Thursday, December 4, 2025

"This is a result of Privatisation" ::::: Govt under attack for Indigo fiasco :::: "Where is the Civil Aviation Minister? Is he sleeping ?

CPI MP P  Sandosh Kumar says :

 "This mess has been going on for the last two days. Why do we have the Union Ministry to control all these things? Where is the Union Minister? I

Is he sleeping? IndiGo is the largest private airline operator in our country... It's not just an accident. A very serious probe is needed... I demand a very strong enquiry...".  






DGCA withdraws instructions to all operators regarding Weekly Rest for crew members.

"...In view of the ongoing operational disruptions and representations received from various airlines regarding the need to ensure continuity and stability of operations...the instruction contained in the referenced paragraph that no leave shall be substituted for weekly rest is hereby withdrawn with immediate effect..."



***

IndiGo domestic flights departing from Delhi Airport on 5th December 2025 are cancelled till midnight today (till 23:59 hours). 

The airport operator added that its dedicated on-ground teams are working diligently with all partners to mitigate the disruption and ensure a comfortable passenger experience.








CPI-M leader and MP Amra Ram says, "... Saying sorry is not enough. These private companies apologise and then run from their responsibilities. All private companies show the same lethargic behaviour. This is a result of privatisation..."

Has the Naga issue been mishandled? What went wrong?? ::::: When a Maoist veteran says "Armed Struggles have failed in India" .... does he imply others will be ill-advised to pursue the path of Confrontation ??

The Mizo Accord is in news albeit due to a wrong or rather a sad reason. Former Mizoram Governor Swaraj Kaushal has expired. Late Kaushal was a friend of Late rebel leader Laldenga and was also instrumental in ensuring the Mizo Peace Accord of 1986.  


We have other issues in public domain. As Vladimir Putin is on a visit to India - experts are analysing in certain details on the changing global dynamics and a special significance of an evolving RIC -- the Russia, India and China as a powerful bloc. These only underline the fact that these three countries will have to mutually cooperate in order to take on the western and the American hegemony. 



Modi and Xi Jinping : 2019 - Informal Summit 





Another important episode unfolded in recent weeks. The Modi government has decided to deal with the Naxal problem with the firm hands and eradicate it completely. Now on Dec 4th (2025) came a media interview by a senior and well known Maoist ideologue and an influential leader -- 

Mallojula Venugopal Rao alias Sonu


who has said -- "Facing losses upon losses, as the movement weakened and hopes and beliefs faded, we realised that stubbornly sticking to armed struggle… would be unwise". 


He also said:   "My assessment has proven correct. Those insisting on continuing the armed struggle will inevitably be pushed into more mistakes and losses, leading to irreparable damage.... Armed Struggles have failed in India".  



Importantly yet again he said -  "We urge them all to lay down arms, leave the underground life, and come to the vast masses, (and stop) listening to anyone who has been misguiding us for a long time, and (stop) clinging to false prestige".









Hence now; we may have to pull up sleeves and try to do some stocking especially in the context of militancy in north east. And when we talk about it --- few obvious questions come into our mind -- 



** Has the Naga issue been mishandled?


** Even in the context of other groups in states such as Assam and Manipur  -- there is a need to 'explore' --  


What went wrong??

$$ -- Perhaps the natives - sons and daughters of the soil in Nagaland, Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh and also Assam -- will have to ask - where did we Nagas or Assamese (and others) have gone wrong. 



Should Muivah &  NSCN-IM 'examine' issues related to human conditions and need for a lasting Peace ?


Is Naga Movement today ... entering a phase of 'misguided' horizon ? What about Practical problems ?  


Just look back and wonder -- had the Solution pact be signed in 2019 ... in circa 2025 ... Nagas, the state government in Kohima and also the Govt of India would have been discussing something else today ! Let us cross-check what does the Maoist veteran talks about 'ideologies'.  


Here is the sample -- "We failed to enrich our ideology and practice according to changing conditions. The conditions of the 1980s are no longer present in the 21st century. Even in the past 25 years, significant changes in the country’s economic system (part of the world imperialist system) have taken place." 


Importantly; the Naga militancy also coincided 'writing a new chapter' in the 1980s. 

