Friday, October 4, 2019

Jaishankar's US sojourn lauded when global experts think time is ripe for Asia

Jaishankar and his counterpart from Singapore: Venue UN

New Delhi, Oct 4 External Affairs Minister  S Jaishankar's extended tour of the United States, detailed explanation before various think tanks on Kashmir and roadmap undertaken by New Delhi have evoked positive response from global experts at a time when Asia is seen "rising in scale" and turning a new stage of globalisation.


"The impact of India's  foreign policy cannot be judged until the results are in. What we can see now is the government's understanding of the changed world dynamics, its updated political, economic and security interests, and the pursuit of multiple new means to advance them," tweeted Peter Lavoy, a former senior official in Obama administration.

He also pens his missive saying - "I have studied India for 30 years, when its foreign policy was largely hesitant, reactive and ineffectual. My takeaway from Dr S Jaishankar is that India now has a firm grasp of its interests around the world and an assertive, self-confident and purposeful strategy to advance them".
The observations came against the backdrop of Indian foreign minister virtually taking it forward from where Prime Minister Narendra Modi had left during his high-level engagements with global leaders and business tycoons in the US.  


 Dr Jaishankar had in last week shared his views on Kashmir situation and India's positioning on major global issues before all top think tanks in America - Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Center for Strategic and International Studies, Atlantic Council, the Heritage Foundation and the Brookings Institution.

"The reality is that the space yielded by the West has been filled by many players not just China. Some like India can aspire to an improved position, others like Germany could increase the weight through collective endeavors ....," said External Affairs Minister at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington DC.

Lately, a new McKinsey Global Institute research shows 'Frontier Asia and India' - including Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Fiji, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Maldives, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan and India  will play a new game turning themselves collectively into a 'new stage' of globalization.

In this context, the remarks from Jonathan Woetzel, a director of the McKinsey Global Institute, is worth reflecting.
"For years, observers have breathlessly discussed Asia’s future potential. The future has arrived. We have entered the Asian century," says Woetzel.


In fact, such remarks are seen in tune with what many others have said lately that no aspect of life in Europe and the US is today "immune from Asianisation".


External Affairs Minister’s remarks at Atlantic Council, Washington D.C. on 1 October 2019
October 03, 2019


External Affairs Minister, Dr. S Jaishankar: Thank you very much and it's a pleasure to be back at the Atlantic Council. Let me begin actually by recognizing two people who are not here but with who, for me in many ways were the engagement when I was ambassador and earlier which is Fred Kemp and Jon Huntsman. And I'm delighted to, I know many of you but I'm particularly delighted to see Ambassador Dobriansky because the two of us worked on the kind of issues that I'm going to talk about when we were both in the administration.

So look when I thought I should come and avail of your invitation I felt I should really address what is the core mission of this institution, which was initially, to my understanding, a body which was set up to promote transatlantic understanding and then has grown beyond that to actually take on the responsibility of engaging the world beyond the transatlantic world as well. So my remarks today are really focused on those sets of issues which in a sense, you could say, how does India relate to the West, how does the West hopefully relate to India and where do we go on from here.

Now, you know, many of you would have heard in another country the term, a century of humiliation. India actually had two centuries of humiliation by the West because the West, kind of in its predatory form came into India in the mid 18th century and continued or almost exactly for two or 190 years after that. And it was interesting, I think a year ago, there was actually a very serious economic study which tried to estimate how much the British took out of India in value terms and a very calculated math ended up put a number of $45 trillion at today's value. So that should give you a sense of really what happened in those two hundred years.

So while we will speak of all the things we shared today, the reality also is that the history of India and the West is also a history of really a famine of slavery of opium trade, so that is a very dark side to all of this. Now this is the hundred and fiftieth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi. It's almost on October 2nd is actually the birth anniversary and I think it's worth a while to pause and reflect on how a leader like him actually changed India's attitude towards the West, that in 1947 when India got independence it need not have had the kind of relationship with the West which it did thereafter. We can debate the merits of it but I think it's extraordinary in a way that a country which struggles so long for its independence after that actually, kind of, reached informal understanding or a compact in a sense with the West. And I would sort of regard that as really the ability to set history aside and allow politics and economics and social connections to take over.

So what you don't see in India and have not seen for the last 70 years, even at the most difficult times with the West, has been a kind of mobilization around an anti-western nationalism. That it has been actually, in many ways I would say, a cordial relationship, if it was not cordial it was certainly not frictional and part of that was also the way we set up our own institutions and created our own society and at the end of the day the fact that we are a liberal democracy, the fact that there is a governance model based on a rule of law, the fact that there is social pluralism, and that we are a market economy, I think these were all really very powerful factors which actually enabled us to put that history behind us.

And here I would make one point before shifting to my next argument, which is that India's choices in 1947 and thereafter actually took what were Western values and Western practices and made them near-universal. So today if you have, in the developed world or the South whatever you call it, really Asia Africa parts of Latin America, if you have today a belief that democracy is an ethically superior model of governance, in part it is due to the fact that the first big post-colonial polity actually chose that and then sustained it despite extraordinary odds over the last 70 years.

So let's look at the last 70 years and these last 70 years have really been a very complex history. At one level I would say the West has actually been very-very supportive of India's growth, India's rise if you would. You can see that in politics, you can see that in security, in trade, in investment, in services, in education particularly in the 50s 60s 70s and development assistance of various kinds. You can see that where the Indian diaspora, particularly the more modern voluntary diaspora, is located and I would say that forties to perhaps the late 90s, I mean let's say the 20th century in that sense, this was a period where actually what I described as a cordial, non frictional relationship was largely in play and I think it's had a very invaluable role really in building the India that we have today.

But having said that it is what I would call a Goldilocks era of our relationship which is the West didn't want India to get too weak, it didn't want India to get too strong. So it stirred the Indian porridge or tried to stir the Indian porridge just right and sometimes got it, say there were margins of error on either side. So you actually have a very interesting sort of situation where when India in 1962 after the conflict where we were defeated, actually the West comes to the assistance of India. But in less than a decade in 1971 when it seems to the West that India is seeking a primacy in the subcontinent, the West opposes India so there's a sort of a bandwidth in which the relationship operates. Now this bandwidth is not just episodic, I mean if you look where is it that we got our relationship right and where is it we did not, pretty much across the development spectrum the West was very supportive, but when it came to industrialization, particularly in Heavy Industries or when it came to defense and security the West was very conservative.

So you had, sort of, both geopolitical or political moments as well as sectors where there was this very interesting, I would say, almost a management of relations. And today if you go to the archives and you know a lot of what where the internal thinking or multiple administration's are very, they are for people to access, I think it's more starkly actually laid out by President Eisenhower, but you can see strains of it before him, after him through multiple administrations but this idea that how do you keep India in play, a weak India is bad for American, Western interests, an excessively strong India is also a problem of a kind. By the way, those days mostly they worried about a weak India. So this in a sense was the sort of scenario through the 20th century.

