Wednesday, December 14, 2022

FM Sitharaman uses 'matchstick' analogy to lambaste post-poll violence under Mamata regime

New Delhi 

"Machis kiskey haath mein they...." -- the politics or precisely theparliamentary debate about it was smartly turned against TrinamoolCongress by none other than India's Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman.


"Sir, who has the matchstick is not the issue. Because in democracy peopleelect their leaders and give (power) to them," she said in Lok Sabha in reference tocertain remarks made by TMC member Mahua Moitra.





"We don't need to undermine by saying kisney machis dia...Janta ne dia," Ms Sitharaman said adding, "But kiskey haath mein machis kaise upyog mein ata hae, wohi hae important(Who uses matchstick in the manner they want is more important)".


Trying to strengthen her argument, the Finance Minister said, "Recently the BJP had a fantastic victoryin Gujarat. Post-elections sir, what was the environment there? Peacefully the new government that came topower was sworn in. Whereas compare it with what happened in West Bengal, post elections (2021)....how the matchstick really made use of. That's the main question".

Amid other BJP members screaming, "entire Bengal was burnt down", Ms Sitharaman said "When we havematch stick, we give Ujala, Ujwala, we gave PM Kisan, Swachh Bharat....But when you had the same match stick(in Bengal) there was arson, loot and rape. Our party workers' houses were burnt down".

Top of that, the Finance Minister said Union MoS External Affairs, V. Muraleedharan's vehicle was stoned in WestBengal during his visit.

"Even a central minister was not safe in West Bengal...post-election," she said. 

The Finance Minister also took on Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury for his question "Is Nirav Modi your relative?"

On this Sitharaman said, "Not our relative....he is your relative and that's why he was given the money duringyour (UPA) tenure, but we are catching hold of them and bringing back the money".

The Finance Minister the practice of 'phone instructions to banks...give money to my son in law and that relativehas been stopped by the Narendra Modi government".

Trinamool member Ms Moitra had also referred to the term 'Pappu' vis-a-vis economic managementand on this, the Finance Minister said - if Moitra “looks back into her own backyard, she will find Pappu in West Bengal”.

“There is no doubt, when there are wonderful schemes which can benefit common people, West Bengal sits over it and doesn't implement them. You don't need to search anywhere else for Pappu, you will find in Bengal” the minister said.

Sitharaman said that India is the fastest growing major economy in the world with inflation within bearable limits.


She said funds under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MNREGA) could not be released to West Bengal since March 2022 as the Mamata Banerjee-led dispensation has not yet replied to complaints of misuse of funds.


ends 



Tuesday, December 13, 2022

Saffron 'streamlining' : 4 sitting MLAs join BJP in Meghalaya: Two from NPP, One Trinamool


Saffron 'streamlining' : 4 sitting MLAs join BJP in Meghalaya


PM Narendra Modi likely to be in Shillong on Dec 18 





New Delhi 


The NPP of Conrad Sangma perhaps gets its initial taste of an 'indifferent' BJP. 


The saffron party is now getting itself geared up for the fast approaching assembly elections in Meghalaya.


"....the north east India has been mainstreamed completely," said a beaming Himanta Biswa Sarma welcoming the four MLAs. Three of them have already quit their seats. 

Four sitting legislators of the present House including two MLAs from alliance partner NPP, and one Trinamool Congress and one Independent joined the saffron party on Wednesday here in the national capital in presence of NEDA convener Sarma.




In Nagaland, the story is getting more complex by the day. The NDPP had played a smart game. It wanted to win 2023 as a "friend' of the BJP and making optimum use of 'Narendra Modi factor', but yet wanted to keep the Lotus party crippled in Nagaland. A battery of BJP leaders will visit Kohima on Dec 16th.


In Meghalaya, the MLAs Benedict Marak (Raksamgre) and Ms Fairlene Sangma (Selsella) were in NPP and Himalaya Muktan Shangpliang (Mawsynram) was in Trinamool. Samuel Sangma Independent MLA is from Baghmara assembly segment and understandably yet to resign his seat.