For all practical purpose that means --- the Chinese assistance has stopped or is now confined to minimum. If that's the situation with Naxals - things could be worse for groups in north east of India.

We know for years -- innovative forms of anti-India resistance was visible from the militants including the NSCN-IM, ULFA, PLA of Meiteis and also the Naxals in the mainstream India. But where does thing stand today?




  


Paresh Baruah's cadres have been surrendering at regular intervals.

The Meitei and Kuki armed groups are in the margins.

Organisations like ULFA and NSCN-IM had in the post extended moral support and even endorsed the activities of Khalistanis and armed groups in Tamil Nadu and Jammu and Kashmir.  But in 2025 December -- Jammu and Kashmir militancy and Khalistanis are on wane or almost 'dead' issues.

This will make the Govt of India mandarins throw up the most evocative question -- Can't Thuingaleng Muivah or V S Atem see the writing on the wall ? 


The onetime Naxal hero - Mallojula Venugopal Rao says: "The Indian armed movement has reached extremely adverse conditions, all avenues to rectify it are closed, and there are no opportunities to protect its people ....


.... – if I had made this decision out of fear for my own life, I would have made it long ago. I was not afraid, why should I be afraid? 

But I thought of protecting everyone’s lives and thereby preserving the revolutionary movement." 








Hence - leaders like Muivah and because he has an able deputy Atem and Paresh Baruah should also think about 'preserving' the legacy of their movement. 

The largesse from China and other countries had in the past enriched and thus strengthened the resistance power of anti-India forces such as various militant groups in northeast and also the Maoists and Khalistanis. It was the cement that bound these forces to continue to fight a democratic set up/apparatus run from Delhi.

But in the new world order; such support and assistance will not come easy. Various groups and authorities in Myanmar are realising the folly of depending on Beijing or other external forces.


The Nagas or the Assamese - to be precise the NSCN-IM and the ULFA (I) - cannot be so casual with the shared future of the respective land and the people.











ends   

Pilot shortage is one reason :::: 550 IndiGo flights cancelled, airline apologises for widespread disruption :::: "We continue to keep our customers apprised of any changes"

 550 IndiGo flights cancelled, airline apologises for widespread disruption


"An accumulation of several operational challenges, including minor technology glitches, schedule changes, adverse weather conditions, heightened congestion in the aviation ecosystem, and the implementation of the FDTL norms, compounded negatively to create a cascading impact on our operations," wrote Indigo CEO in an internal email. 

That went viral !!


IndiGo, one of the largest carriers in the country, is grappling with significant operational disruptions in the past few days, and about 300 flights were cancelled on Thursday alone. 

Scores of flights were delayed. 

In November, the airline witnessed the cancellation of 1,232 flights and severe delays in many flights.


The operational inconvenience continues for one of the premium Indian carriers, IndiGo, as 550 flights were cancelled on Thursday, Dec 4.  


The operational inconvenience continues for India's one of the premium carriers, IndiGo, as the airline witnessed cancellations of 550 flights across the nation on Thursday. Of the total flights, at least 191 flights were cancelled in Delhi, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, and Hyderabad, leading to chaos at the airports. The carrier has issued a statement on the ongoing crisis.


"The last two days have seen widespread disruption across IndiGo’s network and operations. We extend a heartfelt apology to all our customers and industry stakeholders who have been impacted by these events. IndiGo teams are working diligently and making all efforts with the support of MOCA, DGCA, BCAS, AAI and airport operators to reduce the cascading impact of these delays and restore normalcy. 


We continue to keep our customers apprised of any changes to their scheduled flights and advise them to check the latest status," IndiGo said.








Following the drop in performance, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) decided to launch a probe. It asked the airline to cite reasons behind the drastic decline in operations.  

The civil aviation body asked the airline to cite appropriate reasons behind the rapid flight cancellations and the delays that occurred throughout the month of November.



In response to that, the carrier referred to a number of reasons, including staff shortage, failure in Air Traffic Control (ATC), and others behind the cancellations and drop in performance.  




