Tuesday, February 3, 2026

Guest column - Sanjay Das :::: "MGNREGA did not live mainly in files or speeches. It lived in homes"

 What MGNREGA Meant for Rural India


MGNREGA did not live mainly in files or speeches. It lived in homes.


It lived in village kitchens where a few weeks’ wages meant food on the stove. It lived in households where families delayed migration just long enough for a child to finish a school term. It lived in the lives of women who could earn money close to home, whose work was finally recognised by law rather than treated as informal help.


The Act did not promise prosperity. It promised something simpler and more urgent: breathing space. And for the poor, breathing space often means survival. It is the difference between coping and collapse, between staying rooted and being forced to leave, between dignity and despair.


Under MGNREGA, a worker did not beg for employment. She applied for it. She demanded it. She went to the panchayat with her job card and the law on her side. That mattered. It told her that her survival was not a favour—it was a right. It told her, plainly: your life matters enough for the state to respond.









The Moral Vision Behind the Law
MGNREGA began with an uncomfortable but necessary truth: poverty is rarely a personal failure. It is shaped by landlessness, caste and gender exclusion, climate shocks, and an economy that creates wealth for some while leaving others with nothing but uncertain labour. The law refused to pretend otherwise. From this honesty came its moral logic. If the market cannot provide work, the state must step in. If lack of work leads to hunger, the state cannot look away. And if dignity depends on having a livelihood, then livelihood cannot depend on charity—it must be protected as a right.
For nearly two decades, MGNREGA served as a law that held responsibility in place. It was imperfect and often delayed, but its purpose was clear. It told the poorest citizen something the Indian legal system had rarely said before: you are allowed to ask, and the state is required to answer.
The State’s Obligation and Its Withdrawal
When a worker applies for work and is told to come back next month, what she experiences is not a policy debate—it is absence. Democracy is not something she feels in speeches; she feels it in whether the state responds when she needs to survive.










The legitimacy of democratic power rests not only on elections, but on whether the state takes responsibility for those with the least power to protect themselves. A society shows its character not when the economy is growing, but when people are struggling.
MGNREGA recognised this. It treated unemployment as a long-term reality, not a temporary inconvenience. It treated hunger as a public responsibility, not a private shame. By guaranteeing work on demand, it turned concern into duty.
The repeal of MGNREGA and its replacement with a discretionary, capped, centrally controlled framework breaks that duty. What has been withdrawn is not just a programme, but a promise.

There was a time when the state said: if there is no work, we will provide it. A time when it said: hunger is not your fault. A time when it said: dignity does not require permission.


Today, the message is different. Workers are asked to wait. They are told funds have run out. They are expected to adjust, migrate, and endure. And often, the state says nothing at all.
This is not a technical delay. It is the state stepping away from its responsibility. It is not governance under pressure. It is abandonment.







Twenty years ago, India passed a law that did something rare and necessary: it spoke honestly about poverty. It did not describe it as bad luck, laziness, or something people should quietly endure. The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) recognised poverty for what it often is—the result of not having work, land, or security in an unequal economy.
MGNREGA was not just another welfare programme. It was a promise by the state that survival would not be left to charity or silence—that if people were willing to work, the state would not turn away.


As someone who has watched this law shape everyday life across rural India—and in Meghalaya in particular—I mark its twentieth anniversary with pride in what it achieved, grief at what has been taken away, and deep concern about what its dismantling tells us about how power is exercised today. A law that once guaranteed the right to work has now been repealed by the BJP-led Union Government and replaced with a framework that removes that legal guarantee.


This is not a routine policy change. It is not a technical adjustment. It is not reform in any meaningful sense. It is a moral decision. At its heart, this is not a debate about budgets or efficiency. It is about right and wrong


.The writer is General Secretary, Meghalaya Pradesh Congress Committee)

Y Khemchand Singh to be new chief minister of Manipur ::: Biren Singh -- CM during 2023 violence is now "marginalised"

 


Senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader and former state cabinet minister Yumnam Khemchand Singh has been chosen  for appointment as the new Chief Minister of Manipur.

Manipur is under President's rule for nearly a year now.







The post of chief minister has been vacant ever since N Biren Singh resigned on February 9, 2025 amid a prolonged period of ethnic violence in the state between Meiteis and Kukis.


Khemchand Singh's name as the next CM of Manipur was announced on Tuesday after he was elected as the legislature party leader of the Manipur BJP, following a meeting held in New Delhi.


