Thursday, October 15, 2015

Narendra Modi and Sanjiv Bhatt: Backtrack to Future Tense


The Supreme Court has nailed Sanjiv Bhatt, but probably he does deserve sympathy.

This blog is about two people. One politician and the Prime Minister of India and the other a Gujarat cop - now dismissed. From a reader’s perspective there are always different ways of looking at a blogger. On the other hand, bloggers too preserve their rights and prejudices too.
Narendra Modi has been a politician, a chief protagonist of my three books on his state and him – 'Godhra – A Journey to Mayhem' (published 2004), ‘Modi to Moditva – An Uncensored Truth’ (2012) and ‘CM to PM - Narendra Modi' (a joint work with a Delhi-based publisher in 2013). But Modi was never a friend though I had always admired him for certain traits as an administrator in Gujarat and as a 'grounded' leader who looked decisive on many matters chiefly working on developmental projects. 

On the other hand, Sanjiv Bhatt was a good friend and more a 'good source' in Gujarat police when I was deputed by Press Trust of India (PTI) there to cover the year’s toughest assignment the post-Godhra mayhem of 2002.


I always believed Sanjiv or our 'Sanjiv Sahab' never lied to me. I will continue to cherish this belief. 

But on October 13, 2015, none other than the Supreme Court of India had choicest of words and phrases for him.
“We are not impressed by aforesaid submissions. It cannot be said that the petitioner (Sanjiv Bhatt) has come to this Court with clean hands,” the court of Chief Justice of India H L Dattu and Justice Arun Mishra ruled.

I continued to be in a mystified stage as the reports of the court proceedings came in. Of course, I knew from 2009-10 that Sanjiv Bhatt was perhaps erroneous in his handling of the entire episode wherein he had filed an affidavit claiming Modi as Chief Minister of Gujarat told select few senior police officials (on February 27, 2002) that the Hindu rioters should be allowed to avenge the injustice of Godhra train inferno.
Other police officials, including the then DGP K Chakravarthy had denied that Sanjiv Bhatt had attended such a meeting. There was no police record to substantiate Sanjiv's claims too. The official version being – he was too junior to be summoned for such a high-level meeting. 
Godhra's charred train and Modi: Feb 27, 2002
Despite regarding him a friend and ‘reliable source’ – to use a journalistic cliche – I was somehow not convinced about Sanjiv Bhatt’s version. I was often ridiculed in the established-secular lobby of New Delhi and Ahmedabad journalism for my ‘not trusting’ a friend and backing a Hinduva leader, Namo.

I probably went by my instincts and thought Sanjiv Bhatt must have fallen into some wrong hands. The official claim that Sanjiv Bhatt was too junior to attend such a meeting somehow worked in me. One reason for the same being, only ‘trusted’ senior cops would be convened for a high-level meeting with a Chief Minister. I knew from my experience in Nagaland, mere seniority does not make you win a Chief Minister’s trust. S C Jamir, the former Nagaland Chief Minister and the present Odisha Governor, had tutored me a few tricks of running an administration!

So my argument was: even if Sanjiv Bhatt was authorized to go to such a meeting (in the absence of his senior), there was no surety the Chief Minister would trust a junior fellow. To say that Sanjiv Bhatt did not know this would be wrong again!
Nevertheless, the detailed ruling from the apex court of the land and that too telling in as many words that  Sanjiv Bhatt has used ‘media card’ and was only a tool to Modi’s political detractors was a sad affair overall.

The court had ruled, “He (Sanjiv) had exchanged  e-mails with rival political party leaders and was being tutored by the  lawyer of NGO and its activist. Ghost questions and answers were also prepared as to what the petitioner was required to speak before Justice Nanavati Commission. Petitioner has used the media card, has even sent the e-mails to influence the judicial proceedings of a  3-Judge Bench of this Court (Supreme Court) and has tried to influence the amicus  curiae. The e-mails also indicate that he tried pressure groups and  tried to invoke media pressure”.