"Out of those 1,232 flights, 755 were cancelled because of staff shortages, 92 were cancelled due to the failure of Air Traffic Control (ATC), 258 were cancelled due to airport restrictions, and 127 were cancelled for other reasons," the airlines noted. The aviation body suggested a handful of key measures, including hiring more crews and others to improve the services.


The rapid inconvenience resulted in massive crowd dissatisfaction among passengers who shared their experience on social media.


Meanwhile, the CEO of IndiGo, Pieter Elbert, shared an apology note in an internal email, shared with the employees. He mentioned the reasons behind the operational delays and cancellations. The email went viral on social media.


"We serve close to 380,000 customers a day and want each of them to have a good experience. We could not live up to that promise these past days, and we have publicly apologised for that," he said.  



IndiGo is likely to receive a partial waiver from the DGCA on new pilot rest-duty norms after a severe operational meltdown forced over a thousand flight cancellations. 


The second phase of the rules, effective from November, limits night landings and significantly increased crew requirements. 

IndiGo, which failed to plan for the transition, is now facing a pilot shortage due to inadequate hiring and delayed training.


ends 

Muslims in West Bengal :::: It all started in 1971 .... it was later encouraged by 'appeasement' under Left and then Mamata :::: West Bengal, like Assam, seems to be witnessing a quickening of the process of change in religious demography :::: Muslim presence could reach pre-Partition level !!

The state of West Bengal and Muslims in terms of mutual relationships often present a bundle of contradictions.


Among the 42 Muslim majority sub-districts -- Muslims have a presence of nearly 90 percent in three; 

their share is above 80 percent in another seven, 

between 75 and 80 percent in eleven. 


When it comes to election strategies; the RSS focuses on consolidating the Hindu vote, which has been observed in constituencies with large Muslim populations in various elections across India.


Recently, the BJP in West Bengal has also attempted a "Muslim outreach". New BJP state president Samik Bhattacharya says - "Marchhey musalman, morchhey musalman (If Muslims are indulging in violence; the maximum casualty is also among Muslims only) 


A few BJP leaders argue that Muslims do not vote for the BJP in large numbers anyway, but others suggest the party is simply clarifying it is only against "infiltrators" and not "rashtravadi (nationalist) Indian Muslims".











Enough might have been written about Muslims in Gujarat - especially due to post-Godhra mayhem of 2002. Enough studies have been made about Muslims in Uttar Pradesh too -- the state that sends as many as 80 lawmakers to the Lok Sabha. 

And polarisation has more often ruled the roost. At present the state is being ruled by a Hindu-monk politician -- Yogi Adityanath and his admirers say the chief minister has steered the province out of the 'BIMARU' bracket.

It is not without good reason that one may say West Bengal, like Assam, seems to be witnessing a quickening of the process of change in religious demography.


Muslims constitute about 27% of West Bengal's population (as of 2011 Census).



** But current estimates suggest a higher percentage (30-33%) with growth projected to continue. 

The impact of the 'partial transfer of populations' that occurred in West Bengal and some adjoining areas at the time of Partition is likely to be completely negated.



The Muslim presence in the state could reach the pre-Partition level soon. 


*** The challenges for the community and governance are rooted in historical and structural factors, and inadequate policy implementation. 

Key problems include lower literacy rates and educational backwardness.

These contribute to socio-economic disadvantages. But certain things are debated intensely as influx from neighbouring Bangladesh continued unabated for years.


During 2001-11, Muslims have grown by 21.8 percent compared to the decadal growth of 

10.8 percent registered by the Hindus.


Muslims have a significant presence of at least 10 percent everywhere in West Bengal, except in Darjeeling, Bankura and Purulia districts. 

But their presence and growth is particularly high in two regions-- 

* Dinajpur-Maldah-Murshidabad-Birbhum region lying to the west of Rangpur and Rajshahi Divisions of Bangladesh 


** And in 24-Parganas-Kolkata-Haora region lying to the west of Khulna. 


Muslims now form a majority in the former.

Their share in the population there is estimated 52 percent.

In 1951, it was less than 40 percent and around 48 percent in 1941, before Partition. 


In West Bengal, the share of Muslims in the population has risen by 7.5 % since Independence and Partition.

