Friday, January 6, 2023

HM Amit Shah thinks 'being practical' means giving Neiphiu Rio more time

HM endorses 20-40; but CM "may work" for Solution by Jan 26


New Delhi/Dimapur


If P V Narasimha Rao's famous dictum 'Not to take a decision is also a decision' is an ideological guide with some BJP guys including Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee what was/are stated 'halfheartedly' were often more important.  














Has beleaguered Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio won the crucial and semi-final round? Did Home Minister Amit Shah still show trust in the incumbent leadership in Nagaland and wants the Chief Minister to deliver on both fronts -- elections and Solution?


Only consolation for those working hard for last two years -- the civil society organisations and making impatient plea for an early Solution even with slogans and banners on Friday - seems an halfhearted reference to the phrase 'President's Rule'.


In his closed door meeting with 11 key leaders, Shah even negated all clamours and grievances about 20-40 formula which is largely seen as a 'life saver drug' for Rio personally.


"Well if elections are not allowed and people do not participate...whatelse; we can have President's Rule," he reportedly said but those present suggest it was like a passing remark and perhaps uttered more in a lighter vein. But it could be important to read 'between the words'.  


"We will stick to the 20-40 formula. It is being practical. Time is not yet ripe for us to get a BJP chief minister in Nagaland," Shah reportedly said at the meeting.  One participant at the Friday meeting said the NNPG is ready to sign the peace pact and resolve the issue. At this probably there was a query -- "Don't you think, the Govt of India has to assess which group has more arms?"


This is understandably the version of NDPP leadership. So, either Govt of India is buying this line, or want the state government to 'deliver'. 


But for any Solution to the Naga problem, Shah was firm that either of the contentious demands the Flag or the separate Naga constitution cannot be accepted ever.


It is worth mentioning that the apex NPAC could possibly gauge things from before and has even stated in a memorandum addressed to Home Minister Shah on that if the negotiations happening since 1997 are not brought to its logical conclusion, it will be perhaps better to call the Naga talks a "fiasco" as the "indecision does not benefit any party".


Of course, like any incumbent government even the Narendra Modi-led dispensation will have to ensure that the elections in each state in the country are held on time.  Thus even Shah explained -- almost repeat of what Indrajit Gupta ( communist Home Minister in 1998) had said - "As India's ruling party and the government in office we have to ensure conducting of elections".







Of course the final taste of the pudding or even any Gujarati or Naga delicacy lies in its eating.


If the Election Commission by itself says, situation is not conducive for polls, then automatically President's Rule will come. The official argument can be that conducting polls in the job of the election panel and governments both in the centre and in the state(s) can only provide officials and ensure safety and security of candidates, election workers and voters by and large.


The second but big 'if' still remains - as they say - between lip and the cup -- may be Shah during his meeting has given a time-specific directive to Chief Minister Rio to deliver on Solution 'on time'.


This could mean that even by January 26th - the Republic Day or even January 15 - all stakeholders can be brought together to sign the final peace pact.


Ironically, in 1998, the NSCN-IM was against the polls. In 2023, what's its stance is not known publicly. But it is whispered that the group has "nexus" with state politicians in 'good positions' and thus they are not against election per se and it wants their men to be in power. 


The NNPG led by N Kitovi Zhimomi on the other hand is fiercely against the elections. The NNPG had earlier more than once demanded resignation of the regime led by Rio to facilitate an early signing of a peace pact. It has already signed the preliminary Agreed Position in 2017 when R N Ravi was the state Governor and negotiator. It is well known that political lobbying and some pressure tactics ultimately led to transfer of Ravi as the Governor of Tamil Nadu.





'Nagaland Page' link


"There are leaders who would like to continue with the status quo so that undeterred exploitation of Nagaland and its people could continue. For them ‘no solution is solution’ so that they could continue to loot the State and its people," wrote former CM and ex-Gujarat Governor S C Jamir in an article.


There are two other scenarios. Post-polls NDPP could merge with the BJP and there will be reasons more than one to do so. Secondly, Rituraj Sinha's exercise on Jan 5th to meet NDPP stalwarts and sitting MLAs was not for a winter picnic session. 


ends     


Pakistan lands at a crossroads: Citizens fear imposition of 'Afghan-style Sharia'

New Delhi 

What you sow, so shall you reap !


After about two years Pakistani military establishment and other stakeholders rejoiced the defeat of US-led forces in Afghanistan and the win of the Taliban, an eminent Pakistani expert and author says, "To help lift the Afghan Taliban into power was a massive strategic miscalculation (by Islamabad)." 












"For years, our security managers used state propaganda machinery to assure us that the Afghan and Pakistani Taliban are somehow different. That delusion stands fully exposed,' writes Pakistani author and expert Pervez Hoodbhoy for that country's newspaper 'Dawn'.


He laments that - "Over 100 attacks have occurred over the last 50 days. Most spectacular among them was last week’s capture of the (Pakistani) Counter Terrorism Department in Bannu by the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) .

Hoodbhoy also says, "Tactical blunders are also making Pakistanis increasingly anxious".