I felt let down. 
Did Sanjiv use some of his media friends too and needless to add as basking in the ‘glory’ of being one-man against Modi – Sanjiv’s friend circles in media had changed by then. His onetime ‘babu moshai from Mumbai’ (this blogger) was hardly in the inner circle! And thus during December 2012 election campaign for the state assembly, my interaction with Sanjiv Bhatt – when his wife Shweta was contesting against Modi from Maninagar assembly segment - was minimum and more of a courtesy meeting.

Sanjiv’s friends now were high flying journos, TV anchors and Padmasri awardees!
On October 14, a day after the apex court ruling, I confided in my wife and few close friends in Delhi and Mumbai and also with one special friend on Facebook that overall it was a ‘sad’ affair. Sanjiv has been slammed – this time not by BJP’s battery of spokespersons but by the Supreme Court itself. And if Sanjiv sahab had any ‘media card’ – our profession has been misused.

I have stated earlier of the apprehension I had about him falling into ‘wrong hands’ – for essentially I thought and many journalists who have served in Ahmedabad would believe that he was a sharp cop.
In my book ‘Modi to Moditva – An Uncensored Truth’, I traced a few fond memories of his genuine friendship and helping me in discharge of my duties as a journalist for a highly demanding wire agency Press Trust of India (PTI).
A Derailed bus!
But, I am afraid, one cannot sympathise with him further. So, rather one is convinced to take the harsh but candid line of a noisy TV anchor that ‘the credibility of Sanjiv Bhatt is over’. This is perhaps a big casualty of the 2002 Godhra train inferno and the subsequent politics perpetrated from either side.

On a broader larger scale, what angers me most is the gross abuse of police force, IPS cadre and a brilliant police officer – despite his temperamental and other issues – by Modi detractors. This judgement of the Supreme Court, according to me, has made our friend Sanjiv Bhatt the Man-of-the-year 2015 – of course with the sad elements attached to it.

Is Sanjiv Bhatt it a case of abuse of a ‘weakest’ link by Congress party and the NGO brigade?

We know in contest of un-equals or unbalanced confrontation, like the story of David and Goliath; the weakest has to outsmart the strongest. My friend just could not. Who can outsmart the political class as a group? 
We might see a morrow, wherein Narendra Modi and Sonia Gandhi would join hands – solve national problems and share power and the limelight together; where will be my helpless friend then? He will not approve of what I am stating. My friend, Sanjiv sahab is still active in social networking. He has the right to do so. But he needs to pull himself back for a while. And I sincerely feel so, more in my personal capacity.
(ends)

Tail Piece:

Sanjiv Bhatt would still sit in some corner and probably tell himself and his wife – “the cause I am fighting is bigger than me”, as he had told TV journalists in 2011 after he was released from prison for being arrested in a related case. 

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

Subhas Bose Mystery: Between ‘Past lies’ and ‘Future Truth’ remains an ‘Uncomfortable Present’


In the dirty world of politics it seems, Narendra Modi’s single most important quality is to remain methodical in unnerving the Congress party and shake their hitherto untouched ‘dynasty’. 
The return of ‘Subhas Bose mystery’ in the national debate – at least for next few months – till January 23, 2016 actually endorses the theory that contemporary Indian history was badly rigged. It was manipulated in favour of one particular family, one particular political party and one particular political thinking – Left of Centre – if someone wants to call it. 

In Gulzar’s famous film ‘Machis’, based on Punjab terrorism, one key protagonist attributes his reason of joining terrorism or violent cult of politics to a question he had faced many a times during his school days, “tell the class, who brought Indian independence”. That’s precisely the way post-Indian independence history has been written and taught. The sole goal being: glorifying one family and give entire credit to one ‘surname’ Gandhi! It’s ironical the dynastic power transferred to Nehru-Gandhi dynasty as a strategic master stroke and there by my Class IV daughter needs to be told, who is Rajmohan Gandhi; but knows the likes of Rahul and Priyanka!

Extract from Anuj Dhar's book
Let’s face another facet of country’s struggle for independence. It’s the glorification of a half-hearted episode called Quit India movement. “Many Indians still do not want to accept and perhaps never will that, that the ‘failed’ INA military onslaught and the Red Fort trials of 1945-46 , and not Quit India movement, majorly impacted the British decision to quit India,” writes Anuj Dhar, a die-hard Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose admirer, in his highly appreciable book ‘India’s Biggest Cover Up’.