Himalaya Muktan is a key catch for the saffron party in Khasi belt which has 36 seats.


A popular Khasi leader, Muktan said, "We need a change in Meghalaya and that change can come only through the hands of honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modi".

 

He further said, "The BJP is growing by the day and people are getting more impressed by the developmental changes being brought by PM Modi". 


"Guwahati is becoming the fastest growing city in the country and all these are possible because PM Modi has a

soft corner for the north east," he said.


PM Narendra Modi is likely to be in Shillong on Dec 18 to address the golden jubilee 

celebrations of the North Eastern Council. 


In terms of drama and anxiety on whether polls will be held in Nagaland in view of progress in peace

talks and ENPO related developments, Himanta - often considered a friend of NDPP leadership -

incidentally said, "We are preparing well for elections in all three north eastern states - Meghalaya, Tripura 

and Nagaland".


"BJP's growth in the north east is not a temporary phenomenon. You have seen the governments in 

Arunachal Pradesh, Assam and Manipur headed by BJP have been repeated twice," he said adding,

"The BJP's outreach in the northeast has become permanent. Now the address of BJP has become completely 

permanent in the north east".      


On July 26 -- ten days after making a fervent appeal for expediting the peace process, Chief Minister

Neiphiu Rio along with Himanta Biswa Sarma met Home Minister Amit Shah and settled for 20:40 seat

deal leaving an overwhelming section of the saffron party and ticket aspirants aggrieved.


Interestingly, a team of BJP national office bearers including Rituraj Sinha, Nalin Kohli and

Priyan Pandey (of Ram Madhav era) will visit Nagaland and also meet Chief Minister Rio on

December 16.

Interestingly, the date of journey coincides with the visit of the official team that will arrive for

ENPO related works and visit to the 'region' that is craving for separate statehood.


The BJP's scheduled programme has listed 'pre-Christmas dinner' on December 17 evening.


Most such extravaganzas for BJP central leaders including BJP's organisational

general secretary B L Santhosh in the past have been hosted by the Chief Minister and not any

state level BJP leader.  



end 



 MLAs Benedict Marak (#Raksamgre) & Fairlene Sangma (#Selsella) from #NPP and Himalaya Muktan #Shangpliang (Mawsynram) Samuel Sangma Independent MLA from #Baghmara join #BJP in presence of Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma




"This is a new beginning...Since 2014, the north east has undergone a tremendous change. Every sector, the north east is progressing. Thanks to the visionary leadership of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi," Himanta said, adding, 'today north east has been mainstreamed completely".



"Four important Meghalaya legislators have joined BJP. I am confident, BJP will strengthen and we are confident, this time we will get the blessings of the people of Meghalaya,"  BJP leader Rituraj Sinha said.


Enthusiastic BJP workers in Meghalaya 



BJP leader and coordinator North East, Sambit Patra also was present and pointed out that Himalaya Muktan was in Trinamool Congress. 


Himalaya Muktan said all four of them were overwhelmed to join the BJP. "We are growing by the day and it is getting more impressed by the developmental changes being brought by Prime Minister Narendra Modi," he said.

"Guwahati is becoming the fastest growing city in the country and all these are possible because PM Narendra Modi has soft corner for the north east," he said. 


"The great party BJP has really impressed all four of us," he said adding, "We would like to tell the people of the country that in a place like Meghalaya, BJP is growing by the day and it is getting more impressed by the developmental changes that have been brought by none other than our great Prime Minister Narendra Modi".




"It is a pride moment for the BJP," Assam CM and NEDA convener Himanta Biswa Sarma said. 


"We are preparing well for elections in all three north eastern states - Meghalaya, Tripura and Nagaland," Himanta told reporters on the occasion. 


Himanta further said that the BJP will do well in elections in three states of Meghalaya, Nagaland and Tripura.  


"As a result you have seen that three state governments run by BJP have been elected twice consecutively. BJP's growth in north east is not a temporary phenomenon. Now you have seen the governments in Arunachal Pradesh, Assam and Manipur headed by BJP have been repeated twice," Himanta said.