"....freshly victorious against a superpower, Kabul’s new rulers openly taunt Pakistan, dismissing possible Pakistani air or land incursions against TTP sanctuaries inside Afghanistan. Pakistan has created for itself yet another hostile neighbour and another nightmare," he laments.

In the meantime creating alarm for Pakistani intellectuals, common citizens and security establishments,reports suggest many elements have started operating from Afghanistan itself. Another report said, the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and Baloch separatists have announced their government in the northern region (of Pakistan) and declared various ministers in an attempt to break Pakistan into two nations. 

It is also the "largest militant organization" that is fighting against Pakistani border security personnel. 

An article in 'India Today' has raked up issues that are being debated in several quarters in India, Pakistanand other South Asian countries. "After 14 years, did Pakistan appear to be staring towards similar security threats? In the last few weeks, multiple bomb explosions have been reported in the Afghan-Pakistan border regions. The question is, will Pakistan be able to stop these attacks from reaching the capital this time around?"

As a concerned intellectual, Pervez Hoodbhoy writes in his piece in 'Dawn' that -"As a starter, TTP wants to impose Afghan-style Sharia in Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) before extending the system across Pakistan. This means terminating female education, justice via limb-chopping, installing a shura system headed by an amirul momineen in place of democracy, and cutting Pakistan off from the modern world".


He also points out: "For non-Muslims, Shias, (Sunni) Barelvis and modern-minded Muslims, this is grotesque".

On the other hand, he argued that the radicalised sections of "urban Pakistani society as well as backward areas welcome this version of Sharia".

Relations between Taliban rulers and Pakistani establishment that seemed so smooth in 2020 August have also deteriorated. According to Pakistan, the TTP is using  Afghanistan's soil to launch attacks on Pakistan and this prompted a  sharp denial from the Taliban government in Kabul.Pakistani Interior Minister Rana Sanaullah too has suggested that Islamabad could be forced to take unilateral action against the TTP inside Afghanistan.

In response, a Taliban spokesperson said that it was trying its best that the territory of Afghanistan is not used against Pakistan. "We are committed to this goal, but the Pakistani side is also responsible to try controlling the situation".


ends 

  



(Foreign secretary said the outcomes of the two-day ‘Voice of Global South Summit’ virtual will be channelled into India's G20 presidency.) 


New Delhi 

India is keen to befriend the global powers, but it has always taken along countries which areunder the Global South.  

Sri Lankan President Ranil Wickremesinghe will be among the 20 world leaders who will participate in the "Voice of the Global South Summit" (VGSS) on Jan 12 and 13 to be hosted by India virtually. 

The Summit will be chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Foreign Secretary, Vinay Kwatra said. 


Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and also leaders from five African countries Angola, Ghana, Nigeria, Mozambique and Senegal, three countries from the ASEAN grouping Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam will be also.Leaders and heads of governments in Uzbekistan, Mongolia, UAE and Papua New Guinea are also expected.


"The theme of the Summit is – ‘Unity of voice, Unity of purpose’, and it essentially envisages bringing together countries of the global South and share their perspectives and priorities on a common platform across a whole range of issues. More than 120 countries are being invited for this Voice of Global South Summit. This initiative is inspired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vision of ‘Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas Sabka Vishwas aur Sabka Prayas’," the Foreign Secretary said.

He said the mega event is also underpinned by India's philosophy of 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam'.

The ministerial sessions will be at Finance, Environment, Foreign, Energy, Health, Education, and Trade levels. 

The theme of the Inaugural Leaders' session is "Voice of Global South - for Human-Centric Development" and that of the Concluding Leaders' session is "Unity of Voice-Unity of Purpose". 


Four sessions would be held on Jan 12 and remaining six sessions on 13th January.


The Foreign Secretary said, "India has always been in the forefront and consistently championed the cause of the developing world. We have been strongly articulating the interest and concerns of our partners in the global South in all international fora, and mechanisms". 

He maintained that of course matters related to the Covid pandemic, and its serious impact and the fallout  of the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, increasing difficulties of access and affordability of food, fertilizer, and fuel, will figure prominently at the Summit.

Mr Kwatra said, "while assuming G20 Presidency, you would recall, Prime Minister Modi had said that India's G20 priorities would be shaped in consultation with not just G20 partners but also with our fellow travellers in the Global South, whose voice often goes unheard". 

This Summit, he pointed out, will thus also be an opportunity for those countries that are not part of the G20 process, he said.Mr Kwatra also said that, "the Environment Ministers’ session will focus on the theme of ‘Balancing Growth with Environment Friendly Lifestyles’.

He also stated that, "The valuable inputs generated from the partner countries receive due cognizance globally and India's ongoing Presidency of the G20 provides us with a special and strong opportunity to channelise these inputs into the deliberation and discourse of G20." 

To a question, the Foreign Secretary said, "The other element of the Voice of Global South Summit is that if you look at the concerns, interests and priorities of the large, overwhelming developing world that is outside the G20 often, the evidence would show that the relevant mechanisms that are supposed to factor them in, take them on board, address them, mitigate those challenges and amplify the opportunities".


ends 

More pressure mounts for Naga Solution, 'impatient plea' before Shah





Dimapur


The message from the state of Nagaland is amply clear, only Prime Minister Narendra Modi can deliver the Solution to the vexed Naga problem and so he must.