Taking the discussions further, we need to examine, how was Pt Jawaharlal Nehru’s basic treatment to Subhas Bose episode? He time and again rejected demand for a probe and repeatedly accepted the well-run theory that “Subhas Bose’s death is correct”. But there were certain facets and traits that made others comment not so favourably on Nehru. Sri Chinmony, an India-born spiritual leader who passed away in 2007 in the US, had said, “even regarding Netaji’s plane crash and death, Nehru’s own public pronouncement contradicted each other."
Namo with Bose kin: Oct 14, 2015
Even Nehru suffered from uncertainty nights or perhaps he deliberately wished to mould reality-day in his own way! …God only knows if Nehru deliberately misrepresented the truth or if he himself was a captive of uncertainty”, he had said further.
While Congress-dynasty retainer-variety politicians P R Dasmunshi (now ailing) and Shivraj Patil quickly dumped Mukherjee Commission report on the Netaji’s death mystery and sought to glorify Nehru’s defence of INA personnel during Red Fort trial; Nehru had categorically rejected demand by West Bengal assembly for a probe into Netaji mystery in 1952. 
“The state government should be informed that we have taken all steps that was possible for us…” he had responded after Dr Atindranath Bose on 6 Aug, 1952, told west Bengal assembly the demand for a probe into Netaji’s death was “a very faint echo of a national desire which is surging in the heart of Bengal”. 

Bose Kin called Oct 14 'an Independence Day'
There’s another major contradictions and albeit hypocrisy in the manner post-independent India behaved with Netaji and his followers.
“The ‘free’ India government remained hostile to Subhas Bose,” says Dhar in his book. In 1948, Nehru told Parliament that the INA men would have no place in the Indian army. (To reinstate them would lead to many complications….--- was the official version).
Worse in 1949, Army Headquarters issued a circular against displaying the picture of Subhas Bose at permanent places in canteens, quarters etc”.
The Defence ministry also maintained that the history of INA should not be published lest it should affect the moral of the soldiers.

As late as 2005, the Home Minister Shivraj Patil said Mukherjee Commission probing Netaji mystery was wasting government money; -- the Congress desperation is a story to be looked into.
So, have I tried to raise a few right questions? 
In Congress parlance up to this day, ironically despite the worst defeat in Congress history in 2014 and the party routed to ‘zero’ or near zero in many states including the national capital, the Nehru-Indira-Sonia family is sadly the only master after God. 
Even Jinnah was victimised!
The Congressmen and women and their secular (read SICKULAR) ‘Cahoots’ tend to believe in their sheer self justification that, - If we believe in the Family and show loyalty we cannot be guilty. But the spirit of salvation is linked to a desperation.  
Thus, the desperation against Narendra Modi is understandable and this can be linked to fantastically orchestrated writers’ protest as none of these supposed intellectuals had in the past questioned or lamented over the wrong doings/happenings during the Congress regime in last 60 years. My understanding is Netaji kin meeting with PM Modi was announced well in advance and thus in a manner the Congress gameplan was ‘attack’ is a way of defence.
Beneficiary: But how long?
"The new strategy of anti-Modi, anti-BJP sections appears to be to resort to 'politics by other means'," Finance Minister Arun Jaitley wrote in his blog piece very aptly. 
In one of my blogs last year, I had said, by focusing on Nehru's brighter spots and virtues - including knowledge of English, good rapport with Britons like Lord Mountbatten to Sir Stafford Cripps and later his role in stewarding free India, scholars have only judged him softly with kids gloves. On the other hand, circumstances have compelled two others Subhas Bose and Mohammed Ali Jinnah to be judged rather harshly. Time for course correction has come, may be.

