Friday, August 2, 2019

Pak made to eat crow: ICJ suspends Death sentence on Kulbhushan


Guest Column,

 Swati Deb 


It all started amid battle of nerves. Life of an individual, a former naval officer and an ‘innocent Indian’ was involved.  On April 10, 2017, Kulbhushan Jadhav was sentenced to death by a military court in Pakistan.
Obviously, the battle was also about country’s prestige in the context of dealing with Pakistan – where lie is an instrument of foreign policy and where peddling fake news is considered a virtue. 

But things were handled with maturity and a battery of legal and diplomatic minds joined forces to make India’s and Kulbhushan Jadhav’s case at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) at The Hague.

ICJ is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. The ICJ's primary functions are to settle international legal disputes submitted by nations and give its verdict and also opinions on legal issues referred to it by the UN.
In the matter related to the Kulbhushan Jadhav case – the 16 member bench had one Pakistani judge as well and it may be relevant to add here that one dissent vote was from the concerned Pakistani judge only.
The Court pronounced that Pakistan had breached relevant obligations under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. It did so by not notifying India, without delay, of the detention of Jadhav.

Speaking in Parliament on July 18, a day after the verdict, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said – “Pakistan was also found to have deprived India of the right to communicate with Shri Jadhav, have access to him, visit him in detention and arrange his legal representation. The Court declared that Pakistan is under an obligation to inform Shri Jadhav without further delay of his rights and to provide India consular access to him”. 

In a major relief to 49-year-old Jadhav, the ICJ ruled that Jadhav’s death sentence awarded by the Pakistani military court should remain suspended. 
  

The ICJ, based in The Hague, pronounced its judgement certainly favoured India, saying ``Jadhav’s death sentence should remain suspended until Pakistan effectively reviews and reconsiders the conviction or sentence in light of Pakistan’s breach of Article 36 (1), that is, denial of consular access and notification.’’

In fact, earlier after India petitioned the ICJ, the global court had put a stay to the execution of the capital punishment.
Now in retrospect, it was on May 8, 2017 - India instituted proceedings in the International Court of Justice against Pakistan for “egregious violation” of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, 1963 and on May 9 (2017), the ICJ sent an urgent communication to the then Prime Minister of Pakistan Nawaz Sharif putting stay on the military court order of capital punishment slapped on Jadhav.

Here is interesting background information – in April 2017 – Indian Foreign Ministry and the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) had decided about going to the ICJ to ‘prevent’ the death sentence on Jadhav. But the plans were not revealed for obvious reasons.


Sources say – thus – when India initiated the proceedings and within a day got the ‘stay’ order --- also called on India’s Request for Provisional Measures, Pakistan was caught unawares.  
In retrospect again, it is worth mentioning that on April 27, 2017, Ministry of External Affairs spokesman Gopal Baglay on records had questioned the authenticity of Pakistani claim that the military court proceedings against Jadhav was transparent.

“Where are the documents and chargesheets? Where is the copy of the judgement?,” he had said.

Insiders said such rhetoric was used deliberately to camouflage India’s real intent – of moving the ICJ. On the other hand, Pakistan had pushed its argument internationally saying, in last two years (prior to 2017), Pakistan has tried more than 270 Pakistanis in military courts.


It also said Jadhav could seek mercy but that implied that he should agree that he is an Indian spy.


Sushma’s Core Team:

The then External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj took charge of things and formed a core team. She met Prime Minister Narendra Modi on this on number of occasions and kept him well informed of her ministry’s works.

Vishnu Dutt Sharma, MEA’s legal division head, was asked to work as a bridge between diplomats and lawyers and Harish Salve team got into the business.

Ms Swaraj and Deepak Mittal, Joint Secretary Pakistan-Afghanistan-Iran (PAI), from beginning insisted that Jadhav should be given consular access and ultimately that was the point that stuck all along in the legal war.

Sushma Swaraj was also in touch with the family of Kulbhushan Jadhav and thus within minutes the verdict came from The Hague, the former External Affairs Minister had something to cheer about. She tweeted:”......It is a great victory for India. I hope the verdict will provide the much needed solace to the family members of Kulbhushan Jadhav”.
   
MEA sources also point out Pakistan has never contested India’s contention that Jadhav was not informed of his rights under the Vienna Convention. This was endorsed by the ICJ also. A misinformation campaign peddled by Pakistan in first week of March 2016 that Jadhav had a passport bearing the name ‘Hussein Mubarak Patel’ too was unfounded.

India had submitted before the ICJ that it has information that Jadhav was "kidnapped from Iran, where he was carrying on business after retiring from the Indian Navy and was then shown to have been arrested in Balochistan" on March 3, 2016.
Counsel Harish Salve has answered the passport puzzle well: “Pakistan repeatedly played slides of what it claimed was passport it had recovered from Jadhav. Not only did the Court get drawn into it, this displaying passport led to the court rejecting Pakistan's argument that Jadhav's nationality was uncertain”.

Pak cornered:

The ICJ verdict has not only caught Pakistan – now under new Imran Khan regime – unawares, it has also isolated Pakistan an inch more since Pulwama terror attack and UN blacklisting of Masood Azhar.
It is worth mentioning that the Modi government has already got global support in 2016 after the Uri terror attack. Under Modi’s stewardship, India’s relations have improved leaps and bounds with the US, Russia and also China --- and this despite Doklam row in 2017.
The Trump administration endorsed India’s surgical strike in September 2016 and the Balakot airstrikes this year too found international endorsement.
Thus, when the Pakistan government announced on mid night of July 18-19 that ‘consular access’ will be given to Jadhav, it was only reflection of its helplessness.

“As a responsible state, Pakistan will grant consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav according to Pakistani laws, for which modalities are being worked out,” a Pakistan government announcement said.
For quick recap, the ICJ verdict has few important takeaways -
-Pak breached Art 36 obligations of Vienna Convention by denying consular access.
--Pak deprived India Right to Communicate with Jadhav
--Pak failed to inform India of Jadhav's arrest ‘without delay’
-ICJ affirms Jadhav's right to consular access
--The verdict directs Pakistan to provide effective review
--ICJ directs Pakistan to reconsider Jadhav's conviction
--ICJ says Jadhav's death sentence to remain suspended


Of course the court also ruled that the remedy sought by India, including annulment of Pak military court decision convicting Jadhav and his release and safe passage to India.

