Thursday, November 19, 2015

Why BJP faced Brahmin, Bhumihar backlash in Bihar?


If the tally in the ultimate for Bihar polls looked so gloomy for the four NDA constituents including BJP and allies like LJP of Dalit leader Ram Vilas Paswan, HAM of Mahadalit leader Jitan Ram Manjhi and Upendra Kushwaha-led RLSP, they had to blame themselves. But the shocking part of the entire game was the clear displeasure of BJP's traditional support base Bhumihars and Brahmins. 

The BJP chief Amit Shah had claimed that he had the most detailed 'micro-analysis' up to the booth level, but this was a faulty claim. The NDA ally LJP fielded a candidate Geeta Pandey from one of the constituencies in the Arrah Lok Sabha seat. The choice showed that Amit Shah's claim of micro-analysis was bogus as "She is wife of jailed Narendra Pandey alias Sunil Pandey, who is accused in the murder of Brahmeshwar Mukhiya, an iconic figure for Bhumihars".

The sitting BJP MP R K Singh, former Home Secretary, opposed this because even hailing from the elite IAS cadre, Singh comes from the land where Brahmeswar Mukhiya is venerated. "But the BJP leadership lacked all understanding to allow free hand to Ram Vilas Paswan," a party leader said.
Was this combination better?

Post the debacle, while the likes of L K Advani and forgotten characters Arun Shourie sought headlines, on the ground BJP and RSS district level workers point out at other lacunae in campaign strategy and ticket distribution. 

Former Bihar Minister and respected Kailashpati Mishra, a founding father of Bihar Jan Sangh and BJP, was born in Buxar, into a Bhumihar family. The saffron party has been generally sympathetic to anti-Naxal militia Ranvir Sena chief Brahmeshwar Mukhiya, also a Bhumihar chieftain.Thus, BJP traditionally has been also the first choice of the Bhumihars. But this time, it fielded 18 Bhumihars as against over 30 Rajputs, who had always stayed away from Bhumihars and BJP.

As it is from 2014 itself, Bhumihars were unhappy over BJP's alliance with pro-Dalit LJP. In the past too Rajputs as a caste flocked to the RJD chief Lalu Prasad after Congress lost sheen so much so that the RJD in 2009 had four Lok Sabha MPs - three were Rajputs besides Lalu himself.

While senior leader CP Thakur, a Bhumihar, spoke for his group, there was none to champion the cause of Brahmins. Rajputs also have vocal leaders in union ministers Radhamohan Singh and Rajiv Pratap Rudy.
The Brahmins caste felt neglected by Prime Minister Narendra Modi as “there is no Brahmin minister” in the Modi cabinet from Bihar. “The Brahmins were taken for granted,” said a party MP.
Brahmins thus got back at the BJP with vengeance and so the party lost seats where Brahmins influenced the outcome. Buxar, which has always been seen a Brahmin seat, was lost. 
Radhamohan Singh: A non-performer?

The BJP lost 7 seats in Brahmin strongholds Bhagalpur region and it was also decimated in Banka. RJD also uprooted BJP from Mithilanchal region, where Brahmins are in large numbers. Lalu Prasad Yadav’s RJD also swept through Rajput dominated areas of Arrah, Chapra and Champaran.

The verdict ultimately showed that the BJP and Modi's poll managers were disconnected with the reality of Bihar.

In contrast to BJP's traditional ‘Baniya-Brahmin’ image, this time party strategists led by, now embattled, Amit Shah sought to prop up other castes including traditional Brahmin rivals including Rajputs and Bhumihars. Like in UP, Brahmins in Bihar are reckoned as opinion makers and their anguish thus swung voters of other castes too as Brahmins in villages still offer persuasive arguments in tea stalls to work places including to women.

"Brahmins were annoyed for more reasons than one. Our traditional support base was disturbed that on the eve of elections forgetting committed workers for last two decades, BJP indulged in a blatant caste politics and appeasement of backward castes," a source said adding a group of upper caste Bihar leaders at the district levels now propose to take up with the central leadership on how things were mishandled.