Union Home Minister Amit Shah was greeted with slogans and banners with Nagas of Nagaland under the aegis of Naga People's Action Committee (for Solution and lasting peace) making an impatient plea to Govt of India and the Prime Minister that the people of 16th state of Indian union want Solution to the Naga problem. 


The influential Naga People's Action Committee - a collective body of various tribal bodies and intellectuals and former lawmakers - has even stated in memorandum that if the negotiations happening since 1997 are not brought to its logical conclusion, it is perhaps better to call the Naga talks a "fiasco" as the "indecision does not benefit any party".



"Essentially, our case is Elections do not serve any key purpose. This is the story since 1998 when elections were held under constitutional duress and tricks deployed by the Congress party. Now since 2019 we are told the Naga peace talks are over.

 The Centre is also ready to ink a pact and so is umbrella body of seven militant groups NNPG. So, the issue is very simple: why should the game of sabotage win?," said one volunteer holding one of the banners near the Dimapur airport.


Some of the banner slogans read - 'Enough of Talks and Tall promises. Nagas want action', 'Naga Political Talk cannot be indefinite' and even one 'Amit Shah ji you have the power to deliver Solution'.


The NPAC in a memorandum addressed to Home Minister Shah and signed among others by its convener Theja Therieh and Joshua Sumi (Ex-Parliamentarians Association) among others said that, "Uncertainty looms large till date despite the official negotiations being completed in October 2019".


It further said, "We have lost our faith in the democratic process and therefore strongly demand Political Solution before the election. We assure you as the primary stakeholders that we will give our utmost cooperation towards implementation of the Solution."


The NPAC even went on to state that if the negotiations are not brought to its logical conclusion, it is perhaps better to call the talks a "fiasco" as the "indecision does not benefit any party".


The Naga peace talks had commenced in 1997 during the stint of I K Gujral as the Prime Minister and in October 2010 the Modi government and its chief interlocutor R N Ravi had said the talks were over. 

But inking of a peace pact has been delayed and virtually derailed since then with the NSCN-IM insisting on their demands for Naga Flag and a separate Constitution.


Both these demands have been categorically denied by the Centre. The NNPG is also keen to sign the peace pact and in the past it has alleged more than once that things were being delayed and denied by forces 'outside Nagaland'.


"There are leaders who would like to continue with the status quo so that undeterred exploitation of Nagaland and its people could continue. For them ‘no solution is solution’ so that they could continue to loot the State and its people," wrote 91-year-old former Nagaland CM and ex-Gujarat Governor S C Jamir in an article. 


Jamir personally enjoys good rapport with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and whom he calls a ".man with with guts and determination who can deliver and resolve complex issues like that of Nagas".


Jamir was also slated to call on Amit Shah on Friday as Shah arrived here on a whirlwind tour. 


The general refrain in Nagaland now is that the 'people's choice' is in favour of an early Solution pact which at least the centre is keen on and even the Naga National Political Groups (an umbrella body) of seven militant groups are also ready to ink. If Solution cannot come before polls, many like the Gaon Burrah (village elders) Federation and the Like Minded Leaders' Forum say President's Rule is the answer.


The only exception with regard to the Solution agreement, however, is the NSCN-IM which says the pact, if any, should guarantee a separate Flag and Naga Constitution. The NNPG in a strongly worded statement on Thursday accused Nagaland BJP chief Temjen Along of trying to sabotage the final peace pact and Solution.


“The politics of ‘Election for Solution of 2018’ have failed. Indo-Naga political solution is what the Naga tribes and civil societies anticipate. If election is enforced in Nagaland against the people’s demand for honourable and acceptable negotiated political settlement, men like Mr. Temjen Imna Along as per their trivial activities, will most certainly ensure a wipe out of BJP from Nagaland”, the NNPG stated while warning that the 1998 episode and late the Congress debacle and subsequent punishment is staring at Nagaland BJP in the face.


ends 

 



Thursday, January 5, 2023

'Bracing for Prez Rule', Nagaland debates 'People's choice' :::: Political churning: NDPP stalwarts, MLAs meet BJP's Sinha


The fact that a methodical and flamboyant former Chief Secretary, Alemtemshi Jamir, attended the meeting with Rituraj Sinha gives an impression that things have been worked out in certain quarters already.










New Delhi/Dimapur


Onus is on Nagaland's 'Man of the year 2023' - Narendra Modi to deliver.Solution is the 'new year gift' and the President's Rule will be a festival bonus. 

What will come first? 



BJP leader Rituraj Sinha on Thursday got an on-ground feedback on Neiphiu Rio's unpopularity especially among NDPP MLAs and organisational leaders.


More than the question of 'can he'; the issue in debate hours before the Prime Minister's trusted friend and handpicked powerful Home Minister Amit Shah's visit to Nagaland is, 'will he'?


If everyone-- insiders and outsiders and politicians and media persons - thought they knew Nagaland, welcome to new challenges and new opportunities -- time to explore the state yet again in a new fashion.


Reportedly 17 MLAs are ready to dump the sinking ship called NDPP - a party that basked on reflected glories of BJP and PM Modi for the last five years but constantly harmed its growth in Nagaland. 


