Thursday, December 4, 2025

Govt counters Rahul Gandhi's "charge" that he was not allowed to meet Russian President Putin :::: "It is up to visiting delegation to organise meetings outside Govt"

On Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi's allegations that the government is not following the tradition of allowing foreign dignitaries to meet the LoP,  Govt Sources said - 


 "During a visit, MEA organises meetings for the incoming dignitary with Government officials and Government bodies. 

It is up to the visiting delegation to organise meetings outside the Government.







Since 9th June 2024, the following leaders have met the Leader of the opposition, Rahul Gandhi --

 

* Former Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina on 10 June, 2024 


** Prime Minister of Vietnam Pham Minh Ching on 1 Aug 2024 


** Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim of Malaysia on 21 August 2024 


++ Prime Minister of Mauritius Navinchandra Ramgoolam on 16 September 2025 and 


** Prime Minister of New Zealand Christopher Luxon on 8 March 2025."






Reshaping global geopolitics ..... Putin to join Narendra Modi for intense discussions in Delhi :::: Whatever happens next, the eyes of the world will remain on Putin’s visit to India

Though the West continued to pressure India to distance itself from Moscow, New Delhi refused. Russia, for its part, has continued to back India.


All these happening when China is also trying to deepen its grip over Eurasia. 


For Russia, weapons sales to India are another priority and have been since Soviet times. India plans to purchase state-of-the-art Russian fighter jets and air defence systems.  Russia, hit by a labour shortage, also sees India as a valuable source of skilled workers.

There's geopolitics. 


The Kremlin enjoys demonstrating that Western efforts to isolate it over the war in Ukraine have failed. Flying to India and meeting Prime Minister Modi is one way of doing that.


So is travelling to China and holding talks with Xi Jinping, as Putin did three months ago. He met Modi on the same trip. 

The image of the Putin, Xi Jinping and India smiling and chatting together sent a clear message that, despite the war in Ukraine, Moscow has powerful allies who support the concept of a "multi-polar world".


Russia has said that every independent nation should be free to choose its own trading partner. Indeed, Putin just last month praised India’s decision to resist the West’s entreaties not to buy Russian crude as “self-reliant and dignified”. 


New Delhi too has pointed to the hypocrisy of the West, particularly America, which continues to have its own dealings with Russia in the aftermath of the Ukraine war.





PM Narendra Modi - despite coming under intense pressure from Western governments to criticise Russia over its war in Ukraine, has always maintained that dialogue was the only way to resolve the conflict.


This was India's "strategic autonomy" at play – with Modi occupying a particular place in the geopolitical order where he held close ties with Moscow while maintaining his relationship with the West at the same time. That worked - until Donald Trump returned to the White House in 2025.

India-US ties have hit an all-time low in recent months as the two countries have failed to resolve the tariff deadlock.



For both Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Putin, the significance of the meeting may also be beyond trade figures or defence contracts. 


A message to the world, that despite turbulence, the old Moscow-Delhi axis still holds considerable value and weight.

The visit comes at a time when the world’s geopolitical compass is spinning fast and furiously, says 'First Post'.

The US tightening sanctions against Moscow, 

China trying to deepen its grip over Eurasia and 

India positioning itself as the swing state in an increasingly bipolar order. 





"I think the Kremlin is sure that the West, including Europe, totally failed," believes Novaya Gazeta columnist Andrei Kolesnikov.


"We are not isolated, because we have connections to Asia and the Global South. Economically, this is the future. In that sense Russia returned as the main actor in these parts of the globe, like the Soviet Union. But even the Soviet Union had special channels and connections to the US, West Germany and France. It had a multi-vector policy.


"But now we are totally isolated from Europe. This is unprecedented. Our philosophers always said that Russia was a part of Europe. Now we're not. This is a big failure and a big loss. I'm sure that part of Russia's political and entrepreneurial class is dreaming of returning to Europe and of doing business not only with China and India."  This week, though, expect to hear about Russia-India friendship, trade deals and increased economic cooperation between Moscow and Delhi.





"It wasn’t pre-planned. We stepped outside, my car was there....Just two friends in a car" -- Russian Prez Putin on his Sept 1 viral carpool with PM Narendra Modi

As Vladimir Putin and Prime Minister Narendra Modi continue to strengthen the decades-long relationship between the two countries, events in India will be closely watched by the United States.


Regular Soviet supplies and licensed production of aircraft, tanks, submarines and artillery systems through the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s made Russia central to India’s military ecosystem. Training, maintenance and doctrine became intertwined.