Namo in search of "corrective steps"?

“The BJP has humiliated Brahmins and likes of Ashwani Chaubey stood happy in Bhagalpur after party gave ticket to his son Arijit Shaswat. Brahmins were never ignored by the BJP earlier,” retorted an angry Bihar-based leader. Moreover, sources said, attempts to woo Rajputs and Bhumihars were "partly misguided misadventure and partly wrongly handled".
 In the meantime, even as media and analysts throw up reasons those led to the rout for BJP in Bihar, party's own scrutiny of poll performance shows the strategists had simply gone haywire in overestimating the strength of its regional allies especially the Maha Dalit leader Jitan Ram Manjhi.
"It was a poor political combination against a superb caste formula worked out by our rivals. Things went against NDA so much against us that the Maha Dalit card the BJP had depended upon simply failed," a Bihar BJP leader said. 
True, at the end of the day as results came what amazed everyone is that the NOTA vote share was bigger than HAM party led by Jitan Ram Manjhi, - left to himself was also a potential Chief Minister !
"We will not describe Bihar polls simply to victory of the casteist passion whipped
by RJD chief Lalu Prasad Yadav. It was also failure of our caste equations," BJP source said. 

BJP has reasons to form such views as Manjhi himself lost sitting Makhdumpur reserved seat while his son Santosh Kumar Suman was humbled at Kutumba in Aurangabad.

In the elections while NOTA vote share stood at 9,47,185 votes making it 2.5 per cent of votes polled, Manjhi's party - ironically which even spoke of making their leader the Chief Minister - could poll only 2.3 per cent and thus 8,46,856 votes.

Even RLSP led by Upendra Kushwaha, another caste leader, polled a modest 2.6 per cent votes for the 23 seats they contested.
After hard bargaining Hindustan Awami Morcha (HAM) contested 20 seats while
BJP was also forced to give additional seats from its quota to accommodate HAM candidates. BJP and RSS second rung leaders who campaigned in Bihar later said in many assembly segments, genuine party workers were displeased at the manner seats went to allies.

"They were all Narendra Modi fan and keen to vote and work for Lotus symbol, but once they were told about other symbols, things simply went unheard," a party leader explains.
The BJP reading is also clear that Bihar's Yadav castes -- sidelined politically for last 10 years since 2005 - voted with vengeance.
"But Ram Vilas Paswan-led LJP's failure surprised us. While Manjhi's party won only one seat, LJP could pick up only 2 seats. This shows LJP benefited during Lok Sabha polls owing to the Modi wave, their votes did not get transferred," an insider said.

Tuesday, November 17, 2015

Bihar flavour in ‘Assam tea’ ! A Game-Changer


BJP's vote share crossed 36 per cent in 2014 Lok Sabha polls while Congress suffered a 10 per cent decline coming down to 29.9. These had generated hopes in the saffron party to make a bid for power in Assam. But the Bihar results will possibly make things easier for Congress provided it can join hands with other anti-BJP forces.

The Bihar results are a sound message on how elections should not be fought. To lose an election is certainly a no big deal. Politicians have the right to be defeated — this was how the legendary Chandrashekhar had reacted when the VP Singh-Devi Lal machinations humbled him in the internal politics of the then Janata Dal. 

But the manner in which the Bihar polls were mishandled by the BJP and a convincing victory was handed over to rivals from a near winning position is akin to the Indian cricket team’s performance, especially in the  1990s. 
But this defeat has changed the game now in Assam altogether.

Faceless voters: Gamechangers
The political landscape of the BJP in Assam till the other day had suggested that the seat of Dispur was within its reach. 

Even Congress supporters were reconciling to the fact that come April-May 2016, Tarun Gogoi would face his Waterloo.

But once the results from Bihar poured in, notwithstanding the bravado from Assam BJP chief Sidhartha Bhattacharjee, everyone within the saffron outfit and outside felt the fallout could be visible in next spring’s Assam polls.