Now somewhere along the way that began to change and I'll talk about it, but even though it's changed I do believe some of these structural issues which, where there are divergences between India and the West, do continue. It's visible on trade, it's visible on IPR issues, it can be visible sometimes on you know issues of non-proliferation, freedom, civil rights, you know. Which cause do you support, which cause do you not. Sometimes we look at situations where we say, why is why is the West broadly and the US looking away from what is a visible violation of rights. There'd be times when in some form the same question would be asked of us and the bottom line for me really is, for all that we have in common we also need to recognize that we are coming from a different place and we do have different histories. So a lot of the challenge today for us is to reconcile that.



So having stated that what is our current conundrum. From the Indian side I think there's a clear sense that the power of the West remains very strong. That if you look at the world the institutions, the regimes, the rules, the practices, the narratives of the world are still largely shaped by the West. The West underwrites international systems in many ways, it really governs the global Commons also in many ways, but having said that what has been visible particularly in the last years and in the case of China perhaps even before that, there is a rebalancing underway. The rebalancing was accelerated by the 2008 global financial crisis and what was initially seen as an economic rebalancing is actually until they become a much larger, I would say strategic, cultural rebalancing as well. And if there is a single way by which you could capture that it's the fact today that the G20 has really replaced the G7 as the primary body for global deliberations.

Now while I say that the West still retains great dominance over the international system, it's also a fact that we see a much more divided West and part of the reason is - the United States has been, is the glue that holds the West together and I use West in the largest, most expansive sense of the term. I mean I would call Japan in that sense as part of the West, or perhaps Korea also, I use not really a geographical or ethnic definition but I capture the alliance constructs or the OECD part of it as well. And so today as the world is getting more multipolar, the West is also getting more multipolar and that's a very interesting dynamic when you look at the West.

Now I see two propositions, one that the West needs India, it needs India because India is an additional engine of growth that the market access is important, that India's human resources will become more relevant to the world, that we will move to a multipolar world, have in a sense moved to it and therefore it's important to manage the multipolarity by having good relations with multiple worlds. The fact that in many areas there would be burden sharing of some kind, you can already see that. For example in HADR operations in our part of the world and then on global issues it's important to work for with a country like India and I think nothing illustrates that more than climate change and what happened at Paris.

But having said that I would make the converse argument which is India needs the West and India needs the West for a variety of reasons but I would give you the simplest, historical argument for it which is that every major growth story in the last 150 years has actually, paradoxically, happened with the support of the West. So whether it is the rise of Japan, whether, even the rise of Soviet Union, the rise of Korea, of the ASEAN, of China, all these would not have been possible had they not been done in tandem with the Western interests and Western thinking of that period.

The direction of the global economy would also make a stronger argument for this body because as we move into a world of a more knowledge economy world, one of greater technology interdependence, clearly an important factor would be the flow of talent in the world and there I would suggest that actually India has a somewhat unique position vis-à-vis with the economies of the West. So the question which flows from all of this is that is it possible, is it likely that there is actually a new compact between India and the West because if this rebalancing has to be reflected in a different equilibrium, in different equations, in new methods of working each other, is there is there actually a sense of how to work that out. So that brings me then to the next question what does it take us to get to that new compact? And obviously the first point there is to have the realization that there's a need for a new compact. I think that realization is today strong in the United States. I see that, to a certain extent, in Japan. I see that, less in Europe but moving in the right direction. So even the awareness aspect of it clearly need more work for this to develop further.

Now when I say what does it take, I would say that awareness first of all needs to translate itself into a recognition of the need for a new balance, which means you really have different kinds of collaborations, different conversations and in all of this obviously India would hedge enough to make sure that it will always have a strong bargaining hand vis-à-vis the West. So the fact that India has other equities and other activities does not detract from what will, at the end of the day, a sort of a central aspect of its foreign policy direction.

There are other aspects of what it takes and one of them is also an understanding of a changed India. A changed India that democratization over the last 70 years in India has had its own impact, that if you look today at India the politics of India, the social aspects of India, bluntly put the old elite is now out of business and really you have a new set of people there with different thoughts, with their own sense of roots who relate to the world obviously differently from the people who dominated the Indian political scene before them.

A third aspect of it, certainly from the Indian point of view, would be, one part of it is how do you build bridges and there the role of the Diaspora would be very important. But increasingly what we can see is that the treatment of the diaspora abroad becomes a factor in India's responses to a particular country or Society. So I see that really not just as a conversation between India and its diaspora but also a factor in our relations with other countries and other partners. And in a sense that's a two-way factor because the diaspora also relates, particularly the Indian diaspora relates much more to development in home country than many other Diasporas do. That's something we can discuss if there's interest.

From the Indian point of view as I said we, in the past noted the fact that the current world order is very much built on institutions and practices which were advanced, which were created, envisaged and socialized by the West. But we also, frankly looking ahead, our sense is really the theories of the decline of the West are grossly overstated. That if you look at technology, if you look at even defense budgets, if you look at the will to exercise power, in all of this, if you look at new instruments of pressure which have appeared on the international scene in the last ten years, in all of this actually the West very much maintains its leads.

So the task before us, if we are to move in this direction, is one of course to strengthen our convergences and there are issues today, very obvious issues to work together, issues like counter-terrorism, issues like maritime security, issues like connectivity. But there will also be divergences and I think part of the challenge would be to manage those. Lot of those would arise in third country situations like Russia or Iran and some of it would also be to overcome history. That one of the, I would say, burdens that India carries is the fact that it was not part, it was not a central part of the 1945 order. It wasn't on the high table and that point of time.

So how do you make the world more contemporary, how do you make the world order more contemporaneous and here I would argue that it is very much in the interests of the West to do that but it's obviously again not a task that is easy. The symbol of that is the UN Security Council but that's not the only facet of that particular argument.

So I would end with a concluding observation which is that as India itself rises, we are today the fifth or sixth largest economy which certainly would be the third largest economy even in nominal terms by 2030. We will be the most populous country in less than the next five years, so the question which we ask ourselves and I guess in a way the world asks itself is really what kind of power India would be, and I think a large part of that answer is obviously with us but I think one part of that answer is also with the West and what kind of relationship we now forge together, to my mind, would really give us the full picture. So why don't I stop my remarks there and I'd be happy to take questions.

Speaker 1: Good morning. Thank you so much Dr. Jaishankar for essentially giving us the Jaishankar Doctrine and you know what anyway going to be a fascinating conversation has sort of been elevated by your willingness to engage in a preview really of a strategic vision of how India engages with the West in the 21st century under your leadership and the leadership of your government. Thank You ambassador Singler and your team from the embassy all of you, honored guests they're very grateful that he would take time this morning to join us. So I'm going to ask the minister a couple of questions to get this conversation going and then of course open it up, you can indicate using your name tent if you want to ask a question I’d be happy to call on you, and again just to remind you that this is on the record.

So Dr. Jaishankar let's start with, in a sense a softball if you would, right, we will start the bouncers in a minute, so starting with the Prime Minister's appearance with President Trump in Houston then a very full week, as Damon alluded to, of bilateral and multilateral meetings in New York and then last afternoon with Secretary Pompeo in the evening. You’d probably you will leave Washington and the United States with a much clearer sense of how the West, as you've described them, is thinking about India at this US-India relationship to where you would like it to be. Would you be willing to give us a bit of a readout as it were about what do you take away from this very long set of meetings over the last week?