But the noisy television media has a point this time. "If Netaji was alive after air crash and if Nehru knew about it....Nehru would stand guilty".
(ends)

Tail Piece:

Courtesy: Dhar's book 'India's Best Cover Up'

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

Dadri and aftermath: A case of Catalytic SICKULARISM


Ignorance, prejudices and fear have triumphed over reason and knowledge. This is new India. Modern. Liberal and certainly "secular", even as - to use that journalistic cliche - SICKULAR.
Indians – both Hindus and Muslims (and also others) – might have been surprised over Dadri. But did they have reason to be shocked? The hate politics has taken over the country. An overwhelming section of political class and even the self-styled champion of neo-liberal-national spirit of India, the media, quickly passed the verdict against the right wing BJP and RSS for the same. Prime Minister Narendra Modi did not do any service to himself by delaying his "comments" on Dadri. 

On the other hand, the RSS and its affiliated organizations say the appeasement politics (towards minorities) has hardened the unity and fundamentalism among the Hindus. 
Speechless Gau-mata
Thus the lynching of a 50-year-old old man, father of a Air Force personnel, made news. Importantly, the victim was a Muslim and the pretext was rumour of a cow slaughter. This brought in quick 'TOURISM' element to Dadri.

The ‘#Beefydebate’ as highlighted in the social networking sites has remained and would continue as ‘competitive’ communal politics surfaced over the incident. Azam Khan was in competition against Asaduddin Owaissi, one-time Hyderabad MP and now trying to establish toe-holds in at least two 'cow-belt' states.
Lalu Prasad, out on bail after being convicted for corruption in fodder (cow's food) scam, is not only teaching morality. He also said, Hindus eat beef.
In Kerala, where a self-styled sickular lot like in West Bengal thrive in lampooning at anything Hindu and India, beef parties were organised. Where's the word - provocation?

Incidentally the forensic reports later claimed that the meat in the deceased Akhlaq Ahmed fridge at Dadri village not far from national capital was mutton and not beef.
His wife Ikrana lamented that the case against her family was fabricated. She wants the government now to find the truth behind the murder. Predictably all these were linked to Bihar polls and also easily concluded that the saffron brigade had orchestrated it to salvage NDA boat once RSS chief played spoilsport to Narendra Modi's electoral journey of electoral success by playing the anti-quota politics.
But the sudden reactions from writers’ fraternity added a new drama. It was well orchestrated. First a Jawaharlal Nehru kin - Nayantara Sehgal said she is returning Sahitya Akademi award because India has become so intolerant. The connection is lost on me as it would to Rabindranath Tagore also. The Nobel laureate had returned Knighthood – given by the Britons – to protest Jallianwallah Bagh. Here none of the awardees got the prize during Modi regime. But when dictates come from elsewhere or is motivated by a campaign, reasons have no place. Forty other writers joined her -- some in groups, some individually -- clearing leaving a mark that it was pre-planned. 

The operation 'let us nail Modi' – in writers manner had one agenda: present a gory picture of India when the Modi government is desperate to set the economy on right track. And, so much of the ‘tolerance’ of these writers, the moment Chetan Bhagat flayed their move – the quick judgement was passed again: Chetan Bhagat is no William Shakespeare ! My analogy is simpler: SICKULARISM ZINDABAD.

Thy hand: Anarchy

Thursday, October 8, 2015

Review on Jairam Ramesh’s new book : ‘To the Brink and Back – India’s 1991 story’


Politicians earn celebrity status for many reasons. Books become bestsellers for many reasons too. Jairam Ramesh is a man of many hats. He is of course a dynamo of activity. The Congress leader is in news these days for his book ‘To the Brink and Back – India’s 1991 story’. Notably, during 1991 turbulent period of economic crisis, Jairam was appointed in the PMO under P V Narasimha Rao but was later shunted out to the Planning Commission as OSD in September 1991. 
In his own words, “I was convinced that I was being sacked. What  baffled me completely was that just forty eight hours back, the Prime Minister had asked me to attend his meetings”.

There are dozens of books on contemporary politics penned by those who rule and see things unfold from the other side of the table – the former babus, former ministers and so on. That’s another debate. But Jairam’s book in focus will be considered an exception for couple of reasons. One is Jairam, an ambitious Congress neta, still has many more years to go and thus his offering and more so the timing of it is actually strategic. The book perhaps would help Jairam to position himself in intra-party politics of Congress and those of us who still doubted his role in 1991 revolution called liberalizing India’s economy. Thus, one is not surprised that the book is in first person with deliberate emphasis more than once.