The mega new twist in the tale came on Thursday when a group of ticket aspirants, NDPP stalwarts Imkong Imchen and Alemtemshi Jamir met BJP leader Rituraj Sinha and reportedly made a big case of doing away with the now infamous '40-20' formula. The deal inked on July 26, 2022 was grossly unjustified for the saffron party and peculiarly favoured Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio's continuation in office.


Two snaps in circulation in social media do not show Nalin Kohli, the so-called 'Nagaland in charge'of the saffron party whose contribution to Meghalaya BJP in 2018 was 2-seats win. BJP's Nagaland stateunit president Temjen Along was also not around, eyewitness accounts said.

BJP's Rajya Sabha MP, S Phangnon Konyak is seen alongside Rituraj Sinha. 

Those who attended the 'suddenly convened' meeting included a few sitting and former MLAs from the NDPP camp and most of them were apparently not ready for such a gathering today. "We all had perhaps given up.The 20-40 formula had a one-point agenda, ensure Rio in power and finish BJP in Nagaland. I was in the marketbut around 1300 hours I got a call. It was refreshing," said one sitting MLA. 


Going by the 'body language' and political gestures from some of these leaders -- most of them if not all - are already in the BJP by mind and heart. Formality awaited. "My resignation letter from the NDPP is in the briefcase, it willsoon reach my pocket," said one leader in a rather jovial mood.

"I have set no conditions for a BJP ticket as I am the junior most in the party now. But we are pro-change in the statefor many reasons," said another leader. 







Going by Thursday's meeting, if 32 ticket aspirants are obliged and BJP has 12 sitting legislators, the total number comes up pretty good and the saffron party could even contest all 60 seats, observers say. 


The fact that a methodical and flamboyant former Chief Secretary, Alemtemshi Jamir, attended the meeting with Rituraj Sinha gives an impression that things have been worked out in certain quarters already.


Does it imply, in days to come -- say within a fortnight more NDPP MLAs may quit and the stage could be ready for President's Rule?  

The general refrain in Nagaland now is that the 'people's choice' is in favour of an early Solution pact which at least the centre is keen on and even the Naga National Political Groups (an umbrella body) of seven militant groups are also ready to ink. If Solution cannot come before polls, many like the GB Federation and the Like Minded Leaders' Forumsay President's Rule is the answer.

The only exception with regard to the Solution agreement, however, is the NSCN-IM which says the pact, if any, should guarantee a separate Flag and Naga Constitution. Both the demands have been outright rejected by the Government of India.  

"There are leaders who would like to continue with the status quo so that undeterred exploitation of Nagaland and its people could continue. For them ‘no solution is solution’ so that they could continue to loot the State and its people," wrote former CM and ex-Gujarat Governor S C Jamir in an article. Jamir personally enjoys good rapport with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and whom he calls "a man with guts". 



ends 


 NNPGs adopt ‘Solution not Election’ stand


DIMAPUR, JANUARY 5: While launching a barrage of stinging criticisms at Nagaland BJP President Temjen Imna Along, the Working Committee of Naga National Political Groups (WC, NNPGs) has asserted that it was left with no option but to adopt “Solution not Election” stand as desired by the Naga people.


In a statement issued on Thursday, the Committee claimed that the “anti-solution stance of Nagaland State BJP President Mr. Temjen Imna Along and his cohorts” has greatly hampered the progress and fruition of Indo-Naga political talks.


“The evasive manoeuvre and non-committal attitude, the arrogance of Nagaland BJP President have accumulated beyond tolerance. Never once did he exhibit genuine concern and commitment for the Naga cause. On 9th November 2022, the WC, NNPGs wrote an official letter addressed to State BJP President for a meeting on crucial matters. Till date there is no response and he is still at large.


“Mr Temjen Imna Along has failed the Nagas and his own party. A man devoid of any principle, an opportunist and morally bankrupt, he is responsible for misleading the Naga people and betraying BJP leadership in New Delhi. WC, NNPGs will not allow such a man to represent the Nagas either at Kohima or in Delhi”, it stated.


The Committee reminded that in 1998, the Congress party assumed power uncontested after going against the wish of Naga people. “They failed to honour the people’s demand and rather believed they had wiped out all other regional political parties in Nagaland. The Naga people responded by promptly showing it an exit door. Sadly, the Congress party is struggling to regain the confidence of the people.


“After assuming state BJP leadership, Mr. Temjen Imna Along, a conman and a trickster, has fiddled with Naga political issue and played every dirty trick in the book to thwart the progress of Indo-Naga talks. The treacherous habit of State BJP leadership has deeply eroded the Naga people’s confidence”, it added.


According to the Committee, it has identified and observed numerous “selfish anti-Naga solution individuals and groups” working day and night to sabotage Naga solution.


“The politics of ‘Election for Solution of 2018’ have failed. Indo-Naga political solution is what the Naga tribes and civil societies anticipate. If election is enforced in Nagaland against the people’s demand for honourable and acceptable negotiated political settlement, men like Mr. Temjen Imna Along as per their trivial activities, will most certainly ensure a wipe out of BJP from Nagaland”, it stated while warning that the 1998 Congress debacle and subsequent punishment is staring at Nagaland BJP in the face.