Senior Congress leader and former Home Minister P Chidambaram was the first among the opposition leaders to have welcomed the verdict.
"ICJ delivers `justice’ in the true sense of that word, upholding human rights, due procedure and the rule of law. A 15:1 verdict is actually a unanimous verdict,” he tweeted.

Congress party in its official Twitter handle sought to shed its political differences and said the verdict was a “big win for India”.

Rahul Gandhi was, however, guarded when in his reaction, and did not compliment the government of the day or the legal team. The Congress President wrote in the micro blogging site – “My thoughts tonight are with Kulbhushan Jadhav , alone in a prison cell in Pakistan & with his distraught family for whom this verdict brings a rare moment of relief, joy & renewed hope, that he will one day be free to return to his home in India”.


Sword of Sanctions:

Pakistan now faces the threat of sword of global sanctions because ICJ operates under the mandate of United Nations.
Senior Counsel Harish Salve, who represented India and Kulbhushan Jadhav in the International Court of Justice at The Hague, expectedly welcomed the 15-1 verdict of the court and said if Pakistan violates the directives, Islamabad can even attract sanctions.

He also said there are "fantastic lawyers" in Pakistan, who will take up the cause of Jadhav, on whom the Pakistani military court had served the death sentence but the verdict of the 'farcical' process was suspended by the ICJ. 

"Consular access has to be given, if it is not given, we can go back to the ICJ. If the country brazenly defies the ICJ edict, there are other provisions including sanctions," Mr Salve told reporters in London.


He welcomed the ICJ order and said Pakistan has to do everything to implement Vienna Convention and also take necessary "legislative measures". Answering questions, Salve maintained that the ICJ order makes it clear that he cannot be 'tortured'. He said if the trial is not fair, "we can go back to the ICJ".

"We expect Pakistan to do whatever it has to do including appropriate legislative measures to guarantee a fair trial. So Pakistan's conduct is under watch and if what they do is another farcical attempt, we will be back in the Court," the attorney said.

Closer scrutiny of the verdict suggests the Court has rejected yet another Pakistani contention that consular access need not be given to someone who has been held involved in ‘espionage’. The ICJ verdict makes it clear now that the Vienna Convention cannot exclude from its scope for persons who is charged with ‘espionage’.

When it comes to immediate reactions and interpretation of the verdict, Pakistan tried to put up a brave face on the first day and gave a spin that India’s request for ‘safe passage’ was not given. 

“ICJ has decided not to acquit or release Jadhav thus not accepting Indian pray”, came the Pak foreign ministry statement. Even Pakistani media screamed – ‘ICJ rejects India’s plea for Kulbhushan Jadhav’s acquittal’.

But, Islamabad got a snub from MEA spokesman Raveesh Kumar on July 18 when he said: "Frankly, it seems to me they (Pakistan) are reading from a different verdict. Main verdict is in 42 pages, if there is no patience to go through 42 pages, Pakistan should go through 7-pages Press Release, where every point is in India's favour”. 

For his part Mr Salve has answered the issue of annulment saying - "We had ambitiously asked for annulment, the court said no.....but they have said Pakistan has to do everything to make Vienna Convention a reality".

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said in Parliament – “Sir, in 2017, Government made a commitment on the Floor of the House to undertake all steps necessary to protect the interests and welfare of Shri Jadhav. Government has made untiring efforts in seeking his release, including through legal means in the International Court of Justice. I am sure the House will join me in appreciating the efforts of all those involved, especially the legal team led by Shri Harish Salve”. 

Dr Jaishankar said: The judgement is not only a vindication for India and Shri Jadhav, but for all those who believe in the rule of law and the sanctity of international conventions”. 
Jinnah: Pak Creator

Lesson not learnt:

But Pakistan seems to have developed a habit of not taking any lesson. It is being argued in the corridors of South Block in Delhi that Pakistan  “cannot achieve much” now by delaying Jadhav’s return to India. One school of thought even says Imran Khan, who often tries to give an image of a liberal though after pushed to the wall, should order his release and may be this gesture can ‘lure India’ back to the negotiating table.

Pakistan has in the past ‘surrendered’ and order return of Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman and lately felt the pressure and acted against JuD chief Hafiz Saeed and also Masood Azhar.

However, it can be still imperative to try to analyse what are the possible options Pakistan has to delay Jadhav’s return or make things ‘difficult’ for India. They may commute the sentence to life sentence and then say – Islamabad is ready to talk on all fronts including Jadhav and Kashmir.

The back channel parleys have never been suspended between two sides but New Delhi is talking only on piece meals. Kartarpur Corridor is one such an example.
Rightly say people in the know of things - Pakistan is now under a ‘global gaze’ as to what direction it would follow.

In his blog, former Defence Minister Arun Jaitley, an eminent lawyer himself and the ailing BJP leader said: “Pakistan lost conclusively before the ICJ. The court has given Pakistan an opportunity to comply with the rule of law and reform its processes. Will Pakistan use this opportunity or will they squander it?” 

The answer may lie in the proverbial womb of time, but it is for Pakistani military to act quickly and ‘judiciously’. Imran Khan has an opportunity to give an impression that is a man of different kind. The ‘Kulbhushan Jadhav plot’ was after all hatched by Pakistan when Nawaz Sharif was in power.

Reports say while Harish Salve charged only Re 1 as fee on this case; a fund crunch Pakistan reportedly spent Rs 20 crore. It is yet another case when Pakistan only wasted its resources and precious time. 

Thursday, August 1, 2019

"Bachhey vote nahi dete ...," says Smriti while pushing POCSO Bill


New Delhi, Aug 1  Union Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani on Thursday said the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Amendment Bill passed by Parliament may not be aimed at 'vote bank politics' as the children do not votes but the new legislation will lead India march forward towards progress and prosperity.

"Bachhey vote nahi dete ....(Children do not vote)," she said in her spirited reply to the debate in the Lok Sabha.

The House of the People passed the Bill by voice vote. The Bill was approved by Rajya Sabha also in near consensus spirit on July 24.