Secondly, and that’s perhaps more importantly, he wants to give a good impression to P V Narasimha Rao admirers in Andhra Pradesh that he (Jairam Ramesh) was close to the then Prime Minister. A man with fantastic journalistic instinct, Ramesh generally speaks highly of Rao and also admits that “Rao-Manmohan Singh duo happened to be at the right place at the right time”. As a reviewer/blogger I also do not grudge when he says, “They (Rao and Dr Manmohan Singh) had neither bargained nor lobbied for the responsibilities they found themselves with…”.
But as a writer, he has been perhaps economical with truth at certain places as he dwells minimum how Narasimha Rao was later ill-treated by the Congress party. For reasons, we understand clearly, Jairam also focused less on the dynasty’s role vis-à-vis the treatment meted out to Rao. Jairam is forthright in his assessment of the former PM, whom press unhesitatingly crowned as being Chanakya; when he writes, “Rao was a complex personality…”. 
Blogger and journo Manish: Never in Jairam inner circle
But his take: “I was simply in no position to know what went wrong between him and his own party….” remains an unacceptable nugget of information. No Congressman can stir the hornet's nest. Moreover, Jairam is fond of being understood in party circle as someone close to Rahul Gandhi and thus as Environment Minister he worked so closely with Congress vice president that everywhere Rahul was supposed to go, environment clearance did not come.

Monday, October 5, 2015

North East Women Employment – Knocking at Traditional Bastion

Sailing through rough seas has been the norm for Indian women. However, in the North-east, they are respected, unlike their counterparts in many other parts of the country. Traditionally women there have been equal partners in running households as well as holding the purse. In fact, in Meghalaya it’s a role reversal as Khasis, Garos and Jaintias practice a matrilineal system.

But in terms of measuring the North-eastern womenfolk’s true potentials and contribution to the village economy, there is a need for an understanding of the complex and dynamic challenges they face. Rural womenfolk, as also men in the region, are often faced with a situation in which revenue or income from traditional sources has declined or, at best, is reaching saturation point. Government jobs are simply evaporating and thus there has to be a good synthesis of modern education and traditional qualities and aptitudes. 
Women: Power and Responsibility
Competition has grown manifold and at times there is the pressure to avoid the traditional working system. There are also issues of infrastructure, poor roads and  unsafe law and order situations.

Even in tribal-dominated states like Nagaland and Mizoram, where social respectability of rural  tribal women is much higher than their counterparts elsewhere, limited access to assets, punctuated with lack of bargaining power, constitute significant economic disadvantages.

Nagaland and Mizoram are notable exceptions to the rule because till date they have not elected a woman legislator. However, over the years government initiatives and various schemes charted out at both the Central and state levels have helped improve the chances of employment for rural womenfolk.

“The government of India under Prime Minister Narendra Modi recognises the importance of the role of women in the development of society, rural India and growth of the nation. We remain committed to give a high priority to women’s empowerment and welfare,” says Union rural development minister Chaudhary Birender Singh.

In fact, the ministry is implementing various poverty-alleviation and rural development programmes that, as always, involve special components for women. Some of the guidelines stipulate certain provisions for the creation of specific facilities at the worksites for women. For instance, to encourage more women to work under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, the ministry has rightly suggested that individual bank/post office accounts be opened in their names and that their wages be directly credited to their accounts for the number of days worked.
Naga shawls: Money spinner
The Centre has also advised states to identify widowed, deserted and destitute women who qualify as a household under the Act to ensure they are provided 100 days of work. Similarly, several schemes are tailor-made in various states to encourage women’s employment, especially in the rural sector. 

In the process, we can safely conclude that the progress and development of any nation or society is also depended on the social and economical position of women. In this context, it is also relevant to understand that the “participation of women in economic activity” only highlights the quality of employment.  At the same time, these also bring into focus the powerful relevance of self-employment; and this aspect is often qualitatively a better option to change the face of the North-east. The handloom and handicrafts sectors have played game-changers in these realms. So also the involvement of women in agri and horticulture, at both the production and marketing levels.