Thus, he maintained, the BJP's "outreach in northeast has become permanent....Now the address of BJP has become completely permanent in the north east".   


For his part, Himalaya Muktan  said, "We need a change in Meghalaya and that change can come only through the hands of honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modi". 











Who holds the key? Nagaland matters ::::: Historical; IPS cadre - The new vehicle for Peace and Development

Modi-Shah duo depending a lot on two IB sleuths


New Delhi 


A K Mishra, the peace emissary in Naga peace talks, has a historical role to perform.Of course he will be aided by two in-service officials Mandeep Singh Tuli, IB Joint Director and A K Dhyani, Director North East Division.

Like Mishra, Tuli is also of IPS background and grooming and linked to India's elite intelligencewing - the IB.





Mishra is of Rajasthan cadre, 1987 batch and Tuli of Sikkim cadre and much younger to Mishraas he hails from 1999 batch. Dhyani of course is a civil official.


In media terminology, it is often said that the north east region is a home to many untold stories waiting to be told. In terms of the perspective of intelligence studies, north east India is still a puzzle and perhaps even a virgin land.



'Nagaland Page' Link


We know ivory tower expertise by the executive/bureaucracy - let us include both IAS and IPS fraternity and also political leadership - and also the media often offers many stereotypes and myths about the northeast region.


Well, this should be dispelled. Now whether intelligence agencies have added to the complexity of the region is anyone's guess. No region like the north east India and vibrant communities like Nagas in the world perhap shave been as conflict ridden as this part.  There are diverse topography, cultures and of course socio-economic traits and socio-religious divisions. 

For the media these could be simple Masala. 


It goes without stating that for intelligence agencies and officials,these factors are very much serious challenges as they have also fuelled disturbances.


Thanks to New Delhi's ways of handling things, there is a perceived sense of alienation, faulty policies, scarce resources and of course 'interference' by neighbours - both small and large ones.



Former Nagaland Chief Secretary A M Gokhale had his reasons to say (in the late nineties) -- "New Delhi still thinks like Aurangzeb's Delhi". Here Aurangzeb symbolised an image of a ruthless and an unreasonable administrator.


A K Mishra


Where does a  department like the IB fit into all these?  After central security forces if any department as a unit is seen with suspicion by Nagas are these intelligence wings. 


Late J B Jasokie, former CM, understood certain complexities well. Once he told me, "I am sure very soon IB officials will tell you to inform them first before you come to interview us. They may even suggest questions".


Like any newcomer in the field, I would smile and get impressed at the sharpness of a veteran politician. 


There is of course another version -- "Well, our job is thankless. When we save hundreds of incidents and terror attacks, no one thanks us. But when something wrong happens, the first usual screaming is - intelligence failure". 


But some of their inputs matter. Late Shikiho Sema, a Congress leader, understood their importance well. In 1988-89, Vamuzo was apparently denied opportunity to form government after the Hokishe Sema government fell chiefly due to some adverse inputs from IB sleuths. 



But now PM Narendra Modi and his trusted Home Minister Amit Shah have reposed faith in a retired IPS man, Mishra. Of course, his predecessor R N Ravi too was from IPS cadre and things did move under his stewardship definitely.


A senior Naga politician when asked remarked rather aptly, "History has provided an ample opportunity and a rareoccasion to A K Mishra to deliver. Along with peace parleys with NSCN-IM and NNPG, now he has to handle ENPO matters too. He should deliver and Nagas will remember him for long".


Mishra is known to his colleagues as a workaholic and a cool customer in terms of gathering intelligence. Both these qualities suit the Modi-Shah duo's scheme of things. At times, Mishra's gentleman type approach could be misread as a sign of basic weakness, but he has the firmness of a true cop.  


Mishra was posted at Kohima when Thuingaleng Muivah was denied entry to Manipur in 2010 and was lodged at Viswema for about a month. 