Even today, it is estimated that 70 to 80 per cent of Indian hardware when it comes to arms and ammunition comes from Russia. 


India relies on several Russian-made weapons systems including the Su-30MKI fighters, T-90 and T-72 main battle tanks, BMP-2 infantry fighting vehicles, S-400 Triumf, INS Vikramaditya aircraft carrier and the Chakra II nuclear submarine.





This handout photograph released by the Indian Air Force on May 22, 2019 and taken at an undisclosed location in 2017 shows a BrahMos air to surface cruise missile being launched from a Sukhoi Su-30MKI fighter aircraft. File Photo/Handout/Indian Air Force/AFP  (First Post) 




Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal said: "Our PM Narendra Modi had captured the very soul of our relationship with Russia when he said, 'On hearing the word Russia, the first word that comes to the mind of every Indian is 'India's sukh-dukh ka saathi'." 

It translates to India's companion and friend in good and bad times."  


MoS Defence Sanjay Seth on Dec 4, Thursday received Defence Minister of Russia Andrei Belousov at Air Force Station, Palam in New Delhi. 


Chief of Defence Staff General Anil Chauhan was also present.


The Russian Defence Minister will co-chair the 22nd India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission on Military & Military Technical Cooperation ministerial meeting with Raksha Mantri Rajnath Singh at Manekshaw Centre.






In an interview with 'India Today TV', the Russian leader went on to say that during the SCO Summit earlier this year, they mostly spoke about the summit's agenda. 

"It wasn’t pre-planned. We stepped outside, my car was there, and I suggested that we ride together. It wasn’t some elaborate orchestration, we simply got into the car as two friends."  "We talked throughout the drive; there’s always something to discuss. We even sat inside the car for quite some time afterward," he added.


At the time, that is on Sept 1, PM Modi had posted a photo on X of the rare carpool, with the caption, “After the proceedings at the SCO Summit venue, President Putin and I travelled together to the venue of our bilateral meeting. Conversations with him are always insightful."







Putin’s trip to India comes as the shadow of Ukraine continues to hang over the world. It also comes after high-level talks between the United States and Russia over Ukraine failed to deliver a breakthrough. Trump, remember, had vowed to end Ukraine within 24 hours of returning to the White House.  




Despite US President Donald Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff and son-in-law Jared Kushner meeting with Putin and the Kremlin on Tuesday, there was no forward progress on bringing peace to Ukraine.











Some memory references:


Jawaharlal Nehru’s 1955 and 1961 visits to the USSR were building blocks of the relationship. 

The Soviets backed India’s industrialisation drive at a time when few others were willing to invest political capital in India’s development.  


Indira Gandhi era and the treaty 


The Indo–Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation signed by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1971 brought the relationship into a new stratosphere.


As India and Pakistan clashed over East Pakistan — soon to become Bangladesh — global alignments hardened. 

The Nixon administration tilted sharply towards Pakistan, deploying the Seventh Fleet’s Task Force 74 to the Bay of Bengal. Britain moved the HMS Eagle into the region. 


India’s recognition of Bangladesh raised the stakes even further.  



The Soviet Union stepped in. It deployed its own naval assets, including nuclear submarines, signalling that any intervention by outside powers would be met with consequences. And at the UN Security Council, Moscow repeatedly vetoed ceasefire resolutions pushed by the US and UK, buying India the diplomatic space it needed. Days later, Pakistani forces surrendered in Dhaka.



Migration to urban centers for opportunities continues !!! India’s boom continues .... but it's "uneven" ::: Rural households see little of glittering growth :::: Why a disconnect between where people work and where wealth is created ??


India's growth is at a crossroads. Rural households, reliant on the vagaries of monsoons and market prices, see little of the glittering growth. India’s boom continues to be uneven, and its most enduring economic imbalance remains the disconnect between where people work and where wealth is created.  


The rural-urban divide in India's growth story is characterized by disparities in income, employment, and access to services, although some indicators suggest a narrowing gap in consumption patterns, particularly for the poorest segments. 

The growth has historically favored urban areas, creating an imbalance with rural areas suffering from lower agricultural productivity and limited access to quality education and healthcare. 

Migration to urban centers for better opportunities continues.






Consumption growth in rural areas is sometimes outpacing urban areas, indicating a complex and evolving economic landscape. 



Agriculture lags, forcing policymakers to confront the rural-urban divide and rising state debt. On the other hand, Manufacturing and Services see north bound graph. For many families, analysts say daily life remains a juggling act: paying for fertilisers, diesel for pumps, seeds and electricity.