In fact, in Meghalaya, Tripura, Mizoram, Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh horticulture is a chief occupation among a large section of people, especially womenfolk. Across India there’s an abundance of fruits. With more than 28.2 million tonnes of fruit and 66 million tonnes of vegetables, the country ranks as the second largest producer of these items in the world.

In fact, more innovative experiments are being conducted to tap the potentials of fruits and fresh suggestions are pouring in. In some North-east states, since moderate consumption of wine is considered part of culture and good for health, wine-making is being looked upon as an industry. In fact, Meghalaya organises wine festivals in idyllic Shillong with the enthusiastic participation of women.

Switching over to this practice with the support of modern technology can help North-east enthusiasts to make a fast buck, exhibit their skills and even sell surplus local fruit. 
(ends)

Sunday, October 4, 2015

EX-CAG Vinod Rai was denied opportunity to work in Nagaland in 1972


Ex-CAG Vinod Rai’s book: An eye opener that crushed my Vanity  

Perhaps the only way of dealing with volumes of information – facts and fictions, rumours and truth and probably life and death – ‘Information Overload’ for a journalist is to read. And read more ! I got hold of former CAG Vinod Rai’s book ‘Not Just An Accountant: The Diary of Nation’s Conscience Keeper’ --- only recently.
And the first glance at the book, which was published in 2014 left me pleasantly surprised. The book to me now stands as an eye opener vis-à-vis my knowledge about Nagaland! Yes, I mean it. My vanity about knowledge of Naga people and the state of Nagaland is crushed ! 
This was for someone like born, brought up and also had baptism into journalism in Nagaland. Till one has glanced through the pages of Rai’s first chapter ‘Dimapur to Delhi’, there was a perception that we knew most - if not all things - about Nagaland! 

Book Extracts

One is not saying this to pass any adverse remarks on either Rai or Nagaland.  
Vinod Rai, who from 2010 to 2014 hit headlines almost on daily basis, was originally a Nagaland cadre official. And can you take it, his stint in the Naga hills was cut short or in other words had never began as the Nagaland government in 1972 had then “not agreed to accept them in the Nagaland cadre”.

“That year (1972),” writes Rai “Nagaland had no insiders among the successful candidates; all five of us were from the outsider category. The government of Nagaland, a Congress-led ministry with Hokishe Sema as Chief Minister, was of the view that the state, which had only three districts at that time, could accommodate only two or three officers in a batch”. Well, as stated above Rai’s was not alone.

“Five IAS (Indian Administrative Service) probationers reported to Dimapur railway station (today). Since the state government has not agreed to accept them in the Nagaland cadre, they have been directed to go back and report to the department of personnel, Government of India,” says Rai’s book which otherwise throws light on the CAG statistics and figures vis-à-vis probe into government functioning and much to the discomfort of the then Manmohan Singh regime.

Here’s another coincidence! How many of us – journos and ivory tower experts – covering Nagaland did bother to know that R S Pandey, former Nagaland Chief Secretary, was in that group of five.
Pandey later became union Petroleum Secretary under Prime Minister Dr Singh and post-retirement was taken in as government’s chief negotiator in Naga peace talks. In the run up to the 2014 Lok Sabha polls, Pandey quit as the peace interlocutor and joined BJP. Denied ticket in Lok Sabha polls, Pandey is now all set for electoral contest in the ensuing assembly elections in Bihar.
Three other officers were A.P Sharma, Ravi Dhingra and N.G Laloo.

The book then talks about the five officers meeting with their senior colleague, Binod Kumar, who later became Home Commissioner under S C Jamir stint around the time in later eighties and early nineties – I was in Kohima dreaming of becoming a journo, -- na, the so called ‘ivory tower experts’.
This volume and the pages in the book has left yet another lesson for me that things keep coming circling back. The five officials also had interacted with the then Chief Secretary (1972) H Zopianga – a local Naga official whom Vinod Rai rightly describes as “exceedingly gentle and warm person”.
At a later stage, we knew Zopianga through his daughter Banu Z Jamir, who also joined IAS, and her husband Alemtemshi Jamir, who at one-point under S C Jamir earned for himself the 'compliment of being called 'Additional Chief Minister'. 