In fact, no sooner did the Bihar results herald a Black Sunday (8 November) — ironically on the eve of Diwali — for the BJP; its principal rivals,  the pro-minority All India United Democratic Front and the Congress, wasted no time in claiming that the pro-Hindutva party’s journey would be halted.
Terming the success of the JD(U)-RJD-Congress grand alliance as a victory for  “secularism”, All India United Democratic Front chief Badruddin Ajmal claimed the Bihar poll results would have a national impact and the BJP would suffer defeat in Assam. As expected, embattled chief minister Tarun Gogoi was the happiest person when he said, “We are not talking about a mahajot (grand alliance). We are talking of ‘maha-understanding’ among forces fighting the BJP” — thereby making a clarion call to  all non-BJP parties like the Congress, AIUDF, Asom  Gana Parishad, Bodoland People’s Front and Gana Mukti Sangram to come together.


But here lies the big catch. In the words of Gogoi itself is hidden the bitter ground reality of Assam that can, in fact, save the day for  the BJP. The saffron party, which picked up seven of the 14 Lok Sabha seats in Assam in 2014, never had to face a united opposition in the past. Or in a precise political sense – “anti-BJPism” has never been a cause for unity with rest of the political forces in the state.
Instead, it has been one of the key partners of the AGP, once known for its regional muscular polity, and reportedly a few individual BJP leaders have done “unofficial” business even with the AIUDF for specific seats like in communally vulnerable Silchar.

Moreover, unlike Bihar where Amit Shah’s brand of politics did not cut any ice with voters, in Assam the saffron party has a much cooler and level-headed Ram Madhav as the general secretary in charge. Having handled a tough election in Muslim-stronghold Jammu and Kashmir, Madhav, though an RSS favourite, has been undertaking his responsibilities in Assam in a very sober and matured manner.
The complacency the  BJP showed in Bihar could be corrected by then in Assam and in contrast a taste of victory for the Congress — 27 seats in Bihar — could bring back the good old arrogance demon in Congress workers. In such a scenario with about five months to go for the spring, the battle in Assam now also looks wide open.


Despite advantages, the Congress has the good old face of Tarun Gogoi, three-time chief minister. He now harbours ambitions of putting forward his member of Parliament son Gaurav Gogoi’s case. This will certainly not go down well with both voters and Congress workers. The desertion of Himanta Biswa Sarma, one-time trusted Gogoi lieutenant, is essentially attributed to the “Junior Gogoi factor” than Sarma’s trust on the “vibrant leadership” of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, as they put it.
 Interestingly, Sarma’s willingness to join the BJP came within some  weeks of the saffron party calling him a key suspect in the Louis Berger scam. Only God and Amit Shah can now confirm what has been promised to Sarma. But that has not dampened the former state minister’s enthusiasm. He also already roped in nine sitting Congress legislators to the BJP. 

On the face of it, this also could appear a case of India Shining when the BJP faced defeat in the 2004 parliamentary polls. But in reality many dedicated BJP workers are not happy as these former Congressmen could bargain for tickets.

It goes without saying that the internal sabotage is still being attributed as one of the major reasons for the BJP’s defeat both in 2004 and, more recently, in Bihar. Among the existing BJP leaders, Sarbanand Sonowal is a prominent face but he, too, is a former AGP man. Moreover, Prodyut Bora has already walked out of the BJP while loyalists of Union minister Sonowal are at cross purposes with new BJP state unit chief Siddhartha Bhattacharya.
Will BJP's gamble with Himanta work?

The saffron party has, moreover, already faced criticism – and in the coming days this can only intensify — as the BJP has made a certain U turn on tricky issues like big dams, land boundary pacts with Bangladesh and deportation of illegal Bangladeshi nationals.