She said most members during the debate rose above party affiliations and participated in the debate.
The new law is expected to discourage the trend of child sexual abuse by acting as a deterrent due to the strong penal provisions and it also seeks to protect the interests of vulnerable children in times of distress.



The new law entails death penalty for brutal sexual assault on children and stringent punishment including life imprisonment for using children for pornographic purposes.Union Minister Ms Irani also clarified that if the perpetrators are children, the capital punishment clause would not apply to them.

"Hence no body should presume if the perpetrator is below the age of 16 years will be hanged till death," she said.

Sources said, there has been a rise in crimes against children in the country in recent years. It is estimated that 1.6 lakh cases of child abuse are pending in 31 states and union territories (UTs).
As per official data, about 12,609 rape cases were registered under the POCSO this year.
During the debate, Speaker Om Birla also sought to compliment the Minister for piloting the draft law - which was appreciated by several opposition lawmakers.

"Sara sadan apke sath hae (Entire House is with you)," Mr Birla remarked.

Among others BSP member Kunwar Danish Ali and NCP MP Supriya Sule also backed the Bill.
So did Trinamool Congress member Shatabdi Roy and JD(U) member Rajiv Ranjan Singh.
JD(U) member from Munger said, quoting a study, that while 18,960 cases were reported formally in 2006 on sexual harassment on children, by 2016 the number shot up to over 1,06,000 with one child subjected to the trauma  every 15 minutes.

"Apparently nobody is safe. Not even at home, the child faces these problems at school and market place too," Mr Singh said.

However, there was clash in the House after Congress member from Alathur in Kerala, Ramya Haridas made reference to the Unnao rape case.

Kirron Kher of BJP also took exception to her remarks.

In her response to the debate, Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani made it clear that the law on rape and sexual assault makes no exception for state legislators and elected Members of Parliament also.

"...kahin yeh nahi bola, MP aur MLA achhuta rahega (...Nowhere it is said elected state legislators and MPs are exempted from the law of the land)," Union Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani said.

BJP lawmaker Nishikant Dubey slammed the ivory tower NGO activists and other self-styled social workers who over the years took to streets with candle lit processions but did little in terms of concrete actions against the offenders of sexual child abuse.
Participating in the debate on Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Bill, the vocal lawmaker from Godda constituency in Jharkhand said - time has come for action against such defaulters and it goes to the credit of the Modi government that an effective Bill has been brought in.


"Tum chhor do rasm mom battiyon jalane ki, ab baari hae darinde ko jalane ki (Time to give up the ceremony of lighting candles, it is time to take actions against the offenders)," Mr Dubey said.


Parl passes bill providing death penalty for aggravated sexual attack on children


New Delhi, Aug 1 In a landmark legislative measure, Parliament on Thursday gave nod to The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Amendment Bill that entails death penalty for brutal sexual assault on children and stringent punishment including life imprisonment for using children for pornographic purposes.
The Bill piloted by the Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani got immense support in the Lok Sabha with members cutting across party lines backing the government to impose death penalty for brutal sexual assault on children and take other aggressive measures to bring down the trend of child sexual abuse.

The House of the People passed the Bill by voice vote. The Bill was approved by Rajya Sabha also in near consensus spirit on July 24.Supporting the draft law among others, NCP member Supriya Sule said while the Minister needs to be complimented for taking initiatives in bringing the new Bill, the central government should also take measures to curb eve teasing.Another opposition member Kunwar Danish Ali (BSP) - also supported the Bill - saying: "As an issue, I am against capital punishment, but if the norm of death penalty remains, the issue of sexual abuse on children is one area, I will support".NDA ally JD(U) also backed the Bill. There has been an alarming 500 per cent increase in the episodes of sexual harassment of children in India between 2006 and 2016, Rajiv Ranjan Singh of JD(U) said.


JD(U) member from Munger said, quoting a study, that while 18,960 cases were reported formally in 2006 on sexual harassment on children, by 2016 the number shot up to over 1,06,000 with one child subjected to the trauma  every 15 minutes."Apparently nobody is safe. Not even at home, the child faces these problems at school and market place too," Mr Singh said.

However, there was clash in the House after Congress member from Alathur        in Kerala, Ramya Haridas made reference to the Unnao rape case.Kirron Kher of BJP also took exception to her remarks.
In her response to the debate, Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani made it clear that the law on rape and sexual assault makes no exception for state legislators and elected Members of Parliament also.
"...kahin yeh nahi bola, MP aur MLA achhuta rahega (...Nowhere it is said elected state legislators and MPs are exempted from the law of the land)," Union Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani said.

The new law is expected to discourage the trend of child sexual abuse by acting as a deterrent due to the strong penal provisions and it also seeks to protect the interests of vulnerable children in times of distress.

Sources said, there has been a rise in crimes against children in the country in recent years. It is estimated that 1.6 lakh cases of child abuse are pending in 31 states and union territories (UTs).


Five-fold spike in 2006-2016 in cases of sexual harassment of children: JD(U)
New Delhi, Aug 1 There has been an alarming 500 per cent increase in the episodes of sexual harassment of children in India between 2006 and 2016, Janata Dal (United)' s Rajiv Ranjan Singh said in Lok Sabha on Thursday.Participating in the debate on Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Bill, JD(U) member the Munger MP said, quoting a study, that while 18,960 cases were reported formally in 2006 on sexual harassment on children, by 2016 the number shot up to over 1,06,000 with one child subjected to the trauma  every 15 minutes.


"Apparently nobody is safe. Not even at home, the child faces these problems at school and market place too," Mr Singh said. The JD (U), he added, would back the new draft law brought by the Ministry of Women and Child Development.


Shiv Sena's Vinayak Raut expressed concern on the rise in number of child pornography and maintained it is a matter of concern that there has been a spike in such cases in the Capital.In this context, the Ratnagiri-Sindhudurg representative praised the measures taken by the Maharashtra government to check child pornography.Kotha Prabhakar Reddy of Telangana Rashtra Samiti also spoke.