Till 2020, Tuli - a Sikh gentleman who also served in Imphal, was posted as Deputy Director (NE Desk).


There will be little to dispute that both Tuli and Mishra have been picked up personally by Shah for the important assignment. 


The grapevine in Delhi is that Mishra has been able to do his best in Naga peace talks notwithstanding challenges.





Delivering the right information and perhaps more importantly the right analyses -- staying away from any media glare and major rows - on the conflicts has been a challenging task for these cops.

In the ultimate, the roles of these officials as the true 'servants' of the motherland, the Indian government and thus the Constitution must not be lost.


Skeptics could dub some of their actions anytime as 'nationalist prism/lens'. Some optimists nevertheless feel developmental and constitutional triumphism will work finally.


Just as a social worker concurs when he says - the structures privileging the 'greed' of a few at all levels and the so-called unjust systems would be defeated at the end of the day.


ends 

Jammu & Kashmir eyeing self-sustaining Eco. development

New Delhi 


Election promises are made and some are fulfilled, and some are not. In the just concluded elections especially in Gujarat, the faceless voters have shown that a party and a government which delivers ought to be rewarded. 

Thus, the BJP returned to power winning seven elections in a row.


Analysts admit that some of the developments that came for the saffron party was due to achieving the coveted goal of 'self sustaining' economic development with a focused approach for empowerment of people and transparency in governance. 






Sources say the UT administration in Jammu and Kashmir is also striving hard to achieve this lofty target. 


In Gujarat, observers know, things are transparent and there is always a focused approach on empowerment of women and other vulnerable sections. 



Thus, there have been a number of "systematic reforms" introduced in the financial management system to enhance transparency and accountability in the functioning of the official and semi-official apparatus.


One such move with the hope of getting short term as well as long term dividends is setting up of
the Budget Estimation, Allocation and Monitoring System (BEAMS). Besides this, there have been steps
such as implementation of e-tendering and also JKPaySys.


There were steps such as IT-enabled EMPOWERMENT -- meaning - Enabling Monitoring and Public Overview of Works Being Executed and Resources for Meaningful Transparency portal - janbhagidhari.jk.gov.in.





"It is true financial discipline and rigorous monitoring has resulted in manifold increase in the rate

of project completion," says a source adding while in 2018 - that is before abrogation of Article 370 -

9229 projects were implemented, these increased to 12,637 in 2019-20 and 50,627 in 2021-22 and as many

as 65,000 in the current fiscal 2022-23.


There were works in the social sector in creating "livelihood for community".


The gross agricultural output which is to the tune of Rs 37559 crore per year will now

grow up to Rs 65,701 crore per year over next five years. There have been necessary steps

to implement National Education Policy - NEP - 2020 in letter and spirit.


Moreover, 500 Atal Tinkering labs shall be established and the administration will also set up free NEET coaching centres for government school students with meritorious records.


The administration will also try to achieve 'target oriented' citizen centric government business IT initiatives.


The UT administration is also on the way of achieving the cherished goal of Anemia Mukt and Nasha Mukt Bharat.


Steps are being taken for 'sectoral investable projects' for tourism, hospitality, healthcare and Ayush and Wellness sectors.


Sources further said the UT administration of J&K is also working on plans and various schemes to implement 'Integrated Healthcare and Education Delivery System'.


Under this, there will be 20 virtual Reality Labs to encourage scientific temperament and free NEET coaching, further enhance seats of doctors and para medicals to match the growing need and building of world class schools on the lines of international exposure.


Steps will be also taken to attract private sector and corporate participation and joint ventures for creation of medicities, the source added.


ends 



Monday, December 12, 2022

Indian Constitution has evolved & transformed as a "wonderful flower", says Attorney Gen Venkataramani

 

(Mr Venkataramani says that the "idea of a constitution" itself has a global significance and Constitution making as an exercise has taken place across Europe and other parts of the world. 

In the Indian context, he said, "The idea of a Constitution is as powerful as the concept of Dharma in India". All powers in the society -- the public power and private power have to be regulated.) 