Notably, much of this accretion has occurred after 1971. 

Proportion of Muslims in the state was 19.5 percent in 1991 and 20.5 percent in 1971 ... it has reached 27 plus now. 

Their share before Partition was around or less than 30 percent. 


During Partition, this region did not witness as complete a transfer of populations unlike the northwest.

However, Muslims still lost about one-third of their share. Much of that loss has now been made up, and observers say the share of Muslims in West Bengal is likely to soon reach the pre-Partition levels.





The vulnerable region forms part of an eastern border belt of very high Muslim presence and growth that stretches to Purnia and Santhal Pargana regions of Bihar and Jharkhand on the west and to Lower and North Assam on the east. 

Muslims now form a majority in this whole belt, and there are large pockets within it, where they have an overwhelming majority.


The share of Muslims in 24-Parganas-Kolkata-Haora pocket is now near 28 percent; it was 19.6 percent in 1951 and 20.6 percent in 1971. In 1941, it was nearer 27 percent.


West Bengal, like Assam, seems to be witnessing a quickening of the process of change in religious demography that has picked up pace since 1971.







In 2011, of the total population of 9.13 crore counted in West Bengal -- about 6.44 crore were Hindus, 2.47 crore Muslims and 6.6 lakh Christians. 


There are 9.4 lakh persons counted under the category of ORP (Other religions and persuasions).

These belong mainly to the tribes of Bankura, Purulia and Pashchimi Medinipur, many of whom are counted as followers of Sari Dharma, similar to Sarna Dharma of neighbouring Jharkhand. 


West Bengal had 2.83 lakh Buddhists in 2011; of these 2.60 lakhs wee in the districts of Darjeeling and Jalpaiguri. Besides them, there are 63.5 thousand Sikhs and 60 thousand Jains. 


Widening gap between the growth of Hindus and Muslims


Growth Gap in Hindus and Muslims

Year Decadal Growth% Relative Gap in %

                 Hindu Muslim

1951-61 32.63    36.48

1961-71 25.75 29.76

1971-81 21.37 29.55

1981-91 21.09 36.89

1991-01 14.23 25.91

2001-11 10.81 21.81


This comparison may be very relevant. In Assam, the growth of Hindus during this decade has been very similar at 10.9 percent.

But Muslims have grown at a much higher rate of 29.6 percent. 


Yet the gap between the two growth rates is rather wide in West Bengal; the decadal growth of Muslims during 2001-11 has been 102 percent above that of Hindus. 

This gap has remained fairly wide and has kept widening since 1971-81. 


High accretion to the share of Muslims


The share of Muslims during 2001-11 increased from 25.25 to 27.01 percent marking an accretion of 1.77 percentage points. 


This quantum of accretion is the fourth largest in India after Assam, Kerala and Uttarakhand.

The accretion in the share of Muslims during 2001-11 has been of 3.31 (Assam), 2.03 (Kerala) and 1.87 percentage points in Uttarakhand.

Compared to the average national accretion of 0.8 points, the increase in West Bengal is indeed very large.




Born Hindu - 'political conversion' ??




This high level of accretion to the Muslim share has continued for four decades after 1971. Their share in the State has increased 

from 19.5 percent in 1951 and 

20.5 percent in 1971 to 27 percent in 2011.

They had a share of about or less than 30 percent throughout the pre-Independence period. 


At the time of Partition, the transfer of populations in this part of India  was much less intense than in the northwest. But the share of Muslims in the State had declined by about 10 percentage points. 


Muslims have already recovered about 70 percent of this decline.


Distribution of Muslims across different regions of West Bengal  ::


Muslims have a high presence in -

Uttar Dinajpur, Dakshin Dinajpur, Maldah, Murshidabad and Birbhum districts that lie on the west of Rangpur and Rajshahi divisions of Bangladesh.

And also in North and South 24 Parganas, Kolkata -- not far from Khulna.


In 2011 ::

There are 99.65 lakh, or nearly a crore, Muslims in Uttar Dinajpur, Dakshin Dinajpur, Maldah, Murshidabad and Birbhum 


** About 76.85 lakh in North and South 24 Parganas and Kolkata

In Nadia, the Muslim presence was around 26.8 percent. 