The BJP may also have tie-ups with tribal organisations like the Bodoland People’s Front but the party’s past experiences in pre-poll alliances in the state has been bitter. This offers a tremendous advantage to Tarun Gogoi. The Congress high command still backs him but he needs to win over parties like the  AGP and the AIDUF to counter the BJP.
(ends)

Saturday, November 14, 2015

Paris Attack: Lesson in India and Pakistan

Only on November 9, 2015, hours after India’s Bihar state enjoyed the victory of so called SICKULARISM – supposedly a blatant anti “Hindutva brand” of politics – Foreign Policy (magazine and website/run from west) sparked off a debate, “does violent extremism stem from Islam’s sacred texts?”

The Paris attack came on November 14. 
Have I already communalized the debate?

In Indian sub-continent context, may be, I have. India is a ‘tolerant’ country and Narendra Modi is making it “intolerant” – so believes Sonia Gandhi to Indian president Pranab Mukherjee, also a former dedicated Congressman.
So believe writers and fraudsters, bear with my language. There was no award-return protests when Osama bin Laden was hailed as a “perfect Muslim”. 

So much was the camouflage over minority-appeasing SECULARISM – or SICKULARISM – that Pranabda’s compatriot in Congress Digvijaya Singh called him ‘Osama ji’. 
Sand work: Sudarshan Pattnaik

Thursday, November 12, 2015

Lesson from Bihar mandate: Voters - even if wrong - are always right


People of Bihar represent a dichotomy.

They wanted to reward a person - Nitish Kumar - who got rid of the ‘jungle raj’ in 2005 and typically declined to trust the Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi, who was promising them, a ‘better Bihar’ and a cushion against second installment of jungle raj of Lalu Prasad.
That’s precisely the Bihar elections for you. I have not answered the priceless question I posed with my previous blog on Bihar – “who will have the last laugh?”

Today that answer has little meaning. Let us examine what went wrong for Narendra Modi, himself a good reader of people’s pulse, and his trusted poll manager Amit Shah. BJP’s negativism guided by ‘excessive obsession’ with Nitish Kumar from the beginning of electioneering when the Chief Minister was not quite yet on the radars for contest enlarged Nitish Kumar’s profile to such levels that he along with Lalu Prasad’s solid support base of Yadavs – who perhaps voted with vengeance - literally eclipsed the saffron party. 


Now, what went right for Nitish Kumar?

The success of Nitish Kumar-Lalu Prasad combine was a huge political lesson that a good face and a good caste combination can make a formidable force to unleash nightmare on most potent rivals. Nitish Kumar made this year’s election a referendum on him and used his sober but personal magnetism. A few Biharis can actually deny that that life had gotten better under Nitish Kumar’s tutelage.
They wanted to reward a person who got rid of ‘jungle raj’ in 2005.

In the process, the jungle raj allegation against Lalu Prasad too did not stick and Modi’s master ability in understanding of crowd psychology to advantage too did not yield results.
“The voters wanted Nitish Kumar’s continuation and many were fed up with Prime Minister Modi’s rhetoric and zero performance of the centre in last 18 months,” rightly said JD(U) leader K C Tyagi later
These put the BJP on the back foot and at later stage when PM Modi charged Nitish Kumar about ‘DNA’ – the local Bihari voters decided to back their “own man” – Nitish. Moreover, the BJP’s ticket distribution and allocation of seats to three allies HAM, LJP and RLSP displeased party’s foot soldiers. 