The BJP's present strength in the 60-member Manipur Assembly stands at 37. Initially, 32 candidates of the 'saffron party' were elected in the 2022 Assembly polls. Meanwhile, the JD(U) had won six seats.


However, out of those half-dozen, five later defected to the BJP. Moreover, one seat in the state legislature fell vacant following the death of a serving MLA.




WHO IS YUMNAM KHEMCHAND SINGH?

Khemchand Singh, who belongs to the Meitei community, is a two-time MLA. He was elected from the Singjamei Assembly seat for two back-to-back terms, in 2017 and then in 2022.


He rose to prominence in March 2017, when he was elected as the Speaker of the Manipur Legislative Assembly. He held the post for a full five-year term.


Following the 2022 Assembly elections, Singh was inducted into the second Biren Singh cabinet as a minister. The leader was entrusted with several portfolios, including Rural development and panchayati raj, municipal administration, housing development, and education.


*Manipur State : New Govt*

 

🛑*Chief Minister* - Mr Y Khemchand, BJP MLA Singjamei


🛑  *Dy Chief Minister* - Ms Nemcha Kipgen, BJP MLA Kangpokpi


🛑*Dy Chief Minister* - Mr L. Dikho, NPF MLA Mao


🛑*Home* - Mr Govindas Ningthoujam, BJP MLA Bishnupur


🛑Eight more Cabinet Minister to be announced by tomorrow.

Is BNP still far away from capturing power in Bangladesh ??

 

All of a sudden or rather gradually, the BNP is losing out its steam in the fast approaching Feb 12 elections in Bangladesh.


The party is now nervous that things are being staged in favour of Jamaat and NCP.  BNP has now officially opposed Election Commissipn move to deploy "many Bangladesh National Caset Corps  cadets" on election duties as they are college and university students who may be affiliated with political parties or ideological groups.






The refrain being arguing their involvement could compromise the neutrality of the electoral process.

BNP leader Mahdi Amin said the party has sent a letter to the Election Commission requesting that BNCC cadets not be deployed for election duties.


In addition, the BNP raised objections to the appointment of election observers, citing Election Commission data which show that as of January 26, a total of 55,454 observers from 81 local organisations had been approved, with 34,442 drawn from just 16 organisations.


The party alleged that some observer organisations are led by individuals linked to a particular political party, creating the risk of misuse on polling day.


To ensure a level playing field, the BNP placed two demands before the Election Commission -- a comprehensive review of the approved observer list to remove individuals linked to political parties or candidates, and a reduction in the number of observers from organisations with limited monitoring experience, along with restrictions on allowing more than two local observers to enter a polling centre at the same time.






These probably happen in all democracies. But in Bangladesh context; these have some special significances. Post demise of Khaleeda Zia and arrival of her son Tarique Rehman; a view largely circulated that there was a wave in favour of BNP and the party may virtually cake walk to victory. But the political machinations have prevailed and NCP and Jamaat have probably turned the table.


Hence the BNP is bit nervous. In other words, a fierce competition is on cards. 


That way; Bangladesh watchers and analysts presume the Jamaat may actually come out with flying colours. But what will such eventuality actually mean kn ground vis-a-vis New Delhi from geo-strategic point of view.

Has India again tried to put all eggs in one basket ? The new basket being BNP and does it also imply that the Awami League is history?

The safest reply will be - Not quite to both the queries. But that would mean Team Modi will have to work out new and more practical policy approaches. 






At least 29 fake and misleading pieces of information have been circulated BNP Chairman Tarique Rahman, said the spokesperson of the party’s election steering committee, Mahdi Amin, during a press conference at the committee’s office in Gulshan.


He said leaders and activists of a political party were once again spreading false narratives, using the same language and slogans previously employed to mislead the public.


India is trying to redraw its strategies. One argument being - if Pragmatic diplomacy means New Delhi foreign policy engine room can work or coordinate with military rulers in Myanmar; why not it evolve the new branding with possible and radical Islamists in Bangladesh.



The new Moditva doctrine ideally is we should have friends everywhere. 


That means the sloganeering "Bhaj pa - Jamaat bhai bhai " can also be seen as a new era evolution.





Globally, there is a never-ending debate over whether voters are driven more by policies or personalities. In Bangladesh, where most political parties are leader-centric rather than bottom-up democratic organisations, experience suggests that leaders—not policies—win elections. Policies rarely influence the masses.


 Manifestos, therefore, receive little serious scrutiny as tools to judge a party, its candidates, or a leader’s electability. It is no surprise that manifestos have become the least of priorities in the February 12 election for major parties vying for power. 


