In
the recent past and not without good reason, Japan
has remained only a sub-text in Indian foreign policy paradigm as New Delhi ’s policy makers have been overwhelmed by the
possible future charm of BRICS where in China is a major player.
Therefore,
the strength or quality of Indo-Japan relationship is more understood from the
context of Indo-China relationship. The Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s maiden
visit to Japan
thus raised serious curiosity.
But the need to harness an enhanced cooperation
with The importance of Indian Ocean remains a dominant factor as it is around 60 per cent of global maritime cargo, including oil supplies from the Middle East passes through
The significance
of Japan in the context of India ’s foreign policy framing has again gained
currency as the new regime in New Delhi under
Prime Minister Modi is understood to be in the process undertaking necessary
tweaking vis-à-vis India ’s
relationship with major global players.
Having dealt with Japan in his capacity as the chief minister of
Gujarat, Prime Minister Modi has a special bond with Japan and especially with the
present regime there.
Having
said so, let us examine the vertex of Sino-India and Indo-Japan relationship. China is India ’s
neighbour in dispute on borders, India
has unsuccessfully fought 1962 battle against it and China is a key member of BRICS. Japan is
neither of these.
So was the hype about Modi’s Japan sojourn more than justified?
The
Modi detractors in India
are already celebrating that the Indian Prime Minister could not extract a
civil Nuclear deal. Lest we forget, Japanese are very touchy about nuclear
issues as victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki holocaust they
see the technology as a chief harbinger of destruction and scaled up human
tragedies.
Civil
nuclear talks were already hit badly by the Fukushima
disaster in 2011 but Japan
agreed to resume negotiations last year (importantly India under Manmohan Singh regime)
as it said it wanted to contribute to “nuclear safety worldwide”.
Although
much is being written about Sushma Swaraj missing the Japan trip, it was Modi’s
External Affairs Minister Sushma only who had rightly flagged off the nuclear issue
with her Japanese counterpart Fumio Kishida during
their one-on-one meeting on the sidelines of Asean Regional Forum (ARF)
meet in Myanmar's capital Naypyitaw.
Sushma
also had made it clear that New Delhi
does not further delay in signing the nuclear agreement deal and made her
preference clear that during Prime Minister Modi’s visit there is a progress on
that line.
MEA
sources also maintained that as Prime Minister Modi shares a good rapport with
Japanese PM, Shinzo Abe; both the leaders would walk the talk – at least give
the nuclear talks a direction.
The big ticket announcement on Nuke-talks was
hardly big.
Nevertheless, the trip cannot be dismissed as a
set back as "The two
prime ministers reaffirmed the importance of defence relations between Japan and India in their strategic
partnership and decided to upgrade and strengthen them," the leaders said
in their joint statement after
their summit-level parleys.
The two prime ministers "recognised the enormous future
potential for transfer and collaborative projects in defence equipment and
technology between the two countries", the statement further said while
Modi also welcomed Japan 's
“relaxation of restrictions on transfer of defence equipment and technology”.
The two sides also said they would speed up talks on nuclear
energy co-operation and claimed "significant progress" although they
failed to reach a last-minute agreement on safeguards sought by Japan .
But the
optimism on the same is not lost out as both the leaders “directed their officials
to further accelerate the negotiations with a view to concluding the Agreement
at an early date, and strengthen the two countries' partnership in
non-proliferation and nuclear safety".
During Modi’s stay, Japan promised $35 billion in investment and
financing for Indian infrastructure for the next five years while Modi promised
to introduce a special mechanism like a "Japan Fast Track Channel for
Japanese investors in India" to woo investment into the country.
Perhaps realizing it well before hand that civil nuclear deal
would not fructify, Modi displaying real polity instead focused on his new
found political constituency in Varanasi and
extracted an agreement under which his parliamentary constituency of Varanasi will be developed as a "smart city" in
partnership with the Japanese city, Kyoto .
Ahead of the visit, Mr Modi had said he expected the visit
"will write a new chapter in the annals of the relations between Asia 's two oldest democracies and take our strategic and
global partnership to the next higher level".
This visit was aptly described as an attempt to balance ties
with key world powers and to strengthen India 's position in the
international community.
It was also seen as if both nations would hope to “curb China ’s
rising activity” in the East and South
China Seas
and the Indian Ocean .
In fact, Modi walked an extra mile when without naming Beijing he made a veiled
attack on ‘expansionist” designs of the 18th century. The reference to “encroachment” and “entry
into the seas” is being interpreted as a reference to China ’s spats with Japan
over the Senkaku Islands .
In another please Tokyo agenda, the two Prime Ministers expressed concern
over North Korea 's
continued development of its nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs.
They urged North Korea to take
concrete actions towards ‘denuclearization’, a long time demand of Japan , and
other goals to fully comply with its international obligations.
They welcomed that the next rounds of Foreign Ministers Strategic
Dialogue and Defence Ministers dialogue would be held by the year end. They
attached importance to the dialogue between their National Security Advisors,
launched earlier this year soon after the creation of the National Security
Secretariat in Japan
and also underlined the importance of the 2 plus 2 dialogue, involving foreign
and defence secretaries, for their growing strategic partnership, and decided
to seek ways to intensify this dialogue.
The communists bogey in China is already alarmed at
Abe-Modi greater synchronization.
A communist party-run newspaper in China has
already said that strategies and the development of China-India
strategic relations will inevitably exert far-reaching influence upon Japan 's
strategic resources, channels and markets.
Consequently, dividing China and India
has become a key issue for Abe, it further said. Tokyo
and New Delhi must consider the coexistence of China , Japan
and the US
in the region when promoting their security cooperation. As two Asian powers,
how the growing intimacy between Japan
and India coordinates with
US "rebalancing to Asia " strategy
and cooperates with BRICS member states” span out remains to be seen. One
cannot agree more.
True, this hyped visit of Narendra Modi therefore solicits
plenty of attention.
Good gist on the coverage
ReplyDelete