NOTA vote share stood at 9,47,185 votes making it 2.5 per cent of votes polled and Manjhi's party - ironically which even spoke of making their leader the Chief Minister - could poll only 2.3 per cent and thus 8,46,856 votes. Most of these NOTA votes were BJP cadres’ votes in protest against the manner Amit Shah handled the elections.
The RJD-JD(U)-Congress combine actually also benefited from a different kind of backlash – the anguish of upper castes especially Brahmins as they felt “betrayed” after BJP gave away seats to allies of backward class and Dalits and tickets chiefly to Rajputs. 
Thus even renowned Brahmin strongholds have been breached. Election results in Bihar therefore for Narendra Modi and BJP are crystal clear message of how elections actually should not be fought. 
In terms of fallout, post Bihar-debacle for NDA, the media focus is rightly on the crisis in BJP, especially after four elderly BJP leaders directed their tirade against Narendra Modi-Amit Shah duo. "To say that everyone is responsible for the defeat in Bihar is to ensure that no one is held responsible," the statement from 4 veterans L K Advani, M M Joshi, Yashwant Sinha and Shanta Kumar said. This was to contest BJP's highest policy making body Parliament Board's stand that sheer arithmetic led to the crushing defeat and that the defeat must be accepted collectively. 

Paswans failed Amit Shah

The crushing defeat for BJP has sparked off a debate among the political circle whether RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat had deliberately scored that 'self-goal' for BJP by his comments against quota only to corner the Prime Minister Narendra Modi's team.
Is Modi's loss a RSS gain? 

The RSS and BJP watchers know it pretty well that Mohan Bhagwat is not a politically naive person. 
"Bhagwat is one of the most political RSS chiefs in recent past. This statement was not made in a closed door meeting. It was given as an interview and no one is convinced that Bhagwatji did not know, he has handed offer a favourite fodder to Lalu Prasad," remarked a senior BJP leader.
 In fact, no sooner RSS interview to Sangh fountainhead's own organisers went viral in media, Lalu Prasad had quickly latched on to the statement and dared PM Modi to abolish reservation.
BJP poll strategists admitted even after first two phases of polls -- wherein many seats with Dalit and OBC people went to the elections, the writing was clear that things had gone out of hands. “We know, no magic could help BJP recover that lost ground,” said senior leader C P Thakur, whose son too lost the polls. 
Cow: Negative Impact

Since coming to power in the May 2014 general elections, Prime Minister Modi tried to make himself a ‘new Indira Gandhi’ – a phrase borrowed from the BJP dissident camp. "The principal reason for the latest defeat is the way party has been emasculated in the last one year," the statement from four veterans said.

For his part, Narendra Modi assumed the 2014 mandate was for him akin to 1984 mandate to Rajiv Gandhi. While Rajiv benefited by sympathy wave as his mother was mercilessly killed by assassins, for Modi the 2014 mandate came as people were fed up with a non-functional MMS regime - of the Congress ruled UPA. Thus they put in lot of expectations in the basket of Modi Sarkar.
Prime Minister cannot blame people of Bihar for their anguish against him as both the BJP and Modi himself had campaigned tirelessly for 'achhey din'. 

After Arvind Kejriwal's Broom Revolution in Delhi, the caste idioms and absence of anti-incumbency against two-time Chief Minister Nitish Kumar in the ultimate proved nemesis for Narendra Modi-Amit Shah duo. The fallout could be huge politically. Amit Shah's exit as BJP president looks imminent. And the Prime Minister Modi needs to take the poll outcome of a governance-starved state as ‘alarm bell'. 
A fast learner he showed the right vibes when he gave a push to the economic reforms. 
Half Glass Full or Half Glass Air

Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Fun, Food, St Anthonian Gang: Hijack by ‘Naga hospitality’


While concluding a previous blog on September 25, 2015, I promised to write another on our St Anthony’s Shillong gang get together. Here it’s.



Nov 8, 2015 Meet
These writings are difficult more from an individual perspective. Struggling to key in first initial words, one had to fight back the tears – certainly the tears of joy. But the incorrigible ‘tears’ do blur our visions nevertheless. If all these years – we had parted ways around 1984-85 – I was wondering what’s happiness all about, by August-September in 2015 when our group was born on ‘whatsapp’ tool; I realized it’s all about FRIENDSHIP. The feeling that you have friends and you too are a ‘friend’ of some individuals – highly successful ones in life an career – gives one some POWER.

This POWER HEIGHTENS one’s happiness!