Wednesday, January 4, 2023

'People's choice for Solution' and game of sabotage ::::: Big churning in #Nagaland politics before Amit Shah visit.

The trick called '40-20 formula' ....ensured Nagaland CM Neiphiu Rio continued in office... 'how long'? asks many Naga leaders !! 


Big churning in #Nagaland politics hours before Amit Shah visit. #BJP gets war-ready for polls. over 30 ticket aspirants including #NDPP (Rio's party) stalwarts, sitting legislators meet central BJP leaders and make a case against CM #Rio's 40-20 formula









NNPGs blast Temjen Along, adopt ‘Solution not Election’ stand


The pro-solution umbrella organisation, NNPG led by N Kitovi Zhimomi, on Thursday launched a barrage of stinging criticism at Nagaland BJP president Temjen Imna Along and asserted that it was left with no option but to adopt “Solution not Election” stand as desired by the Naga people.


In a statement the NNPG Working Committee claimed that the “anti-solution stance of Nagaland BJP chief Temjen Imna Along and his cohorts” has greatly hampered the progress and fruition of Indo-Naga political talks.


“The evasive manoeuvre and non-committal attitude, the arrogance of Nagaland BJP President have accumulated beyond tolerance. Never once did he exhibit genuine concern and commitment for the Naga cause. On 9th November 2022, the WC, NNPGs wrote an official letter addressed to State BJP President for a meeting on crucial matters. Till date there is no response and he is still at large".


 People's choice for Solution' and game of sabotage


New Delhi 


The 'hands of clock' seem to have come back to the same position from where it all started. More and more Naga organisations and individual leaders are calling for avoiding or boycott of ensuing assembly elections in Nagaland giving reminiscence of the 1998 drama.

The United Front was in power in the centre and S C Jamir-led Congress government headed the regime in Kohima. Similar calls were made to stay away from assembly elections, but the poll process that follows a constitutional mechanism did take place and as many as 43 Congress candidates including Jamir just cake walked into the august House and Jamir retained power. 


The BJP and two regional parties Nagaland People's Council (which now is NPF) and the fledgling Nationalist Democratic Movement (NDM) had stayed away from the polls.


NNPG leader Kitovi eyeing Solution






This time around all eyes are on Union Home Minister Amit Shah's visit to the state possibly for couple of hours on Friday, Jan 6. Leading organisations such as Nagaland Gaon Burrah Federation (NGBF), Central Nagaland Tribes Council (CNTC) and Eastern Nagaland Public Organisation (ENPO) have counseled avoiding elections at this juncture.


The general refrain being - 'people's choice' is in favour of an early Solution pact which at least the centre is keen and even Naga National Political Groups (an umbrella body) of seven militant groups are also ready to ink. The only exception is the NSCN-IM which says the pact if any should guarantee a separate Flag and Naga Constitution. Both the demands have been outright rejected by the Government of India.


On September 12, 2022 meeting in Delhi, Home Minister Shah told Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio and other state legislators "woh baat nahi karna (do not raise the bogey of separate constitution). The ENPO stance for staying away from polls is on different ground -- it wants carving out of a separate statehood for Eastern Nagaland.


The Rio cabinet's appeal to ENPO to reconsider their decision has been rejected too.

"The people of Eastern Nagaland shall not participate in any election process of the state and the center until and unless a separate statehood “Frontier Nagaland” is fulfilled as demanded by the people of Eastern Nagaland", the ENPO said. 


Ironically, in 1998, the NSCN-IM was against the polls. In 2023, what's its stance is not known publicly. But it is whispered that the group has "nexus" with state politicians in 'good positions' and thus they are not against election per se and it wants their men to be in power. The NNPG led by N Kitovi Zhimomi on the other hand is fiercely against the elections.


The NNPG had earlier more than once demanded resignation of the regime led by Rio to facilitate an early signing of a peace pact. It has already signed the preliminary Agreed Position in 2017 when R N Ravi was the state Governor and negotiator. It is well known that political lobbying and some pressure tactics ultimately led to transfer of Ravi as the Governor of Tamil Nadu. 


"There are leaders who would like to continue with the status quo so that undeterred exploitation of Nagaland and its people could continue. For them ‘no solution is solution’ so that they could continue to loot the State and its people," wrote former CM and ex-Gujarat Governor S C Jamir in an article. Jamir personally enjoys good rapport with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and whom he calls "a man with with guts and determination who can deliver and resolve complex issue like that of Nagas". 





The influential Gaon Burrah Federation (of village elders) in a detailed statement said - “NGBF is convinced that although elections are a necessity in a democratic World, it is not advisable at this hour in Nagaland. Let elections be postponed in favour of President's Rule to ensure honorable and acceptable solution". 


It further said, “NGBF understands that openly expressing decision to boycott and abstain from democratic exercise in any part of India or in Nagaland either by ENPO of Central Nagaland Tribes Council (CNTC) will seriously dent the image of the largest democratic nation in the world and its political leadership". 

However, it said that since the matter is about a decades-long political struggle, the people have the legitimate political and historical right to express themselves, in the knowledge that 'negotiations have already concluded'.


