A little bit more than patriotism. A little bit lower than jingoism. --- Nirendra Dev
Tuesday, August 16, 2011
Anna's arrest leave Congress nervous: Opposition unite
The Congress nervousness over Anna Hazare arrest is crystal clear.
The parliamentary strategy of the ruling party was to disallow the opposition members speak on the issue even after the chairs in both the Houses allowed the respective leaders of the opposition to speak on the arrest.
Both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha had to be
adjourned for the day on August 16 amid noisy protests from both the
opposition and treasury benches over the detention of activist Anna Hazare and his associates.
Uproar erupted in the Lok Sabha immediately after the house assembled
for the day's business, with the opposition led by BJP protesting
Hazare's detention by Delhi Police earlier in the morning. Other NDA
members were also supporting them.
The opposition MPs, while terming the government's move as
undemocratic and unjustified, demanded the suspension of the question
hour to take up a full-fledged debate on the issue.
Shouting anti-government slogans, opposition members demanded an
explanation from the UPA government for detaining the crusader and
hundreds of his supporters ahead of their peaceful protest to press for a stronger Lokpal bill.
As soon as the House met, the Speaker Ms Meira Kumar informed the
House that suspension of Question Hour notices had been given by
Leader of the Opposition Ms Sushma Swaraj, CPI leader Mr Gurudas
Dasgupta and JD(U) member Mr Sharad Yadav among others. She also said
BJP's Yogi Adityanath and Shailendra Kumar of SP had given separate
notices of adjournment of House proceedinsg to discuss Hazare and UP
matters. She ruled that the notices were rejected but allowed the
Leader of the Opposition and others to speak for a while on Hazare's
arrest.
Immediately after Ms Sushma Swaraj was on her feet, the Parliamentary
Affairs minister Mr P K Bansal said the discussion should be taken up
after 12 pm. He said the opposotion members after making their
submission disrupt the house and thus do not allow the government to
have its say.
Amid ruckus, the House was first adjourned till 11.30 and then again
till 12 noon.
However, after 12 as the Speaker called for laying down of papers, the
opposition members including Ms Sushma Swaraj, and her party
colleagues including Mr Yashwant Sinha, Shahnawaz Hussain, Yogi
Adityanath were up on their feet demanding that Ms Swaraj should be
allowed to speak.
Mr Bansal, however, argued that the Speaker's ruling for the time for
opposition members was confined only during Question Hour. This
angered the opposition bench members' further.
The Parliamentary Affairs Minister insisted that if Swaraj is allowed
to speak, the Home Minister should also be allowed to make a
statement.
Agitated members of BJP, JD(U), CPI-M, CPI, SP and BSP were on their
feet objecting to Mr Bansal's comments.
A few Congress members also sprang up on their feet. Among others, Mr
Satpal Maharaj and Mr Sanjay Nirupam were leading the charge
on behalf of the Congress. Mr Sanjay Nirupam said his party was
objecting to opposition parties supporting those going against
democracy.
The Leader of the Opposition, Ms swaraj charged that the same
yardstick was being applied by the government both inside and outside
parliament to suppress the voice of its opponents.
Amid bedlam, the Speaker then adjourned the House for the day.
Similar noisy scenes prevailed in Rajya Sabha too.
The Congress members prevented Leader of the Opposition in the upper
House, Mr Arun Jaitley from making a statement on the
detention of Anna Hazare and forced adjournment of the House first till noon.
When Chairman Mr Hamid Ansari took up the first question as soon as
the House met for the day, Mr. Jaitley rose to make a statement.
“Let us hear the Leader of the Opposition,” Mr. Ansari said as ruling
party members stood up demanding that the Question Hour be taken up
first.
At this, opposition members shouted back at the ruling benches,
plunging the House into turmoil.
The Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Mr Rajeev Shukla said
Home Minister Mr P. Chidambaram will make a statement at 12 p.m. on
the detention
of Anna Hazare.
But this failed to pacify the opposition members and the din grew
louder with ruling party members raising their pitch against Mr.
Jaitley being allowed to speak.
“This is not right. Please allow the Leader of the Opposition to
speak,” Mr. Ansari said, and asked members to resume their seats.
“Has the government decided that House will not function? Will the
government not allow the House to function?” Mr. Jaitley asked,
pointing out that the Chairman has given him the permission to speak.
“Does the ruling party want that the House should not discuss serious
issues facing the country,” he posed. “We express anguish and protest
over murder of democracy both outside the House and inside the House.
They want to murder the right to protest,” he said.
Mr Jaitley said, the detention of the 74-year-old Hazare was a "murder
of democracy", triggering protests from Congress members..
The ruckus continued and Chairman Mr Hamid Ansari first adjourned the
House till 12 noon and later for the day.
The arrest united the opposition parties today with Marxists like Sitaram Yechury and other Left colleagues D Raja and Gurudas Dasgupta responding positively to Ms Swaraj's invite for a meeting to work out the parliament
strategy.