External Affairs Minister, Dr. S Jaishankar: First, my meetings aren't over yet so I still have a few more secretaries to go, so I'm meeting Secretary Asper I think tomorrow and the new NSA as well as the Homeland Security acting secretary and be meeting a lot of business in different formats. But look, I mean to my mind I'd kind of put my interest areas in two broad baskets, okay. One would be really the politics of the West, particularly the internal politics of the West because to say that the Western societies are today having an active debate would be the understatement of the year. Every one of them in some form has that as an ongoing activity, but really it's actually a very, I mean to my mind, really these few years are going to also, probably, take us in a very different direction than in the past, that's very obvious. And it's also obvious it's very differentiated, I spend a lot of time in Europe, not just in this job even in my previous job and as you can see today that if you take the breath of the political spectrum, both to the left and the right, I mean on both sides actually there's been a kind of a expansion and I think to a large extent that's true of American politics as well. And when you have the two extremes expanding, you obviously have, in each case, much sharper arguments with it but our concern is not to get into those arguments because we look at the aggregate outcome and where does, where do individual power centers and our nation stand and where do they stand collectively.

And that really brings me to the second basket, and the second basket is really the economic, technology basket, if you would, because I think the rate of change, rate of social change in the world is so extraordinary today and the importance of Technology, I mean it holds a promise actually beyond our imagination that if we were to think back every five years you couldn't have imagined where you were out there. And what does that then do for our relationship because in India we can't grow the old-fashioned way, we can't go up the manufacturing ladder and then industrialize and then scale it up, so we'll have to, kind of, do a very unique mix of leapfrogging of shortcuts, of improvisations.

So if you were to ask me, how is India going to grow, would it be manufacturing, would it be services, would it be startups, would it be skills, would it be exports, would it be you know globalized talent driven, would it be insular, my answer would be all of the above because I think we’ll kind of end up in that situation. And that kind of India and this much more differentiated complex West, they're coming together, to me is really a proposition which is very desirable but is not it's clearly not just not inevitable but not easy. It will have its challenges, I mean there will be issues, there will be decisions we would make which some segments here may not like, it would work the other way around as well and we'll have to take our lumps as we try to forge a different and better relationship.

So I leave after this trip even more fascinated by the internal discourse of the places I visit, but I also leave confident from everybody I met and on all the conversations that I had that there is, if there are some issues on which everybody agrees, today certainly the idea that the Western world and especially the United States, which as I said has been the thought leader in that direction, the fact that our relationship today has a strategic significance I think I’ll leave very confident of that.

Jaishankar in meeting with Secy of State Pompeo and others


EAM’s remarks at Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington D.C. on 01 October 2019

October 03, 2019

Dr. John Hamre: I'm looking for Rick Ross, he was going to introduce the speaker but I will do that and I just want to say a word of welcome to all of you. Thank you for coming we have public events we always start with those safety announcement. So Rick if he doesn't show up I'm responsible for your safety we'll take care of you. If you here a voice exit - we're going to go to these exits right behind me. I am no worried about the foreign minister, he's got help okay. I am delighted to have you here today especially this opportunity to listen to the foreign minister, he was the ambassador here in Washington and we're very fortunate that he has returned, he's come back to be voice to help us understand you know in this trajectory is a very important message that India is bringing to the world right now and we're very fortunate this is the only event that he agreed to do it with a public format. So I ask you all to be enthusiastic with your promise and please welcome Foreign Minister of India.

External Affairs Minister, Dr. S Jaishankar: Dr. Hamrey, dear friends, it’s good to be back and I am delighted to see so many familiar faces in front of me. The topic that I chose for my talk today was ‘Preparing for a different era’ because I am sure all of you would agree that we are, if not in a different era, certainly moving towards one. And I thought I'd share with you both a sense of how we see the world and how we propose to engage that world which we see.

Now we do live in tumultuous times and you would all agree that this is a far cry from the mantras of globalization that we heard just a few years ago. The primary characteristics of the world politics today are the rebalancing of the global economy and polity as well as the sharpening contradiction between the United States and China. Both power are engaging today in a manner very different from their past. Whatever the outcomes of their current arguments their behavior will impact the rest of the world very significantly. It will change And probably in time create new approaches to global affairs.

The tilt, till recently was firmly in the opposite direction, the world was not only more interlinked in its activities but also in its thinking. Technology was supposed to be the great promise that we could see whereas more connected with each passing day. The default solution to any significant challenge whether promoting trade, addressing climate change or responding to terrorism was through shared endeavors. However all that has started to change.

It is not that we did not exist before but national and global interests were usually reconciled through a network of agreements, mechanisms and practices between nation states and international community stood intermediaries, alliances, regional structures of likeminded partners. But this world evolving steadily since 1945 stands eroded today by the disenchantment with the globalization, anger at mercantilism and an inability to accept changes. Its three key principles that we have taken for granted, access to global markets, value of global supply chains and reliance on global skills mobility are all under stress. Players are moreover multiplying even as rules are wakening. The world order is visibly changed but the new one is not yet in sight. Perhaps there will be none for quite some time. Getting used to operating in this indeterminate zone is probably the first challenge of contemporary developments.

Now the globalized world is multi-dimensional and its different facets support each other. It builds on the constructs of earlier periods, be it the colonial era, the Cold War or even the unipolar world. Identifying common ground and nurturing transnational linkages, it is most vigorously expressed in economic activities especially over recent decades, a vast range of understandings and regimes were created that covered most aspects of our lives. As technology and economics threw up new domains we responded by fashioning rules for them to, while the practical world of business provided the bedrock of independence, of interdependence, multilateral rules and institutions decided how these businesses actually ran. Between arbitrating competitive interests and overseeing global Commons, they created the basis for reconciling national demands. However imperfect or even unfair it may have been, multilateralism was, till recently, the best game in town. But then this too is enveloped in the tectonic shifts underway.

Once globalization comes under attack, all its facets are subject to pressures. Opposition to globalized business will naturally undermine its governing rules and affect the institutions that oversee it. A self-centered worldview does not have place for commitments that do not serve immediate goals. The structural impact on the global order of these developments are likely to be visible over the next generation that would have many dimensions each one of them itself a factor of disruption. The most obvious one is that the world will be increasingly multipolar as distribution of power broadens and Alliance discipline dilutes and India or a Brazil will demand a greater voice with a growing economy. A Germany and a Japan cannot be impervious to changes in American thinking.

Secondly a more nationalistic approach to international relations will weaken multilateral rules in many domains. This will be particularly sharp in respect of economic interests and sovereignty concerns. Developments pertaining to the WTO or the law of seas are not good signs. This prospect of stronger multipolarity with weaker multilateralism clearly suggests a more volatile near-term. Third, such a world is also likely to fall back on balance of power as its operating principle rather than collective security or a broader consensus. History has demonstrated that this approach usually produces unstable equilibriums.

Fourth, world affairs will see a proliferation of frenemies, they will emerge in both categories, allies who publicly turn on each other or competitors who are compelled to make common cause on issues. Fifth, a more transactional ethos will promote ad hoc groupings of disparate nations who have a shared in dressed on a particular issue. This could be supported by requirements or burden-sharing and the need to reach out beyond Alliance structures. Finally, the combination of these developments will encourage more regional and local balances with less global influence on their working.