But what they get in return is - crop prices fluctuation. 


 Urban consumption and discretionary spending drove much of the domestic economy, lifting Private Final Consumption Expenditure (PFCE) nearly 8 per cent in the quarter. 

From the vantage point of Mumbai’s highrises, Bengaluru’s tech corridors and Gurugram’s financial hubs, India seems unstoppable.


Yet, venture just a few hundred kilometres into the countryside and the story is markedly different. Agriculture, forestry and fishing, the sectors that still employ nearly half of India’s working population, are barely keeping pace. The Union ministry of statistics and programme implementation (MoSPI) records a mere 3.5 per cent growth in Q2 FY 2025-26 for these sectors, almost unchanged from Q1.


There is structural fault line that should worry the policy makers especially PM Narendra Modi, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and also Union Agriculture minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan. 






FMCG companies, such as Hindustan Unilever and Dabur, report flat or even negative volume growth in villages.

But double-digit gains in cities. 

The consumption story mirrors the divide: growth is strong, but not evenly shared.


Since the 1991 liberalisation, India has transformed. 


The economy has expanded at an average 6.8 per cent per year, but agriculture has grown at just 3.2 per cent. 


During phases of high growth, between 2003-08, while the GDP rose 8.8 per cent, what was not a real satisfactory story was  agriculture growth was 3.7 per cent.


Now see the comparison in the period 2016-19, agriculture growth was only 2.9 per cent but the GDP was 7.1 per cent.


Even during the post-Covid rebound from FY2022 to FY2025, the economy grew cumulatively 21.3 per cent while agriculture added just 10.2 per cent. 


Nearly half the country continues to rely on a sector that accounts for less than a sixth of the national income.









Some data may be matters of concern:

Agricultural exports, which had peaked at $50.2 billion in FY2021-22, fell to $45.9 billion in FY2024-25.

** This was due to curbs on staples such as rice, sugar and wheat. 

** Credit flows tell a similar story: 

-- Agricultural lending grew 7.4 per cent in the first half of FY26, well below the 15 per cent rise in industrial credit. 


** Then Crop production -- Kharif foodgrain output for 2025-26 is estimated at 150.2 million tonnes, down slightly from last year.

Due to shortfall in rainfall -- 5 per cent below normal and even unevenly distributed. 

Pulses and coarse cereals suffered declines while rice acreage expanded marginally.

Notable impacts:

Real rural wages have barely moved, rising only 2.1 per cent year on year in September 2025. 

Between 2018 and 2024, agricultural labourers’ cumulative real wage growth was just 8 per cent.  But rural consumer prices climbed 22 per cent. 






Two-wheeler sales—a modest barometer of rural income—rose only 2.5 per cent in Q2 FY26 

** Passenger cars in urban centres jumped over 10 per cent. 



Cabbage farmer in Garo Hills - Meghalaya 

(Widening gap between agricultural and non-agricultural sector incomes, particularly since late 1990s, and the inability of the industry to absorb “surplus” labour from agriculture, have worsened the disparity)


Expenditure difference: In 2017-2018, an average urban dweller could consume about 2.5 times more than an average villager, though this ratio has reportedly declined from 1.63 in 1993-94. 


While headline CPI has hovered near 4.4 per cent, food inflation fell from 6.2 per cent last year to 3.9 per cent this year. 


This has helped keep GDP numbers robust but dampened farm-gate prices. Fertiliser subsidies have risen to Rs 1.97 lakh crore in FY26 from Rs 1.81 lakh crore, shielding farmers from global price shocks but leaving incomes largely stagnant. 

Distress is addressed but he system is unable to fundamentally transform livelihoods. 


What may happen if the simmering socio-economic contradictions in rural India reach a boiling point ?



ends 



Wednesday, December 3, 2025

Namo's India remains 'unfazed' by Trump's punitive sanctions and tariffs : New Delhi to host Russia’s Putin .... Oil cooperation to continue ... Both sides eye deepening defence and civil Nuke cooperation

Russian President Vladimir Putin will be in India on Dec 4-5 for the 23rd India-Russia annual summit.


The US has accused India of importing Russian oil and reselling it in the open market for a “significant profit,” enabling Moscow to fund its aggression. 


The countries are likely to extend cooperation in defense and civil nuclear sector.


India-Russia aim to expand bilateral trade to $100 billion by 2030 from $68.7 billion in fiscal year 2025.