BJP MP Dubey slams 'candle lighting' activists vis-a-vis child abuse


New Delhi, Aug 1 BJP lawmaker Nishikant Dubey on Thursday slammed the ivory tower NGO activists and other self styled social workers who over the years took to streets with candle lit processions but did little in terms of concrete actions against the offenders of sexual child abuse.

Participating in the debate on Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Bill, the vocal lawmaker from Godda constituency in Jharkhand said - time has come for action against such defaulters and it goes to the credit of the Modi government that an effective Bill has been brought in.

"Tum chhor do rasm mom battiyon jalane ki, ab baari hae darinde ko jalane ki (Time to give up the ceremony of lighting candles, it is time to take actions against the offenders)," Mr Dubey said.

In this context, he said the illustrious Nelson Mandela used to say that the soul of any society or country lives in its children and thus it is imperative that adequate steps ought to be taken to safe guard children from such abuses.

While he said he is against the idea of comparing India with any western country, at the same time it ought to be mentioned that in the US there are very strict laws for protecting child rights. "Even parents can be booked merely for scolding or slapping a child ....," he said.

"Our society is different...," he remarked but maintained that at the same time "we ought to note that even in India we have been facing these instances of child abuse sexually for long time".

He said the Modi government and the Women and Child Development Minister Smriti Irani thus ought to be complimented for bringing the clause of death penalty. "The government has shown the political will," he said.

The BJP lawmaker said in the contemporary setting children and even school going students have developed the habits of going to lavish parties, smoking and drinking but there is 'no control or mechanism of putting any restriction' on these.

Wednesday, July 31, 2019

West Delhi MP sparks row with demand for SIT for action on Masjids on 'Govt land'


Actions to be taken against those not vacating 'designated accommodation': Hardeep Puri


New Delhi, Jul 31 The government on Wednesday asserted that firm actions will be taken against people "no matter who they are" and are continuing not to vacate the government bungalows allocated to them under 'designation accommodation' scheme.




"Designated accommodation is only meant for certain specified people. If certain families choose to keep on to a house or certain officials do it, I will not subscribe to that. I assure the House that if some people are utilizing loopholes in the system to do that, we will move against those people, no matter who they are, whether officials or Members of Parliament," Urban Development and Housing Minister Hardeep Singh Puri said in Lok Sabha during the debate on The Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Amendment Bill.




He said such exemplary actions were required as this is what is required to ensure "equity and justice".



"So, I am very clear that that will be done," he said in reply to questions from BJP member Rajiv Pratap Rudy.


The Bill was later passed by voice vote.




Mr Puri also said he will send "written replies" to all the questions raised during the debate when several members spoke on various issues related to eviction of the government residential buildings.



"If you want, I will even circulate them because I think we have a good story to tell them; and also,
it is in the interest of full disclosure and transparency that what we are saying should be made known to all. I will be sending the replies in writing as well," Mr Puri asserted.


Among others, BJP lawmaker Parvesh Sahib Singh Verma said some people have developed a habit of not vacating government bungalows.
In this context, he sought to put the blame on Congress President Rahul Gandhi and his family members for 'occupying big bungalows'.


Though Mr Verma did not take any names, his words implied that he meant Congress president Rahul Gandhi and his family members.


In contrast amid objections from some Congress members, the West Delhi lawmaker said several BJP leaders including the likes of Arun Jaitley, Sushma Swaraj, Shivraj Singh Chouhan and even Late Sahib Singh Verma (the lawmaker's father) had vacated their houses soon after they ceased to be authorized occupants.
"Even former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's family members had vacated the official residence within four weeks of his death," Mr Verma said.



Mr Rudy said former Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan also has vacated her designated residence allocated to the presiding officer of the Lower House.



West Delhi lawmaker Verma also demanded that a Special Investigation Team - SIT - be set up to take appropriate actions against mosques, graveyards and 'Mazars' those are erected on government land without proper authorisation.

New Delhi, Jul 31West Delhi BJP lawmaker Parvesh Sahib Singh Verma on Wednesday demanded that a Special Investigation Team - SIT - be set up to take appropriate actions against mosques, graveyards and 'Mazars' those are erected on government land without proper authorisation.

Participating in the debate on The Public Premises Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants Amendment Bill, Mr Verma said "Such things can happen only in our country...We have a culture of appeasement politics" - and said government needs to take actions against "illegal" construction of mosques, Mazaras and graveyards.

Amid strong protest from opposition members, the lawmaker said "even in my constituency and in Delhi, there are at least 500 such places where lands belonging to DDA, Delhi government and civic bodies have been encroached and there are illegal Masjids and graveyards.


"In this context, I have written to Delhi Lt Governor with a list of 54 such spots and sought actions. When I talk to other Members also, they say it is happening all over the country," Mr Verma remarked.

He said Union Urban Development and Housing Minister Hardeep Puri should immediately set up a SIT and "I will provide you information about encroachment on land under your ministry and under DDA".

Mr Verma, son of former Delhi Chief Minister Sahib Singh Verma, also said "Whenever I raise these issues, people and even media friends ask whether I will also talk about temples and Gurudwaras".

"My answer is I do raise similar questions....You give me a list of temples and Gurudwaras. If necessary take actions," he said.

Amid repeated objections from opposition members, Rajendra Agrawal, who was on the chair, said only what is being said by Mr Verma will go on record.

"When you get chance, you will get chance to make your point," Mr Agrawal told opposition members.

But in last five years, he has not found a single spot (in his constituency) where there is case of encroachment of land for construction of temples and Gurudwaras, Mr Verma said.

"These government lands could be made use for making hospitals and schools," he said.


Saugata Roy of Trinamool Congress said some of the remarks from the BJP member were not in proper tone and spirit.

"Such comments are Muslim bashing.....," Mr Roy said such remarks in House are "against the Constitution of India".

Mr Agrawal, who was on the chair, remarked he will take a closer look at the records of the speech.
and whatever objectionable will be 'expunged'.

MPs clash in LS during debate on Bill that seeks earlier vacation of Govt bungalows


New Delhi, Jul 31  The Lok Sabha on Wednesday took up a bill with the government and principal opposition Congress agreeing initially that it should be passed at the earliest to facilitate vacation of government residential buildings and bungalows occupied by unauthorised occupants.