On the ENPO demand for a Frontier Nagaland state, the NGBF maintained that “Resolving the Naga political issue and post solution realignments of flawed political and administrative status will fulfill the aspiration of Eastern Nagaland Tribes". 


In fact, NNPG sources also say that as agreed between the umbrella body and the centre, in their Status Paper, the NNPG had proposed for 'special autonomous territorial councils' for Nagas of Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur and Nagaland even with legislative powers.

 

Some influential civil society groups who were keen for early Solution have requested BJP state unit and others to organise a meeting with Home Minister Amit Shah on Jan 6.


"We are sure, we want Solution. We are not sure what the centre wants. If we are back again on debate between elections and Solution, perhaps we are not being fair to posterity. Still, a meeting with India's Home Minister will be important. This is the time to speak out, are they really keen for Solution. When will be the mood again for such consensus in Nagaland," a key civil society leader said unable to conceal his growing frustration.  


Gun and peacemaker: blogger in jovial mood 



Some even say the Congress went against Naga people's wish in 1998 and was in power for five years. But since then Congress has lost its base completely in the state. The BJP should thus draw lessons from the past blunders of Congress of 1998. 


Ironically, incumbent Chief Minister Rio was part of Jamir's inner circle then. 


ends







(Nirendra Dev is a New Delhi-based journalist. He is also author of books, 'The Talking Guns: North East India'

and 'Modi to Moditva: An Uncensored Truth'. Views are personal)



1998 drama unfolding? Civil society keen to meet Shah amid talk on poll boycott

The fact that a methodical and flamboyant former Chief Secretary, Alemtemshi Jamir, attended the meeting with Rituraj Sinha gives an impression that things have been worked out in certain quarters already.


Kohima/New Delhi

The 'hands of clock' seem to have come back to the same position from 
where it all started.


Besides ENPO, the Central Nagaland Tribal Council (CNTC) has also threatened poll boycott. Things are complex as such and some influential civil society groups who were keen for early Solution have requested BJP state unit and others to organise a meeting with Home Minister Amit Shah on Jan 6.



"We are sure, we want Solution. We are not sure what the centre wants. If we are back again on debate between elections and Solution, perhaps we are not being fair to posterity. Still, a meeting with India's Home Minister will be important. This is the time to speak out, are they really keen for Solution. When will be the mood again for such consensus in Nagaland," a key civil society leader said unable to conceal his growing frustration.  


'Nagaland Page' Link


Others say, Nagaland is yet again at a crossroads. This opinion was also shared by some  who held a meeting in Dimapur on Tuesday under the aegis of 'Like Minded Naga Leaders' Forum'.

"We Nagas want Solution now and urgently. It seems negotiating parties are not
ready. There is no unanimity between New Delhi and Naga organisations.Moreover, no final decision has been taken on the ENPO issue also. So as of now and the kinds of things we all are witness to...We should get President's Rule. That's the only viable option," Hukavi Zhimomi said on behalf of the forum. 


Adding to the confusion during Tuesday's meeting with Morcha leaders and BJP office bearers at Kohima, sources say Nagaland in-charge Nalin Kohli (one signatory to now famous 20-40 deal with NDPP) and Rituraj Sinha apparently spoke only about Amit Shah's visit.


"It was like a drill training class. I enjoyed such interaction after a long time," said a Morcha functionary also ventilating his confusion about polls. 


Asked whether elections figured at the pep talks, one source said, "It did not figure in my meeting. But it was discussed in another very important meeting. After five years, we are still talking about strengthening party organisation and on ground, we are in a mess. If I was confused about polls before the meeting, I am still confused," the party insider said.  





 
The Like Minded Leaders Forum said as the present government in Nagaland under Neiphiu Rio is not performing well and the Government of India and the Naga negotiating parties have also not reached any consensus to sign a peace agreement for Solution, "so it will be appropriate to have the present government under Shri Rio dismissed and place Nagaland under President's Rule".

"The ENPO issue is also hanging and so Nagaland is not ready for elections because any election the manner we have cannot serve any purpose," another Forum leader remarked. 


Lately, even Congress pradesh president K Therie also demanded imposition of President's Rule.

Meanwhile, sources say central security forces have started landing at Dimapur and these could be related to polls. All these developments are seen crucial ones as they came on the eve of Home Minister Shah's possibly two-hour long visit to Nagaland on Jan 6. Shah will be in Manipur also on the same day wherein he is expected to meet civil society leaders from hill areas. 


ends   


The year ahead 2023 - Reflections of 'My master's laptop'


New Delhi 

Yup. You got it right. I am the 'laptop' and not the lapdog of my master - Nirendra.

It has been an interesting year, 2022 and 2023 looks exciting but could be frustrating for you Indians and also for the global population. One third of the global economy could face recession.Things will be worse in states and towns where cash doles are part of daily life. 

My master has been using me to write time and again; that -- there are some 'land' where payments are made for works done in heaven.


Well, nothing comes free. Someone pays the price. The year 2022 left all of you wondering why Tuensang-Mon region continues to suffer and miss out on infrastructures. Dimapur and adjoining hubs and jungles grew richer.


Let me caution, some of you - my master's friends could be swept away into uncharted waters.
2022 almost saw all hell break loose; but for a change Naga people are showing patience. Is it good?