So far, leaders have been announcing policies at campaign rallies in a fragmented manner rather than releasing them as a cohesive package, selectively targeting different segments of the electorate.


Changing Dynamics :::: 


Bangladesh often seems to treat foreign policy as subject to seasonal political moods. If one government is branded “India-friendly,” another “China-leaning,” then a third is cast as “Washington’s favourite.”


 In reality, Dhaka engages all three powers every day—on trade, loans, borders, security, climate, migration, the Bay of Bengal, etc. But it does so without a clearly stated hierarchy of interests and without a stable policy framework that survives elections and domestic political manoeuvring. This is a major weakness of Bangladesh’s foreign policy. 


Moreover, political actors often use foreign policy as a weapon in partisan storytelling for a domestic audience. So India becomes a symbol, not a relationship. 


China becomes a chequebook, not a strategy. The United States becomes either a saviour or a conspirator, depending on who is speaking and who is under pressure.


Ends 

Indo-US trade deal raises India's stature on the global stage

 On US-India trade agreement, Former Foreign Secretary and Rajya Sabha MP Harsh Vardhan Shringla says, 


"I think it is a historic deal. Full credit goes to the Prime Minister, who has waited patiently to ensure that the best conditions were available to finalise the deal. It is also attributable to the strong personal chemistry he has with President Trump. He was full of praise for PM Modi. It not only gives us a competitive market advantage in the US. At the same time, it uplifts India's stature on the global stage. It is a matter of pride that we have concluded two of the largest deals..."Opposition has nothing to say now, and is agitated that the PM has gone and concluded the 'father of all deals'."


"Purchase of oil is largely left to the oil companies, who are doing it. They will purchase oil, which is the most cost-competitive. People have to decide based on the national interest."

Sunday, February 1, 2026

No key Reform push ::: Budget suffers from one major defect — its business-as-usual approach

When it comes to BUDGET making, the Modi Govt has two problems.


One, it does not undersrand much about Economy and secondly -- it understsnds the Politics of Economy -- or political economy much better. 


Hence it is always over cautious. In Defence matters; it is aggressive and slso assertive. 





In politics, its superb and BJP has almost achieved one nation-one party nilestone. But when it comez to Reform and hard core Economy - the Modi govt. has been much cautious -- either 2014 or 2026 -- that is after 12 years in power. 

So in Budget 2026 -- no steps were taken to reduce gatekeepers and rent-seekers, who increase the cost of production in India. 

Moreover, Similarly, reforming the archaic agricultural distribution system has not been unlocked. And this means there will be huge loss in this sector either. 

***


Except for offering a tax holiday for data centres set up by foreign investors, Nirmala Sitharanan had nothing worthwhile, either in terms of incentives or reforms. 



 Ms Sitharaman continued fiscal consolidation by lowering the fiscal deficit to 4.3 per cent in the financial year 2026–27 from 4.4 per cent in the fiscal year 2025–26. Similarly, she did not splurge on either populist policies or growth-focused capital spending. 


Despite Operation Sindoor, capital expenditure grew merely from Rs 11.11 lakh crore to Rs 12.2 lakh crore in FY26.


This is the kind of financial discipline that global investors and credit rating agencies want governments to have. However, the Budget suffers from one major defect — its business-as-usual approach. 


When protectionism is rising, and great powers are forcing middle powers to choose sides, India cannot buy time; it must set its house in order and make itself attractive for investors.





Pro Govt views however ;;; - 


Bottom line:

Budget 2026 will not excite those who look for giveaways.

It will reassure those who understand statecraft.


It is a budget that assumes India’s rise is inevitable but only if policy remains patient, boring, and relentless.

That, arguably, is the hardest kind of leadership.  


But ....


The reality check is ☆ *** 

At a time when China has emerged as the second biggest world economy and it is now moving to the top position, India could have taken some bold steps to reach to the third position. 


The Indian economy is still way behind the $5 billion economy mark, which the government had promised to achieve in 2024. 


Economists also believe that Nirmala Sitharaman missed the big-ticket reforms like lowering tax rates or simplifying tax structures, bold deregulation, structural labour and land reform.

Privatisation of loss-making PSUs or major policy announcements also did not come..


The finance minister attempted some structural and policy pushes, particularly aimed at longer-term industrial and economic goals rather than one-off headline reforms. 


She put some extra thrust on renewed manufacturing and strategic sectors like those of semiconductors and rare-earth corridors to deepen domestic industrial capacity.