Significantly, Samajwadi Party, which has been opposing Anna
Hazare's team hijacking the right to formulate laws, today
termed the arrest of the noted Gandhian as "unconstitutional" and said
he and his supporters should be released immediately.
"His detention is unconstitutional and if the government has any sense
left, Hazare and his supporters should be released immediately,"
party chief Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav told reporters outside Parliament here.
Mr Yadav faulted with the government and the Delhi police for picking
up Anna from his Mayur Vihar residence saying the 144CrPC was
not imposed in that area and also "there was no violence happening there".
The SP chief said the government's step has led to a situation where
"students, advocates and others have come on road to protest against
this in various parts of the country".
Asked if he supported Anna's movement, Mr Yadav merely "We have been
fighting against corruption and he is also doing the same."
The Samajwadi Party MP Mr Shailendra Kumar also attended a meeting of
opposition parties convened by Leader of the Opposition Ms Sushma
Swaraj where in a joint decision was taken to demand a statement from
the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh on the event.
RJD MP Mr Raghuvansh Prasad Singh also attended the meeting convenced
by BJP leader Ms Swaraj brushing aside his party's strong
opposition to BJP on various issues.
Earlier, in the day, the RJD supremo Mr Lalu Prasad Yadav strongly
ridiculed Anna Hazare and his team for trying to undermine the powers
of the Parliament. Counseling "patience" for the Team Anna when the
Lok Pal bill has already come before the Standing Committee of
parliament,
Mr Lalu Prasad said "fast-unto-death should be the last resort" for any protest.
"We have seen Anna's Lok Pal draft and we have told him that we will
examine it. Anna should have patience," he told reporters.
Stating that perhaps Anna Hazare is being "misguided", he said the BJP
is "fully behind the Anna stir".
Asked whether he felt that RSS was behind Hazare, Mr Lalu Prasad
answered in the affirmative. "Yes, it is."
"Anna Hazare does not have have any organisation. There must be some
organisations which are behind him," he said.
However, he said, though everyone has the right to protest in a
parliamentary democracy, it is also important that supremacy of
parliament should be upheld.
(ends)
Monday, August 8, 2011
Hit by corruption charges, PM, HM looking to score points in North East
(the following piece appeared in The Statesman, North East Page
on August 8, 2011)
nirendra dev
REELING under serious corruption charges, the UPA government is trying to win some brownie points by making a breakthrough in talks with North-east insurgent groups. The timing somehow suits beleaguered Union home minister P Chidambaram and also Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, as both are under attack for alleged financial irregularities and mismanagement and need to prove their merit one way or the other.
The Prime Minister is a Rajya Sabha member from Assam. The home minister and he are understandably under tremendous pressure after tainted former Union telecom minister A Raja named them. So if they achieve something positive — a semblance of peace (accords) — with the NSCN(IM) and Ulfa it would be like the proverbial saving grace for them. No wonder, some weeks ago in a joint statement with the NSCN(IM) the Union home ministry said differences between the two sides were “narrowing down”. No one, however, has explained how this nearly six-decade-old gulf has suddenly narrowed. The government feels the NSCN(IM) will give up its demand for sovereignty.
The selective use of phrases in the joint statement — like “proposals for an honourable political settlement based on the uniqueness of Naga history and the situation which was recognised by the government of India in 2002, as well as the contemporary realities and a future vision consistent with the imperatives of the 21st century” — is, in fact, a double-edged sword.
A section in the government feels the NSCN(IM) should be persuaded to give up its emotive demand for “Naga integration”. If this happens, the once most potent, and to some extent most credible Naga militant group, would be really treading a difficult path. The NSCN(IM) is determined to achieve this, come what may. No Naga politician worth his salt can today dare speak
against it. In fact, Nagaland chief minister Neiphiu Rio has already backed the demand.
Predictably, the United Committee of Manipur and the All Manipur United Clubs’ Organisation have accused New Delhi of driving wedges between communities in the North-east even as they slammed Rio for supporting the demand for the division of Manipur. Interestingly, Rio’s party, the Naga People’s Front, has already set up its units in Manipur’s Senapati and Ukhrul districts, ignoring objections from Manipuri organisations as well as from the Manipur government.
In 2002, the Vajpayee government formally recognised the “peculiarity and uniqueness” of Naga history. By that yardstick, there is no indication that the NSCN(IM) would even come nearer to compromise on their pet demand of Naga integration — Nagalim. In fact, it was only after the 2002 Bangkok pact between then government negotiator K Padmanabhiah and NSCN(IM) general secretary Th Muivah that the real impact of the demand for Naga integration was felt in Manipur — and Imphal Valley burnt for days.
The government was forced to withdraw the extension of the Nagaland ceasefire to Manipur.
The Centre and its current negotiator, RS Pandey, may be mounting pressure on the NSCN(IM) to appreciate the reality of 2011. One ready reference is the turmoil of 2010 when Manipur suffered immensely due to the economic blockade of its lifeline by the Kohima-based Naga Students’ Federation. In this context it is difficult to understand the real meaning of “narrowing down the differences”. The ground reality vis-à-vis the Naga political issue has been always different — something the ivory tower experts in Lutyen’s city have seldom appreciated.