Put together it does appear that the world's creativity and diplomatic skills are really going to be tested. Now even if contradictions between China and the West sharpen, it is difficult to foresee a return to a bipolar world and the reason for that is that the landscape has now changed irreversibly. Other nations are independently on the move including India, half the 20 largest economies of the world are non-western now, diffusion of Technology and demographic differentials will also contribute to the broader spread of influence. We see forces at play that reflect the relative primacy of local equations when the global construct is less overbearing.

The reality is that the space yielded by the West has been filled by many players not just China. Furthermore both the US and China have a use for third parties and the politics of the day will drive multipolarity even faster. The beneficiaries will be the G20 powers and those at that level, powers who already have prior advantages like Russia, France and UK will probably get a fresh impetus. Some like India can aspire to an improved position, others like Germany could increase the weight through collective endeavors but this would also be a world of a Brazil or a Japan, of a turkey or Iran or Saudi Arabia or an Australia each having a greater say in their vicinity and perhaps even beyond.

With Dr. Mark T. Esper, US Secy of Defence

Thursday, September 26, 2019

In major embarrassment for Pakistan, vocal FM Qureshi left dumbfounded



New York, Sep 26 Almost two months since Pakistan had chosen to embarrass India on the abrogation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir, Islamabad was faced with a major embarrassment on Thursday at the United Nations after its vocal foreign minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi was left dumbfounded in front of waiting journalists.

"....the spokesman will speak to you...," Mr Qureshi merely remarked after he was confronted by journalists and television crew including from India and Pakistan.

Earlier, Mr Qureshi decided to give a miss to Indian Minister Dr S Jaishankar' s speech at the SAARC Foreign Ministers meet convened every year on the sidelines of UNGA.

It is worth mentioning that it is Islamabad which has been keen to open dialogue with India but New Delhi had made it clear that while it is 'not shying away' from the same, Islamabad will have to take concrete actions against terrorists taking shelter in India's western neighbour.


Mr Qureshi, a known hardliner in Indo-Pak relations, arrived late at the SAARC's Council of Ministers meeting and came in after Dr Jaishankar had made his speech and left the venue.
Pakistani authorities led by PM Imran Khan and foreign minister Qureshi had indulged in bravado and big talk on Kashmir since August 5 when the Modi government bifurcated J&K and also abrogated Article 370.

In a rather defensive tune, Imran Khan has lately told Jehadis in his country - ''Anyone, who thinks that he will cross the border to join Kashmiris is a big enemy of them and Pakistan''.
Pakistan had failed to list a resolution by the deadline September 19 at the UN Human Rights Council against India on ‘Kashmir’ and in Bangkok, it got a setback as it has been judged to be very low in terms of taking actions against terror funding.
Pakistan government's worst fear is about being included in the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) blacklist.
Initial reports said the meeting of the SAARC Foreign Ministers on Thursday was delayed for about 20 minutes at the behest of Pakistani government, and it was only at the later stage that it was made known that Mr Qureshi will be staying away from the meeting.
In a tweet, Pakistan's ruling party Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf said that Mr Qureshi will not attend Indian Minister Dr Jaishankar's speech.

''FM SM Qureshi refuses to attend Indian Minister of External Affairs Subrahmanyam Jaishankar’s statement at the meeting of SAARC Council of Ministers,'' the missive on the micro-blogging site said.

Mr Qureshi, a known hardliner in Indo-Pak relations, arrived late at the SAARC's Council of Ministers meeting and came in after Dr Jaishankar had made his speech and left the venue.
As Mr Qureshi arrived at the venue, he was confronted by journalists. One of the scribes was also heard asking Mr Qureshi in loud voice - ''Why Pakistan has supported Hafiz Saeed?''
The meeting between Mr Qureshi and Dr Jaishankar would have been the first face to face contact between the two foreign ministers after the Government of India abrogated Article 370.

India has said that Article 370 was a temporary provision and strictly India's own domestic matter.
Last year, the then External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj had snubbed Pakistan at the same SAARC Ministers meet as she had immediately left the venue after her speech and did not have any exchange of words with the Pakistani minister.
The Late Minister had also told the meeting that the terrorism was the single largest threat to peace and stability in South Asia.
On September 17 this year at a press meet in New Delhi, Dr Jaishankar has said it was well known to all other members of the SAARC -- Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and Maldives -- that who is promoting SAARC and who is against it.
"SAARC is a body for regional cooperation, my message on SAARC will be what you require for regional cooperation. You need trade, you need connectivity...If you are to talk about the future of SAARC, which country is today promoting SAARC and which country is today impeding SAARC?" Dr Jaishankar had said.

Nepal is the convenor of this year's SAARC ministerial meeting here on the sidelines of UNGA.

The last SAARC Summit was hosted by Nepal in November 2014 when Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif had attended the same.



Although Nepal was supposed to hand over the chair to Pakistan in the 19th SAARC Summit in Islamabad, the meet was cancelled after India decided to stay away from it protesting the Uri terror attack that killed 19 Indian soldiers.

In what was a clear snub to Pakistan during the swearing in ceremony of his government this year on May 30, the Prime Minister had invited BIMSTEC - Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation) nations, Mauritius and Kyrgyzstan for his swearing-in ceremony to emphasise the importance of neighbourhood in his government's foreign policy framework.

Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Nepal and Thailand are BIMSTEC members.




Qureshi skips Jaishankar speech at SAARC meet: 'Why Pak backed Hafiz Saeed ?' asks journo

 

New York, Sep 26  High drama unfolded at the SAARC Foreign Ministers' meeting after  Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi on Thursday decided to give a miss to Indian Minister S Jaishankar' s speech.

The episode is largely seen as a victory of Indian diplomacy and yet another mix of goof-up and embarrassment for the Pakistani establishment.


Initial reports said at the behest of Pakistani government, the meeting of the SAARC Foreign Ministers was delayed for about 20 minutes and it was only at the later stage, the Pakistani authorities made it known that Mr Qureshi will be staying away from the meeting.


In a tweet, Pakistan's ruling party Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf said that Mr Qureshi will not attend Indian Minister Dr Jaishankar's speech.
''FM SM Qureshi refuses to attend Indian Minister of External Affairs Subrahmanyam Jaishankar’s statement at the meeting of SAARC Council of Ministers,'' the missive on the micro-blogging site said.


As Mr Qureshi arrived at the venue, he was confronted by journalists. One of the scribes was also heard asking Mr Qureshi in loud voice - ''Why Pakistan has supported Hafiz Saeed?''


Mr Qureshi, a known hardliner in Indo-Pak relations, arrived late at the SAARC's Council of Ministers meeting and came in after Dr Jaishankar had made his speech and left the venue.

The meeting between Mr Qureshi and Dr Jaishankar would have been the first face to face contact between the two foreign ministers after the Government of India abrogated Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir.


Last year, the then External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj had snubbed Pakistan as she had immediately left the meeting venue after her remarks and did not have any exchange of words with the Pakistani minister.


The Late Minister had also told the meeting that the terrorism was the single largest threat to peace and stability in South Asia.

On September 17 this year at a press meet in New Delhi, Dr Jaishankar has said it was well known to all other members of the SAARC -- Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and Maldives -- that who is promoting SAARC and who is against it.