We had another meet on November 8, 2015 – as Mumbai-based Samik Bhattacharya – he calls himself Sam B’charya and Shillong-based Congress neta Sanjay Das landed here in Lutyen’s city. Sam is truly a ‘be chara’ (please spare political element in you – Lalu Prasad here) – as Sam is only ‘bachelor’ in our group till now ! Moved in bag and baggage, we have promised on Delhi variety of ‘hospitality’, but this globe trotter says he has learnt all tricks of ‘hospitality’ in Africa ! Sanjay Das laughed little with gusto – cheerfully.
Sanjay, like most Congress netas, had a blast that day as Narendra Modi was humbled in Bihar and his party had something to cheer about after months!

So, perhaps Sanjay's laughter had a vengeance as he was ‘teasing’ this Modi bhakt – your’s blogger! Was the former cricketer in our school team still playing gentleman's game?  

Ainul Haq Mazumdar , our admin/moderator in Whatsapp group, played a 'cool customer' and kept things “safe” as he did not have wife’s permission to drink on a day – Modi was knocked off in Bihar!! But the cool customer kept his smile all along and kept encouraging most of us to press refresh memories about our good old days in Shillong! A good moderator is like a shepherd keeping the flock together.

Surajit Bhattacharya played his usual mischief. He wore his old-heart on his sleeves throughout. But like all dutiful husbands, the fellow got unmindful - scared - at times as his in-laws had visited his house and he was with us in 'very important business conference'.
But classic was Gautam – the UN official – throwing the usual googly, “today all you have is only beer”. Everybody kept a momentary silence – mourning the absence of hard booze.
Snaps were posted on whatsapp already and ‘jealous’ guys outside Delhi were already worried, whether Hangover is over ! There was no lion in the room.
Christopher, Odisha-based cop, landed in Delhi but missed the fun as his job ensured he should not move out of the Delhi airport. Poor fellow!
Good jobs often deny you good times.
No time to talk: Business First

But Life is like that. Mere fun and friendship would not make your life the way you want to shape it.

Rightly goes the Jagjit Singh number, Apni Marzi se kahan apni safar ke hum hain
Rukh hawaaon ka jidhar ka hai udhar ke hum hain

(This journey is not of our making,
We go in whichever direction the wind blows.)
 
Gang with Naga neta Thomas Ngullie

The song stands true not only for cops, it’s for everyone. 

Another thing in life is uncertain is who will host party for whom. Our ‘mutual party’ in terms of footing the bill turned topsy turvy as a former Nagaland minister Thomas Ngullie walked in. He too shared the ‘secret’ that he is Anthonian (by college) ! 
He had a cup of ‘fika cha (black tea)’ as we savoured popular Naga dishes and as he walked out, he said, “enjoy Naga food guys, its all on me”. 

Do you still doubt the ‘power’ of God’s will? Do you still doubt the traditional Indian theory – tolerant India or ‘intolerant’ India – that every corn is named after you or someone? Is there still any question about 'Naga hospitality'? Do you still doubt that Nagas have big hearts ?

Thank you Anthonians ! Thank you Thomas Ngullie. Happy Diwali.

(ends)

Monday, November 9, 2015

Life in and around Assam Rifles camps: A Winning Partnership of ‘TOLERANCE’

The Assam Rifles camps in towns like Mokokchung, Lunglei and Imphal once reflected image of mini-India where people of varied backgrounds including local Nagas or Lushais lived together in a perfect harmony. There would be merits in former youngsters try to revive the old friendship, more so when India is looking to rediscover ‘Tolerance’!


Quite often memories come crowding in of men and women, mostly Bengalis, Assamese, Nepalis, Biharis and North and South Indians with anxieties writ large on their faces in the capital towns of Nagaland, Mizoram and Meghalaya for fear of being asked to leave the places they had loved and lived in for many years and some of them even identified themselves with the locals. 

The memory haunts me more so at this point of time when the country is seriously debating what “tolerance’’ and “intolerance” is. Not that I am into this political debate, my mind is elsewhere and what follows may help some North-easterners to either refresh memories or raise eyebrows. 