Muslim share in some regions of the state remained nearly unchanged during 1951-61, and rose by about 1 percentage point in each of the following two decades. 


But in the three decades since 1981, however, their share has risen by more than 6 percentage points. 




Blogger 


ends 


"Value of defence imports from Russia was demonstrated during Operation Sindoor" -- Congress MP, Shashi Tharoor :::: Moscow-based expert says - “Russia is no longer anxious about the risks of political isolation"

Putin says India-Russia cooperation is not aimed against anyone, including US



Has the “no-limits partnership” between Moscow and Beijing has rattled India ?

On Russian President Vladimir Putin’s India visit, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said:


"It's hugely significant. It is a crucial relationship, and has been for a long time. In today's rather turbulent world, where so many relationships have become uncertain, it becomes important to shore up the ones we have. 


No one should misunderstand that this will affect our relationships with other countries, because India has the capacity to have independent relationships with different governments. 


"We are a nation that has always believed in sovereign autonomy. Our autonomy to decide our friendships, our partnerships and our national interests is encoded in our DNA. The value of Russian friendship has been proven in recent years, particularly in two domains. 







"We've had a lot of oil and gas from Russia in recent years, and the value of defence imports from Russia was demonstrated once again during Operation Sindoor when the S-400 protected us from a number of Pakistani missiles that were targeting our cities, including Delhi... ". 


"If agreements come through during this meeting, that's part of strengthening a vital relationship, which in my mind, does not come at the expense of relations with America or China...", he said.






“Russia is no longer anxious about the risks of political isolation.”


Petr Topychkanov, Moscow-based senior researcher at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, said that for Russia, “the importance of this visit lies primarily in the fact that it is happening at all”.


“It will signal that Russia is returning to something resembling normal international relations,” said Topychkanov.   



India’s relationship with Russia goes back to the cold war and has remained deeply entrenched since then, with Russia remaining India’s biggest defence supplier. It is an alliance that was long-tolerated by western governments, even after Putin’s actions in Ukraine, but Trump’s return to the White House has signalled a markedly different approach.



Over the past three years, the US and Europe turned a blind eye as India became one of the largest buyers of cheap Russian oil, despite sanctions in the west. 




But after the US president’s peacemaking efforts in Ukraine failed earlier this year, Trump began to accuse India of bankrolling Russia’s invasion. 


He publicly put pressure on Delhi to halt its Russian oil purchases, which culminated in a punishing additional 25% punitive US tariff on Indian imports.











For India, thus there are even greater stakes at play. 

As Aparna Pande, director of the India and south Asia initiative at the Hudson Institute, put it, Delhi is currently grappling with its most unfavourable geopolitical climate in years, thanks to “a semi-isolationist America, a weaker Russia and a very powerful China”.  (The Guardian) 


In a notable sign of the tightrope India has to walk, on the eve of Putin’s arrival a joint opinion piece by the French ambassador, German high commissioner and UK high commissioner to India was published in the Times of India, titled “Russia doesn’t seem serious about peace”.

It prompted a stinging response from India’s foreign ministry, which said it was “not an acceptable diplomatic practice to give public advice on India’s relations with a third country”.


India has returned to its default mode of “hedging” in its unorthodox alliances, write two experts for 'The Guardian' (London) - 
Hannah Ellis-Petersen and Pjotr Sauer.


India has thus signaled to the US it has multiple options and waiting to see where everything will fall.


The last meeting between Putin and Modi was just three months ago, alongside Chinese premier Xi Jinping, where the three leaders were pictured holding hands and sharing jokes – optics that prompted fury from Trump.



Yet India has other pressing priorities in its engagement with Russia, namely the vast superpower that sits along its febrile north and north-eastern border. “From the Indian side – for all the talk of Russian being a great and loyal friend – the real reason that relationship is important is geography,” said Pande.

But,  China remains the greatest threat to India for the foreseeable future and since the Soviet Union, India has always relied on Russia as a continental balancer against China.









The increasingly close, “no-limits partnership” between Moscow and Beijing has rattled India, said Pande, and left them hoping to find a way to “prevent Russia from ever getting too close to China and ensure it can count on Moscow to put some pressure on the Chinese”.