No going back, they got a taste of it when in 2010 the infamous Naga-Manipuri feud was stoked by the government when it okayed the proposed visit of Muivah to his native village in Manipur in May last year without really assessing the ground reality in the state.
(ends)
The writer is The Statesman’s New Delhi-based Special Representative and author of the book, The Talking Guns: North East India
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Chamchagiri -- Or Political Googly
Congress minister likens Manmohan to 'mother'
It's chamchagiri at its height or a political googly.
Salman Khurshid, a known Sonia Gandhi loyalist, seems to be overwhelmed by
the recent allotment of key portfolio of Law and Justice to him that he chose to compare Dr Manmohan Singh as an asset to the core value of a mother in a man's life.
Minutes after the BJP member Mr Yashwant Sinha, took a potshot at Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh in Lok Sabha during debate on price rise on August 3 over his staying away from a direct electoral battle, the new law minister, Mr Khurshid, likened the economist-PM to the Bollywood “mother” from Deewar.
“Jo chunao nahi larte ... woh sukhi hae (Those who do not contest elections are fortunate),” Mr Sinha said in the Lok Sabha while initiating the debate on price rise. Turning towards finance minister Mr Pranab Mukherjee, the BJP leader said, “At least you should understand price rise because you contest elections”, in a clear dig at the PM being a Rajya Sabha member. Dr Singh was sitting next to Mr Mukherjee. Amid laughter, Mr Sinha said the steep rise in prices of kerosene was what cost him the Hazaribagh seat during the 2004 Lok Sabha poll. In his intervention, Mr Salman Khurshid quoted from the conversation between Shashi Kapoor and Amitabh Bachchan in the film Deewar, where the former says: “You may have everything but I have mother”. Mr Khurshid said, “Similarly, BJP may have everything with them but we have Dr Manmohan Singh.” He said under Dr Singh’s leadership India has been able to brave economic challenges and emerge as a “role model”.
The big question is whether Salman has a the nod of 10 Janpath to accord such good words for Dr Manmohan Singh, who is now under tremendous pressure for flip-flop in handling the corruotion cases.
Any takers?
It's chamchagiri at its height or a political googly.
Salman Khurshid, a known Sonia Gandhi loyalist, seems to be overwhelmed by
the recent allotment of key portfolio of Law and Justice to him that he chose to compare Dr Manmohan Singh as an asset to the core value of a mother in a man's life.
Minutes after the BJP member Mr Yashwant Sinha, took a potshot at Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh in Lok Sabha during debate on price rise on August 3 over his staying away from a direct electoral battle, the new law minister, Mr Khurshid, likened the economist-PM to the Bollywood “mother” from Deewar.
“Jo chunao nahi larte ... woh sukhi hae (Those who do not contest elections are fortunate),” Mr Sinha said in the Lok Sabha while initiating the debate on price rise. Turning towards finance minister Mr Pranab Mukherjee, the BJP leader said, “At least you should understand price rise because you contest elections”, in a clear dig at the PM being a Rajya Sabha member. Dr Singh was sitting next to Mr Mukherjee. Amid laughter, Mr Sinha said the steep rise in prices of kerosene was what cost him the Hazaribagh seat during the 2004 Lok Sabha poll. In his intervention, Mr Salman Khurshid quoted from the conversation between Shashi Kapoor and Amitabh Bachchan in the film Deewar, where the former says: “You may have everything but I have mother”. Mr Khurshid said, “Similarly, BJP may have everything with them but we have Dr Manmohan Singh.” He said under Dr Singh’s leadership India has been able to brave economic challenges and emerge as a “role model”.
The big question is whether Salman has a the nod of 10 Janpath to accord such good words for Dr Manmohan Singh, who is now under tremendous pressure for flip-flop in handling the corruotion cases.
Any takers?
"Corruption responsible for price rise"
Corruption is chiefly responsible for growing price rise, senior Lok Sabha members said today.
Initiating the debate under Rule 184, BJP members and former finance minister Yashwant Sinha said corruption leads to "conspicuous consumption" which is bound to have impact on growing price rise and inflation. His views were readily agreed by at least two members Mr Sharad Yadav of JD-U and Shailendra Kumar, Samajwadi Party.
Sharad Yadav said the growth has being pursued at present is jobless. "Unlike in NDA when at least we had opened avenues for 60 lakh jobs," he said.
Agreeing with Sinha’s diagnosis, he said besides corruption, the menace of black marketing is principally responsible for growing inflation.
He wondered why oil subsidies are being given even to well-to-do hotel industry.
"Corruption is the biggest cause of price rise," Sinha said.
The former finance minister also said the government had huge stocks of food grain but it was not being given to the poor. The food grain are rotting in warehouses, he said.
He said just by bringing about 25 million tonnes of its stock of food grain to the market the government can contribute to help bring down food prices.
He also said that once food prices come down, it will also have an impact on prices of other commodities.
In its response, the government fielded new law minister Salman Khurshid, who rubbished charges leveled by the main opposition BJP that it lacks seriousness in taming rising prices and inflation.