But FM Nirmala Sitharaman should be credited for custom rationalising, focusing on fiscal discipline, increasing infrastructure spending, giving more support to the MSME sector. 



Blogger


Ends 

Budget 2026 anchored by Sitharaman, an ex Def Minister, intends to build a modern, self-reliant military


Defence spending has risen to around Rs 5.9 lakh crore from Rs 4.9 lakh crore in FY26 (Budget Estimates), marking a growth of around 19 percent year-on-year. 


This underlines the focus on operational capability rather than recurring costs alone. Over the past decade, India’s defence budget has nearly doubled, rising from Rs 3.52 lakh crore in 2016–17 to over Rs 7.8 lakh crore today.

This Budget rightly positions AI and digital innovation as key enablers of a future-ready farm sector.


Growth may be an underlining theme of the Budget 2026-27. But Nirmala Sitharaman's ninth consecutive Budget reflects a decisive shift from incremental preparedness to sustained military strengthening. 


The government has set aside Rs 7,84,678 crore as total defence outlay for 2026–27, up from Rs 6,81,210 crore in the previous financial year. This marks a year-on-year increase of more than Rs 1 lakh crore and represents one of the strongest growth rates in recent years.

One might say Op. Sindoor was also responsible but changing geo political challenges cannot be ignored. 


Hence in a year India demonstrated 56 inch chest courage and left Pakistan devastated amd showed vulnerability of military prowess of China and US; the Budget curated by Team Modi has opted for a robust double-digit increase in defence spending.


The  Defence budget for 2026–27 reflects a decisive shift from incremental preparedness to sustained military strengthening. 


The scale and structure of the hike signal the Modi Govt is keen on investing in long-term deterrence and strategic autonomy. 

In other words, New Delhi is not only responding to immediate threats as they are emerging by factors such as Bangladesh, Myanmar and of course Pakistan. 

Steps proposed are ; 

** Raising capital outlay, prioritising high-value platforms.

*** Easing customs duties for defence manufacturing.


The 'orange economy' enters Budget 2026: What it is, and how the govt wants to scale it

Sitharaman said that India's Animation, Visual Effects, Gaming, and Comics (AVGC) sector is a rapidly growing industry and is projected to require 2 million professionals by 2030.

 


Defence budget for 2026/27 seen at 5.95 trillion rupees vs revised 5.68 trillion rupees for 2025/26

*Education budget for 2026/27 seen at 1.39 trillion rupees vs revised 1.22 trillion rupees for 2025/26

Health budget for 2026/27 seen at 1.05 trillion rupees vs revised 946 billion rupees for 2025/26


Sitharamman noted that while India's design industry is expanding rapidly, the country continues to face a shortage of trained designers.

She noted that while India's design industry is expanding rapidly, the country continues to face a shortage of trained designers.

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Sunday proposed a strong support for India's creative industries or 'orange economy' to create future-ready creative jobs.






"I propose to support the Indian Institute of Creative Technologies, Mumbai, in setting up AVGC Content Creator Labs in 15,000 secondary schools and 500 colleges, Sitharaman said while presenting the Union Budget for 2026-27.


This move is expected to boost India's next-generation creator workforce, powering jobs, startups, etc.


The Economic Survey 2025-26 too had noted that creativity-led sectors including culture, media, entertainment and intellectual property can emerge as significant drivers of employment, urban services and tourism.

@@@@


The launch of Bharat Vistaar is a significant step towards empowering farmers with AI-driven, real-time, climate-smart support, helping them make informed decisions, reduce risks from unpredictable weather, optimize inputs, and ultimately improve yields and livelihoods. 

The continued focus on precision agri-tech practices supports efficient, sustainable, and climate-resilient farming while enhancing farmers’ incomes. 





India is expected to close this financial year with 7.4% gross domestic product (GDP) growth according to the country's Economic Survey, but economic expansion will slow slightly next year as US President Donald Trump's 50% tariffs on Indian exporters start taking a greater toll.


The budget has laid a strong emphasis on fiscal restraint, targeting a lower deficit for the upcoming financial year. The fiscal deficit is the gap between the government's total expenditure and its total revenue.








Special Investment scheme for NRIs

Special Investment scheme for NRIs: The government has proposed to introduce special portfolio investment scheme for NRIs wanting to invest in India.


NRI Investment Limits: 


The government has proposed to increase NRI investment limit in listed companies from 5% currently to 10%. The overall NRI limit in listed companies hiked to 24% from current 10%.







Consolidated filings for investors: 


The government has introduced simpler mechanism of filing for investors who have multiple holdings across companies.