Blogger in Northeast
But the Chief Secretary Zopianga had explained to Rai and his friends about state government’s stand. Thus, in the words of Rai, “we (let’s call them Famous Five) were in no man’s land, figuratively and, in fact, even literally. We had been allotted a cadre which refused to accept us, were effectively unemployed and without pay, far from home….”.
Then he recalls the “stay of uncertainty” in police mess lasted for 53 days till the Prime Minister Indira Gandhi intervened and advised the Chief Minister (Hokishe Sema) to accept the officials for training period and that after the training three of these officials could be shifted to other states.
Rai then pens some wonderful lines on his training in remote Tuensang district along with another compatriot, R S Pandey. The visit to Angh’s village and home in Konyak Naga tribal belt were equally interesting as they got the first glimpse of ‘a collection of skulls’ in Angh’s (village chief’s) house. Want to read more on these and the famous ambush on another IAS officer K K Gupta of 1969 batch – please switch over to the page-turner.
Before, I conclude, I must add, as assured by Indira Gandhi – Rai was later shifted to Kerala cadre. And the coincidence is less than baffling: 
“I was a trifle baffled to find a glass of pale yellow liquid on Menon’s table (then Kerala Chief Secretary KPK Menon). Coming from Tuensang in Nagaland, where the redoubtable John F Halliday (Mizo officer and DC Tuensang in 1972) started his early lunch with a glass of beer, I had not expected to witness the same trend in distant Kerala”.
Well, oh boy! The game did not end with this. 
Vinod Rai could only realize at a later stage that: ‘contents of that glass’ in Kerala was perhaps different. “People of Kerala prefer to boil their drinking water (to make it safe for consumtion) and add some flavor to it…”.

Wrap UP:

I generally tend to endorse T N Seshan’s definition of ‘IAS’ cadre – I am Sorry! This is how actually I tease my class mate (fellow St Anthonian, Shillong) – Palungthang Vaiphei, Manipur cadre. Of the ‘civil servants’ I have also read: they are servants to devil and civil to everyone. In my analysis, I presume ideologies and practical political compulsions often leave our civil servants puzzled. 

They could be good men/women and perhaps also not so too good as individuals. But in the end, they do reflect the country and the state(s) they serve, and importantly the times and the society they lived in. Each IAS officer must have had dreams, some achieve it, and perhaps most do not - like us, the working journalists. 
Likes of Vinod Rai end up turning into fighters against corruption fungus at least as an auditor; R S Pandeys leave ‘peace parleys’ half-ways. In journalism, my friends quit the profession and embrace more soothing world of ‘public relation firms’. Some seniors craze to end up in the din of Rajya Sabha.
But the ultimate story is, --- no one is born for hatred or heroics. Only time decides that.
 (ends) 

Friday, October 2, 2015

The Beefy debate: Pouring out all anti-Namo Anger

I start with a proclamation: The 'Indian secularism' is a political ploy and already like a tattered garment, let us not make it worse.
 

Cow: Motherly love
"Svetlana found it harder and harder to recognize her husband. Over just a few months, he had become another man, although with the same features and body; he seemed inhabited by another being, a mean, grumpy character who spoke and behaved in ways that were not typical of the old Volodia." - 

Extracts from 'Farewell: The Greatest Spy Story of the Twentieth century'— by Sergei Kostin and Eric Raynaud

(Let us change Svetlana with 'Indian people' and the words 'husband or old Volodia' with 'Indian SICKULAR media' and perhaps our understanding of all the issues involved will be clearer.) 
We would know how the 'features' and 'body' have changed and there's another being in the room.
MS CEO Nadella and Namo

Indian media rather sickular media's hatred for Narendra Modi is no secret. But this hatred is slowly giving in to DESPERATION.....Whenever Modi is on a 'good drive' especially abroad....sickulars display their true colour. Prime Minister's recent visit to the US had shaken the SICKULAR CLUB yet again.....so they worked overtime on how Modi dragged Facebook owner Mark Zuckerberg, how someone called Satya Nadella, Microsoft CEO, wiped his hands after shaking hands with Namo.Then came Dadri.....and oh boy......what an issue!! Sickular army has hit the jackpot.
The verdict is passed BJP, RSS and Hindutva crusaders are responsible and of course the prime accused will be Narendra Modi.
A section of media gave unto itself the role even to lampoon at the Hindi press.
And more precisely, this brings me into writing this blog.
The campaign is near success of Teesta-Sanjiv Bhatt variety when Zaheeras and a shocked tailor are or were forgotten. Here the mandate is again quite clear - BJP is responsible and perhaps that's why Modi is silent. The lamb and the fox story - retold!