“All leading economies are battling high inflation. It is a global phenomenon," he said.
It's a fact that emerging economies from Sri Lanka to Ukraine are reeling under inflation ranging from 6 per cent to 20 per cent.
He mentioned that schemes like MGNREGA, National Rural Health Mission and described them as far sighted ones.
It is the Prime Minister’s leadership that India has emerged as a role model in running the economy. "I am not saying all is well, we still need to do some more," he maintained.
“Government is now releasing excess food stock through public welfare schemes for the BPL families," he added.
(ends)
Initiating the debate under Rule 184, BJP members and former finance minister Yashwant Sinha said corruption leads to "conspicuous consumption" which is bound to have impact on growing price rise and inflation. His views were readily agreed by at least two members Mr Sharad Yadav of JD-U and Shailendra Kumar, Samajwadi Party.
Sharad Yadav said the growth has being pursued at present is jobless. "Unlike in NDA when at least we had opened avenues for 60 lakh jobs," he said.
Agreeing with Sinha’s diagnosis, he said besides corruption, the menace of black marketing is principally responsible for growing inflation.
He wondered why oil subsidies are being given even to well-to-do hotel industry.
"Corruption is the biggest cause of price rise," Sinha said.
The former finance minister also said the government had huge stocks of food grain but it was not being given to the poor. The food grain are rotting in warehouses, he said.
He said just by bringing about 25 million tonnes of its stock of food grain to the market the government can contribute to help bring down food prices.
He also said that once food prices come down, it will also have an impact on prices of other commodities.
In its response, the government fielded new law minister Salman Khurshid, who rubbished charges leveled by the main opposition BJP that it lacks seriousness in taming rising prices and inflation.
“All leading economies are battling high inflation. It is a global phenomenon," he said.
It's a fact that emerging economies from Sri Lanka to Ukraine are reeling under inflation ranging from 6 per cent to 20 per cent.
He mentioned that schemes like MGNREGA, National Rural Health Mission and described them as far sighted ones.
It is the Prime Minister’s leadership that India has emerged as a role model in running the economy. "I am not saying all is well, we still need to do some more," he maintained.
“Government is now releasing excess food stock through public welfare schemes for the BPL families," he added.
(ends)
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Saluting the Pragmatism of Mizos
(The major portion of the following piece also appeared in The Statesman --- in popular North East page published every Monday)
Welcome to the island of peace, Mizoram.
The general impression about Mizos is that they are a labourious lot. The oft-repeated diagnosis of a principal malady of the North-east ~ the “White Collar Job Syndrome”, the well-known craze for easy office going jobs, somehow does not apply to Mizos. They are used to hard work. Therefore, it is ironical that when confronted with the rat famine, locally called Mautam, and caused by flowering of bamboo hit the then Lushai Hills district of Assam in 1959 they approached the government for immediate relief. But when it did not come in time they set up an organisation calling itself the Mizo National Famine Front. The late Laldenga, a clerk in the district council then, headed the organisation.
He subsequently dropped the word famine in 1961 and took up arms against the establishment demanding independence. The “Operation Jericho” by the Mizo National Front caught the Centre napping. For many days, they were virtually in command of the district town of Aizawl. The lush green landscape burnt for many years.
In 1986, then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi struck a deal with Laldenga. The Mizoram Peace Accord was signed on 30 June by Laldenga on behalf of the MNF, RD Pradhan, then Union home secretary and then Mizoram chief secretary Lalkhama...
This year marked the completion of 25 years of the accord. Mizoram celebrates 30 June as “Remna Ni”, the annual peace day. Present chief minister Mr Lal Thanhawla, a Congress veteran, has his own reasons to describe the pact as “the most successful accord in the country”. Truly, one of the most violent forms of insurgency ~ where bombing and even merciless killing of civilians on both sides was the order of the day ~ had come to an end with the stroke of a pen. Mr Lal Thanhawla had to bow out of office as chief minister to pave the way for Laldenga to take charge.
However, amid jubilation the credit for the same should also be given to the sagacity of Laldenga as also to the pragmatism of the Mizos as a community. In fact, unlike other rebel leaders like Nagaland’s AZ Phizo, Laldenga could carry the entire militant MNF with him. So, following the latter’s coming to the national mainstream, there was no splinter groups left in the jungles.
Despite peace being restored, Mizoram was haunted for sometime by a neo-insurgent group Hmar People’s Convention, clamouring for an autonomous district council. They however surrendered on 27 July, 1994 and ended their five-year rebellion. The Mizoram government still confronts the Reang (now known as Brus) National Front which operates from their camps in Tripura. But on the whole, Mizoram today is an island of peace. In fact, within a short period after assuming power, the Laldenga-led MNF government was toppled making way for the Congress. The MNF men could have been frustrated but it was the Mizos’ spirit of pragmatic thinking that prevented them from taking up guns again. Lal Thanhawla says most clauses of the historic accord have been implemented. But a years ago, the Peace Accord Mizo National Front Returnees’ Association, alleged they have not received the full amount as promised to them. This needs to be addressed. The Mizo Accord, like that of Nagas, also makes a veiled reference to the issue of unification of Mizo- inhabited areas of other adjoining state. One only hopes the Mizos will remain a practical lot.