It has also prompted India to try to move away from its dependence on Russia, particularly on defence. 


For decades, about 70% of Indian defence purchases came from Russia but in the past four years, this has reduced to less than 40%.



The sale of weapons and planes – in particular Russian S-400 air defence systems and the Sukhoi Su-57 fighter aircraft – will probably be a key component of Modi and Putin’s talks.

India will also try to strike a balance; 

-- keep purchasing enough Russia weapons to retain the alliance, 
but 

not be so dependent that if Russia suddenly cut off supplies under China’s pressure. 


ends 

Putin lands in Delhi ... .... "a powerful global message that India, Russia will not be cowed by US pressure" ::::: Modi-Russian Prez hug ... moves in same car ::::: Defence Minister Rajnath Singh meets Russian counterpart Andrei Belousov :::: 'Welcome Putin' written with diyas during Ganga Aarti in Varanasi

Against turbulent geopolitical backdrop, analysts say the significance of Russian President Vladimir Putin travelling to India to meet Narendra Modi has both a major symbolic value of the enduring relationship between the countries and also 

.... a powerful global message that neither would be cowed by US pressure.


The summit comes at a critical juncture for both countries. Putin arrives in Delhi after rejecting the latest Ukraine peace proposal proposed by the US, confident that recent advances by Russian forces on the battlefield have strengthened his hand.


Petr Topychkanov, Moscow-based senior researcher at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, said that for Russia, “the importance of this visit lies primarily in the fact that it is happening at all”.


PM Narendra Modi tweets, 


"Delighted to welcome my friend, President Putin to India. Looking forward to our interactions later this evening and tomorrow. India-Russia friendship is a time-tested one that has greatly benefitted our people."


PM Modi is hosting a private dinner for Vladimir Putin on Thursday evening, in a reciprocal gesture to the hospitality extended to him the Russian President in Moscow in July 2024. 










Maxim Oreshkin, Deputy Chief of Staff in the Russian Presidential Executive Office, says : 


"President Putin and Prime Minister Modi have set the target of 100 billion USD by 2030. So this is the target we are working on. And we believe that the key source of this and that increase will come from India's export in goods and services going to Russia."




2001 : Vajpayee-led Indian delegation to Russia had Gujarat CM Modi as well 



Defence Minister Rajnath Singh tweets, 

: "Delighted to meet with the Russian Defence Minister Andrei Belousov in New Delhi. 


India-Russia relationship is based on a deep sense of trust, common values and mutual respect, which are the defining principles of the special and privileged strategic partnership, between both countries. 


"India is determined for expanding capacity of indigenous defence industry for both local production and exports, under the aegis of ‘Atma Nirbhar Bharat’. I also laid emphasis on exploring new opportunities for enhancing collaboration between both the counties across niche technologies."






Defence Minister Rajnath Singh and his Russian counterpart co-chair the 22nd India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission on Military & Military Technical Cooperation in New Delhi
 
Both sides reiterate that India-Russia ties are based on a deep sense of trust, common principles & mutual respect. Rajnath Singh stresses on new opportunities to enhance collaboration across niche technologies

 
Russian Defence Industry is ready to support India towards becoming self-reliant in defence production, says Andrei Belousov









'Welcome Putin' written with diyas during the Ganga Aarti being performed in Varanasi.








Russian President Vladimir Putin has arrived in Delhi. President Putin is on a two-day State visit to India. He will hold the 23rd India-Russia Annual Summit with PM Narendra Modi in Delhi on December 5.







Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday night kick-started a nearly 27-hour visit to India to further shore up a nearly eight-decade bilateral partnership that remained on firm footing notwithstanding the fractious geopolitical environment and tensions.

In reflection of the importance India attached to the visit, Prime Minister Narendra Modi received Putin at New Delhi's Palam airport with a hug and accorded him a warm welcome to India after a gap of four years.


The two leaders left the airport in the same car, nearly three months after they travelled together in a vehicle in the Chinese city of Tianjin following the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit.






