, but nowhere had I described her as a security threat nor had I projected myself as a former intelligence chief. I had given my correct designation as a retired additional secretary at the Cabinet Secretariat.


Woolridge said there was talk among diplomats in New Delhi that I must have written the article at the instance of Mr Sharad Pawar and Mr P A Sangma, who had broken away from the Congress (I) the previous day over this very same issue. I replied it was rubbish and added that I did not know either of them.


The Times of India carried a report on its front page alleging that I must have drafted the statement issued by Pawar and Sangma. It claimed to see a similarity in the style and language used in my article and in their statement.


On May 19, 1999, I was pleasantly surprised to find my article figuring on the top of the editorial page of Business Line under a more correct five-column headline: 'Ms Sonia Gandhi as PM: Points to Ponder, Problems to Solve.'


In my article, I had stated as follows: 'Ms Sonia Gandhi would go up in the esteem of the people of India and the rest of the world were she to make a gesture of self-abnegation and announce that while she would continue to lead and guide the Congress (I) for which the Nehru-Indira Gandhi families have contributed so much, it would not be proper on her part to aspire to the office of Prime Minister. If the party gets the opportunity to form the Government, she should help in choosing some other leader for the post. Further, were she to take the initiative in proposing for inclusion in the Congress (I)'s manifesto, a promise for an amendment of the Constitution to lay down that only Indian citizens by birth can hold the offices of the President, the Vice-President and the Prime Minister, she will be the toast of India.'


Surprisingly, the article was ignored by the Congress (I). In a television interview, Shri Inder Malhotra, the eminent journalist, was asked whether it was a motivated article. He replied: "I know Raman well. He is not the type who will write an article like that with any hidden motive." In another interview, Shri Mani Shankar Aiyar of the Congress (I) was asked about it. He replied: "I don't know who this Raman is. I wouldn't take him seriously."


The article elicited rebukes from many former intelligence chiefs. One asked: "What went wrong with you? " Another described it as unwise and stupid.  



"A few days later, I received a phone call from the late R N Kao, the founding father of R&AW (Research and Analysis Wing, India's external spying agency). 


He said: "Raman, somebody told me about your article which I had missed. I read it today. I wanted to compliment you. I hold Sonia Gandhi in great esteem and I know how Rajiv loved her and what affection Indira Gandhi had for her. 


She and her family would get involved in an unpleasant and divisive controversy if she aspired to the office of PM. I like your idea of self-abnegation. This needed to be voiced and only you would have had the courage to do so in such polite and compelling language."


ends 


Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Fresh violence erupts in Sheikh Hasina's hometown :::: "People can vote against us. That is their democratic right. But the same right must be given to Awami League", said Hasina

A police station and a lawmaker's residence were set ablaze amid escalating tensions in Gopalganj, while authorities have deployed armoured vehicles, drones and body cameras to monitor the situation.  


Fresh violence erupted in Gopalganj, the hometown of deposed Bangladesh prime minister Sheikh Hasina, and neighbouring areas following the killing of a local Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) leader during clashes involving police and supporters of the former ruling Awami League.




File snap of violence in Bangladesh 



The unrest broke out in the Tungipara sub-district of Gopalganj following the arrest of several suspected Awami League supporters. It subsequently spread to neighbouring areas, including Faridpur, where BNP's local farmers' wing leader Raju Mollah was killed during clashes in Bhanga on Tuesday, Nov 17. 


Amid the violence, a police station and the residence of BNP lawmaker SM Zilany were set on fire. Attackers also reportedly targeted a local BNP office and several motorcycles. Family members and others fled the lawmaker's residence during the attack, while his whereabouts remained unknown.


The latest violence comes just days after supporters of the banned Awami League staged demonstrations in Gopalganj, raising concerns over the deteriorating law and order situation in the district.


Amid escalating tensions, Bangladesh has deployed 10 platoons of Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB) personnel at key locations across Gopalganj to maintain law and order and prevent further violence.


The developments come amid growing political tensions in Bangladesh over reports that Hasina plans to return to the country in December.


Supporters of the Awami League have intensified their activities in Gopalganj, Hasina's ancestral hometown, amid calls for her return. The party has been disbanded by the current authorities. In a separate development in Dhaka, unidentified miscreants reportedly set fire to at least four parked buses and detonated crude bombs at several locations on Tuesday evening. 


No casualties were reported in these incidents.  


Last week, former Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has questioned the decision to bar her party, the Awami League, from participating in elections, saying voters should be allowed to decide whether to accept or reject it.


“If the authorities believe the party has lost public support, they should allow it to contest elections and let the people decide,” she said. “People have every right to criticise me or the Awami League. Parties can campaign against us. They can vote against us. That is their democratic right. But the same right must be given to us"/


Hasina referred to the Awami League’s role in Bangladesh’s independence struggle and its history of surviving military rule, political bans and the imprisonment of its leaders. She said the party’s history could not be erased through a government order.


ends 

Should the Naga talks be allowed to go the Free Trade Agreement way ? ::::: Nagas may be floating between different streams - a good Govt job or a lucrative business

I attended a seminar on 'Management Rules and Failures' sometime back. Among many interesting anecdotes and 'lessons'; the g...