(ends)
Welcome to the island of peace, Mizoram.
The general impression about Mizos is that they are a labourious lot. The oft-repeated diagnosis of a principal malady of the North-east ~ the “White Collar Job Syndrome”, the well-known craze for easy office going jobs, somehow does not apply to Mizos. They are used to hard work. Therefore, it is ironical that when confronted with the rat famine, locally called Mautam, and caused by flowering of bamboo hit the then Lushai Hills district of Assam in 1959 they approached the government for immediate relief. But when it did not come in time they set up an organisation calling itself the Mizo National Famine Front. The late Laldenga, a clerk in the district council then, headed the organisation.
He subsequently dropped the word famine in 1961 and took up arms against the establishment demanding independence. The “Operation Jericho” by the Mizo National Front caught the Centre napping. For many days, they were virtually in command of the district town of Aizawl. The lush green landscape burnt for many years.
In 1986, then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi struck a deal with Laldenga. The Mizoram Peace Accord was signed on 30 June by Laldenga on behalf of the MNF, RD Pradhan, then Union home secretary and then Mizoram chief secretary Lalkhama...
This year marked the completion of 25 years of the accord. Mizoram celebrates 30 June as “Remna Ni”, the annual peace day. Present chief minister Mr Lal Thanhawla, a Congress veteran, has his own reasons to describe the pact as “the most successful accord in the country”. Truly, one of the most violent forms of insurgency ~ where bombing and even merciless killing of civilians on both sides was the order of the day ~ had come to an end with the stroke of a pen. Mr Lal Thanhawla had to bow out of office as chief minister to pave the way for Laldenga to take charge.
However, amid jubilation the credit for the same should also be given to the sagacity of Laldenga as also to the pragmatism of the Mizos as a community. In fact, unlike other rebel leaders like Nagaland’s AZ Phizo, Laldenga could carry the entire militant MNF with him. So, following the latter’s coming to the national mainstream, there was no splinter groups left in the jungles.
Despite peace being restored, Mizoram was haunted for sometime by a neo-insurgent group Hmar People’s Convention, clamouring for an autonomous district council. They however surrendered on 27 July, 1994 and ended their five-year rebellion. The Mizoram government still confronts the Reang (now known as Brus) National Front which operates from their camps in Tripura. But on the whole, Mizoram today is an island of peace. In fact, within a short period after assuming power, the Laldenga-led MNF government was toppled making way for the Congress. The MNF men could have been frustrated but it was the Mizos’ spirit of pragmatic thinking that prevented them from taking up guns again. Lal Thanhawla says most clauses of the historic accord have been implemented. But a years ago, the Peace Accord Mizo National Front Returnees’ Association, alleged they have not received the full amount as promised to them. This needs to be addressed. The Mizo Accord, like that of Nagas, also makes a veiled reference to the issue of unification of Mizo- inhabited areas of other adjoining state. One only hopes the Mizos will remain a practical lot.
(ends)
Wednesday, July 27, 2011
This can happen only in India: A Secretary over ruled PM Gujral
Nirendra Dev
This is a test case of combination of bizaire style of governance in India as also the much talked about muscle-flexing by bureaucracy.
A former Telecom Secretary Mr A V Gokak “over ruled” the then Prime Minister Mr I K Gujral in 1997 and referred the study on licensee fees to other fora instead of Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI)as directed by Gujral.
“This was a major lacuna… This should not have happened and was unexpected. Prime Minister is the highest authority and any order from him should have been implemented in letter and spirit,” the JPC chairman and senior Congress MP Mr P C Chako told reporters here today.
Briefing journalists about the 12th sitting of the all-party panel examining the high-profile 2G spectrum scam, Mr Chako said on November 1, 1997, Mr Gujral had directed that TRAI should study on various pros and cons about the fees “not recovered” from the licensees.
“Instead of giving the assignment to TRAI, the secretary telecom (Mr Gakok) felt the necessity to assign the task to Bureau of Industrial Costs and Pricing (BICP), which was also later outsourced to ICICI Bank,” Mr Chako said.
To a question, Mr Chako said even the then Telecom minister Mr Beni Prasad Verma, the present Steel minister, “was not consulted”.
To a question, Mr Chako said, the former secretary, who retired 12 years back, explained to the panel that he “felt the necessity to assign the task to BICP as he thought TRAI would take more time to make the study and submit its report”.
“This reply is not satisfactory to the JPC,” Mr Chako said adding Mr Gakok, who appeared before the panel for 2 and half hours, will again appear tomorrow. “Six more members of JPC are to question him”.
Mr Chako said that ironically the report from BICP and ICICI later came only 11 months after the assignment was given and incidentally after Mr Gakok had retired.