It relates to one of the most talked-about and nearly 100-year-old para-military forces — the Assam Rifles. I have a personal affinity to this force which is maintained by the Union home ministry but under Army command to fight insurgency, because my father had served in it. And I grew up in Assam Rifles’ camps.

Moving further with this piece, let me take shelter of an old adage of journalism that a reporter might be occasionally right and often go wrong in his interpretation.  The Assam Rifles, once titled ‘Friends of the Hill People’, by its history has never been in search of a township to settle or set up its camps. Rather the townships have most of the time - if not all - have developed around the Assam Rifles camps. 
These have been the case in towns like Kohima, Wokha, Mokokchung in Nagaland, Serchip and Aizawl in Mizoram, Shillong in Meghalaya and also several rural hamlets.
Going into certain details, in Kohima for instance Assam Rifles (initially 3rd Battalion and then 29th Battalion) was set up around Mid Land area – not very far from Nagaland Old Secretariat – where the Chief Minister used to sit.   

With an Assam Rifles camp in the vicinity, an atmosphere of “security” prevailed in these insurgency-infested towns in the 1960s and 1970s. The fear of insurgents targeting public places even forced a Kohima privately-run cinema to suspend screening films. In search of entertainment, one would often go to the Assam Rifles compound to watch movies run by generators. 


One also had access to the unit’s canteens where one could buy items at reasonable prices. And the so-called “wet canteens” nearby sold jalebis, laddus and samosas. The popular Tibetan delicacy, momos, and Chinese chowmein came much later.
In Mokokchung, the hub of Ao Nagas, where I attended school for three years, Dusherra and Durga puja were celebrated in a grand manner. On Navami day, goats, ducks and a buffalo were slaughtered in the Assam Rifles compound. Special arrangements were made for “gao buras (village chiefs) from adjoining Ungma and other hamlets to attend the ceremony. They were treated with tea and halwa and buffalo meat was also given to them.

All communities participated in different festivals and also local ones. And during Christmas a fete was a big attraction. Those were the good old days indeed. Youngsters hardly bothered which community a person belonged to. Football matches were often played between the Assam Rifles team and Douglas School boys.

So well-knit was the cultural affinity that even in the 1980s, in Mizoram’s border town of Lunglei where the 18 Assam Rifles camp was situated, Christian Lushai soldiers greeted their officers with “Ram Ram sahib”. For my younger brother, “breakfast” meant “aloo-puri sabzi” from the langar (soldiers’ mess) and “Ram Ram sahib” was the Hindi version of “Good morning, sir”.

Blogger: Grown up

But things started changing very fast once the soldiers lost their goodwill. There were allegations of human rights violations against civilians. By the 1990s when we were in Kohima, such happenings took place almost daily and locals often protested against molestation of Naga girls by jawans and also demanded shifting of their camps. 
But is there any logic in lamenting over spilled milk? One feels many citizens of India who grew up in these camps along with local Mizos and Nagas need to try to revive the spirit of that old friendship.
It would be a winning partnership; more so at a time when there is talk about “tolerance”. In these Assam Rifles’ camps, youngsters who grew up in the 1970s and 1980s perhaps understood very little about intellectually superlative words like “tolerance” and “democracy”, but we all lived together in harmony basking in each other’s success and unequivocally mourning the loss of lives.
(ends)

Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Who will have the last laugh in Bihar?


There was a time when reference to the phrase ‘an Egyptian election’ meant polls in which results are known before the votes are polled. In circa 2015 things have changed a little. In recent elections this year, the fact that Egyptians seemed not to be voting - but were tweeting in big numbers - was itself mocked with hashtag - Twitter Parliament.

Closer home about Bihar elections, results would be out on November 8, if Facebook, Twitter and media in Delhi and a section of English paper journos and experts in TV studios are to be counted, BJP has already lost the polls. 