Let elections be elections and not money spinning fests. It will make a big difference.  


The word 'Polycrisis' means --- several crises that converged to reinforce each other and create an overall challenge tougher to face/deal with than any single crisis. Nagaland's journey in 2022 has been on that score.

 
In 2023, either the 'Man of the year' Narendra Modi delivers Solution and Peace; or things come back to square one.


This is a new era where fewer people are reportedly having sex than ever before. Social health. 


People say there is a marked decline in all spheres of social life, including close friendships, intimate relationships and community involvement. They call it “social recession”. I have no answer to this.


More bitterly divided than ever, now people stand at an unprecedented crossroads.  

This is the technology era. Reading is becoming a vanishing art and how long can some newspapers survive is anybody's guess. But the obstinate man that my master is -- he thinks Journalism is yet to give its revolutionary punch.
He forgets there is hardly any journalism around. 


In politics, I tell my master, most genius people are at work. The political class swears by one thing, pledges another and thirdly, they do something else. Nexus is a small word. These are all pretty sophisticated techniques.


Money given from Delhi for the ENPO region has vanished and gone to some pockets.  


Did the funds reach people who almost for so many years focused on issuing threats to the Indian government and Indian army. Ting tong.This is another shape of a facilitator. 
 
But I am a tech product. You Indians are doing well, but have to do more with technology. 'Digital India' and payments directly into bank accounts have eradicated 'middlemen' and it's good. 







The potential for tech-driven revolution is still huge. More use of tech should be made to ensure meaningful employment. Those of you who are home sick and have hatred for hard work will continue to suffer. 


The world is your universe and the sky's the limit. Explore the outer world.

The moot point is that technology has a key role in highlighting the futility of violence and confrontation. Most industries if not all including cyber space, Start Ups and horticulture, tourism and even packaged foods should be allowed to function as industries per se. 

Let nothing else, but market dynamics allowed to prevail. 

For a change, give up the 20th century debate about insiders and outsiders. Any outsider is an 'insider' somewhere and vice versa. A few years back, some people from the northeast felt the buzz of 'outsiders' in Bengaluru.




Should their friendship bring in much desired Solution?





The global village and its 'mission' cannot be accomplished if some sets of people are not comfortable in your land. If one violence is mob lynching, the other one against a poor rickshahwallah cannot be virtuous self defence.

Those who work hard and display sincerity should replace the laggards. Those who run extra miles, must be rewarded and emulated; not ridiculed and sent in 'love letters'.


If you stop doing these in years to come, there will not be any demand for creation of a new state. 

Often it's said that success can become a tangible reality only when our products and services go places. 


Hatred also spreads and it sticks too. Some decades back, local-non local debates turned a gory turn. Kukis were hated and attacked; what are all that bitterness and ramifications over?  


We can no longer craft a narrative of a 'conspiracy' of outsiders to explain what are essentially your failures. Signing out with a promise to restart anytime. 

Look at me, my makers were Americans, brains were South Asians and maybe I have been marketed by some other human race, Taiwanese or Koreans. I am still on my own, often alone. Need timely healing.

 

“To be alone is the fate of all great minds.”
— Arthur Schopenhauer


ends 



For some ‘no solution is solution’ so they could “continue to loot the state and its people” : S C Jamir

Jamir with blogger: Aug 2022


It is a matter for great rejoicing that the dark age of imaginary dreams and visions in this beautiful land of the Nagas is slowly but surely disappearing. How grim and dismal was the time when this pristine land was enveloped in fanciful dreams and illusory chimera, the people readily swallowing even the most absurd possibilities which the fertile human imagination could contrive and present to the gullible! 


As in the story of individuals, so in the history of the nations, ‘night’ is the time of sleep, - the time to rest and rejuvenate oneself with renewed energy and vision. Unfortunately it is also the time when people see strange, unrealistic dreams. 

The people of Nagaland were made to sleep for a pretty long time by dreadful circumstances, dreaming illusory dreams and seeing intangible visions- detached from reality and flavored with icings of falsehood. We know that night is the time when the magician waves his mysterious wand, fascinates and enthralls the sense with fantastic tricks. 


The ‘night’ of ignorance is indeed the time when the deceptive priests and hierophants hold the human soul in hapless intellectual bondage and spiritual servitude. Similarly, in the darkness of ignorance, for several decades, sadly, the Nagas were fed with all sorts of make-believe and fanciful pictures of the Naga future. They were thoroughly mesmerized by all the propagandas that except politics nothing mattered in the Naga collective life. Side by side, anti-social and anti-national elements through their gun culture had unleashed fear psychosis in the minds of the entire population of Nagaland and kept them enslaved. 


Even today, people by and large are afraid to speak out the truth. But the irrevocable arrival of dawn and daylight of sane understanding had to enable the Nagas to distinguish reality from mere dreams and sieve the truth from falsehood. Today’s younger generation of Nagas, as such can no longer be held captive in the night of dismal and hideous make-believe fantasies and ephemeral dreams. 