"SAARC is a body for regional cooperation, my message on SAARC will be what you require for regional cooperation. You need trade, you need connectivity...If you are to talk about the future of SAARC, which country is today promoting SAARC and which country is today impeding SAARC?" Dr Jaishankar had said.


Nepal is the convenor of this year's SAARC ministerial meeting here on the sidelines of UNGA.
The last SAARC Summit was hosted by Nepal in November 2014 when Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif had attended the same.
Although Nepal was supposed to hand over the chair to Pakistan in the 19th SAARC Summit in Islamabad, the meet was canceled after India decided to stay away from it protesting the Uri terror attack that killed 19 Indian soldiers.

 


SAARC Foreign Ministers' Meet: Will Dr Jaishankar emulate Late Sushma Swaraj


New York, Sep 26 (UNI) Will Dr S Jaishankar, a text book diplomat-turned-External Affairs Minister, follow the footsteps of his illustrious predecessor Late Sushma Swaraj during the SAARC Foreign Ministers' meeting here later in the day?



"We will see when that happens....." - Dr Jaishankar had remarked on September 17 in Delhi when asked at a press conference on how would he interact or give any message to his Pakistani counterpart Shah Mahmood Qureshi when they meet on the sidelines of United Nations General Assembly.


Dr Jaishankar and his Pakistani counterpart Mr Qureshi will be face to face for the first time after the abrogation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir and in recent past both India and Pakistan have been targeting each other either on the issue of terror or alleged restrictions and human rights violation in Jammu and Kashmir.


During last year's SAARC foreign ministers meeting on the sidelines of UNGA, Late Sushma Swaraj had immediately left after her remarks and did not have any exchange the Pakistani minister.



She had also told the meeting that the terrorism was the single largest threat to peace and stability in South Asia.


On September 17 at the press meet in Delhi, Dr Jaishankar also has said - "SAARC is a body for regional cooperation, my message on SAARC will be what you require for regional cooperation. You need trade, you need connectivity...If you are to talk about the future of SAARC, which country is today promoting SAARC and which country is today impeding SAARC?"

Dr Jaishankar also has said - "That's an issue all SAARC nations need to reflect upon and I am pretty confident every other SAARC nation knows what the answer is".

Dr Jaishankar also asserted that Article 370 is not a bilateral issue but strictly an internal issue of India.

In last few days during his stay in the US, Dr Jaishankar has called Pakistan - 'terroristan' and wrote in an article that - "A provision (Article 370) intended to provide temporary comfort to the process of aligning with the rest of the nation was misused for many years. By doing so, it encouraged links between separatist politicians and terrorist groups sponsored by Pakistan".


Global issues may dominate Modi's speech at UNGA apart from Pak-sponsored terror

New York, Sep 26 (UNI) The much-awaited speech of Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the 74th United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) may focus on establishing India's aspiration at the global level apart from talking tough on Kashmir and terrorism emanating from western neighbour Pakistan, says a known India watcher.


''India's ambitions internationally is greater than the issue of Pakistan,'' opined Alyssa Ayres, senior Fellow for India, Pakistan and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations on a TV channel here.
    
She said that Mr Modi is expected to make a strong pitch on terrorism vis-a-vis Pakistan's role and climate change, adding that the Prime Minister may speak about abrogation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir as well.

Apart from Kashmir, Ms Ayres says that Prime Minister Modi's address may cover a wide range of India's other ambitions including maritime and space.
''Space has been an important issue for India certainly in the past couple of decades that are important to India globally,'' she said.
 

Undoubtedly the Kashmir issue will come up, she said, adding ''Any Indian leader will feel obligated to give a reply given the importance Pakistan has given to it. But I do think India's international ambitions are much larger than the very tough issue of Pakistan.''

Prime Minister Modi on Wednesday told global business honchos and industry captains that he will "personally act as a bridge" to resolve bottlenecks and other hindrances for foreign companies to make investment in India.
In his Houston address during 'Howdy Modi' show, Prime Minister said back home everything is fine.

Sharing stage with US President Donald Trump and a host of American lawmakers including from Republican and Democratic parties, Mr Modi has said back home everything is fine.
Prime Minister asserted that everything is okay in the country and repeated the phrase in number of Indian languages including Punjabi, Gujarati, Telugu, Bangla and Hindi.
''We are changing ourselves and challenging ourselves....We are aiming high and achieving higher''.

In order to showcase India as an attractive destination for doing business in front of global world leaders, Prime Minister held a Round Table meet and also held separate meetings with some top business honchos.

Mr Modi has made a strong pitch for investment in India, and invited global business leaders to make India their new and sole destination.

He has been highlighting problems on water and climate change on global fora and  Modi pitched for a global electricity grid.

The Prime Minister also initiated International Solar Alliance (ISA), an alliance of 121 countries, to work for efficient exploitation of solar energy to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
Setting the tone of Prime Minister's UNGA speech, External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar has on Wednesday said "there are deep vested interests" which are resisting the change in Jammu and Kashmir enforced by the Modi government since August 5.

Dr  Jaishankar has also virtually backed the concept of not playing cricket with the western neighbour and said with 'terrorism and suicide bombing' dominating it is hard to sell any other narrative.

Tuesday, September 24, 2019

Amitabh Bachchan - an angry youngman on screen - who portrayed India of 1970s



New Delhi, Sep 24 Dissatisfaction, they say is very strong element in the life of a middle class citizen and Amitabh Bachchan's films will keep giving refreshing memories to millions of Indians about the roles he played – umpteen number times as Vijay – much befittingly portrayed every Indian's desire of the time that a man always feels that he could have achieved more.

Born on October 11, 1942 in the family of noted Hindi poet, Harivansh Rai Bachchan and socialite mother Teji - also a friend of Indira Gandhi, Amitabh grew up with best of both the upbringing culture – western lifestyle from mother and the oriental values from his father.

Now that the country has bestowed on him, the highest film award of the country and named after Dadasaheb Phalke, it is worth refreshing what Amitabh in later years had said about his father saying, "If you cannot enter a gate, just jump over the wall".


This is precisely, his army of fans believe, what he did to achieve the stardom, and of course retained it even at the ripe age of 75 plus with a finesse not mastered by many in the world of entertainment.
With a brooding look, fire in eyes and ire practically emerging out of his soul, his masterpiece roles in films like 'Zanzeer', 'Deewar' and 'Trishul' mirrored the disillusionment of young Indian of that time reeling under controlled economy vices – the joblessness, antagonized family life, corruption and price rise.
It was not without reason when one film writer rightly wrote once, one look at him on the screen and the audience would believe - there was nothing much in life to sing and dance about.

"Mainey aap jaisa garib zindagi mein nahi dekha ...." - an illegitimate son telling his father in 'Trishul'.


Amitabh dominated the silver screen when romantic films and chocolate cream images of screen heroes were going strong.

His roles were 'swinging' against the stream when he signed for a role as inspector ‘Vijay Khanna’ in Prakash Mehra's 'Zanzeer' in 1973 to record his first milestone performance.

The role came to him only after Dharmendra had rejected it. Grapevine was that with past failures, prior to 'Zanzeer', Amitabh was almost planning to quit Mumbai for good!
Zanzeer was his first film as the leading protagonist to achieve box office success that earned him a Filmfare Nomination for Best Actor.