New Delhi 


Change and transformation are the essence of human life and evolution of a society and a nation and it is true that the Indian Constitution has evolved over the years into a "wonderful flower",  Attorney General of India, R Venkataramani has said here.


"If those Constitution makers are to live today, they would have looked at the sky and wondered what this Constitution which we gave to the people of the country has transformed itself into a wonderful flower," he said addressing the 'Lily Thomas Memorial Lecture Series on the Constitution of India'. 


He said the biggest strength of the Indian Constitution is that the "people can play a role in constitution making, in the constitution processes".


 In terms of the role to be played by the Supreme Court and the lawyers, he said, "..we are not dealing with cases. As lawyers of course we are dealing with briefs,  but the Supreme Court is dealing with issues,... the whole national panoramic of issues between government and individuals unfold their dimension for the purposes of resolution of meaningful orderly and peaceful and rule of law of the constitution".


Mr Venkataramani also said while each ideology either Marxism or capitalism have their limitations and failures, it ought to be kept in mind that the "genius of the human species is much larger than the ideologies".


IANS story link



Thus, he emphasised "the genius of the human species is what makes our Constitution working".


Mr Venkataramani also said that the "idea of a constitution" itself has a global significance and Constitution making as an exercise has taken place across Europe and other parts of the world.


In the Indian context, he said, "The idea of a Constitution is as powerful as the concept of Dharma in India".


The Attorney General, a constitutional lawyer with experience of over four decades, said, "The idea of a Constitution in my understanding is that all powers in the society - public power and private power - have to be regulated".


Rich tributes were paid to lawyer Lily Thomas who would be remembered for initiating improvement and change to existing laws by filing petitions in Supreme Court and various regional courts.


Lily Thomas, who was hailed most notably for petitioning to amend the Representation of the People Act, expired on December 12, 2019. 


ends 





"Central team visit to ENPO region must fix accountability, cleanse system", says Naga civil society activist Theja

 "Central team visit to ENPO region must fix accountability, cleanse system"
Theja Therieh says bigger issue is of 'Neta-Babu raj' failure 


New Delhi

 
The speed with which the centre has acted in terms of setting up of a panel to make an on the spot scrutiny of developmental works on ground in ENPO region and to relate it to people's grievances ought to be welcomed, says a prominent Naga social worker Theja Therieh.


"Well, I welcome the move. I also welcome the entire process as this will put the wrong doers under the scanner. I should also appreciate the ENPO stance for having highlighted the grievances because most of the problems now seem to be related to the corruption menace," Therieh told 'Nagaland Page' in a brief interview over phone.


"I for one have been insisting on Solution to the Naga problem with several colleagues in the civil society. Most often we have been misunderstood by a section of political leaders and our executives. In Nagaland and that includes the ENPO region the bigger issue is of executive failure.... the so-called Neta-Babu raj as you all keep stating in Delhi," he said.


Blogger and crusader Theja !!


To a question he said, "Dividing a state is no solution. Issues must be addressed. In no way, I am supporting division of Nagaland".


Answering questions, Theja Therieh, who is convener (Media), Nagaland Tribes Council, and  newly floated Naga People's Action Committee, said, "Corruption means things were not delivered to people not only on time. It means nothing was delivered at all....huge amount got sanctioned in Delhi and papers were cleared easily in Kohima....Cheques were handed over for no works done and you had mansions coming up in Dimapur".


"In a lighter vein, I will say it is time now these cheques should bounce now," he remarked.


"I think, with the Solution to the Naga problem as is being envisioned, we should look forward to restoration.


This gives us an opportunity to soul searching. We must look forward to Restoration to old Naga values when there were no thieves around and Nagas kept their door unlocked....But the picture today is in sharp contrast. The ENPO exercise and the visit of the central team should help cleanse our rotten system of the last few decades. For once let us prove, corruption is not part of our routine life," he said.