The REAL SUCCESS OF #Beefy campaign is not the justice for ill-fated victim, incidentally also a father of an Air Force man deputed in Chennai. It's the bigger message that polarized Hindu India would deprive Muslims and Christians their staple food. Will foreign investment come in?
The lynching of the 50-year-old man to death is certainly condemn-able, but where's the local police - their accountability and the elected government of Uttar Pradesh run by socialists and also 'champion of secularism'? 
Some Hindi papers headlines

None seem to ask these questions. That is deliberate among the political class not to raise it. BSP supremo Mayawati, who once championed the cause of Dalits, has of course questioned the role of Samajwadi Party government - she has her reasons because her Lok Sabha strength is now zero. The conspiracy theory of a not so hidden agenda between BJP and Samajwadi Party of Mulayam Singh would ensure that BSP (read messiahs of Dalits in UP) turns into pages of history. Or is there a 'her-story' brewing? Who would rule out BJP-BSP alliance in future in UP? Past records say - they have stuck deals earlier !
In neighbouring Bihar, Modi's BJP has stuck deals with not one -- but two Dalit-based parties.
The moot point is: I am not saying Dadri lynching should be forgotten as an 'accident'. It ought to be probed simply because even 'routine type road accidents' are also probed or investigated - at least on papers.

Always An Hindutva protagonist! 

Instead what is coming out is reflection of influence of some kind of --- psychological conditioning…..Are all intellectuals and those showing liberal wings are administered drugs? I say this because without seeking reasonable explanation, SICKULAR INDIANS have poured out all the anger accumulated for months. Will it help improve the condition on ground zero? Did lampooning at Modi for reasons -- from 2002 mayhem and even so called snooping over an individual - helped the cause of 'secularism' in India? Could that prevent Narendra Damodardas Modi become Prime Minister of India? In fact, just the opposite happens. Thanks to Dadri lynching Mahesh Sharma could emerge a key political leader in UP in months to come. 
Secularism as being propagated by the likes of communists, Mamata Banerjees and of course ‘virtuous’ Congress is actually a booster dose to promote COMMUNAL-ISM.
It all had started in 1970s when Indira Gandhi played the appeasement card. The constitutional amendment ensured ‘Secularism’ need not be practiced in public or private life. Rather it can be badge of being Congress and even a right to become Prime Minister of India even if the intellect and personality was akin to illustrious poor farmer H D Deve Gowda! Meghnad Desai writes acidly: “India became officially secular just when it ceased to be so in practice”. (The Rediscovery of India).

Now, even as there’s no central law or states-specific law explicitly banning consumption of beef, cow slaughter is prohibited in UP, Delhi, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab and Rajasthan. In Assam and West Bengal slaughter of cows of over the ages of 10 and 14 years, respectively is permissible. Most Indian states prohibit the slaughter of calves, whether male or female. 
In northeast India, beef is considered staple food. But as someone born and brought up in northeast, I must say, never beef eating or for that even pork eating is a social issue. Tribals and especially Nagas, I am sharing from my personal experience, would be virtually apologetic when they invite non-Nagas to their large kitchen and say, “sorry, you can have your fish; I will need my pork and beef”. There’s need to understand – food habits as something directly linked to geographical and economic conditions. In coastal states like West Bengal, even Durga Puja celebration is not complete without fish cutlet every evening ‘not very far from pandals’.
Let us ensure, the wrong doers are booked and no Dadri recurs! The onus is certainly on the Prime Minister to show that perpetrators of such gory episodes will be brought to justice.
ends