The same year, he married Jaya Bhaduri on June 3 and around this time they appeared in several films together. Later Bachchan played the role of an industrialist’s son Vikram in the film 'Namak Haraam', a social drama directed by Hrishikesh Mukherjee and scripted by Biresh Chatterjee addressing themes of friendship.

His supporting role opposite Rajesh Khanna and Rekha was praised as his angst-laden dialogue delivery and manerism won him the Filmfare Best Supporting Actor Award – spelling a tough competition for Rajesh Khanna ahead.

Subsequently 'Anand' had made Amitabh and probably unmade Rajesh Khanna. In 1975, he starred in a variety of film genres from the comedy 'Chupke Chupke', the crime drama 'Faraar' to the romantic drama 'Mili'.

However, 1975 was the year when he appeared in two films which are regarded as important in Hindi cinematic history. He starred in the Yash Chopra directed film ‘Deewar’ opposite Shashi Kapoor, Nirupa Roy, and Neetu Singh which earned him a Filmfare Nomination for Best Actor.
The film became a major hit at the box office in 1975. He did not look back since then.

Released on August 15, 1975 was 'Sholay' (meaning Fire) which became the highest grossing film of all time in India earning Rs 2,36,45,00,000 equivalent to USD 60 million, and perhaps another film that made his position practically invincible.
Although with angry young man image, Bachchan cemented his status as Bollywood's pre-eminent action hero, the Big B, as he came to be known later, illustrated that he was flexible in other roles, successfully playing the romantic lead, in films such as 'Kabhie Kabhie' (1976) and comic timing in comedies such as 'Amar Akbar Anthony' (1977) and of course earlier in 'Chupke Chupke' (1975) .

In 1979 for the first time, a multi-facet quality of his came to light when Amitabh was required to use his singing voice for the film 'Mr Natwarlal' which he starred in alongside Rekha. His performance in the film saw him nominated for both the Filmfare Best Actor Award and the Filmfare Best Male Playback Awards.
In 1979 he also received Best Actor nomination for 'Kaala Patthar' (1979) and then went on to be nominated again in 1980 for the Raj Khosla directed film 'Dostana' in which he starred opposite Shatrughan Sinha and Zeenat Aman.

Sunday, September 22, 2019

On eve of Trump-Imran meet, Modi says everyone knows where terror thrives


Houston, United States, Sep 22 A day before President Donald Trump meets Pakistani leader Imran Khan, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday painted a gloomy and pro-terror image of India's western neighbour and mastered a standing ovation in favour of American battle against terror.


The Prime Minister said whether it is 9/11 in America or Mumbai terror attack of 26/11 in India, ''everybody knows where the conspirators of these terror activities are found''.

In what is seen as taking India's ties with the US to a new scale, Mr Modi also virtually endorsed US President Trump for a second term and echoing his own election slogan said - ‘Abki Baar Trump Sarkar‘.


The presidential polls in the US are due in 2020 and Mr Modi, undoubtedly a popular leader among overseas Indians, making the statement in front of nearly 50,000 Indian-Americans at the ‘Howdy, Modi’ event would signal something big for Mr Trump.

It was for the first time that an incumbent US President has addressed a rally with a foreign leader in the United States.
Mr Modi also hailed Trump's “sense of leadership" and the resolve to make America great again.

“His name is familiar to every person on the planet. His name comes up almost every conversation in the world on global politics...From CEO to commander in chief, from boardrooms to oval office, from studio to global stage. It is my honour and privilege to welcome him here," Mr Modi said at 'Howdy Modi' event amid repeated applause from the capacity crowd.

“When I met him for the first time, he said India has a true friend in White House. Your presence here today is great testimony to that. In these years, our two nations have taken the relationship to new heights,” Modi said.
Prime Minister Modi lashed out at Pakistan for pursuing a policy of hatred against India while President Trump said - ''We are committed to protecting innocent civilians from the threat of radical Islamic terrorism''.
In fact, Mr Trump's remarks drew a 50,000 strong capacity crowd of Indian Americans and US lawmakers stand up in approval.
Without naming Pakistan, Mr Modi said, ''Some people have made it a habit to pursue hatred against India as the nucleus of their politics.''
''There are the same people who thrive in violence and trouble and are sponsors of terrorism...They nurture terrorism and the entire world knows their identity,'' the Prime Minister said amid strong applause from the crowd which has gathered for a rare historic occasion.
''Time has come to fight terrorism and also take decisive steps against those who support terrorism,'' Mr Modi said obviously trying to build a pressure on the US leadership.


''I would like to emphasise that President Trump is firmly with us in this fight," he said and urged the gathering to give a standing ovation to the President for his pledge to fight terror.
Addressing the 'Howdy Modi' gala event here, Mr Modi referred to his government's decision to abrogate the Article 370 and said the new measure will ensure equality and development in Jammu and Kashmir.
''This was an internal matter of India but it has disturbed those people who cannot run their own country," Mr Modi said.
Prime Minister Modi will be leaving for New York and is slated for a crucial bilateral engagement with President Trump on September 24.

Despite ‘Howdy Modi’ sound and fury; focus is on grapes, almonds and cardiac stents



Houston, United States, Sep 22 Notwithstanding the hype about ‘Howdy Modi’ rally at NRG Stadium, the Narendra Modi-Donald Trump bear hug, shake hands and walking hand-in-hand on Sunday could finally end up doing deal about grapes, cardiac stents, pork and almonds.

Apparently much progress has been made in the trade talks between two sides and a big ticket announcement is possibly on the cards.

In the meantime, speculation is rife which among the two – Mr Modi or Mr Mr Trump would bargain hard and give in the maximum to the other side.

The US is eyeing a pact on ethanol among other facets of commercial parleys as well.

The Modi government and Union Commerce Ministry want market access for grapes and some other farm products to export to the United States and in return may give in with lower tariffs on high-end American electronic products.


India has been the largest beneficiary of the US government’s special concession regime GSP, which was enforce since 1970s but the Trump administration earlier this year ended duty-free access for about USD 5.7 billion worth of Indian exports. These included chemicals, plastics, leather and rubber goods, and auto parts. India also responded with higher retaliatory tariffs on 28 US products, including almonds, apples and walnuts.


India is the second largest importer of US apples and the top buyer of US almonds, paying USD 543 million for more than half of US almond exports in 2018.

The talks are thus focused on US keenness for reduction in agricultural tariffs by India including those for almonds, pork, dairy products, cherries and apples.


The US team led by Trade Representative Robert  also wants the Modi government to remove high pricing barriers on imported medical devices including cardiac stents.

"...The trade problems are normal with people you are closest to since most trade happens with them," External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar has said in Delhi this week.


Giving broad hints that the trade disputes between New Delhi and Washington could be handled, Dr S Jaishankar has told reporters that - "only way not to have trade dispute is not to have trade at all".
Dr Jaishankar also said that "sharper edges" in trade relations between India and the US will be addressed in the "not too distant future".
For his part, President Trump wants better terms of trade from most of the top commercial partners of the United States including India.

Washington has thus also taken up with India’s the issue of new investment rules on e-commerce.