"Please be realistic" ... Swaraj Kaushal had told NSCN-IM leader Muivah :::: Swaraj Kaushal no more :: He handled Naga peace talks in 1998-99 ::: He was former Mizoram Governor

#SwarajKaushal no more .... 


"Brother, you have the maturity and understanding. Please be realistic..." -- Swaraj Kaushal had told NSCN-IM leader Thuingaleng Muivah in 2020



#Delhi CM #RekhaGupta expresses condolences on the demise of former #Mizoram #Governor. He was husband of Late #SushmaSwaraj ".. my deepest condolences are with Member of Parliament #BansuriSwaraj Ji and all their family members".  


He was 'first' interlocutor to Naga peace talks appointed in 1998 when #Vajpayee was PM


Daughter Bansuri Swaraj and 'dad' Swaraj Kaushal 




"You have maturity, Please be realistic" - Swaraj Kaushal's advice to Naga leader Muivah ..... 

..... in 2020



Former Mizoram Governor Swaraj Kaushal, who was the first peace interlocutor in Naga talks in 1998, 

on Oct 17, had urged NSCN-IM leader Thuingaleng Muivah to be 'realistic' and said the latter should not press for demands such as Flag and a separate Naga Constitution. 


"Brother, you have maturity and understanding. Please be realistic and not press for such demands. Please live and prosper in a democracy. 

Everything in this country (India) belongs to the people," Kaushal wrote in a series of tweets. 



"The symbols of sovereignty namely, separate constitution, flag, currency, defence and foreign affairs are sacrosanct and never negotiable," he said and also pointed out that such media interviews at the fag end of over two-decades old peace parleys would serve little purpose. 



"I have seen my brother T. Muivah’s interview to a digital media. Was this interview necessary ? I think ‘No’. 


Will this interview help you or your organisation ? I think ‘No’," said Kaushal emphatically in response to NSCN (IM) general secretary's interview to a 'controversial' website wherein he insists on the twin demands of a separate Flag and Constitution for Nagas. 


The Naga rebel group NSCN (IM) is in parleys with the Government of India since 1997 and the parleys have progressed under all governments headed by different Prime Ministers - I K Gujral, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Manmohan Singh and 
Narendra Modi.



In reference to Muivah's outburst against the then Nagaland Governor and peace interlocutor R N Ravi, Swaraj Kaushal had said -


"You are angry with Governor Ravi. You say he has ‘betrayed’ you. You say ‘he has thrown us away’ and “he is acting at the behest of the Union home ministry.” 

Please appreciate, Mr. R.N.Ravi is an interlocutor appointed by the Union Home Ministry. 


He cannot act on his own. He is bound to act at the behest of the Union Home Ministry. What is wrong with that ?" 


Kaushal, also husband of Late Union Minister Sushma Swaraj, further says - "I ask myself a simple question. 

"Can an interlocutor go beyond his brief ? My answer is ‘No, Never.’  Your answer should also be the same. Then why blame Mr R N Ravi in the media ?" 



Questioning the rationale behind media interview at a time when the peace parleys are at the fag end, former Mizoram Governor said. 


"Have such interviews ever built a consensus ? I think No. Then how do such interviews help ?" 


"Brother, when you get very angry, reason flies out of the window. And that is precisely what happened here," he opined.









Kaushal had urged the NSCN (IM) and Muivah to "rise to the occasion now" and cautions otherwise - "the settlement will elude us for many years".



"Brother, you have the maturity and understanding. Please be realistic and not press for such demands. 

Please live and prosper in a democracy. Everything in this country belongs to the people. The state and the government are their trustees," the former Governor wrote in the micro blogging site.


The issues related to Naga insurgency dates back to pre-independence era. 



Nagaland attained statehood in 1963 after signing of a 16 Point Agreement.
Originally led by A Zapu Phizo, the Naga National Council split a number of times especially after the 1970s.


The NSCN (Isak Muivah) faction for long was led by Late Isak Chishi Swu and Muivah. Swu, the former chairman of NSCN (IM) breathed his last in 2016.



The peace talk is now like hanging fire and the status quo club with a powerful section of overground politicians are busy derailing and delaying the final peace and Solution pact. 



Ends