Mr Gakok’s stint as telecom secretary covers the duration between 1996 and 1998. Among other things, he was also questioned by the committee on how the DoPT has failed to collect “outstanding license fees” to the tune of Rs 3779.45 crore including the amount of Rs 685 crore plus Rs 50.76 crore and another amount of Rs 33 crore as were also reflected in the CAG report No. 6 of 1998.
“Mr Gakok’s explanation to the committee was that the industry was at the nascent stage and things were just settling down,” Mr Chako said.
He explained that one reason for failure to recover the dues was that most of the 34 licensees had failed to open “third party account” as was mandated as one of the pre-conditions. “In fact, the failure to open such an account meant the licenses should or could have been cancelled,” he said.
Mr Chako maintained that the JPC was “not at all satisfied” with the former secretary’s explanations.
Answering questions, Mr Chako threw broad hint that all former telecom ministers could be summoned before the JPC but indicated that Mr Beni Prasad Verma and Mr Buta Singh could be exempted as nothing much apparently happened during their tenure. Other names as former telecom ministers who could be summoned “only after concensus” include Ms Sushma Swaraj, Mr Jagmohan, Late Pramod Mahajan, Mr Ram Vilas Paswan and Mr Arun Shourie. “Even Atal Bihari Vajpayee held the portfolio for sometime, but no member has raised the demand of summoning any former prime minister,” he added.
With the appointment of three of its Congress members— Mr Kishore Chandra Deo, Ms Jayanthi Natarajan and Mr Paban Singh Ghatowar—as ministers, the Congress has fallen into minority in the JPC, sources say adding the vacant slot can be filled up only after a resolution of the both houses of Parliament.
BJP has already charged the Congress of delaying the process. Mr Chako today said the JPC would be able to finalize report only by the end of winter session and not by August end as was initially assigned.
Meanwhile, BJ mounted pressure on government today by demanding that Home Minister Chidambaram should be summoned by JPC.
“I have received a letter of request from Mr Sinha on that,” the JPC chairman Mr P C Chako confirmed but hastened to add that the matter was under his examination.
Mr Sinha, when contacted said Mr Chidambaram “should come before the JPC as a former finance minister”.
Asked whether in his letter to the JPC chairman, he has also referred to Mr A Raja’s submission in the court during last two hearings wherein he has named the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh and Mr Chidambaram, the BJP leader said, “…. but why make a distinction on whether he (Chidambaram) should be questioned on what Raja has said in court or otherwise”.
Mr Chako later said Mr Sinha’s letter was under his consideration but in the same breath, he said, “former ministers and politicians can be summoned only in the last leg… after we finish up with former secretaries and AGs and others”.
The JPC chairman Mr Chako, however, said, the committee would like to question Mr Raja at the earliest as the members expected him to throw more lights into the matters. “We are not with any closed mind for summoning others,” Mr Chako added.
The battle of one-up-manship between Congress and BJP is really picking up in the case.
In May, earlier this year, Mr Sinha, who was heading the Group of Ministers on Telecom policy during NDA regime, volunteered to depose before JPC.
Apparently, BJP is opposed to Mr Chako’s “prematured and prejudicial media briefings”, sources said and a few BJP leaders are also toying with the idea of having parallel briefings. Even during the meeting in the past, opposition members maintained that Congress members in JPC were coming prepared and briefed by the government and akey senior minister. The Home Minister Mr Chidambaram has already demanded the resignation of BJP member Mr Yashwant Sinha from the JPC.
(ends)
This is a test case of combination of bizaire style of governance in India as also the much talked about muscle-flexing by bureaucracy.
A former Telecom Secretary Mr A V Gokak “over ruled” the then Prime Minister Mr I K Gujral in 1997 and referred the study on licensee fees to other fora instead of Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI)as directed by Gujral.
“This was a major lacuna… This should not have happened and was unexpected. Prime Minister is the highest authority and any order from him should have been implemented in letter and spirit,” the JPC chairman and senior Congress MP Mr P C Chako told reporters here today.
Briefing journalists about the 12th sitting of the all-party panel examining the high-profile 2G spectrum scam, Mr Chako said on November 1, 1997, Mr Gujral had directed that TRAI should study on various pros and cons about the fees “not recovered” from the licensees.
“Instead of giving the assignment to TRAI, the secretary telecom (Mr Gakok) felt the necessity to assign the task to Bureau of Industrial Costs and Pricing (BICP), which was also later outsourced to ICICI Bank,” Mr Chako said.
To a question, Mr Chako said even the then Telecom minister Mr Beni Prasad Verma, the present Steel minister, “was not consulted”.
To a question, Mr Chako said, the former secretary, who retired 12 years back, explained to the panel that he “felt the necessity to assign the task to BICP as he thought TRAI would take more time to make the study and submit its report”.
“This reply is not satisfactory to the JPC,” Mr Chako said adding Mr Gakok, who appeared before the panel for 2 and half hours, will again appear tomorrow. “Six more members of JPC are to question him”.
Mr Chako said that ironically the report from BICP and ICICI later came only 11 months after the assignment was given and incidentally after Mr Gakok had retired.