India could ramp up its shipments of machinery, chemicals, food and pharmaceutical products to Russia, while Moscow is pitching its technological solutions for civilian nuclear energy, including building small modular reactors in India.


The two old strategic partners are also seeking to compensate for India’s reduced purchases of Russian oil by diversifying their trade relationship to other areas, including defense and civil nuclear cooperation.


The two leaders are likely to discuss India’s purchase of Russia’s next-generation Su-57 fighter jets and its advanced S-500 missile defense shield, 








Of course, this is an annual exercise. Vladimir Putin's visit was planned before US-India ties touched the troubles and soured region; nevertheless the Russian Presidents visit signifies that New Delhi is not beholden to the whims of the Trump administration.  

It's a typical case of 'Modi hae toh Mumkin hae'.  It is the assertion of a confident India and its declaration globally that it will maintain an independent foreign policy.



Kremlin said last week that Putin’s visit was of “great importance” with the Russian president and Prime Minister Narendra Modi set to discuss the “scope of Russia-India special and privileged strategic partnership in politics, trade and economy” and also other issues.


The two leaders are certainly expected to issue a joint statement. A wide range of bilateral interdepartmental and business agreements are also on cards.










PM Modi and Putin met in September on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit in China. They held an hour-long discussion in the Russian leader's limousine.



Earlier this month, PM Modi conveyed his greetings to Putin when the Russian president's aide, Nikolai Patrushev, called on him in Delhi. The PM also said that he looked forward to hosting Putin in India next month.



India and Russia share a strong relationship with bilateral trade and investment ties dating back to the Soviet era. 



The two countries have strengthened economic cooperation over the years, with Russia emerging as one of India's top arms suppliers. India has also been one of the biggest importers of Russian oil.


Trump had blamed India's purchase of Russian oil for funding their war against Ukraine. Putin's visit could mark a pivotal moment in India's geopolitical strategy, strengthening the resilience of Indo-Russian relations even as New Delhi navigates its complex ties with Washington.









India has been under pressure from the U.S. to cut back on its imports of Russian oil as Washington claims this enables Moscow to withstanding pressure of economic sanctions by the West and continue its war against Ukraine.


New Delhi incurs an additional 25% levy, on top of 25% tariffs on its exports to the U.S. as a “penalty” for its purchases of Russian energy. The 50% U.S. tariffs on Indian goods, amongst the highest on any country, came into effect on Aug. 27.


New Delhi has said that its oil imports are based on the “objective of ensuring energy security of 1.4 billion people of India.”

PR-war between God and Demon, who has won it ??? “There is need for making a fine delicate balance between fake news and freedom of speech” -- says Govt :::: Challenging times in information era ..... Unless we catch 'next flight' we will be left on the departure lounge !!

These days airports are in news. Flights are getting rescheduled and delayed. There are technical glitches and also air pollution and so on. 


But these also talk about our lives. The competition is fierce. What's the competition about ? No one would bother about you - if you come second. There is a competition to control future. But who has started controlling the Future ?


Technology is one answer. Unless we catch the 'next flight' we will be left on the departure lounge. That's life today.


This is the era of Artificial Intelligence, and also an era where the friendship or any kind of relationship is actually laid on the foundation of being Artificial. There is nothing in real. There are pretenders.

Now comes Fake News. And it is a serious challenge.   




The issue of Fake News has been flagged off in a report by a Parliamentary panel. 


Information and Broadcasting Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw has for records now appreciated the recommendations of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Communications and Information Technology, chaired by BJP lawmaker Nishikant Dubey.

The Minister says the panel had offered several constructive suggestions that would shape the proposed regulatory framework. 


“There is a need for making a fine delicate balance between fake news and freedom of speech,” he added. 


Responding to a separate query on online betting and money-gaming platforms, the minister said the Modi government has enacted a strong legal framework to curb such activities. “Modi government never shies away in taking strong action against such misconduct,” he said. On complaints regarding television channels allegedly spreading false information, Vaishnaw said both the government and the Press Council of India examine such cases and take action wherever required.





But all these said have little meaning. We will go step by step. 


The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Communications and Information Technology, chaired by BJP member Nishikant Dubey, has asked the government to define the term 'fake news'.

It also said that the government must incorporate suitable clauses in the existing regulatory framework for the media to combat misinformation and protect freedom of speech. Some of these aspects have actually have interesting implications. 

Now an interesting facet is to understand the realism that this is also an era of perception war. Thus, the so-called 'public-relations' communication make a lot of difference. But mind you once a British writer had said -- the God has always lost the public-relations war with the mammon. 