The restrictions are said to have harmed the interest of companies like Amazon.com Inc and Walmart-backed Flipkart which are more than keen to tap the rapidly growing online market set to touch USD 200 billion by next 7-8 years.


Thus as the two quintessential ‘masters of ceremonies’ will take stage, mandarins and experts would be keeping fingers crossed for an early trade pact that will ensure that a powerful market of a combined population of world's largest democracy and most powerful democracy will offer a win-win situation to both the countries.


“Prime Minister Modi will need to show something concrete when he returns to India after a week long tour which has already attracted bitter criticism from opposition Congress and the Left parties in the country,” says a BJP source.

Besides attending 'Howdy Modi' event together, Prime Minister will have a bilateral with President Trump on September 24 in New York.

The bilateral meet between Mr Trump and Mr Modi will be fourth such engagement between the two leaders in last four months.


How PM charms Kashmiri Pandit delegation with 'Namo Namah' remark ?


Houston, United States, Sep 22  Someone who takes pride and also excels in establishing intimate bond with his audience, Prime Minister Narendra Modi left his charm over Kashmiri Pandit delegation here on Sunday.

Prime Minister joined the group which met him here in reciting 'Namaste Sharade Devi' Shloka.

But as the Shloka ended with words 'Namah Namah' and praying for the betterment of humanity including people of Jammu and Kashmir; Prime Minister in his irresistible style added: "again Namo Namah" - throwing the entire group including women into peels of laughter.

The much impressed gathering could not help applauding Prime Minister's sense of wit with a big applause.
As Prime Minister's name is Narendra Modi, he is often given the acronym 'Namo' and the phrase 'Namo Namah' is used more often to lay emphasis either on his unique style of functioning or his much successful career graph. 
One delegation leader S Kaul later said: "We thanked the Prime Minister on behalf of the 7 lakh Kashmiri Pandits all over the globe for such a historic decision".

During interaction, Prime Minister told them ".....you have suffered a lot together,  now we have to build a new Kashmir".


Within hours of landing in the United States, Prime Minister met a delegation of Kasmiri Pandit community which ''unequivocally supported'' Government of India's decision to abrogate Article 370 and bifurcate the erstwhile development-starved and militancy-hit Jammu and Kashmir.
''In Houston, a delegation of the Kashmiri Pandit community met the Prime Minister. They unequivocally supported the steps being taken for the progress of India and empowerment of every Indian, said the PMO in its tweet.


This is Prime Minister's first visit to the US since August 5 when his government decided to abrogate Article 370 and bifurcate J&K into Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh regions.
Prime Minister Modi was also felicitated by delegations of Dawoodi Bohra community and the Sikh community here on the very first day of his seven-day trip to the US.

Saturday, September 21, 2019

Confident, Global Agenda of Modi as against ‘not so sure’ Imran: Tale of Two PMs


New Delhi/Houston,  Sep 21 Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrives here on Saturday – as a confident leader sure of India’s role in framing the global agenda and championing the spirit of Mahatma Gandhi’s life and teachings.


In a sharp contrast would be his Pakistani counterpart Imran Khan, who has tried to indulge in bravado without much substance since August 5 when the Modi government bifurcated the erstwhile militancy-hit and development-starved state of Jammu and Kashmir and abrogated the Article 370.

Imran Khan has lately told Jehadis - ''Anyone, who thinks that he will cross the border to join Kashmiris is a big enemy of them and Pakistan''.

A ‘not so sure’ leader Khan would  not be quite pleased in the manner his diplomats and Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi have conducted themselves lately. Pakistan has failed even to list a resolution by September 19 at the UN Human Rights Council against India on ‘Kashmir’ and in Bangkok, it got a setback as it has been judged to be very low in terms of taking actions against terror funding.



Thus, Imran Khan’s worst fear is about Financial Action Task Force (FATF) blacklist and thus during his US sojourn, the Pakistan Prime Minister is more expected to hold a series of meetings with a large number of heads of governments in various countries to gather support to keep Pakistan out of the FATF blacklist.


Indian diplomats led by a strong government and a decisive Prime Minister Modi have already started mocking as well as questioning Pakistan’s real intent during the UN General Assembly.

Foreign Secretary Vijay Gokhale dared Pakistan to raise Kashmir issue at the UN General Assembly, but said Mr Modi will focus on issues as a responsible and emerging economic power only. ''If they wish to dwell on this issue in the speech by Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan, they are welcome to do so.....Our Prime Minister will focus on what the United Nation General Assembly high level segments means to focus''.

Another senior mandarin, Syed Akbaruddin, the articulate Permanent Representative at UN, told pointedly that “Poison pens do not work for too long”. The reference was to Pakistan's latent support to the Jehadi violence and cross border terrorism.

"We are confident that we will soar. We will soar when they (Pakistan) stoop low," he said adding Pakistan has been a ‘mainstream terrorism’ nation.
Yet another bureaucrat and India’s envoy to the US, Harsh Vardhan Shringla has written in 'The New York Times' - "What Prime Minister Khan finds difficult to accept is that the Kashmir region is now back on the road to progress and prosperity because the Indian government has repealed an anachronistic and temporary provision of law that has hindered development there”.

He further wrote: "Under Prime Minister Khan’s watch, the people of Pakistan are reeling under economic depression, with inflation at a five-year high, national debt exceeding gross domestic product and an International Monetary Fund bailout for the 22nd time".
Heart in Heart, Imran Khan too would be knowing well, say Indian experts and officials on the difficult economic situation Pakistan has landed. His problems would be mounting further if FATF blacklist finally happens.

In contrast, notwithstanding some domestic challenges like joblessness, Prime Minister Modi has some inherent advantages. The difficult trade relations between US and China have somehow pushed the Trump administration to move closer to New Delhi. Already over 40 US Congress members have urged Trump administration to reinstate the Generalized System of Preferences (GSP) status to India.
In fact, at Houston during ‘Howdy Modi’ rally, President Trump is likely to make some big ticket announcement.

During his week long tour, PM Modi will interact with CEOs of energy and oil sector global companies on Saturday in Houston and other major corporate houses on September 25 in New York.


Moreover, as BJP leaders in India say, in order to boost the economy, the Modi government is working hard and making efforts. The recent corporate tax reduction is seen as a major move and Prime Minister Modi is keeping fingers crossed with the hope that these initiatives will generate jobs.

BJP chief and Union Home Minister Amit Shah has also said that new measures will help India emerge as a manufacturing hub.

External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar has aptly summed up the ‘differences’ between India and Pakistan in global context and said: while over the years, Pakistan thrived on International Terrorism, India progressed with Information and Technology -- both IT.



Trade pact headway may offer both US and India - a win-win situation


New Delhi, Sep 18 India and the United States are working overtime to finalise an early trade pact and thus ensure that a powerful market of a combined population of world's largest democracy and most powerful democracy will offer a win-win situation to both the sides.

An improved trade ties with India - which is likely to be emphasised yet again in next few days especially during Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to the US - will help Trump administration at a time when it is engaged in trade related confrontation with China.

Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal has already said that both sides are involved in dialogue on a number of issues.

Giving broad hints that the trade disputes between New Delhi and Washington could be handled, External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar told reporters here on Tuesday - that "only way not to have trade dispute is not to have trade at all".