Mr Gakok’s stint as telecom secretary covers the duration between 1996 and 1998. Among other things, he was also questioned by the committee on how the DoPT has failed to collect “outstanding license fees” to the tune of Rs 3779.45 crore including the amount of Rs 685 crore plus Rs 50.76 crore and another amount of Rs 33 crore as were also reflected in the CAG report No. 6 of 1998.
“Mr Gakok’s explanation to the committee was that the industry was at the nascent stage and things were just settling down,” Mr Chako said.
He explained that one reason for failure to recover the dues was that most of the 34 licensees had failed to open “third party account” as was mandated as one of the pre-conditions. “In fact, the failure to open such an account meant the licenses should or could have been cancelled,” he said.
Mr Chako maintained that the JPC was “not at all satisfied” with the former secretary’s explanations.
Answering questions, Mr Chako threw broad hint that all former telecom ministers could be summoned before the JPC but indicated that Mr Beni Prasad Verma and Mr Buta Singh could be exempted as nothing much apparently happened during their tenure. Other names as former telecom ministers who could be summoned “only after concensus” include Ms Sushma Swaraj, Mr Jagmohan, Late Pramod Mahajan, Mr Ram Vilas Paswan and Mr Arun Shourie. “Even Atal Bihari Vajpayee held the portfolio for sometime, but no member has raised the demand of summoning any former prime minister,” he added.
With the appointment of three of its Congress members— Mr Kishore Chandra Deo, Ms Jayanthi Natarajan and Mr Paban Singh Ghatowar—as ministers, the Congress has fallen into minority in the JPC, sources say adding the vacant slot can be filled up only after a resolution of the both houses of Parliament.
BJP has already charged the Congress of delaying the process. Mr Chako today said the JPC would be able to finalize report only by the end of winter session and not by August end as was initially assigned.
Meanwhile, BJ mounted pressure on government today by demanding that Home Minister Chidambaram should be summoned by JPC.
“I have received a letter of request from Mr Sinha on that,” the JPC chairman Mr P C Chako confirmed but hastened to add that the matter was under his examination.
Mr Sinha, when contacted said Mr Chidambaram “should come before the JPC as a former finance minister”.
Asked whether in his letter to the JPC chairman, he has also referred to Mr A Raja’s submission in the court during last two hearings wherein he has named the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh and Mr Chidambaram, the BJP leader said, “…. but why make a distinction on whether he (Chidambaram) should be questioned on what Raja has said in court or otherwise”.
Mr Chako later said Mr Sinha’s letter was under his consideration but in the same breath, he said, “former ministers and politicians can be summoned only in the last leg… after we finish up with former secretaries and AGs and others”.
The JPC chairman Mr Chako, however, said, the committee would like to question Mr Raja at the earliest as the members expected him to throw more lights into the matters. “We are not with any closed mind for summoning others,” Mr Chako added.
The battle of one-up-manship between Congress and BJP is really picking up in the case.
In May, earlier this year, Mr Sinha, who was heading the Group of Ministers on Telecom policy during NDA regime, volunteered to depose before JPC.
Apparently, BJP is opposed to Mr Chako’s “prematured and prejudicial media briefings”, sources said and a few BJP leaders are also toying with the idea of having parallel briefings. Even during the meeting in the past, opposition members maintained that Congress members in JPC were coming prepared and briefed by the government and akey senior minister. The Home Minister Mr Chidambaram has already demanded the resignation of BJP member Mr Yashwant Sinha from the JPC.
(ends)
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Has Jairam been shown his place by PM?
Is vocal Jairam Ramesh forced to tone down his ‘aggressive’ stance on Land Bill?
The new Rural Development minister Mr Jairam Ramesh’s first solemn pledge of putting the draft Land Acquisition Amendment Bill within a week
of his taking over has failed. Does it imply, after the initial
aggressive posturing, the pro-active minister is slightly toning down
his positioning vis-à-vis the much talked about legislation?
“It is not due to babudom….,” the minister told reporters here and
maintained that the draft bill will be put on the ministry’s website
by next week. This is truly in contrast to his media interaction on July 13, when he said the draft will be ready "within a week".
He also remained half-hearted to a question when asked whether the new land bill will be introduced in parliament and passed by winter session, he merely said, "I will try".
The minister had also on July 13 virtually reversed government’s hitherto
positioning on the highly controversial bill when he had said that his
ministry will not have any confrontation with Sonia Gandhi-led NAC.
The basic difference between the NAC and the Rural Development
ministry on the bill was on the quantum of role the state
(administrative mechanism) is going to have. While NAC had suggested
for 100 per cent role for the state, key UPA ally like Trinamul
Congress has been advocating for zero per cent state role.
In a modest contradiction to his last week’s remarks, Mr Ramesh today
merely said, “NAC’s views on the bill is one of the views”. He also
sought to give importance to the stance of Trinamul when he said,
“there are also other views like TMC who say zero role”. “The debate
is not about 70:30 or 100: 0 or anything like that. The state has to
play a facilitatory role in all the land transactions for
developmental works. It should have two vital elements,
industrialization along with compensation for land owners and
livelihood of those affected,” Mr Ramesh clarified.