However, the members clashed during the debate on The Public Premises Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants Amendment Bill, 2019 when BJP lawmaker Parvesh Sahib Singh Verma referred to 'three members' of a family occupying government residential buildings.


Without naming anyone, his words definitely meant Congress president Rahul Gandhi and his family members.

The BJP MP also demanded government should take appropriate actions against mosques, graveyards and 'Mazars' those are erected on government land without proper papers.


Agreeing with Urban Development and Housing Minister Hardeep Singh Puri that the Bill concerned should be approved of by the House without much debate, Congress floor leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said - "I do not find any substantiate argument to oppose it".


Earlier, Mr Puri said the government has been "very tolerant" to those who have not vacated the houses and that includes former Members of Parliament also.

"These people need to be encouraged, the word encouraged within quotes," Mr Puri said.

Mr Puri lamented that people under various categories "even after they cease to be authorized occupant" make delay in vacating the government allocated residential buildings.

Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, however, narrated his own experience and said the estate officers should not be authorized with unbridled power to decide on the disputes.

However, BJP lawmaker Parvesh Sahib Singh Verma said some people have developed a habit of not vacating government bungalows.

In this context, he sought to put the blame on Congress President Rahul Gandhi and his family members for 'occupying big bungalows'.

In contrast amid objections from some Congress members, the West Delhi lawmaker said several BJP leaders including the likes of Arun Jaitley, Sushma Swaraj, Shivraj Singh Chouhan and even Late Sahib Singh Verma (the lawmaker's father) had vacated their houses soon after they ceased to be authorized occupants.

"Even former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's family members had vacated the official residence within four weeks of his death," Mr Verma said.

Tuesday, July 30, 2019

Archaic, medieval practice finally confined to dustbin of history: PM on Triple Talaq Bill passage

A known Modi government baiter and Indepndent MP KTS Tulsi was not present in the Upper House even though he had given notices to move amendments to Triple Talaq Bill piloted by the Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad

NCP lawmakers Sharad Pawar and Praful Patel gave the crucial proceedings a miss. Oscar Fernandes and four other Congress MPs were absent.

Two Samajwadi Party MPs, Ram Jethmalani of the RJD, two Trinamool Congress MPs and one Telugu Desam Party (TDP) also skipped voting. 



PM Narendra Modi: 


An archaic and medieval practice has finally been confined to the dustbin of history!

Parliament abolishes Triple Talaq and corrects a historical wrong done to Muslim women. This is a victory of gender justice and will further equality in society.
India rejoices today!

-This is an occasion to salute the remarkable courage of those Muslim women who have suffered great wrongs just due to the practice of Triple Talaq.
The abolition of Triple Talaq will contribute to women empowerment and give women the dignity they deserve in our society.

I thank all parties and MPs who have supported the passage of The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Bill, 2019 in both Houses of Parliament. They have risen to the occasion and this step of theirs will forever be remembered in India’s history.


Narendra Modi
@narendramodi
·
तीन तलाक बिल का पास होना महिला सशक्तिकरण की दिशा में एक बहुत बड़ा कदम है। तुष्टिकरण के नाम पर देश की करोड़ों माताओं-बहनों को उनके अधिकार से वंचित रखने का पाप किया गया। मुझे इस बात का गर्व है कि मुस्लिम महिलाओं को उनका हक देने का गौरव हमारी सरकार को प्राप्त हुआ है।


पूरे देश के लिए आज एक ऐतिहासिक दिन है। आज करोड़ों मुस्लिम माताओं-बहनों की जीत हुई है और उन्हें सम्मान से जीने का हक मिला है। सदियों से तीन तलाक की कुप्रथा से पीड़ित मुस्लिम महिलाओं को आज न्याय मिला है। इस ऐतिहासिक मौके पर मैं सभी सांसदों का आभार व्यक्त करता हूं। - Narendra Modi

Amit Shah also tweets:

Today is a great day for India’s democracy.

I congratulate PM 
Narendra modi
 ji for fulfilling his commitment and ensuring a law to ban Triple Talaq, which will free Muslim women from the curse of this regressive practice. I thank all parties who supported this historic bill.


Shah Bano

Shah Bano of 1986 fame !! 'Woman of the week'
--- as Triple Talaq Bill gets Parliament nod finally 
- four Congress MPs abstain !!

Gamechangers  
TRS 6 TDP 2 AIADMK 11
JDU 6 BSP 4 
help modi #RajyaSabha

Number Management: A tribute to Amit Shah's politics


Govt floor managers managed BJD's seven members.  NDA ally JD- U's six  MPs and AIADMK 11 members walked out.
The ruling NDA had 107 members in the 242-member Rajya Sabha.

Passing amendment to the Right To Information (RTI) Act last week despite lacking numbers gave confidence to the ruling side!


Modi government scored a major political victory as morally opposition parties tried to play up the Triple Talaq Bill as an issue of BJP's politicisation agenda!
\
Finally, after Lok Sabha approved The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Bill for third time last week, Rajya Sabha gave its nod 99 members voting in favour and 84 of them voting against.



The bill will replace an ordinance promulgated on February 21 to the same effect.

Rajya Sabha on July 30, 2019 also rejected an opposition sponsored motions to send the bill to a Select Committee of the House and for making triple talaq a civil offence with 100 votes against it as compared to 84 in favour.

"I am a minister of Narendra Modi government and not Rajiv Gandhi government," Ravi Shankar Prasad said citing the Shah Bano case of 1986.


"Should I leave them (Muslim women) crying and sobbing on the foothpaths," Prasad said adding the government will not hesitate to stand by them and do justice to them.

"When Muslim world is trying to reform, why can't a democracy do the same".


Just before the voting, Ghulam Nabi Azad said the opposition has been 'forced' to vote against the bill.

The triple talaq bill makes declaration of talaq-e-biddat or pronouncing talaq three times in spoken, written or through SMS or WhatsApp or any other electronic chat in one sitting illegal.

Mr Azad and other opposition leaders said there was a move to "finish" one particular religion.
"......cat has come out of the bag," said Azad adding 
it is not just Muslim women, but also Hindu, Christian and Jain women who need empowerment.