The statement in effect reflects a common observation within religious commentary that society often prioritizes the pursuit of material wealth over spiritual values. 

Eberhard Arnold has tried to argue that -- God or Mammon; spirit or money. 

Spirit is the deep relationship between living things, the innermost connection between them. In contrast of course Mammon is related to materialism.


So who wins ? And who actually wins ?  There is another element about our lives. The more successful or great we are both as a nation, community or individuals; the more fearful and 'touchy' we become.

Hence. there is also a thin line border between Criticism and character assassination.

So, Fake news can be defined or redefined in numerous forms and shapes. That Rahul Gandhi talks about Vote Chori every time he loses is --- a mere allegation, an expose or  a fake news.


There can be many other examples. The ultimate take away is things in human hands and minds.   


Journalism is passing through a different and difficult stage. But certain basic things have not changed. Like Netas -- journalists are considered experts on any or at least numerous subjects. 

Netas should be left to destiny and the people who vote them.

But for journalists -we may have something to talk about. 


The multiple forces of political hostility, corporate interference and editors being not-editors and pushing personal agenda combined with 'misinformation' have polarised public opinion. But in the end; the readers must not forget that behind every para or even an intro or the headline lies a human story. 

That story is of journalist; it is also about his/her equation with the desk person. 


Newsrooms - many working journalists and those who have quit journalism would tell - has so many 'donkeys'. 

One is actually like a left 'luggage'  at the airport which is busy round the clock and often has announcement about flights delayed or canceled. 


ends 



 

Mosque inside Kolkata airport kicks up storm. How did it actually get there? ::::: Bankara mosque near secondary runway "obstructs safe [aircraft] operations"

 Mosque inside Kolkata airport kicks up storm. How did it actually get there?

The century-old Bankra mosque, which is situated a few hundred metres from the secondary runway of Kolkata airport, has sparked a political row. BJP leaders have flagged safety and security concerns regarding the mosque. How did the mosque come to be in the airport in the first place?  


WHY BJP LEADERS ARE RED-FLAGGING ? 


"The Ministry of Civil Aviation has admitted that a mosque is situated near the secondary runway. It obstructs safe operations, displacing the runway threshold by 88 metres. 


This affects runway utilisation during urgent situations when the primary runway is unavailable. Passenger safety cannot be sacrificed by appeasement politics. Mamata Banerjee must know that," wrote BJP IT Cell head Amit Malviya on his X handle on Wednesday.






This isn't the first time that controversy has erupted over the Bankra mosque.


For decades, various governments, both in the state and at the Centre, have tried to resolve the situation by proposing to shift the mosque. But the Muslim community has reportedly turned down such requests.



People outside Kolkata might not be aware of the existence of a mosque inside the city's Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport. 


The Bankra mosque at the Kolkata airport, less than 300 metres from the secondary runway, has repeatedly flared up as a topic of debate over the years over safety concerns. The issue resurfaced again on Wednesday after West Bengal BJP chief Samik Bhattacharya's questions and the response of the Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA), on the mosque, became public.  


The copy of the parliamentary question and its answer, where the MoCA admitted to having knowledge of the mosque's existence near the secondary runway, was amplified further when BJP IT Cell head Amit Malviya. 


He claimed that that mosque near the secondary runway, according to the MoCA, "obstructs safe [aircraft] operations" and "affects runway utilisation during urgent situations".


For decades, various governments, both in the state and at the Centre, have tried to resolve the situation by proposing to shift the mosque, which was built in the late 1890s, to a nearby location outside the airport premises. However, the Muslim community has reportedly turned down such requests.  


With the renewed concern over the mosque from the BJP leaders, the natural questions have resurfaced as to how did a mosque end up inside the international airport in Kolkata in the first place? Which came up first?


Was it the mosque? Or was it the airport at Dum Dum? But before we get to that, let's look at what Samik Bhattacharya actually asked and what the ministry replied, and how BJP leaders framed that response.  


Earlier this year, the leader of the Opposition in the West Bengal Assembly and BJP leader Suvendu Adhikari called for the immediate sealing of the boundary at Kolkata airport.


He said, "What is happening at Kolkata Airport is a matter of great concern from a security perspective. Prayers are being performed on the ground. The boundary of Kolkata Airport is not being sealed..." Speaking about the delay in Kolkata Airport's expansion plans, Adhikari said, "The reason given is the relocation of the mosque to the second runway. This cannot go on...". 








ends