He also said Trinamul MP Dr Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar met him today, but
maintained that they did not discuss the land issue.
To a question, he was aware of general perception that during the last
3-decades under Left, the rural development sector was neglected in
West Bengal and said he would visit the state soon. However, he said,
when the country’s ‘poverty-bowl’ is referred, the perception relates
to Bihar, MP, Odhisa, Chattisgarh, UP, Rajasthan and north east. He
said the chief malady in these states including Naxal-affected states
“is shashan ki kami (absence of civil governance)”. He said in order
to improve on that scale, his ministry will sign a MoU with the office
of Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) to allow comprehensive audit
of all its schemes.
Mr Ramesh, who held a meeting with CAG Mr Vinod Rai here today, said
the CAG had informed him that they were willing to appoint special
auditor generals for rural development and local government programmes
in eight states which get maximum funds from the rural development
ministry. “These will also include Congress-ruled Andhra, Maharashtra
and Rajasthan as we do not to do any politics on it,” he said. The
minister said he would be leaving on a two-day visit to Kanker and
Dhamtari, the Maoist-hit areas of Chhattisgarh, to review
implementation of rural development programmes.
It is for others to interpret now who has tamed Ramesh, either the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh, as Ramesh does not enjoy good rapport with the
Prime Minister, or its the powerful 10 Janpath, who has asked him to go slow.
(ends)
The new Rural Development minister Mr Jairam Ramesh’s first solemn pledge of putting the draft Land Acquisition Amendment Bill within a week
of his taking over has failed. Does it imply, after the initial
aggressive posturing, the pro-active minister is slightly toning down
his positioning vis-à-vis the much talked about legislation?
“It is not due to babudom….,” the minister told reporters here and
maintained that the draft bill will be put on the ministry’s website
by next week. This is truly in contrast to his media interaction on July 13, when he said the draft will be ready "within a week".
He also remained half-hearted to a question when asked whether the new land bill will be introduced in parliament and passed by winter session, he merely said, "I will try".
The minister had also on July 13 virtually reversed government’s hitherto
positioning on the highly controversial bill when he had said that his
ministry will not have any confrontation with Sonia Gandhi-led NAC.
The basic difference between the NAC and the Rural Development
ministry on the bill was on the quantum of role the state
(administrative mechanism) is going to have. While NAC had suggested
for 100 per cent role for the state, key UPA ally like Trinamul
Congress has been advocating for zero per cent state role.
In a modest contradiction to his last week’s remarks, Mr Ramesh today
merely said, “NAC’s views on the bill is one of the views”. He also
sought to give importance to the stance of Trinamul when he said,
“there are also other views like TMC who say zero role”. “The debate
is not about 70:30 or 100: 0 or anything like that. The state has to
play a facilitatory role in all the land transactions for
developmental works. It should have two vital elements,
industrialization along with compensation for land owners and
livelihood of those affected,” Mr Ramesh clarified.
He also said Trinamul MP Dr Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar met him today, but
maintained that they did not discuss the land issue.
To a question, he was aware of general perception that during the last
3-decades under Left, the rural development sector was neglected in
West Bengal and said he would visit the state soon. However, he said,
when the country’s ‘poverty-bowl’ is referred, the perception relates
to Bihar, MP, Odhisa, Chattisgarh, UP, Rajasthan and north east. He
said the chief malady in these states including Naxal-affected states
“is shashan ki kami (absence of civil governance)”. He said in order
to improve on that scale, his ministry will sign a MoU with the office
of Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) to allow comprehensive audit
of all its schemes.
Mr Ramesh, who held a meeting with CAG Mr Vinod Rai here today, said
the CAG had informed him that they were willing to appoint special
auditor generals for rural development and local government programmes
in eight states which get maximum funds from the rural development
ministry. “These will also include Congress-ruled Andhra, Maharashtra
and Rajasthan as we do not to do any politics on it,” he said. The
minister said he would be leaving on a two-day visit to Kanker and
Dhamtari, the Maoist-hit areas of Chhattisgarh, to review
implementation of rural development programmes.
It is for others to interpret now who has tamed Ramesh, either the Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh, as Ramesh does not enjoy good rapport with the
Prime Minister, or its the powerful 10 Janpath, who has asked him to go slow.
(ends)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Putin says - Europe was in a “humiliating decline” and anti-Russian sanctions backfired" :::::::: “We should eliminate trade and investment barriers... and also promote balanced development,” says Chinese President :::::
US President Trump Lands in Shenzhen Ahead of Key Talks With Chinese and Russian Leaders Trump's stated goal for the first-ever summit b...
-
I landed in PTI, New Delhi -- its news headquarters - in 1998. The administrative headquarters was still Mumbai. Within weeks, one ex-PTI an...
-
How much Pakistan fake currency angle was true for demonetisation in 2016 ?? : The claim that Pakistan-backed 'fake Indian currency...
-
Tensions often can rise when an emerging power builtt up with good will challenges the dominance of an established power. Politics more ofte...