Taking a dig at Narendra Modi, senior Congress leader Digvijaya Singh: said: "Would you ask the pradhan sevak to help pradhan sevika to get justice (Kya aap pradhan sevak se kahenge ki wo pradhan sevika ko nayay dilaye)." 

-

Sunday, July 28, 2019

CUT ABOVE THE REST SPOKESPERSON : Jaipal Reddy - no glib talker, just a master spokesperson


IN JAIPAL REDDY'S DEATH, INDIAN POLITICAL SPACE HAS LOST A GOOD SPOKESPERSON -





Though he became a Congressman at a later stage and took part many debates cornering stalwarts such as Atal Bihari Vajpayee, the Prime Minister of the time, Late Reddy would be perhaps best remembered for his criticism of Arun Shourie, then Editor of a powerful newspaper.

In response Shourie’s article that claimed that V P Singh had 'approved' of removing of bricks from Ayodhya, displaying the irreplaceable gift-of-the-gab, Jaipal Reddy had said, “After excelling in journalism; Mr Shourie is now trying to excel in fiction writing”. 


Unlike today’s generation of suave and ambitious individuals, the role of spokespersons for political parties has come a full circle. But unlike the era of V N Gadgil (Congress) and K L Sharma (BJP), both deceased, there is a perceptible change in the functioning of politicians to work as party’s face before the media.

“One should have political acumen with good grasp on various issues?,” thus spoke the late Gadgil on his role and did not hesitate to describe himself as “a learned fool” – to keep the humour line open.

K L Sharma, who pioneered BJP’s media cell, along with J P Mathur, made it a point to interact informally with reporters even during late hours.
S Jaipal Reddy, who died on July 28, had excelled as spokesman for Janata Dal, used read at least 20
newspapers every morning preparing for the “afternoon onslaught” and the results
were always forthcoming.

Compared to this, a Congress spokesman in 2005 surprised scribes with feigning ignorance on which Minister was served with non-bailable warrant. “Congress or Prime Minister is second to none in upholding public accountability,” the leader had said.

Such rhetoric if part of the strategy serves no purpose for the party interest. Similar was the case when weeks after weeks stories were being taken merely on speculation – and often planted by Congress spokespersons themselves – that cabinet expansion was on cards.

Actually all key Congress media managers from Anand Sharma to Ambika Soni were seen among hopefuls.

In BJP, all blue-eyed-boys and girls (especially Sushma Swaraj) of Advan-Vajpayee era were only ambitious lot.

In later stage, some people were lucky - Nirmala Sitharaman, a former spokesperson is Prime Minister Narendra Modi's 'a key trusted aide'. She became first woman Defence Minister and also first woman Finance Minister.


Sushma, Nirmala - Talented but Lucky Two




The death of S Jaipal Reddy leaves a big vacuum in the political space and only highlights the great transition one sees among the political spokespersons who unlike the present generation players perfectly knew the art of giving out the knockout punch without being impolite and vulgar.
Certainly, the likes of Jaipal Reddy, who breathed last on Sunday, and veteran spokespersons of that era K L Sharma and V N Gadgil were not necessarily the camera-savvy glib talkers.

Late S Jaipal Reddy would be best remembered for his role as a spokesman for Janata Dal when India had plunged into a political whirlpool of coalition games in the corridors of power.
During those days and late evening briefings, Late Reddy would sport that infectious smile and would brief journalists sincerely and frankly.
"As spokesman of Janata Dal, I used to ready 20 newspapers in the morning preparing to field questions," Reddy had later said in 2010.

"One ought to have the political acumen....," he also had said on virtues required to be a good spokesman.
ON N T Rama Rao's death, Jaipal Reddy was again at his best with minimum words: "National Front is orphan today". N T R was the chairman of National Front that had parties such as Janata Dal, AGP, DMK and TDP as the key constituents.



Prominent editor of his time, Mr Shourie was also sacked by the newspaper for that controversial article.
The quote from Jaipal on Arun Shourie had said it all !

There was no spewing personal vitriol - no heart burning either.
Thus, senior journalists who covered Jaipal Reddy or the likes of V N Gadgil, another veteran spokesman of the Congress party in early 1990s, have good reasons to ponder at Reddy's death - when was the last time, media had such memorable quotes from the new generation political spokespersons.


There were few other occasions when Jaipal Reddy displayed his talent making use of powerful phrases and showing the faultline in the rivals camp.

In December 2000, the Lok Sabha had taken up a detailed debate on the Babri Masjid demolition.
The motion, moved under Rule 184 that entails voting had said - "This House calls upon Prime Minister (Vajpayee) to drop three ministers (L K Advani, M M Joshi and Uma Bharati)....for their involvement in demolition of Babri Masjid".

Late Reddy, then a Congress lawmaker initiated the debate attacking PM Vajpayee and said - Vajpayeeji had mounted the 'chauvanist Hindutva tiger' and completed his pilgrimage from "hypocrisy to theocracy".

Terming the demolition of the Masjid at Ayodhya a 'colossal crime', Jaipal Reddy had said - "Prime Minister is appearing neutral in a moral crisis of epic magnitude".

No pressure or influence can decide India's stance on national security: PM Modi



New Delhi, Jul 27 Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday made it categorically clear that as far as national security is concerned vis-a-vis dealing with terror menace and related challenges including from overseas forces, his government will not allow any 'pressure or influence' to decide its strategy.

blogger 

"Rashtriya suraksha ke liye na kisi ke dabao mein, na pravao mein kaam hooga (On national security, no external pressure or influence can work)," Prime Minister said.


Addressing a grand function organised to mark 20th anniversary of Kargil Vijay Diwas in presence of top military and civil officials, Mr Modi said at the same time there will not be any issue of funds and arms shortage for the forces.

He paid rich tributes to valiant Indian soldiers who fought steadfastly during the Kargil Conflict of 1999 and lashed out at Pakistan for its aggressive policies while pointing out to the global community that India has never adopted such strategies.

"Our history is a witness by itself that India has never been an aggressive country. We always cherished peaceful measures in the larger interest of humankind. Our country has always remained committed to that policy," the Prime Minister said.

Referring to the Kargil Conflict of 1999, he said "previously international community had maintained
a blind eyes approach towards our neighbour" - but it was the Kargil Conflict that exposed them.