Moreover, he said most trade issues crop up only when the relations are sound between two sides.

Dr Jaishankar also said that "sharper edges" in trade relations between India and the US will be addressed in the "not too distant future".

"I will talk about a glass that is 90 per cent full rather than a glass that is 10 per cent empty," he said trying to highlight his optimism and the upward trajectory in bilateral ties.

"...The trade problems are normal with people you are closest to since most trade happens with them," the External Affairs Minister has said and also pointed out that - "there is no facet of the relationship today which has not gone upwards over the past 20 years".

In the past few months, no less than US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has tried to forge a 'new kind' of cooperation with India.

Moreover, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer-led team is also on the job.

In terms of perspectives, it is presumed that the US could be expecting from India "easier and business friendly atmosphere" for the American companies to operate in India.

The new pact may also focus on agricultural market access, reduction in IT tariffs and medical device pricing. For its part, the Trump administration may allow India's 're-entry' to Generalised System of Preferences (GSP) and thereby help reduce prices of India-made goods in the US.

Thursday, September 19, 2019

After Oppn brickbats for 'silence', Mamata raises NRC bogey with Shah



Detractors mock as a mellowed down version of Mamata leaves everyone surprised


New Delhi, Sep 19  The BJP leaders and also others feel it was a 'different' Mamata Banerjee in the national capital when she met Prime Minister Narendra Modi, invited him for a coal block project inauguration in her state and also expressed keenness to meet Union Home Minister Amit Shah.

It was like a 'surrender' by a firebrand leader, say many detractors of Trinamool Congress supremo and West Bengal Chief Minister.

"It was a case of Mamata Banerjee looking to see a doctor, seeking his help and the senior doctor then deciding to send her to the junior doctor," Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said in reference to Ms Banerjee's decision to meet Mr Shah after her meeting with Prime Minister on Wednesday.

After her meeting with Mr Modi, the West Bengal Chief Minister said she would be keen to meet Mr Shah.

''If I get time, I will meet Mr Shah tomorrow,'' she said.

The proposed meeting between Ms Banerjee and Amit Shah can take place around 1330 hours.
"In natural course, if Mamata Banerjee wanted to discuss only development matters after meeting Prime Minister, she should go to Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman. So the issue is different," said Mr Chowdhury.
Several other leaders have also flayed Ms Banerjee for taking a 'selfish' route vis-a-vis progress in the probe in the Saradha chit fund case and the interest of the state.

The Left leaders in West Bengal have questioned Ms Banerjee's silence on National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise when she met Prime Minister.
"Only a few days back, Ms Banerjee staged a street protest in Kolkata saying she will not allow NRC in Bengal, but when she met Prime Minister she did not raise the issue and later said NRC is only an issue for the state of Assam. Then why was she protesting over it in Kolkata?," asked CPI-M leader Sujan Chakraborty.

After her meeting with Prime Minister, Ms Banerjee had said that NRC did not figure in talks as it was only an issue for the state of Assam based on the agreement the Assam Accord signed in 1985.
The meeting on Wednesday between Mr Modi and the Chief Minister came within days the CBI dragnet almost touched former police commissioner Rajeev Kumar in the Saradha chit fund case. The cop is absconding during last few days.
Apparently looking for rapprochement with the central BJP leadership whom she bitterly attacked, Trinamool Congress supremo on Wednesday invited Prime Minister to attend a coal block function in Birbhum district in October and also gave a freehand to the centre to 'make suggestions' for changing the name of West Bengal.
"Keeping the word Bangla, if they some suggestion to make; I will not have any objection to accept it," she has said adding "This was a good meeting....I had not visited Prime Minister after he became Prime Minister for the second time".
However, Bengal BJP chief Dilip Ghosh said perhaps the Chief Minister's gesture is coming "too late". Another Bengal BJP leader Rahul Sinha also made light of her meeting with Prime Minister and said: "Mamata Banerjee did not meet Prime Minster for any state related works. She met him only to save her party (on Saradha chit fund case)".
 

After Oppn brickbats for 'silence', Mamata raises NRC bogey with Shah

 
New Delhi, Sep 19 Under attack for not raising the vexed NRC issue with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Thursday took up the matter with Union Home Minister Amit Shah but tried to confine the matter vis-a-vis Assam chiefly.

"I have submitted a letter to Home Minister on the fate of 19 lakhs people excluded from Assam NRC,'' Ms Banerjee told reporters trying to imply there was no reference to the controversy on NRC exercise in her state of west Bengal.


In fact, the Left leaders have questioned Ms Banerjee's silence on National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise when she met the Prime Minister.

"Only a few days back, Ms Banerjee staged a street protest in Kolkata saying she will not allow NRC in Bengal, but when she met Prime Minister she did not raise the issue and later said NRC is only an issue for the state of Assam. Then why was she protesting over it in Kolkata?," asked CPI-M leader Sujan Chakraborty.



After her meeting with the Prime Minister, Ms Banerjee had said on Wednesday that the NRC issue did not figure in talks as it was only a matter for the state of Assam based on the agreement - the Assam Accord - signed in 1985.


But later Trinamool sources said Ms Banerjee told Home Minister that there was no logic for NRC exercise in West Bengal as is being propagated by a section of BJP leaders.


"With regard Assam and NRC exercise undertaken in the northeastern state, Mamata Didi pointed out that Hindi, Bengali and Gorkhali speaking people have been left of the exercise," a source told UNI.



Ms Banerjee also said her stand on the NRC in Bengal was the "same" as Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar as "we do not need NRC in these two states", the sources added.




However, sources maintained the issue of conducting NRC in Bengal in specific sense did not figure at the half-an-hour long meeting.





In her first meeting with Mr Shah, whom she had questioned once saying 'who is Amit Shah to speak about Bengal'; Ms Banerjee said - "lives of NRC affected people are uncertain".



"It was explained to Home Minister that as a Chief Minister of a border state sharing boundaries with Bangladesh, Bhutan and Nepal, it was her duty to speak on matters concerning such people," the Trinamool source said.

Ms Banerjee's meeting with Prime Minister Modi and Mr Shah came after the developments related to Saradha Chit fund case in which former Kolkata Police Commissioner Rajeev Kumar has come under the CBI scanner.

Trinamool detractors, including Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, have in last two days alleged that it was like a 'surrender' by a firebrand leader, who has been always trying to champion the cause anti-BJP politics in West Bengal and at the national level.
"It was a case of Mamata Banerjee looking to see a doctor, seeking his help and the senior doctor then deciding to send her to the junior doctor," Mr Chowdhury has said in reference to Ms Banerjee's decision to meet Mr Shah after her meeting with Prime Minister on Wednesday.



The Lok Sabha elections witnessed fiercest of contests between BJP and Trinamool and the rivalry was so intense that even Mr Shah's chopper was denied landing permission in Bengal during the height of election campaign.

Putin says - Europe was in a “humiliating decline” and anti-Russian sanctions backfired" :::::::: “We should eliminate trade and investment barriers... and also promote balanced development,” says Chinese President :::::

US President Trump Lands in Shenzhen Ahead of Key Talks With Chinese and Russian Leaders Chinese president Xi Jinping opened the Apec CEO su...