'Nagaland Page' - Dec 13, 2022




To another question, he said, "At the same time I feel the central team headed by A K Mishra will not leave any stone unturned. We must know how crores were sanctioned and money got released but there was no work worth talking in the ENPO region. This should also help the centre take necessary corrective steps why such huge amounts used to be sanctioned, but nothing moved on ground". 

 
Naga Peace talks negotiator AK Mishra will head the central panel on ENPO.  
The team will visit the ENPO region including Pangsha between Dec 16 and 18.
It may be mentioned that there is already a controversy over the sanction of Rs 30,000 lakh (Rs 300 crore) in 2012 as part of Special Plan Assistance for ENPO region.


On Sept 21, 2012, the then Planning Minister T R Zeliang had told the state assembly in reply to a question from Pughboboto legislator Joshua Sumi that a component of 10 per cent was added to the amount and allocated it to various sectors/departments.


Lately this issue was raked up by former MP Asungba Sangtam in a TV debate.


Responding to this state Planning & Coordination department on November 24
said in a release that “the government of India did not approve the proposals for Rs. 333.33 crore for Eastern Nagaland region and no fund was released to the state government”. 


Therefore, the “allegation of misutilisation of the said funds is therefore, without any basis”.


It has been also reported in the local media that Nagaland chief minister Neiphiu Rio, had during the twelfth session of the 11th Legislative assembly on September 21, 2012 said that the grant from the Planning Commission as special development package for Eastern Nagaland would be brought in the form of supplementary grants and not under revised demands of grants as demanded by the opposition 
Congress.


ends 




India's 'growing economy' is matter of pride, but Congress making fun : FM Nirmala Sitharaman

India's 'growing economy' is matter of pride, but Congress making fun : FM Nirmala Sitharaman


(The Indian economy was certainly in the ICU during the UPA regime and India was kept in 'fragile five', said the FM and insisted that the economic situation is much better now and thecountry is ranked fifth among the seven top global economies.) 

New Delhi 








Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday, Dec 12, lambasted the oppositionCongress for trying to 'mock' the country and the government when India is at present'the fastest-growing economy under Prime Minister Narendra Modi'.

 "Despite the pandemic and Russia-Ukraine war, India is the fastest growing economy today. 

This is a matter of pride. But they are making fun of it," she said in Lok Sabha responding to Congress member from Telangana A Revanth Reddy's remarks after he raised the issue of alleged depreciation of the rupee against the dollar  

"It's sad that they talk such things out of jealousy when our economy is doing well. Today these people are standing against the Indian economy," she said.

The Finance Minister said it is well known that the US dollar is getting "stronger and stronger" due to "the policy adopted by the US" but she hastened to add, India's foreign reserves have gone up because of the flow of FDIs and FIIs. 

"The fact remains that the reserves are going up. That's why, at this time, talks about foreign exchange, rupee depreciation, reserves coming down or investors running away are actually not proven by data," she said.

Of course, there are various data revelations and views of the experts to suggest that things are changing fast under the stewardship of Narendra Modi as the Prime Minister.

In fact, it is well known that among the seven top economies in the world, while the top on the list is the US, India ranks 5th with 7 percent growth figures.

And India stands above the UK and France. 


Experts say while China ranks second in the list, but its salient feature can be described as -- the moderate growth and low inflation.

In contrast, India has recorded a high growth rate with moderate inflation. The growth rate in China has been 3.3 percent

only. 

Even global media like 'The Economist' has recently said that India will continue to remain a "bright spot" in the year 2023.

'The Economist' further says that in 'domestic investment and manufacturing', India's performance has been relatively better with the west. 

While India under PM Modi has emerged stronger post the Covid crisis, a few neighbouring countries such as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh were faced with bigger challenges and almost

looked in turmoil. 

ends 


Indian Politics, Freedom struggle and History :::: Need Revisit :::: Even Quit India Movement 'resolution' by Congress sought to make .... "its fullest contribution towards realisation of human freedom in the world, which is in danger of being crushed"

Indian history has many features, many layered anecdotes where politics, trade, warfare, and culture intersect.  Long-distance ties shaped I...