"Pakistan had experimented with Kargil, because they thought international community will come in and a new line of border - "nayi rekha" - will be created. But they did not presume that India will retaliate in the manner it was done," Prime Minister said.

Addressing a function organsied to mark the 20th Anniversary of the Kargil Vijay Diwas, Mr Modi said
the victory also symbolises the victory of the sense of duty of every Indian.

He lashed out at Pakistan for its proxy war vis-a-vis terror menace and maintained that "those who believe in human rights must stand with the armed forces to fight the terror menace".

Mr Modi said that under the leadership of the then Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Pakistan was given a befitting response during the Kargil conflict.

"Pakistan shuru se hi Kashmir ko lekar chhal karta raha (From very beginning, Pakistan has been pursuing its well known policy of duplicity and double standards)," Mr Modi said.

He said Islamabad had tried the same games in 1947, 1965 and 1971 as well, "but in 1999 during Kargil conflict, their tricks were exposed".

Lauding the professional approach of Indian armed forces, he said the image of our soldiers at home is about providing national security, "and at the overseas and international level, our forces have an image of a credible peace keeping force".

In this context, he said Israeli leaders often refer to the valiant peace works carried out by Indian armed forces as part of the peace keeping force in that region.

This was the first time the Prime Minister has made an address on the occasion of Kargil Vijay Diwas.

The genesis of the conflict lay in Pakistani intruders and regular Pakistan army personnel crossing over the Line of Control (LoC) and occupied strategic heights.

In the ultimate, the Pakistani forces and intruders were given a befitting reply and chased out of Indian boundaries.

Mr Modi reminded that though the forces in India are capable of fighting the conventional war, in modern times, things have changed.

"Proxy war has become an order of the day and humanity is a victim of the same....In this, terrorism is posing a global challenge to entire human race," he said and underlined that "some forces are trying to draw political mileage by such approaches".

"Some people are encouraging terrorism....And thus, today it is high time that all those who believe in human rights must stand with the armed forces to fight the terror menace".

The three-hour programme held at capital's spacious Indira Gandhi Indoor Stadium had star singer Mohit Chauhan presenting patriotic songs.

The Shillong Chamber Choir also performed and an eight-minute film on the Kargil War was also screened.


Defence Minister Rajnath Singh was also present on the occasion besides the three services chiefs.


People of J&K want development, no 'sinister plans' can succeed, asserts PM Modi


New Delhi, Jul 28 Amid reports that the centre could deploy 100 additional companies of para military forces in Jammu and Kashmir, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday said people of the militancy-hit state are more than keen to join development mainstream and that those creating hurdles to peace and progress will never succeed in their 'sinister plans'.


"A new resolve, a new fervor and grand results..... Our brothers and sisters in Kashmir want Good Governance and proves the dictum that the power of development is stronger than the might of bullets and bombs. It is clear that those who wish to spread hatred en route to development, pose hurdles will never succeed in their sinister plans," Prime Minister said in his monthly radio broadcast Mann-Ki-Baat through All India Radio.


Mr Modi made the remarks in reference to a missive from Shopian-based Bhai Muhammad Aslam, who had said that he likes to listen to Mann-Ki-Baat programme and he also mentioned at length about the 'community mobilisation' programme 'Back to Village' launched in the state.

"Under this programme in the state, top officials for the first time reached the villages," Prime Minister said.


"The people of Kashmir are eager to join the national main stream, their enthusiasm is reflected in the mechanism of this programme. For the first time, senior officials reached the villages, directly, even those officials who had never visited a village were available to the villagers at their doorsteps, to judge for themselves to gauge the obstacles in the path of progress," Mr Modi said.


This week long programme encompassing about 4500 panchayats witnessed the government  officials briefing the villagers about the schemes and programmes implemented by the government and also inquired whether these facilities were available to them or not.
Prime Minister said that during the special outreach prgrammes, issues related to - imparting 'more powers' to the Panchayats, how to increase their income and how the panchayats can bring changes in people's lives vis-a-vis literacy, sex ratio, health, hygiene, water conservation and senior citizen’s concerns were some of the topics those were discussed at length.

The reports that the centre could deploy additional forces have sparked off strong reactions from state leaders.

"Centre’s decision to deploy additional 10,000 troops to the valley has created fear psychosis amongst  people. There is no dearth of security forces in Kashmir. J&K is a political problem which would not be solved by military means. Govt of India needs to rethink and overhaul its policy," tweeted PDP leader and former Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti.

In his radio broadcast, Prime Minister said officials in Jammu and Kashmir also reached the panchayats on the border "which live under the shadow of cross-border firing" like the sensitive hamlets in the districts of Shopian, Pulwama, Kulgam and Anantnag, without any fear.


"Some officers were so overwhelmed by the reception they received, that they decided to extend their stay up to two days in these villages. The organizing of Gram Sabhas in these villages, wherein the people participated in large numbers and chalked out schemes for themselves is something that is an extremely pleasant experience," he said adding this only shows there is a "new resolve" among the people and the government officials and thus "grand results" are on cards.

Mr Modi in his address at a grand function organised to mark 20th anniversary of Kargil Vijay Diwas in Delhi on Saturday had said in presence of top military and civil officials that as far as national security is concerned vis-a-vis dealing with terror menace and related challenges including from overseas forces, his government will not allow any 'pressure or influence' to decide its strategy.

"Rashtriya suraksha ke liye na kisi ke dabao mein, na pravao mein kaam hooga (On national security, no external pressure or influence can work)," Prime Minister has said.

Thursday, July 25, 2019

Lok Sabha debate on Triple Talaq Bill - July 25, 2019


MEENAKSHI LEKHI, BJP - New Delhi MP 


I want to tell that it is not just economic backwardness, but the backwardness of mind and thought and that needs to be corrected. The thinking that religious law is immutable is wrong. People, who think that religion will control every aspect of social life, are wrong in their thinking and this is what needs to be corrected.

“What has been your greatest difficulty in independent India?” - Nehru was asked by Frencj journalist Andrey Markus And his answer was, “To make a just society on the basis of just laws.” And not just this, he also said, “…perhaps to create a secular state in a religious country.” 