The heaviest baggage in this world chiefly for media and intellectuals – in whatever form they are looked upon – is the pre-conceived notion. 

This clouded mindset or ‘notion’ is now the steam pushing Twitter/Facebook wars in Bihar. It’s guiding the basic thinking process in whatever manner people look at the Bihar polls and the possible outcome. The Bihar polls is no longer about governance in Bihar, it’s about stopping a man called Narendra Damodardas Modi or to give him yet another round of booster. For some, everything this man does is sinister. That’s the level of ‘tolerance’!

Hazarding guess on who will have the last laugh in Bihar is futile and hence let me try to examine – what will happen in either of the situations!

Firstly, let’s take up the issue – what will be the implications if BJP/NDA loses and Nitish Kumar retains the ‘brilliantly fought’ battle. Brilliance for Nitish lies in wooing back his old foe Lalu Prasad and ironically for the latter - accused and convicted of infamous fodder scam. Thanks to our national ‘tolerance’ to a sickening legal system – a convicted man in a famous corruption case out on bail is lecturing the country about morality!! And he pretends to be 'rescuer' of Indian pluralism and the people of Bihar.
Blogger in an 'intolerant' snap??
So, coming back to what will happen if Modi loses. A few verdict has already come. One of them is from Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay, a senior journalist and author a book on Modi, who says quite bluntly: “Regardless of the Bihar verdict, the Modi story, as it was anticipated, is facing a danger of nearing its end”.
He feels Modi will either way tilt towards Hindutva core ideology and less towards right economic decisions. 
Secondly, I feel, a Modi loss will create a hyped image of Nitish Kumar-Lalu Prasad duo to anchor anti-BJP forces. So in 2019, who will be opposition candidate for Prime Ministership – Nitish? Lalu Prasad? And then what happens to crown prince Rahul Gandhi, who took to the streets on November 3, along with his mom Sonia and hundreds of ‘yes men and women’? Renuka Chowdhury, a former NTR loyalist, walks away with the talent search prize from the march.

What would happen to ambitions of Mamata Banerjee, who is set to win Bengal yet again? What about Mulayam Singh or Mayawati? 

But it goes without saying, election outcome in Bihar will be critical to certain political developments in the country. 
Bihar election results could be actually a prelude to Uttar Pradesh, a state with nearly population of 200 million, and where elections are due by March 2017.

Bihar also represents a state in transition where young voters may prove pundits wrong and defy caste idioms. Or as I joke with Bihari friends and my brother-in-law -- "will Biharis be Biharis" yet again?

A VHP leader who campaigned aggressively during last one month says Amit Shah’s strategies are well thought of. 
“It tries to penetrate deep into people’s mind which is caught between poverty and often desire for quick wealth, traditional values and modernity, caste idiom and religious polarization and ultimately about people’s agonies, scarcity, issues of governance and aspirations”.
Will he wake up?
Can Shah’s formula work is the question for them?

In case, Modi romps home with 130 seats in NDA’s kitty – what will be the implications?
The worst impact – as a known Modi bhakt in social networking sites – I would presume is that status quo would prevail and Arun Jaitley will continue to be the Finance Minister. My worst fear is not much reform oriented steps and policy decisions will come then!
Modi may also feel that to win election in states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, you need the noise over beef and that transcends communal polarization and counters the complex web of caste. So, we may have few more sound bytes from the likes of Sakshi Maharaj and who knows – even Mahesh Sharma (another noise maker over Dadri lynching) could think of seeing himself as the next chief minister of Uttar Pradesh.

In case Modi-Shah duo wins Bihar, there would be another important message that RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat’s quota controversy could not deprive Modi yet another feather in the cap.
Expecting how things can turn upon these fronts, two former BJP presidents Rajnath Singh and M Venkaiah Naidu have already backed the idea of yet another term as party chief for Amit Shah. Is this aimed at preventing Nitin Gadkari, Bhagwat's blue eyed boy, taking over BJP reins yet again?