Whatever the content of their dreams, the pioneering older generation of the Naga political movement committed themselves unselfishly and unreservedly to the cause they believed in, and together with the people, incalculable sacrifices were made. Paradoxically, today the late comers who joined the fray in more recent times are subsuming what they were never part of, and are making tall, unrealistic claims about deciding the fate of the Nagas of Nagaland without the people’s expressed mandate.

A glimpse of the Naga political scenario today indicates that the road map appears to be more realistic than before. The thought process of the people has been awakened to the stern and sacred realities of truth. The contemporary realities in all spheres of human activities have visibly impacted the Naga society as well. There is now a near universal realization of the futility of being obsessed with past events. Why try to drag out dead bones from the grave and waste time and resources dreaming of giving them imaginary life again? This is not the time to soar into ethereal region of fairs dreams nor spin out romantic fables and myths under the influence of morbid sentimentalism. We should have our vision and dreams of our future based on the stern realities that are in tune with the contemporary world. 


With clear perception we need to envision the kind of world best suited to the people of Nagaland. And what indeed are the political and constitutional realities where Nagaland stands today?


NNPG stalwart Kitovi : Eyeing peace pact patiently

Obviously, in the First Schedule of the Constitution of India, Nagaland is inserted as the 16th State of the Union of India. Article 371A as a special provision was provided in the Constitution specifically for Nagaland. Since 1964, the state of Nagaland is run by elected Members of the State. It would mean that territorially, politically and constitutionally, Nagaland is an integral part of India. The genesis of how and why Nagaland State was created is known to the entire people of the State. The phrase ‘uniqueness of Naga history’, was first coined and used in a press conference by Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee, but this today has become a common political parlance especially among the underground leaders. 


Should we also not ask ourselves whether or not we have been making a ‘unique’ modern Naga history? Naga leaders who spearheaded the Naga political movement were true patriots and nationalists. The NNC was not only formed by the Nagas of Nagaland, but the greatest sacrifices for its cause were also made by Nagas of today’s Nagaland. 

I have had the privilege of holding certain key positions in the government as an elected representative of the Naga people and one can vouch for the fact that the GOI leaders are well aware that much of the ‘mess’ in the Naga society has been created by ‘outsiders’ and ‘tenants’, as the NNPGs once tried to argue.


Nagas of Nagaland were unflinchingly committed to the cause of a separate homeland. In the initial years of the Naga political movement they lived in blood and sacrifice, and gave their all for the Naga cause. This movement propelled by the people’s aspiration for a greater, brighter and better Naga future can be treated as unique in the true sense of the term. But as years rolled by ideological differences as well as selfish polity among the leaders divided and weakened the most cherished movement.  

Nagas started killing Nagas mostly on mere suspicions and thereby creating a wide cleavage in the Naga society. The ugly picture of the Naga movement today is factionalism, each trying for one-upmanship at the expense of the other. The multiplicity of extra-constitutional ‘independent governments and authorities’, is not only a source of great pain to the common people, but is a matter of huge embarrassment. 


Each group functions by the dictates of its own whims and fancies. From such a heterogeneous, conflicting armed conglomeration, to expect order and the rule of law is far-fetched. How can we blame others when in the name of the same cause we are at each other’s throat? Looking at ourselves in the light of the sacrifices of the Naga pioneers, the shallowness of conviction and superficiality of patriotism in today’s leaders become shamefully exposed. Sheer materialism appears to have enslaved today’s leaders across the board.  What sort of a utopian land are we trying to build for ourselves, when the entire people are made to groan under the weight of multiple extortions and rampant corruption in State governance? 

With socio-economic development at a stand-still, it is amazing that there are leaders who would like to continue with the status quo so that undeterred exploitation of Nagaland and its people could continue.  


For them ‘no solution is solution’ so that they could continue to loot the State and its people. How could this impasse be broken? All the elected representatives of the Nagaland State Legislature, the tribal Hohos and Church leaders should with one voice demand that the GOI and the Underground leaders immediately finalize the agreements and usher in permanent peace in Nagaland. 





Time should not be wasted on interpretation of English words and phrases in their agreements that were signed. Since sovereignty and integration of Naga territories have been ruled out, other issues should not be allowed to confuse the general public. 


It is high time that the GOI demarcate the political status of the agreements already signed and raise the final curtain on the Naga political issue. Let the people of Nagaland take care of their State and similarly let others confine to their own States. The public are fully aware of the Agreements of 3rd August 2015, 17th November 2017 and 31st October 2019, and  no further attempts to delay should be allowed for the final announcement. 


It is our hope and prayer that as the New Year unfolds, the Prime Minister, in his political wisdom will redeem the people of Nagaland and other Naga areas from the present impasse and usher in an era of stability in this corner of India. A peaceful Nagaland will ensure acceleration of a prosperous North-east and help realize Prime Minister Modi’s Act East policy.


“Where there is no vision, the people perish; but he that keepeth his law, happy is he. Solid vision keeps everyone on tract, chaos reigns wherever the vision lapses.” 










 

Indian Politics, Freedom struggle and History :::: Need Revisit :::: Even Quit India Movement 'resolution' by Congress sought to make .... "its fullest contribution towards realisation of human freedom in the world, which is in danger of being crushed"

Indian history has many features, many layered anecdotes where politics, trade, warfare, and culture intersect.  Long-distance ties shaped I...