Kya yeh dikkatey Modiji ka nahi hae !! creating secular state in a religious community !

 People like Nehru and Ambedkar must be wondering at the kind of people who succeeded them, because their dream of making India as one nation, their dream of having equality amongst people seems to have been forgotten by the people. 


No area can be away from constitutional protection. That has been repeatedly given colour by the Supreme Court’s enactments and orders. Somebody was talking about Sharia courts. 

I think, Shri Premachandran mentioned that in Uttar Pradesh those courts existand must continue to exist. This has been the observation of Supreme Court inRaghunath vs. Union of India in 1994 on what the State’s role is, could there bea parallel judiciary in the country, how could a parallel judiciary exist when 25.07.2019 Dir (VP)/Rjn Uncorrected / Not for Publication 311judicial role is assigned to Judiciary under the Constitution of India; probably hechose not to quote it but I am just quoting it. The Constitution of India is aparamount document on the basis of which each person needs to be grantedprotection and laws. 

 P.K. KUNHALIKUTTY (MALAPPURAM)

IUML


As per the last census, the percentage of divorce among Muslim communities is very minimal.
No statistics establish your argument. I should bring to your notice that it is only
0.56 per cent, whereas, in other communities, it is much higher. So, what is the
reason for you to bring this Bill? Major minority community of the nation as well
as the whole country knows that it is nothing but your political agenda. Now, the
election is over and you have convincing majority, absolute majority. So, what is
the need for you to pass such a legislation in a hurry? What you are doing here
is you are going ahead with your political agenda, nothing else. That is the
reason for this discrimination. 

The hon. Minister has very skilfully argued his case. Unfortunately, that is not at all convincing for the stakeholders of this country, that is, the major minority community of India. Why
is the Government not at all bothered about that?


Sir, we are a minority party. We have supported the Sabarimala issue. We are believers and you are also believers. Shri Premachandran was talking about
that. So, why is this double standard? Why is this discrimination? Are you not
ashamed? Is it not shameful to have discrimination and make the argument so
convincingly? Any lawyer can make a bad issue a good issue. That is what I
should say to our hon. learned Minister. So, you have to withdraw this Bill. 
P. K. Kunhalikutty
Since you are having a convincing majority and the election is over, political agenda can be set aside. At least you should have a reconsideration about that and withdraw the Bill. 

N K Premachandran, RSP 

If the Government is so pertinent and significant in promulgating an Ordinance and to make a legislation so as to protect the Muslim women in the country, then, Sir, mob lynching is also there in the country. Last week also, three persons were killed by the mob and the hon. Supreme Court has already specifically directed the Government to have a legislation on it. 

Why is the Government not ready to initiate a legislation on mob lynching? I am not going into the history of this case. This is being done with a clear political motive – to target a particular community in the country and there is no doubt about it.Three Ordinances have been promulgated. 

The first Ordinance was promulgated on 19th September, 2018, the second Ordinance was promulgated on 12th January, 2019 and the third Ordinance was promulgated on 21st February, 2019. Consecutive Ordinances have been promulgated so as to ban Triple Talaq. I cannot understand what was the necessity and emergency for promulgating an Ordinance. There is no justifiable answer. 


I would like to know, what is the need for a new law on Triple Talaq when the
hon. Supreme Court’s verdict is the law of the land?

 I would like to quote one of the fundamental maxims of criminaljurisprudence, “Nullum crimen sine injuria”. That means, no person shall bepunished for an attack that does not prove to be significantly harmful to anyone.Here, Sir, after 22nd August, 2017, i.e. after the pronouncement of the Judgment,an act of Talaq-e-Bidat does not in any way harm or violate the rights of a Muslimwife unless the husband refuses to perform the conjugal responsibilities or dutiesupon him or the wife is forced to leave from the residential place of the husband.Only in these two circumstances, you can invoke it. If these two circumstancesexist, we have Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code which can be invoked andwe also have the provisions of the Protection of Women from Domestic ViolenceAct, 2005. You can very well invoke it. 

What is the necessity and need for another law? 

Blogger's New Book


Matters of marriage, divorce, succession, etc., are considered as civilwrongs.Imposing the punishment of imprisonment for three years for divorce isnot applicable to any other community. Why are you not imposing imprisonmentfor divorce in the Hindu community? Why are you not imposing imprisonment fordivorce in the Christian community? Why do you want to have it only in theMuslim community? That is why I say that this is a discrimination against theMuslim community. This is violation of Article 14, violation of Article 15, andviolation of Article 25 of the Constitution.  - Premachandran

DR. MOHAMMAD JAWED (KISHANGANJ): Congress 


Sir, I rise to oppose the introductionof this Bill. I would like to put forward few facts in this august House. The instant Triple Talaq has already been declared unconstitutional by theSupreme Court and is therefore non est. As per this Bill, a Muslim man can be jailed for upto three years along witha fine. This provision has the potential to destroy a marriage because of a falsecomplaint by a scheming relative. As per this Bill, the Magistrate will grant bail only after hearing the wife.This provision has far-reaching consequences as a man may get bail only onthe conditions imposed by the wife. This Bill is in violation of article 14 of the Constitution as it discriminatesMuslim women and women of other religions. Section 498A of IPC, DomesticViolence Act and Dowry Prohibition Act already apply to Muslims too. Therefore,there is no need of having an additional law to protect only Muslim women.


The Supreme Court, in the Triple Talaq Judgment, nowhere said that TripleTalaq should be a criminally punishable offence.


We have to understand what this Government wants to do through this
Bill. Imprisonment, not for abandoning his wife but merely for chanting ‘Talaq’
three times, for three years. Considering the punishment for causing death by
negligence, which is imprisonment of only up to two years, I think, the present
one is much more than what it deserves. This is more than rioting as well. This
Bill is laid with a political intention to harass the Muslim community and to portray
Islam, the religion of peace and equality, in bad light. 

Putin says - Europe was in a “humiliating decline” and anti-Russian sanctions backfired" :::::::: “We should eliminate trade and investment barriers... and also promote balanced development,” says Chinese President :::::

US President Trump Lands in Shenzhen Ahead of Key Talks With Chinese and Russian Leaders Chinese president Xi Jinping opened the Apec CEO su...